Dev Mode. Emulators used.

Select Budget Committee Meeting Session I 11-16-26

Publish Date: 11/16/2026
Description:

Agenda: Call to Order; Approval of the Agenda; Introduction and Overview; CB 121319: relating to the Firefighters’ Pension Fund; CB 121342: An ordinance adopting a budget for 2027; Adjournment.

9:15 CB 121319: relating to the Firefighters’ Pension Fund

47:00 CB 121342: An ordinance adopting a budget for 2027

SPEAKER_06

[14s]

Good morning.

The Select Budget Committee meeting will come to order.

It is 9.31 a.m.

November 16, 2026. I'm Dan Strauss, chair of the committee.

Will the clerk please call the roll?

And if council members are not present, they are excused until they arrive.

SPEAKER_19

[10s]

Councilmember Foster?

Here.

Council President Hollingsworth?

Councilmember Juarez?

Here.

Councilmember Kettle?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Here.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Councilmember Lin.

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Here.

SPEAKER_19

[10s]

Councilmember Rink.

Here.

Councilmember Rivera.

Present.

Councilmember Saka.

Chair Strauss.

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

Present.

And can you call Council President one more time?

SPEAKER_19

[4s]

Council President Hollingsworth.

Here.

Seven present.

SPEAKER_06

[3m33s]

Thank you.

Before we consider the adoption of today's agenda, which is a replicated agenda from the Friday, November 13th meeting, I'd like to quickly discuss the Fire Pension Fund conversation that we had here in Council on Friday.

My recommendation today is to add an item to the agenda.

which will allow a presentation from central staff and the budget director.

We'll get into that in just a minute, but I wanted to, before we get into where did we leave off last Friday, where are we today?

And so if it pleases the body, we'll add this item to the agenda in just a moment.

From there, I'd like to reorient the Select Budget Committee on where we left off from Friday's meeting and which items will be considered at today's meeting.

at the Friday, November 13th Select Budget Committee meeting, we amended the agenda to remove item 29, Council Bill 121321, and added CBA Care 9S to Group B. These actions are being carried forward to today.

For one item, Council Bill 121342, there was a vote on the chair's revised balance package listed in Group A, excluding the items that were removed by request.

This bill was then held for further discussion today.

Central staff then provided us an overview of all items listed on the agenda.

Today we will consider the items removed from Group A, called Group A-2.

We will then move into items listed for individual vote in Group B. Group C were competing items that were substituted with CARE 9, and we'll look to the sponsors to withdraw these items for consideration.

From there, we will conclude with the consent calendar of budget legislation.

when we consider the consent calendar of budget legislation, it'll be the same process in which we went through for the last consent calendar.

And so from there, we'll read through the items.

Colleagues, if you'd like to pull an item from the consent calendar of legislation, we will do so at that time.

We will then move into voting on the consent calendar.

From there we'll vote on items removed from the consent calendar and from there we will vote on standalone legislation and the amendments to each of those pieces of legislation.

I know that that was a lot, four minutes worth.

Before we get into adopting the agenda, are there any questions?

Okay, last comment there is, we're gonna take as much time as we need, we're gonna have as much conversation as we need, That does mean that if we do not complete business by 5 p.m.

tonight, I'm just going to call it at 5 and we'll come back tomorrow.

This is the part of the budget that we just have to work until the work gets done.

And so we'll take it as slowly as we need to so that all questions can be answered in such a way.

But that would mean that we need to come back tomorrow.

If that does occur, I'll just have to work with the central staff director to understand what if what and if that has implications on the remainder of the schedule.

Any questions right now?

And Council Member Rank has been with us for quite some time.

With that, I'm moved to adopt the agenda.

Is there a second?

Chair.

SPEAKER_99

[1s]

Second.

SPEAKER_06

[4s]

It's been moved and seconded to adopt the agenda.

Council Member Rank, did you have a question?

SPEAKER_02

[1s]

Yes, I have an additional motion.

SPEAKER_08

[1s]

Thank you.

SPEAKER_02

[7s]

I move that the proposed agenda be amended to add HSD034A and that'll be placed on the corresponding voting group.

SPEAKER_06

[3s]

And I'm gonna check with the clerk, is that a motion that works right now?

SPEAKER_08

[7s]

Correct, this is just being distributed and the rules will need to be suspended and then we can move forward with the actual amendment.

SPEAKER_06

[10s]

Ah, we're at walk-on amendments.

My apologies, this is the first I've heard of this amendment and so colleagues typically, would you like to distribute it?

SPEAKER_02

[33s]

Oh, my apologies.

Yes.

Tracking where we are right now.

Yes.

Go for it.

Councilmember Rank.

It is a technical change to the amendment that had been included originally in Group B. This is related to HSD for gender-based violence.

It is a technical correction to include a decrease by Finance General for $2 million in 2027 with the distribution of $1 million in 2027 and then $1 million in 2028. Thank you.

SPEAKER_06

[20s]

Colleagues, if there's no objection, the agenda will be amended to add HSD 34. Are there any objections?

Hearing no objections.

Colleagues, are there any other motions on the table that need to be made at this time?

Council Member Lynn.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_04

[23s]

We had a little bit of an issue last week with the confusion around the district project fund and then an amendment I had which basically reduced some of the district project fund and instead would increase OSE and DON by 90,000.

Do I need to walk those on?

I'm happy to move to amend the agenda.

Or are those already?

SPEAKER_06

[3s]

No.

Clerk, would you like to share with us where we are?

SPEAKER_08

[18s]

Yes, Chair.

S.003C was split into two CBAs.

Those two CBAs will be considered when we reach that S.003 and the items removed from Group A. And they'll be considered individually as they were split and we can distribute them shortly.

SPEAKER_06

[1m24s]

Thank you, Chair.

Thank you.

Clerk, are there any other motions that we need to take on amending the agenda other than the presentation at this time that you're aware of?

No, everyone's good.

Great.

Then I will also move to amend the agenda to include a presentation on the fire pension fund.

Second.

Second.

I think it can, great.

If there's no objection, the agenda will be amended to include a fire pension fund presentation at the start of the agenda.

When we get into the group A2, I will ask that we vote on the fire pension fund funding first because I think it has implications throughout the rest of the voting package.

Colleagues, are there any other items to amend the agenda?

Seeing none.

Staff, can you please list the items that were added?

Nope, I don't need.

If there's no objection, the agenda will be adopted as amended.

Hearing no objection, the agenda is adopted.

We're gonna move right on into items of business.

Item one on the agenda as amended.

Will the clerk please read item one into the record?

SPEAKER_08

[2s]

The Fire Pension Fund for briefing and discussion.

SPEAKER_06

[38s]

Thank you.

We're joined by Central Staff Director Lish Whitson, Deputy Director Calvin Chow, City Budget Office Director Ali Panucci.

Welcome to the table, Ali.

Good to see you.

I'm going to turn it over to the table right now to run through a very short presentation on fire pension funds to address some of the confusion that was out there on Friday.

And then, colleagues, I'll take questions for the table.

We'll have conversation if you'd like to.

We can spend as much time as we need to on this topic until you have all your questions answered.

With that, I'm going to turn it over to Lish.

And Lish, if you want to hand it over to however you want to take it from there.

SPEAKER_16

[2s]

I'll hand it over to Director Panucci.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Wonderful.

Welcome.

SPEAKER_11

[3m38s]

Thank you.

Good morning, Chair Strauss, Councilmembers.

Ali Panucci, City Budget Director.

I'm just going to provide a brief overview of what is in the proposed budget and the balancing package as it relates to the fire pension fund.

And then we'll share my screen if it's helpful to kind of show the math and then happy to take questions or defer to the chair on how you want to proceed from there.

The Seattle Firefighters Pension Fund provides certain pension, disability, and medical benefits to eligible firefighters that were hired in Seattle before October 1st, 1977. Currently, the city's pension fund includes two components, is a portion designed to pay current pension, medical disability, and death benefits, that is our state-required fund, and the actuarial account, which was established by choice of the City Council at that time in 1994, to build up a reserve from which to pay the fund's future pension liabilities.

The actuarial account, from what I understand from the history, but I was not here in 1994, was reportedly established in response to a request by the pension board at that time.

So it was a choice that the city made, not a statutorily required requirement of the state.

It was originally established to create an eventual self-sustaining source to fully fund the fire pension obligations indefinitely.

Beginning in 2006, the funds' schedule and funding levels for the actuarial account were repeatedly changed.

In 2006, the period was extended to fully fund the actuarial account five years to 2024. The Pension Board reportedly accepted this proposed change based on the legislative record, but was not required to approve it.

In 2008, 10, 12, and 14, the city adopted ordinances suspending all contributions to the actuarial account in successive two-year periods, which in total suspended all contributions from 2009 through 2016 to this actuarial account while continuing to fund all current obligations of the main pension fund year to year.

These ordinances contain no indication of acceptance or approval of these changes by the board.

In 2016, another city ordinance again extended the funding period for the actuarial account with a four-year extension to 2028 and resumed annual payments into the actuarial account, but not at a level that would have fully funded that account during that time period.

So that is to say the timeline for funding this account has been extended and suspended more than once.

and until and unless the account is fully funded, this actuarial account represents idle, unused resources and does not come with financial advantages for the city.

Practically speaking, abandoning the actuarial account means that future fire pension fund obligations will continue to be handled on a pay-as-you-go basis, which is the city's standard practice and the practice for similar funds, such as the police pension fund.

In fact, pension obligations in the fire pension fund have always been funded as a pay-as-you-go basis and have always been fulfilled.

We do not see this as creating financial risk for our ability to meet our obligations for pension holders who are funded out of this fund.

That is a high-level summary.

I'm going to just show a spreadsheet that kind of shows what is in the budget, if that would be OK with the chair.

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Please.

SPEAKER_11

[3m47s]

OK.

If I can remember how to use my computer.

OK.

So I'm gonna just delete this for a minute.

This is a financial plan for the firefighters' pension fund.

What you see here highlighted in this kind of goldenrod color is what was in the mayor's proposed budget, which is closing the actuarial account and moving the fund balance from that actuarial account into the fire pension fund.

So that is that $25.8 million that you see transferred in in 2026. These are the sources of fund that contribute into the fire pension fund, and you can see in 27 and 28, the amount of general fund proposed to be transferred into the fund to cover expenses is $5 million less per year than in all other years.

That is showing that just in this biennium, the mayor's proposed budget reduced the contribution to the fire pension fund by $5 million, is still fully funding the expenses that are about $25 million a year, and leaves a fund balance and is building a reserve that is shown here.

So that is what was transmitted to you for consideration alongside legislation to close the actuarial account and move this money into the fund.

If the council rejected that proposal to close the account, you would be looking at both having to restore the $5 million in this fund as well as likely either passing legislation to suspend the annual contribution to the actuarial account, or there may be other ways of doing that.

and then what's in the chairs package, and I've just done this yellow line here, is further reducing the annual contribution just in this biennium by $11 million per year into the account.

And you can see if you scroll all the way down, it still fully funds the annual expenditures.

and then reduces the reserve, but starts to build it back in the out years.

And I'll also note of the $11 million each year, or $22 million over the biennium that's proposed to be transferred in the balancing package, and Director Whitson can correct me if I'm wrong here, $6 million of that is spread over four years for a further reserve for the fire pension fund.

So of the $22 million, of reduction in the contribution from the general fund, there's a $6 million reserve being held over four years as further buffer for this fund.

So I'm going to stop sharing my screen for a minute.

My quick analysis in looking at the financial plans is, again, should the council reject this proposal, the combination of the proposal and the chair's balancing package?

and in the mayor's proposal, that would put you out of balance by about $25 million in 2028. So there would be work that would be needed in order to rebalance the general fund.

And I'll pause there.

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

Thank you, Director.

Director Woodson.

SPEAKER_16

[55s]

In order to rebalance that fund, the easiest steps to take would be to remove the funding that's being provided for or that's proposed to be provided for the firefighter overtime.

That would be $14 million.

There is approximately $1 million provided for repair of the fireboat Leschi and the planning for a South Lake Union fire station, and then there's that reserve that's included in the back end for firefighter pensions.

I want to state clearly that the legislation that's in front of you that would close the firefighter actuarial account states clearly that the city maintains a commitment and duty to fully fund the firefighter pensions over time.

SPEAKER_06

[1m04s]

Thank you.

Anything else?

I'll just quickly summarize and then I'll take questions from colleagues.

There's two different tracks that were on.

The body could choose to reject the $22 million transfer, the $11 million per year, and that would just take us out of balance by $11 million per year.

The second track is If the enabling legislation that Director Panucci sent down is not adopted, that's later for this afternoon, that would not only require additional legislation, it would also put the entire budget out of balance by about $25 million.

Did I get that summary correct?

I'm seeing head nods for the record.

Folks are saying yes.

and that we are legally, as the presentation showed, we are legally funding all of the pensions.

This is the same way as the police pension and additional money has been reserved to pay these pensions.

Is that a correct summary from your presentation?

SPEAKER_16

[0s]

Correct.

SPEAKER_06

[12s]

Fantastic.

Colleagues, with that, I'm going to open the floor for questions.

Council Member Lynn followed by Rivera.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_04

[52s]

Thank you, Allie.

Super helpful presentation.

And I just want to kind of clarify a bit my understanding.

So the chart that you showed, that's the pension fund that is not being closed that funds all of these pension obligations that we have.

the mayor's office sent down a proposed budget that would close a separate actuarial account and move all of those funds slightly above 30 million to essentially to this reserve, not reserve, to the pension account and sort of increase sort of the reserves in that account.

Is that sort of what you were proposing?

Director Panucci?

SPEAKER_11

[22s]

That is, thank you Chair Strauss, Council Member Lynn.

Yes, that is essentially, I will just say, and I think I am in writing something quickly earlier, it transfers, it's about 25 and a half million that's being transferred when it closes, which brought the fund balance in the fire pensions fund to over, just over 30 and then as it flows through.

SPEAKER_06

[17s]

And before we move back to you, if we could refer to the fire pension and then the actuarial account, just to reduce confusion, because I think that that's what stirred up some of the confusion.

So we've got the actuarial account that is being closed, and then we have the pension fund, which is fully funded.

Back to you, Councilmember Lee.

SPEAKER_04

[42s]

Thank you, Chair.

Appreciate that.

So the pension fund, under the balancing package does not have sort of as robust a reserve.

And I guess one question is, doesn't sound like we have any legal requirement and certainly wanna be careful about obviously legal issues, but are there any requirements for a reserve in the pension fund?

Can you talk at all about sort of how the amounts in the pension fund, I saw you said we're gonna build it back up over time.

Just any thinking about sort of the the amounts in that pension fund that we should be aware of or thinking about.

Director Panucci?

SPEAKER_11

[1m12s]

There's not a minimum fund balance requirement.

We are obligated to show that we are planning to meet what we are projecting the annual costs to be to fully make our payments to the pension holders, which we are doing in Oh, there's a $500,000.

Sorry.

Thank you, Director Woodson.

There's a $500,000 minimum reserve, which is maintained and shown in the financial plan with the initial balancing package.

I will also just note that the financial plan for the pension fund with all of these actions would maintain at least that minimum $500,000 through 28. It grows to $2.3 million in 2029 and then $4.3 million $3 million in 2030. That is an addition to $1.5 million being held every year in the general fund to further buffer against any future cost increases.

Like for example, when our current firefighters get a new contract in cost of living, our pension holders also get a increase in their pension funds.

So we are making sure that we have a reserve held there.

SPEAKER_06

[5s]

Thank you.

Thank you, Jared.

That's all.

Thank you.

Councilmember Rivera followed by Rink.

SPEAKER_17

[23s]

Thank you, Chair.

So, Allie, I'm sorry.

I just need to confirm because I don't think I heard it this way.

You're not transferring the money in full.

When you close the actuarial account, I thought you were transferring the money in full to the fire pension, but then I heard you say only a portion of it.

So can you please confirm?

Director Panucci.

SPEAKER_11

[25s]

Thank you.

We are transferring all of it.

What I was clarifying is I think I had told perhaps you and Council Member Lynn earlier in the week that we were transferring about 30 million.

The amount of money in the actuarial account now is closer to 25. Once we transfer that into the fund, it brought the fund balance up.

But all of the money from the actuarial account in the mayor's proposed budget is being transferred into the fire pension fund.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Council Member Rivera.

SPEAKER_17

[8s]

Thank you, Chair.

And it's not being used, it's just being transferred to the pension fund?

It is being transferred to the, sorry.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Director, go for it.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_11

[34s]

Is being transferred to the FIRE pension fund, and in the mayor's proposed budget, $5 million each year, just in the two-year period, not in the out years, $5 million of that fund balance is being used to cover the expenses in 2027 and 2028. So we take money from the actuarial account, move it into fund balance.

That brings the fund balance up to about $32.5 million at the end of 27. And it then is used, 5 million of that is used.

SPEAKER_06

[9s]

And it, Director, could you share screen?

Oh, sure.

Just again, because Council Member Rivera, your questions are spot on.

You've got the floor again, Council Member.

SPEAKER_11

[1m28s]

Wait for it.

Okay, so again, here you see in this goldenrod that is being, and it's hard to share a spreadsheet.

So in 2026, you can see the $25.7 million being transferred via the year-end supplemental, that's the current year legislation, into the FIRE pension.

fund, and then you can see here in the mayor's proposed budget, the amount of general fund, so the sources of fund to cover expenses out of this fund in 2007 and 28, is $18 million per year.

So some of the fund balance that is created, like so you can see going all the way down to the bottom, at the end of 20, five, we ended the year with a $3.9 million reserve in the fire pension fund.

Once we transfer the actuarial account money in 26, you have $32.5 million of fund balance, and that gets reduced.

What's showed here is the impact of both the mayor's proposed budget and the balancing package is what would be left and reserved at the end of 28. and then at the end, or excuse me, 27, and then at the end of 28, it would leave $500,000, the fund, our current fund policy minimum requirement, and then you start building it back.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Thank you.

Councilman Rivera.

SPEAKER_17

[13s]

Thank you, Chair.

So you are using some of the money in the reserves to balance the budget?

To balance, yes, correct.

And then, if I may, Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_06

[4s]

I do see Director Whitson had something to add, right as we were getting comfortable.

SPEAKER_16

[19s]

Technically, as you can see on the top line, the general fund contribution to the pension fund is reduced from $25 million a year to $18 million a year, rather than actually using the fund balance for anything other than the firefighter pensions.

SPEAKER_17

[39s]

You're not putting in money, so I think it can be seen as the same, but thank you for the technicality.

I do appreciate what you're saying.

I just think it lands the same.

My other question is about if we don't close the actuarial account and we don't use this funding, you said, Lish, that we would back out the the overtime and these other pieces that were fire-related, but we don't actually have to do that.

The cuts can come from somewhere else in order to keep the actuarial account in place, correct?

Director Woodson?

SPEAKER_16

[11s]

Correct.

Although, speaking for the chair, I think the balancing package was built assuming this transfer would contribute towards the fire overtime.

SPEAKER_17

[41s]

Thank you, Chair.

Yes, but the CBA actually just says general fund for the overtime, so it is possible to do something different in order to, because then what we're left with is we either excuse my voice this morning, we're left with either the having to close the actuarial account, or we don't close it, but then we don't do the fire OT.

At the end of the day, fire is the one who's being impacted.

So there should be a scenario by which, I guess what I'm trying to say is we don't have to take it from the overtime.

We could do something different.

Director?

SPEAKER_16

[4s]

Correct, and we would need to spend some time figuring out what that different thing is.

SPEAKER_17

[11s]

Yes, and I wish we had had more transparency earlier in the process.

So we would know we weren't here today trying to figure this out.

Thank you.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_06

[3s]

Thank you.

Council Member Rink, followed by Kettle.

SPEAKER_02

[60s]

Thank you, Chair Strauss.

And I do want to start by thanking you for giving us time today in committee to discuss this.

It's really appreciated.

And I think just shedding light on the policy choices here is really valuable for our discussion.

So I want to thank you for giving us time here in committee.

And I want to thank you, Director Panucci, for being before the committee to walk us through everything that's going on here.

I know I've learned a lot about pensions in the past couple of days.

and something tells me I should learn a little bit more.

But I'm wondering if Director Panucci and Director Woodson, if you can walk through together again, just for my own clarity, kind of the core differences between what the mayor transmitted as a part of the proposal and the difference between what's in the chair's balancing package and with a specific focus on sustainability in the out years.

because there's a difference here in terms of the amount that is being pulled and so I'm wondering how that might impact 2028, 2029 and so on.

Could you unpack that a little bit more?

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Director Panucci or Whitson?

SPEAKER_11

[1m24s]

I'll start with the how we did this in the mayor's proposed budget.

So there are a number of strategies that we've talked about in previous sessions the mayor used to balance, not just in this biennium, in the out years.

We saw this maneuver as a as a way to, one, free up resources that were basically sitting idle at a moment where we were facing really challenging reductions, and so it helped create a glide path into the out years because our biggest challenge was in the first three years of our current four-year planning period that we're working on in this budget and balancing through 2030. And so essentially, the one-time $5 million savings that this proposal accommodated in the mayors helped mitigate the size of the reduction we were looking at in the fire department's budget this year as we waited for not waited for, but as some of the projections in the out years increased a little bit, and the overall sustainability was like, we used a combination of some one-time strategies and ongoing reductions to get us closer to structurally balanced by 2030. And then I'll let Director Whitson speak to the chair's package.

SPEAKER_16

[54s]

Thank you.

And so, looking at line 35 here, the total expenses for the pension fund, including death benefits, administration, medical benefits, and then pension payments to members, is approximately $2.24 million a year.

At the beginning of 2027, with that transfer from the actuarial count, there would be $32 million in the pension fund available, and so the chair's package identifying that there was a need for additional resources reduced the contributions by $11 million a year.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Councilman Waring?

SPEAKER_02

[37s]

Thank you, Chair Strauss.

I'm going to pause on my questions here and just note, colleagues, I know when we were taking up the package A, I pulled a number of items pertaining to this broader policy discussion to give us options.

As I know, many of us take the concerns of Local 27 very seriously and receiving that letter later in the process, I know I certainly had some questions that I wanted answers to, and I know a number of us did, so pulled those items so we could have this discussion today.

And again, a deep appreciation to Director Panucci and you, Chair Strauss, for giving us the time to have this discussion.

SPEAKER_06

[3s]

Thank you.

Thank you.

Councilmember Kettle.

SPEAKER_03

[4m03s]

Thank you, Chair, and like our colleagues said, thank you for having the opportunity to have this session right now, because I think it's really important to have the transparency and basically the baselining on this topic, which is really important.

And in the broader context, too, you know, over the course of this budget process, I've had a number of CBAs and SLIs and, you know, some of them were submitted to, to be frank, to highlight, as I call, the unfunding of public safety.

and some others as well, working on some of the various, particularly public safety areas of work that we're doing.

But they were pulled because they weren't baked enough.

And baking, whether it's CBA or slide, there's a lot of different pieces to it.

Some is getting positions right, the policy pieces, but it's also the stakeholdering.

I think it's really important that, you know, kind of has alluded to I think a number of times is that this should have come up earlier in the process, you know, in terms of highlighting, you know, it's kind of like the unified care team.

It turns out that was a really big deal for the council, but it was not included in the previous briefing.

HSD didn't even talk to it at all, and I think if we had this kind of daylighting, this stakeholder-ing, this baking of this part of the budget bill, I think that would have helped a lot because, as noted, this came in last second, even though there was discussions with Local 27 and other parts of the fire ecosystem.

I think it's important for us to do this.

And to be frank, I think a number of the CVAs and slides that are still in the mix could be baked a little bit more as well, to be frank.

But on this point, Chair, I think it would be good moving into 2027, you know, in finance committee of maybe having an opportunity to look at the pensions, you know, to note, as noted here, that fire is now aligning with police.

But where are the other elements?

I think it would be very good for all of us to be baselined and and as I've said often, any budget work really should be predicated on a bunch of nice committee work to highlight.

And I think going into next year, a complete review of the pensions I think would be, because we're in this period of transition obviously because of the fiscal constraints that we have.

But in this area it's really important because it goes to people's livelihood, it goes to their ability to live and it's really sensitive.

So this is a super sensitive topic which just really needs to have that kind of review.

And speaking of stakeholder, I do appreciate the outreach from like Local 27 and others on this topic and I also like the fact that as part of this process, the fire overtime is the central tenet of this along with the Fire Boat Lashai, which is really crucial, as is the South Lake Union Fire Station, which is going to help both on the water side, but also the landslide, where we have essentially a brand new city that hasn't been kept up in terms of support, particularly on the firefighter fire side of things.

So I just wanted to highlight that piece, the speaking to, particularly because of the sensitivities of the subject, but also to get the base lining and also to make the ask that next year sometime during the course of finance committee that we do look at the pension system overall because I think it would be really good for us.

And so no questions except for to say one question, I guess I'm last.

So the Fire Pension Board is strong and solvent.

Is that correct, Director Panucci and Director Woodson?

SPEAKER_06

[7s]

And I hear a clarification that the fund is solvent, not necessarily the board.

The board is a group of people.

SPEAKER_03

[14s]

Sorry, the fund.

Did I say board?

The board's come up a lot.

So, you know, excuse me, the fire pension fund, not the actuarial, the fire pension fund, didn't mean to use the word board, is it strong and solvent?

Director Whitson and Panucci.

SPEAKER_16

[10s]

Correct.

And if you pass the legislation that's proposed related to this, you will be reaffirming the city Council and the City's commitment to fully fund the pension.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

And Director Panucci?

SPEAKER_11

[0s]

I concur.

SPEAKER_06

[6s]

Thank you.

Director- Councilmember Cattle, anything else?

Nothing at this time.

Councilmember Foster?

SPEAKER_01

[33s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

And thank you for this presentation and conversation.

I think it was very helpful, as other colleagues have already mentioned, to sort of daylight the mechanics of this and the thinking here.

And Chair, I put my hand up last because I just, listening to this conversation and how useful it was, I actually wanted to make a request that we could have Director Panucci return to the table later today for either our discussion of FG905A or CB12340, which are the sales tax-related items for children and families.

SPEAKER_06

[19s]

Thank you Council Member Foster for that request.

Helpful to receive those types of requests before the committee starts only to say that I asked Director Panucci to upend her schedule this morning.

So I don't know what her schedule looks like for the rest of the day.

So that's my only caveat.

Director Panucci.

SPEAKER_11

[2s]

I'll hang out in chambers.

SPEAKER_06

[5s]

Okay.

Thank you for changing your entire schedule today.

Back to you Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[8s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

I appreciate that.

I was unaware that Director Panucci would be at the table this morning or else I would have made that request in advance.

That's my only question.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_06

[1m38s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any other questions at this time?

Council Member Waters, you had all your questions answered last week.

You're feeling good?

Okay, that sounds good.

I've just, again, wanna highlight the two different tracks that we have today.

We have the $11 million per year, 22 total, and then we have the underlying legislation.

Those votes on those two have different levels of impact on either the chair's package or the entire budget overall.

I will ask for you to help me with some back the envelope math real quick.

We have right now $6 million worth of reserve that is held for four years for the fire pension fund.

We then also have $14.2 million spent funding the firefighter over time.

We have a million dollars set aside for the fire boat and the fire station sly.

And then we have about $150,000 or $100,000 set aside for the fire benefit district advisor.

that all to me on the back of my envelope here adds up to $22.3 or $22.4 million.

Is that similar math that we have right here?

And so to make the change to the $11 million per year, the $22 million total, All of those things would have to be reversed and if we wanted to have any of those items funded, we would have to refund or not fund.

Is that accurate or did I get that wrong?

SPEAKER_16

[8s]

Director.

As Council Member Rivera pointed out, we could also find alternative cuts elsewhere in the budget.

SPEAKER_06

[15s]

Yes, and this is where I'll ask the parliamentary or city clerk, for the items that are on today's agenda, we would have to stick to those items, is that correct?

Or we would have to suspend the rules and move backwards in the agenda, is that correct?

SPEAKER_08

[33s]

So to add any new items that are not on the published agenda, we would have to move to amend the agenda.

If you're wanting to go back and reconsider items that were already adopted, that would be to amend something previously adopted or to rescind actions you have taken in the past.

and that is typically the actions that are taken at the meeting on the 19th that's reserved for, but those are the more technical amendments and I would look to central staff on how much time that would need to prepare those types of resending and amending things previously adopted before we get to the meeting on the 19th.

SPEAKER_06

[31s]

Thank you, clerk.

I think for the quality control aspect, going backwards in the agenda.

The 19th is reserved for technical amendments.

So if we wanted to make these level of changes that Councilmember Rivera mentioned, that Director Whitson mentioned, we would need to do that in this course of business before we get to QA.

And so to accomplish anything that is not on the agenda, we would have to move backwards in the agenda.

Is that correct?

Or reconsider items?

SPEAKER_08

[2s]

We can't reconsider at this point.

We can resend though.

SPEAKER_06

[28s]

So that's just everything that's on the table right now.

And is that a three quarters vote or is it a...

With all nine present, we can do a majority.

Okay, thank you.

So that's the table for today.

I'm gonna turn it over to Director Panucci and Director Whitson for any final comments.

Sounds good.

Well, with that colleagues, any last questions?

Now we got Council Member Juarez.

SPEAKER_07

[1m13s]

Thank you.

I'm sorry.

I didn't mean to be so flippant the first time because we had some briefing and some information.

So thank you.

And I'm one of those nerds that had a Google Accutorial account and what that means in a budgetary and exactly how that works and looking at some other documents as well.

I just want to clarify, Mr. Chair, going back over if we rest on the assumption of transferring the Acura account funds to the pension fund, which is fully funded and we would meet our obligations, that the legislation that rests on that, that there's four pieces and, correct, those, okay, and those four pieces were the new fire station on South Lake Union, that's FAS002, FG904A, a transfer to, that's the actual transfer to the fire pension fund, and then at Sail Fire Department SFD-00B, which is to restore the overtime, and then SFD-005A, please correct me if I'm wrong, that would be the fire boat for Leschi.

Those are the only four pieces that would be affected, that we'd have to revisit for funding.

I'm going to go back to Director

SPEAKER_16

[12s]

Yeah, I think Deputy Director Chell should correct me, but there may need to be some other smaller adjustments made that we would need to identify.

SPEAKER_07

[30s]

So, okay, I know I have it in front of me, but now I can't find it, but what was the actual piece of legislation under the, that came, was it item number?

Was it CB121320 amending the 2026 budget ordinance or was it item 18 CB121319 firefighters pension fund?

Which was the actual one that changed it?

SPEAKER_14

[29s]

Deputy Director?

Council members, they do different things.

So the transfer happens in the year end supplemental and then item 18, which is Council Bill 121319 is the legislation to basically eliminate the actual real fund as an accounting structure.

And then there is a separate piece of legislation that also does some accounting technical fixes as well.

But the two major pieces are moving the balance in the year end supplemental and then eliminating the fund.

SPEAKER_07

[1s]

Mr. Chair?

SPEAKER_14

[0s]

Please.

SPEAKER_07

[9s]

Okay, great.

So that's item 15 and item 18. Those are the two.

Those are the two.

Okay, perfect.

I just wanted to make sure I knew what I was talking about.

Thank you.

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

SPEAKER_06

[9s]

Thank you.

And last question for Director Panucci.

If this money was sent back into this account, do you know what you would use it for next year?

SPEAKER_11

[6s]

It would just continue to sit in the actual URL account.

Okay.

SPEAKER_10

[1s]

If it was sent back to

SPEAKER_11

[16s]

like, well, I guess, sorry, let me clarify your question.

Are you saying if you undid the entire proposal or just what's in the, I mean, either way, it will either sit in fund balance in the fire pension fund or it would sit in the actuarial account.

SPEAKER_06

[5s]

Thank you.

And I can only assume that it would likely be used at some point in the future for something.

SPEAKER_11

[11s]

I would, yeah, at some point down the road, it would all be used to pay the fire pension benefits.

That eventuality would happen.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Thank you.

Director Whitson and Chow.

SPEAKER_16

[5s]

Just to confirm that its intended purpose is at some point to be used to pay fire pension benefits.

SPEAKER_14

[19s]

And I wanted to make just one clarifying comment.

If the transfer was not approved and did not go forward, then in addition to addressing the council balancing package, there is the mayor's piece that has not been identified how that would be addressed as well.

So there would be some additional monies we would have to find.

SPEAKER_06

[23s]

Okay.

Thank you.

Colleagues, since we had conversation continue before I was closing out, triple checking.

Any other further questions?

Not at this time.

Great.

Then we are going to move into item two.

I'm gonna check, do folks need a break?

Keep moving forward.

Keep moving forward.

Wonderful.

Clerk, would you please read item two into the record?

SPEAKER_08

[19s]

Agenda Item 2, Council Bill 121342, adopting a budget including a capital improvement program and position modifications for the City of Seattle for 2027 and creating positions exempt from civil service all by two thirds vote of the City Council for briefing discussion and possible amendments postponed at the November 13th, 2026 Select Budget Committee meeting.

SPEAKER_06

[2m04s]

Thank you.

At the Friday, November 13th Select Budget Committee meeting, Council Bill 121342 was amended to include items in Group A with the exception of the items removed in this group.

The committee then subsequently postponed consideration of this bill to continue the discussion of items removed from Group A.

16 items were removed from Group A, one of those items SDOT 3C was split into two separate CBAs and central staff will provide an overview of these two items when we reach that CBA.

We will now move into our discussion and vote on items removed from Group A, now in A2 for an individual vote.

We are gonna go in alphanumerical order with the exception of, and let me get it correct.

FG, we're gonna move FG 904A to the top of this section if there is no objection.

hearing no objection, we will move through starting with FG 904A and then we will move alphanumerically from Arts 9B through the Arts, through Dawn, through FAS, through FG, through Ledge, OED, SDOT, and then finally with SFD.

Are there any questions at this time?

I'm just gonna help move items.

So unless members, do you want to move your own items or do you care?

I'm just gonna move items.

So feel free to second.

With that, we're gonna move right into this first item.

So I will move FG 904A.

Is there a second?

Second.

Thank you.

It has been moved and seconded.

How we're gonna move through this is we will take central staff overview.

We'll call on the person that pulled the item, the sponsor, discussion, sponsor, and close.

So with that, over to you, Director Whitson.

I don't know if there's more presentation that you can give for this, but either way, over to you.

SPEAKER_16

[13s]

FG904A is the council budget action that would reduce general fund contributions to the fire pension fund by $11 million, as reflected in our discussion that we just had.

SPEAKER_06

[7s]

Thank you, and I believe Councilmember Foster and Rivera pulled this item, so Councilmember, nope, did I get my notes wrong?

SPEAKER_17

[9s]

I think she was 904, 905B, Councilmember Foster, it's the sales test.

I removed this one.

SPEAKER_06

[7s]

Does anyone want to take, who pulled 904?

You did, that's what, yeah.

Yeah.

Do you want to speak to why you pulled it?

SPEAKER_17

[19s]

Thank you, Chair.

We've had the conversation from the chambers.

I'm concerned about the closing of the actuarial account.

Seems like more conversation needed to have happened before that action took place and we are here today.

So I don't have anything further to say.

We've had now conversation about it.

SPEAKER_06

[8s]

All right.

Colleagues, further discussion?

Councilmember Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[9s]

Chair, just a clarifying question.

As we go to vote on these items, a yes vote affirmatively means we are passing it as originally intended.

Is that correct?

SPEAKER_06

[30s]

Thank you, Council Member Foster.

Yes, a yes vote on the item adds it to the budget.

A no vote does not.

Colleagues, any other questions?

Director Whitson, anything else to add?

and as the sponsor, I have nothing else to add myself.

Well, with that, colleagues, we're gonna jump right on in.

Central staff, or I guess clerk, if you can please call the roll on FG 904A.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Council Member Foster?

SPEAKER_01

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_00

[1s]

Aye.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_19

[8s]

Council Member Juarez?

Aye.

Council Member Kettle?

Aye.

Councilmember Lin.

Yes.

Councilmember Rink.

SPEAKER_12

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_19

[4s]

Councilmember Rivera.

No.

Councilmember Saka.

SPEAKER_12

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[5s]

Chair Strauss.

Aye.

Eight in favor, one opposed.

SPEAKER_06

[11s]

Thank you.

If G904A is attached to the budget, we will now move into Arts 9B.

So I move Arts 9B.

Is there a second?

SPEAKER_12

[0s]

Okay.

SPEAKER_06

[6s]

Thank you, moved and seconded to move Arts 9B.

Central staff, if you could give us a brief overview, please.

SPEAKER_16

[4s]

Arts 9B is a one-time contribution in 2027 of $500,000 for murals and activation in the Ballard Brewery District.

SPEAKER_06

[35s]

Thank you, say that 10 times fast.

Council Member Rivera, I just appreciate, and Council Member Kettle, I appreciated our conversation yesterday.

Colleagues, if we wanted to make, to amend this with a verbal amendment to open it up to the whole city, happy to do that.

I don't know if there's any discussion here.

So we're now open to discussion, colleagues.

Council Member Rivera.

Yeah, if you'd like to do that.

Would you like to make it citywide?

SPEAKER_17

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

Yeah, okay.

Okay.

Let's do it.

SPEAKER_17

[15s]

All right.

Thank you, Chair.

I move to amend, to verbally amend Arts 009B to have it be citywide versus just the Ballard Brewery District.

SPEAKER_06

[56s]

I see.

So if we're going to move right in, thank you, Council Member Rivera.

So if we're going to move right into this, central staff, are you able to put the text on the screen for us to see?

Yes.

And then if there's no objection, the rules will be suspended to allow a verbal amendment to this.

Hearing no objection, we will suspend the rules at this time.

and Council Member Rivera, I appreciate your partnership with this.

I would just say if maybe the substitution is removing Ballard Brewery District and adding City of Seattle.

So I'll let you make, the rules have been suspended, I'll let you make your motion and I'll second.

SPEAKER_17

[5s]

All right, I move to replace the Ballard Brewery District language with City of Seattle.

SPEAKER_06

[16s]

Second.

So it has been moved and seconded to make this change.

Clerk, do you need to call the roll or do we do by no objection?

Okay.

If there's no objection, this...

Director Whitson.

SPEAKER_16

[4s]

I'd also recommend removing the words brewery district from the title.

SPEAKER_06

[17s]

If there's no objection, the words brewery district will be removed from the title.

Hearing no objection, these changes are made.

Any further discussion on this amendment?

Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[18s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

I would love to hear more around the intent of how the Arts Department is meant to approach this if administered as a citywide program.

is it envisioned as an open application, or has there been any sort of further consideration given to the administration of this?

SPEAKER_06

[3s]

Thank you.

HB, do you have anything to share?

SPEAKER_13

[16s]

Hi, HB Central staff.

This is the first I'm hearing about it, but I can imagine that the Arts Department will either do a competitive process, or they may, if they're not able to do project management within the department, they would select someone who they believe could affect the work, because that's how they've done it in the past as well.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Thank you.

Councillor Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[9s]

Thank you so much.

And is there any intent or consideration given to prioritization of certain areas or other work that the Arts Department is doing?

HB?

SPEAKER_13

[3s]

Not that I'm aware of.

I think that would be a question for the Arts Department.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Thank you.

Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_13

[0s]

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_03

[1m11s]

Council Member Kettle.

Thank you, Chair.

I appreciate the questions from Council Member Foster.

It kind of goes to the baking of the CBA and I'm good with it, although I would have probably preferred to remain as a Burry district, even though elements of the Burry district spill over the cut into district seven.

and we can see the brewery district from the Queen Anne Hill, but there's advantages of having that cluster.

But I do think that we should build on it, and I will vote for this, but I think it goes to the point that I was saying earlier, that having the brewery district build on the idea, working with arts, and then looking to expand, maybe initially with the brewery district being broader than what it is currently delineated, but then to bring in the other parts of the city.

I think that is important too.

And it goes a little bit to the branding of the city.

I think that's in terms of what we're doing here and in terms of economic development.

I'm sure OED would like to have a role in this as well, which then again goes back to working this through.

So thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

Thank you, Councilmember Kettle.

Councilmember Rivera.

SPEAKER_17

[59s]

Thank you, colleagues.

I probably should have said why citywide.

I feel, well, first of all, I know murals were really important in the last administration and there was a focus on getting murals across the city, but particularly in the downtown quarter as part of downtown activation plan.

I do know that there are other areas of the city that I think would really appreciate having murals.

And so if we're going to spend half a million on murals, I think we should really make sure that other areas of the city also get to participate in the program.

And I know that, like I said, the last administration situated a number of murals.

So I think that both arts and perhaps OED already have had some practice in making sure that these murals, you know, doing the work of siting murals and doing the work that goes behind that.

So thank you.

SPEAKER_06

[8s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, further discussion?

I think it's very exciting to add more murals to our city.

Councilmember Foster, a new hand.

SPEAKER_01

[49s]

Yeah, thank you so much, Chair.

I will be voting no on this.

I appreciate the amendment to make it citywide and as Arts Chair, and also as somebody who's co-parent as a working artist whose full-time job is murals, actually.

I need to explain myself so my home life will be okay.

You know, for me, I'm looking at the Arts Department, I'm looking at the ad tax revenue declining over time, and I'm seeing the ads coming from Council that I think are increasingly specifying and directing the work in the arts department.

I'm aware of the fact that arts has had tons of applications come in for their care program and other infrastructure programs that they're unable to fund.

And I would prefer us to take an approach here at council that allows them to do a more deliberative process within the department.

So I will be voting no on this today.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_06

[4s]

Thank you.

And I love his murals.

Great Ballard Bridge.

It looks so good.

SPEAKER_01

[2s]

Yeah.

He's done some of the Ballard ones, yeah.

SPEAKER_06

[10s]

I'll just say, all right, no further discussion.

Arts 9B has been moved and seconded.

Clerk, will you please call the roll on Arts 9B?

SPEAKER_19

[10s]

Council Member Foster?

No.

Council President Hollingsworth?

Yes.

Council Member Juarez?

Yes.

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Council Member Lynn?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_19

[14s]

Council Member Rink?

No.

Councilmember Rivera.

Aye.

Councilmember Sacca.

Aye.

Chair Strauss.

Aye.

Six in favor, three opposed.

SPEAKER_06

[8s]

Thank you.

Arts 9B passes and will be added to the budget.

Moving on, I will move Arts 13B.

Is there a second?

SPEAKER_12

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_06

[9s]

Thank you.

It has been moved and seconded.

Back to HB.

if you wanna give us an overview and then we'll go on from there.

SPEAKER_13

[25s]

Sure.

Arts 13b would increase arts by 300,000 arts and culture fund using fund balance in the out years for a one-time basis in 2027 and 300,000 on a one-time basis in 2028 and adds 2.0 FTE sunset positions for arts program specialists to support Hope Corps creative placemaking and, as we discussed on Friday, the general need for the arts department to support the council ads that are proposed in this year's budget.

SPEAKER_06

[13s]

Thank you.

And I just realized why I was messing up on who pulled these.

I left those notes on my desk.

So with that, does anyone remember who you did?

Council member Rivera, over to you and then I'll speak to it.

Over to you.

SPEAKER_17

[1m23s]

Thank you, Chair.

The reason I pulled this was because it is creating two positions to administer what is about four, a little over $4 million additional for ads that we've made, is my understanding.

And so to me, it felt like to add two FTEs to just administer a little over 4 million seemed like a lot.

I think one FTE could probably do that work.

And so that's why I pulled this, particularly because even though these are sunset positions, once you hire folks, it is my experience at the city that then it is hard to let folks go, even though, again, they're sunset positions.

So to me, I don't want to create more positions than them.

to figure out how to make ongoing.

So I would have much preferred to have just one person administer this smaller addition.

It's four million is not small, but I think it definitely could be, the work could be done by one sets of position, not two.

So I didn't understand why chair added two to the CBA, unless there's something I don't know about.

SPEAKER_06

[23s]

Thank you, Councilmember Rivera, sponsor of this amendment.

I will just say through the conversations during the budget, the Councilmember proposals and then Chair's package and potential amendments in my conversations with HB.

HB provided me analysis of a number of different options to move forward with and this one seems like it made the best policy forward, which is why I chose it.

Councilmember Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[12s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

I'd like to ask HB to clarify for us the fund source of the $300,000.

I believe it comes from a reserve in the Office of Arts and Culture.

Is that accurate?

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Please, HB?

SPEAKER_13

[6s]

It comes from unreserved fund balance in the out years, so it does not take away from any particular program.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[10s]

Thank you.

So it's correct to say this is a fund balance that we anticipate that the Arts Department would have in the future.

We're pulling that forward to fund these positions.

SPEAKER_06

[3s]

HB?

That's correct.

Back to you, Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[9s]

Thank you.

And HB, can you share with us what those out years shows us in terms of revenue for the admissions tax?

SPEAKER_13

[18s]

Yes, I can share what the financial plan shows that is, you know, ad tax, as you know, is collected and estimated on a quarterly basis.

So projections can vary.

However, the financial plan shows a fund balance in 2030 of 667,000 as our end balance in 2030. So this would reduce that to 67,000.

Councillor Foster.

So the fund balance in 2030 with these ads goes down to 67,000.

SPEAKER_01

[8s]

and can you just make sure I'm correct here, that is with the updated ad tax forecast, is that correct?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

HP.

SPEAKER_01

[20s]

And then HB can you, the thing I'm trying to get to, so let me just say it because I can't remember the numbers, is there when the budget that was sent to us assumed ad tax revenue at a certain amount and then our updated October forecast gave us a lower projection for ad tax in the out years.

Can you share that difference with us please?

SPEAKER_13

[13s]

Yes, I can share the difference.

However, it's important to note that not all ad tax dollars go directly to the arts department.

So the reduction was 2.2 million.

However, some of that comes out of the arena payment as well.

So that does not all entirely affect the arts department.

SPEAKER_01

[7s]

Thank you.

And I'll pause to see if you can share with us the amount that impacts the arts department.

And if we don't have that available, that's okay.

SPEAKER_13

[2s]

I can find that within two minutes.

SPEAKER_01

[1m23s]

Thank you.

Chair, the reason I ask these questions and the point that I really want to make here is I will vote for this because I think that Arts actually needs these positions to administer the ads that we have made and if they don't have these positions they cannot administer the ads that came from Council this year and I think that's not a good position to set the department up for or to set the council members up for who have had specific ads to the arts department.

But I do want to highlight for us sort of the cost, if you will, not just financially, but in terms of what this means for the out-year projection for the arts department.

And again, sort of reiterating what I see is an increased amount of direction coming from here to the arts department, which is something I hope that we will move away from in the future.

I love arts.

I love getting to chair arts.

It's a privilege.

And arts are certainly really important economic driver.

We had so many people down here in City Hall early on in the budget process talking about the way arts intersects with violence reduction and so many other pieces.

But when we are making these changes to their budget, it does have an impact on their need for staff, which then in turn is having an impact on their budget in the out years.

So just wanted to sort of share that explanation, see if I bought HB two minutes or not, but those are my comments.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_06

[3s]

Well said.

HB, need more time?

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

I'm just doing a little math here.

Unless my colleagues have it, I have two more minutes, but it's going great.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Councilmember Frost, you still have the floor.

SPEAKER_01

[13s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

HB, I'm happy to take that as an email follow-up.

I apologize.

I usually will prep you or share in advance if I'm going to ask detailed questions.

So thank you for your fast response and all of your work, HB.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_06

[3s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Rivera, followed by Kettle.

SPEAKER_17

[7s]

Thank you, Chair.

I meant to ask the question, too, about the $600,000 we're adding here, what it's specifically going to fund.

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

HB?

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

It would go to fund the two positions.

They'd come out to just about exactly $600,000.

Member?

SPEAKER_17

[8s]

So we're spending $600,000 to administer for about $4 million.

Sorry, I thought this also included some other arts.

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

And Director Whitson, and then we'll come back.

SPEAKER_16

[21s]

As drafted, it's somewhat flexible.

You see positions added and funding added.

You're not seeing that funding directly tied to the position, so it would be up to the Office of Arts and Culture to determine whether or not they need one or two positions.

And then any remaining funds would be left over for other arts programs.

SPEAKER_17

[1s]

We don't know which.

SPEAKER_16

[11s]

Yeah, I think they've indicated that two is what they think they need to administer the funds that Council is adding.

But, yeah, they could add one or two.

SPEAKER_17

[12s]

No, I meant what other programs, if they're They're not using the whole $600,000 for two positions, and they're doing programming.

We don't know what that programming will be.

Yeah.

SPEAKER_16

[8s]

The funds are going into the Creative Placemaking Division, so anything that that division does would be eligible for those funds.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Council Member.

SPEAKER_17

[7s]

Thank you, Chair, but we're not dictating where that money is going, just that they get to use it for whichever purpose.

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Director.

SPEAKER_17

[4s]

Okay, just want to clarify.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_03

[1m08s]

Thank you.

Council Member Kettle.

Thank you, Chair.

I put my hand up for a couple of reasons.

One, to give Council Member a little bit more time with central staff.

but also to highlight that I appreciate Council Member Foster's points, because I talked about having these amendment proposals being baked, and the big issue is whether the department is able to digest them.

And so to your question and point, I think that's really important.

And arts and culture, I've had many meetings, obviously, because the majority of the major arts and culture venues and so forth are located in my district.

It's really important to support arts and culture, to ensure the health of the arts and culture community, and I'm mindful that they don't necessarily have the staff and so forth to really, you know, work the issues that they have already.

And so I appreciate the line of questionings because the ability to digest these is also important.

I don't know, 90 seconds I got you there at least, I don't know.

Thank you, Councilmember Kettle.

HB?

SPEAKER_13

[14s]

So half a million is the difference in the arena reserve payment based on the October revenue forecast.

So I'm trying to back it out to understand exactly how the 2.2 million affects just 2027, but in terms of the arena reserve payment, it's a half million dollar difference.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Councilmember Foster, anything else?

SPEAKER_01

[53s]

I'll just state briefly, thank you for that HB and thanks again for working so quickly.

Colleagues, I think this is something we should just be paying attention to in the long run as we are dealing with the budget is the potential ongoing decline for ad tax revenue.

And I appreciate Council President Hollingsworth for the slide that she sponsored that includes looking at ad tax revenue for the long term.

And I just want to make sure we're monitoring that.

We obviously have ad tax that's going to other departments this year.

for great purposes.

We love Festall.

I don't wanna reopen that again.

But as we both see ad tax supporting other departments, Seattle Center and Parks, and ad tax revenue declining, and council ads that are specifying action in the arts department, I'm just concerned about where we may be heading with the big picture.

So I believe I've made my point, and if you hear me make it again next year, you heard it here first.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_06

[3s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any further discussion on this item?

SPEAKER_17

[2s]

If I could just do my last.

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

Please, Council Member Rivera.

SPEAKER_17

[2m03s]

Council Member Foster, I appreciate your comments.

And I know the reserve pieces we agree on in general, all the reserves and the impacts that has for budget into the future.

So I really appreciate your comments.

And I will say, I know that we all love and support the arts in general.

So I feel like often we feel like we have to say things if we're going to take an action that we think people may not like and I just don't think that's even on the table because we do support in this city the arts so much that we've dedicated a fun source to it.

I will say that, you know, departments, not just arts, all departments say, you know, we can't do the work unless we have more staff or we want to be able to be who determines what work gets done.

It's really hard also because by the time the budget gets to us, the executive is making determinations about what will be happening in those departments and then it is through the budget process that we're able to allocate some funds to departments to address the things that our constituents would like to see.

So to me I've heard this a lot before Councilmember Foster but I do appreciate what you're saying and Anyway, so wanted just to say that and I'm not going to be supporting this add to today because it does go into the future reserves and also because the funding is unspecified.

The ask was not from the department necessarily on the additional whatever this is going to fund.

And to Councilmember Kettle's point about CBA's not being fully baked, or at least with level of detail that gives transparency as to what this is funding aside from the positions.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_06

[9s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any final comments?

Seeing no final comments, will the clerk please call the roll on Arts 13B, please.

SPEAKER_19

[29s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

Yes.

Councilmember Juarez Yes Councilmember Kettle Aye Councilmember Lin Yes Councilmember Rink Yes Councilmember Rivera No Councilmember Saka Aye Chair Strauss Eight in favor, one opposed.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_06

[24s]

Arts 13B passes and is added to the budget.

I will now move Dawn 1C.

Is there a second?

Second.

Thank you.

It's been moved and seconded to add Don 1C to the budget.

Central staff, if you'd like to brief this item, and then Council President Hogsworth, you pulled your own amendment.

SPEAKER_00

[3s]

I sure did.

I don't know if that's a good idea.

SPEAKER_15

[31s]

Council Members, good morning.

Eric McConaughey, Council Central Staff.

The CBA would increase appropriations in the Department of Neighborhoods, sometimes we could say DON, so if you hear me say that, that's what that is, by $3.2 million for the Central District and Southeast Seattle Reinvestment Fund in 27, and $2.8 million for the same purpose in 2028. Each of those would be one time.

It would also add one FTE strategic advisor position to establish and support this program.

The change today, though, I think I'll let the CP talk about.

SPEAKER_00

[3s]

Yes, thank you, Eric.

Oh, sorry, I'm sorry.

SPEAKER_06

[7s]

Council President, if you wanna speak about your item and then I'll suspend the rules and we'll make the verbal amendment.

SPEAKER_00

[1m18s]

Chair and colleagues, yes, I did pull this and the reason why I'm really grateful for everyone's support on this for the Central District and South End Fund and I spoke about obviously why this is important but the reason why I pulled this today specifically is because I am going to make changes where I'm going to take out all the organization's names in this and the reason why is I don't want language to cause confusion to the integrity of what will be a transparent RFP process.

And so that was my fault because this should have been left alone.

I had other groups that I wanted to make sure knew that they were a part of this type of fund, but I wanna make sure that we can, I don't want the language to cause confusion.

Looking forward to working with Department of Neighborhoods because the initial intent was to illustrate examples of organizations that are eligible to show the breadth of community impact, but there's no way for me to comprehensively add every organization that would be eligible, and there will be a ton because it's a geographical location.

So that was my intent of pulling it so I can remove the organizations but keep the language of the amendment.

Thank you, colleagues.

SPEAKER_06

[23s]

Thank you.

At this time, Councilmember Rivera, a new hand.

So at this time, if there's no objection, the rules will be suspended to allow for a verbal amendment to this item.

Hearing no objection, the rules are suspended.

And Council President Hollingsworth, would you like to describe line by line or would central staff like to present what the changes are?

SPEAKER_00

[34s]

Absolutely, I have the changes.

I would love if that's okay.

That's great.

You all gave me the language, by the way, so I think we know.

So I would like to strike the organizations that are named in the first sentence of the second paragraph that reads, revitalize Seattle's Central District and Southeast Community.

And we would just add a period after that.

Yep, and we would delete those organizations and then begin with council intends that don.

And that would be my simple change, colleagues.

Pretty straightforward.

SPEAKER_06

[3s]

Thank you.

Central staff, anything to clarify there?

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Just to say that this was sort of before you before.

SPEAKER_06

[22s]

Sorry, anything to clarify on those words because I'm gonna take that.

Wonderful.

So with that colleagues, if there is no objection, these changes will be added to this amendment.

Hearing no objection, those changes are made.

Central staff or Council President, anything else to add here?

SPEAKER_00

[5s]

No, I just, I really appreciate you all taking the time to help me make the changes.

Thank you so much.

SPEAKER_06

[8s]

Thank you.

Anything else?

You're good.

Colleagues, any questions?

Seeing no questions, will the clerk please call the roll on Don 1C, please?

SPEAKER_19

[6s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_00

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[4s]

Council Member Juarez?

Councilmember Kettle.

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Councilmember Lin.

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Councilmember Rink.

SPEAKER_02

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_19

[4s]

Councilmember Rivera.

Aye.

Councilmember Saka.

SPEAKER_12

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[4s]

Chair Strauss.

Aye.

Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_06

[22s]

Thank you.

Don 1C passes and is added to the budget.

I will now move FAS 2A.

Is there a second?

Second.

Thank you.

It has been moved and seconded to your FAS 2A.

Central staff, would you like to brief this item?

And then I believe Council Member Rink pulled it, and then I'll move to the sponsor, Council Member Kettle.

SPEAKER_16

[14s]

Right.

FAS2A would add $150,000 to the Department of Finance and Administrative Services for a study of a future fire station on South Lake Union.

SPEAKER_06

[3s]

Thank you.

Council Member Rink, you pulled this amendment.

Would you like to speak to it?

SPEAKER_02

[38s]

Thank you, Chair Strauss.

Colleagues, I'll be brief.

I pulled this amendment primarily to give time and space and really the policy option to pursue an alternative in case we wanted to take action to try and essentially undo some of the changes related to a firefighter's pension that was included in the Chair's package.

This is nothing against a new fire station at all in South Lake Union, to be very clear.

I'm actually a co-sponsor on this one, but rather my pulling it was in service of the larger discussion that we were having related to firefighters' pensions and to give us the policy option in case we wanted to pull and make adjustments to what was included in the chair's package.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Sounds good.

SPEAKER_03

[1m21s]

Councilmember Kettle, anything to add?

Thank you, Chair.

Thank you, Councilmember Rain, because it was tied to it.

I understand and appreciate the reasoning for it.

It also gives me an opportunity to highlight, we almost had bingo on this.

I think I see at least seven names, but it also allows me to, you know, to kind of build on the point I've been speaking to earlier today is that in terms of baking something, this has been baked for a long time.

It goes to the work that we did related to public safety element within the comp plan process because we have literally built a brand new city in South Lake Union.

It's incredible.

You know, being around the world, this kind of thing only happens in Africa and Asia where there's, you know, some little rules and those kinds of things.

But we had this built up in a mature American economy and mature American City of Seattle.

And as part of that, we do have to address the needs of this essentially new city within the city, but also the challenges that we see with Lake Union on the maritime side.

And to further talk about baking the process, I've had numerous meetings with FIRE to include on the ground, which goes to the public-private partnership point in the first paragraph, the central staff summary.

This is something that needs to be worked on and this feasibility study, this CBA will help us do that.

So colleagues, I ask for your support.

SPEAKER_06

[9s]

Thank you.

Any further comments?

Any further comments?

Seeing no further comments, will the clerk please call the roll on adopting FAS 2A, please.

SPEAKER_19

[9s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

Council member Juarez.

Aye.

Council member Kettle.

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Council member Lynn.

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_19

[12s]

Council member Rink.

Yes.

Council member Rivera.

Aye.

Council member Sacca.

Aye.

Chair Strauss.

Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_06

[40s]

Thank you.

The motion passes and FAS...

Bingo.

Bingo.

FAS 2A is adopted to the agenda.

The next item adopted to the budget, the next item on the agenda is FG 2A, which I pulled and I will be withdrawing.

This was the VRAP funding as this was the amendment that I partnered with the mayor's office on.

before that legislation was vetoed.

And so if there's no objection, this item is withdrawn.

Hearing no objection, the item is withdrawn.

We'll move on to FG903B.

I move FG903B, is there a second?

SPEAKER_00

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_06

[9s]

It is moved and seconded.

I'm gonna turn over to Council Central staff.

And then Council Member Foster, you pulled the item.

SPEAKER_16

[20s]

FG903B is a technical amendment to support a balanced Chair's package.

It would transfer $18 million of Jumpstart Fund balance in 2027 and $8.1 million of Jumpstart balance in 2028 to the General Fund.

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

Thank you.

Council Member Foster, you are recognized.

SPEAKER_01

[49s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

I pulled this item because I believe it warrants further discussion.

I think I made some of those points during committee last week, but just to restate them in terms of, I believe it's important for us to understand the impact of the jumpstart transfer, both on the budget now, and sort of more deeply understanding what necessitates this transfer, as well as having a better understanding of what this sets us up to do in the future.

So with that, I think I'll start maybe with a question to Central Staff Chair.

If you can just speak to what changes in the budget necessitate this $18 million transfer this year.

To back up with, my understanding is this is council-generated action to transfer an additional resource from JumpStart that was not included in the mayor's proposed budget.

Is that correct?

SPEAKER_06

[3s]

I'm going to turn this over to central staff.

SPEAKER_05

[26s]

Tom, welcome.

Good morning, committee.

Tom Mikesell, council central staff.

So that is accurate.

So the October forecast provided additional resources to both the general fund and to the JumpStart fund in 26 through 2030 and this transfer in the biennium essentially moves resources from the jumpstart fund to the general fund where they support additions in the chairs package.

SPEAKER_01

[15s]

Councilmember Foster.

Thank you so much.

So the transfer supports the resources that are in the chairs package that we've voted on through package A and that we're discussing today, and that's what this Jumpstart Fund to General Fund is helping support those ads.

SPEAKER_05

[3s]

Tom?

That's correct.

Great.

Back to you, Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[19s]

Thank you, Chair.

And then the other question that I have, and I know we're going to be having a conversation later today about the out years.

Can you speak to the second-to-last sentence in the budget action, which is that the CBA anticipates an additional $11 million transfer in 2029?

Tom?

SPEAKER_05

[20s]

That's correct.

So that's within the context of the six-year financial plan.

So there is an additional transfer of $11 million that's just penciled in in that financial plan, similar to the way that the executive makes adjustments in the future years that would transfer that amount from the Jumpstart Fund to the general fund.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[21s]

Thank you.

So is it correct to say, with the budget that we're contemplating now, with the ads that we have as a council, that were we to pass all of those ads and pass the final package, we're sort of necessitating an additional $11 million transfer in order to keep the budget balanced in 2029?

Back to you, Tom.

SPEAKER_05

[8s]

to balance the financial plan projection in the future, similar to the way that the executive balanced their financial plan in the future.

Correct.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Thank you.

Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[24s]

Thank you.

So I know we're going back to between budget and financial plan.

And I think what I'm trying to get clarity on here is, if we get into our forward spaceship, and we anticipate sitting here in 2029, the actions that we're taking today in order to be balanced in 2029, we would need to do an additional $11 million transfer.

SPEAKER_05

[8s]

Tom?

That's correct.

So if all assumptions as we speak today remain accurate, that is correct.

SPEAKER_01

[9s]

Fantastic.

And then-oh, thank you, Chair.

And then can you speak to where this leaves the Jumpstart Fund balance for 27, 28, and 29?

SPEAKER_05

[16s]

based on the chair's package and the item that we've been discussing this morning, the balance in the, so the unreserved balance net of the amount held in the payroll expense tax revenue stabilization account would be balanced to zero.

SPEAKER_01

[15s]

Thank you.

And that's balanced at zero for 27, 28, and 29. Is that accurate or it's just 29?

That would be 29 and 30. 29 and 30. And it's, sorry, Chair.

And can you speak to the amount for 27 and 28, please?

SPEAKER_05

[8s]

The 27 balance ending would be $40 million.

The 28 balance would be similarly balanced to zero.

SPEAKER_01

[20s]

Okay.

So 27, there's 40 million.

28 and 29, that's when we go into the zero.

That's correct.

Thank you.

And then this is based on, I know you all do, I don't think you use these words, high, medium, and low.

That's how I rate them in my head.

But the optimistic and sort of neutral forecasts.

Can you speak to which forecasts this is based on?

SPEAKER_05

[7s]

Yes, all of the numbers we've been talking about are based on the baseline forecast, which has, I believe, 55 percent probability.

SPEAKER_01

[17s]

Thank you.

The 55% probability is a new one for me.

I didn't realize that.

Thank you, Tom.

And then can you speak to if we are not at the baseline forecast, if we are at the pessimistic or the optimistic forecast, do we know where that would leave us for 27, 28, and 29?

SPEAKER_05

[9s]

I do not know the precise variance that we'd be facing, but by virtue of the pessimistic forecast being lower, the budget would not be balanced.

SPEAKER_01

[18s]

Thank you.

So I think that means we have a close eye to keep on JumpStart revenue as always, because if we are coming in under projection, under baseline, rather, for 2028, we would be looking at an unbalanced fund for JumpStart.

Is that correct?

SPEAKER_05

[5s]

that would hold true for any year in the forecast, 26 through 30, correct?

SPEAKER_01

[37s]

Thank you.

I also know there's been a lot of discussion this budget cycle, as apparently there always is, around one-time ads versus ongoing ads.

And so this budget contemplates a number of ads.

I have some myself that I quite like.

I'm very excited to be supporting the Georgetown farmers market.

But my understanding is that when we talk about the budget being zero, or excuse me, not the budget, I apologize, the Jumpstart Fund balance being balanced at zero in those out years, we are assuming it's balanced at zero because those ads are no longer on the books in 2029. Is that correct?

SPEAKER_05

[16s]

That is correct.

And I would even go further to harken back to the discussion during policy considerations phase that there are assumptions that the executive is making with regards to further reductions in the Jump Star Fund as well.

And that would be required to balance also.

SPEAKER_01

[3s]

I apologize.

Tom, can you repeat that last part?

You got a little far away from the mic for me.

SPEAKER_05

[23s]

Apologies.

So the the jumpstart financial plan as submitted by the executive includes reductions to certain departments in 29 and 30 that would be required to balance and so all of the assumptions including that one-time items Do indeed take a one-time nature and go away in the year that they end All that would be folded into having a balanced jumpstart fund

SPEAKER_01

[18s]

Thank you.

And so said differently, you know, the plan from the executive assumes reductions in 2029 that are not yet made in order to be balanced in the out years.

And then it also assumes that our one-time ads are, in fact, one time.

And with both of those assumptions combined, that is how we get to zero in 2029.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

That's correct.

SPEAKER_01

[1s]

Thank you so much.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_06

[4s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, further discussion?

Council Member Rivera.

SPEAKER_17

[2m11s]

Thank you, Chair, and thank you, Council Member Foster.

I know you have concerns about reserves, as I said earlier today, and so I share your concerns about reserves, particularly the Jumpstart reserves, because the Jumpstart reserves is my understanding, they're not at 100% of where we should be for best practice.

I think the prior administration, started to get us on that path and this administration left that in place so I appreciate this executive leaving that in place so that we would get to the by the end of the next four years where we should be in terms of best practice for the level of reserves we should have for this fund.

So I am concerned that Council continues to take from the Jumpstart reserves to fund, you know, to fund things rather than engage in a difficult but what I think necessary review of the budget and seeing where we could take from the budget rather than have to constantly deplete the reserves because if something should happen at the city, we rely on reserves to be that backstop.

so I really have concerns about utilizing reserves and especially because this fund is not fully funded in terms of what we should be having in there for best practice for reserves.

So I am concerned about this for those reasons.

I'm not gonna vote for this today.

I want us to get to a place where we really are funding reserves to the level of if we should have something like an earthquake or any other emergency at the city that we have a reserves on all our funds to be able to tap from so that we're not in a bad spot as we would be with the constant rating of these reserves.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_06

[33s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, further discussion?

Further discussion?

And at our last conversation, Tom and I had the conversation, it was just within the last two years that this transfer was going in the opposite direction where we were sending general fund in to support Jumpstart.

And so it is two funds that are used very similarly at this point in the last few years.

With that, colleagues, if there is no further discussion, we will move on.

And clerk, will you please call the roll on FG903B.

SPEAKER_19

[10s]

Council Member Foster?

No.

Council President Hollingsworth?

Aye.

Council Member Juarez?

Aye.

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Council Member Lynn?

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Council Member Rink?

SPEAKER_02

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_19

[10s]

Council Member Rivera?

No.

Council member Saka.

Chair Strauss.

Six in favor, three opposed.

SPEAKER_06

[10s]

Thank you.

The next item was already voted on FG 904A.

We will move on to FG 905A.

So I move FG 905A.

Is there a second?

SPEAKER_00

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_06

[20s]

It has been moved and seconded, and Director Panucci, thank you for upending your entire day to be with us.

We greatly appreciate it.

Feel free to join us.

I see Jen Labreck is here.

I'll have you speak to it.

Central staff, over to you, and then Council Member Foster, you pulled the item, so we'll come back to you.

SPEAKER_16

[18s]

I'll provide a brief background, which is that the state legislature authorized the city to levy a 0.01% tax for families and children.

This council budget action would recognize revenues from such a tax.

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

Thank you.

Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[60s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

I pulled this item because I wanted to make sure we had further discussion, and although Friday feels like a long time away, it was just the other day, and when we were discussing this in committee, I was looking to understand a little bit more about what the county was intending to do with these resources versus the city's plan, and I thought it was just a great opportunity when I walked in and saw Director Panucci here today to see if we could get a bit more information as she was referenced in our committee on Friday.

So with that, maybe I'll just start and I'll repeat a little bit of the question that I had on Friday, which is, and Chair, if I may direct it to Director Panucci, If you can just speak to what the city's current plan is, and Dr. Panucci, I'm not sure if you were watching on Friday, but it sounded like you were, okay, you did, great, fantastic.

If you could just speak to what the city's current plan is with the children and family sales tax revenue as it compares to the county's plan, to the extent that you can speak for the county, but here we go.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Director, welcome.

SPEAKER_11

[3m37s]

Thank you.

Again, for the record, Ali Panucci, budget director.

So I will do my best to answer those questions.

So I will say the mayor's proposed budget did not propose to implement this tax at the city level.

So the proposed budget didn't purport to use this revenue.

And so there is nothing in the proposed budget.

From my understanding of how this is being proposed, is this is essentially a strategy to free up general fund resources.

So this money, this new sales tax, which the county already adopted, And so either way, people would be paying this sales tax who live in Seattle.

And if the county adopts it, they collect all the revenue unless a city also adopts it, and then that portion is credited against it.

So this essentially will reduce the amount of revenue the county was assuming to collect by about $4 million per year.

year.

And so as I understand it in the balancing package, it essentially would be supplanting existing general fund.

It is not increasing spending in services for children and families, which are the eligible uses for this fund.

There is a proviso in the chair's balancing package.

So in 2027, My understanding is that that portion of the sales tax or that portion of the proviso, which is on a portion of the mayor's $37 million investment in shelter, would be used to cover half of the cost of a family shelter that was already assumed in the mayor's $37 million investments.

in shelter, in the budget, and then a portion would be used for a one-time investment for capital costs for youth care.

And Jen Labreck or Chair Strauss may be able to speak more to that.

Because we were not, the executive was not part of wasn't consulted on the development of the balancing package in terms of making these after the fact.

I've talked with the county to understand what they were planning to use and what they transmitted.

And a portion of their plan was to fund, to provide investments in youth care and a family shelter Mary's Place, I believe, or the Glen Hotel is what it's being consulted about.

And so in my discussions with Chair Strauss, the idea was to provide a portion of the funds so that the investment in the Glen Hotel could proceed as planned.

And then the one-time investment, I think we can make work in 27 one time, coming out of the mayor's $37 million shelter plan, some details still to be worked out.

and then moving forward would just be used to pay for ongoing investments in youth and family shelter.

I don't know yet what's going to come out the other side of the county's budget process and how this change at the city level will impact programs located in Seattle that they were planning to invest in.

I have had a conversation with the budget chair at the county, and we're committed to continuing to work together to understand those implications, but I can't speak fully to what those impacts might be at this time.

SPEAKER_01

[9s]

Thank you so much, Director Panucci.

Thank you, Chair.

I'll just pause to see if there's anything that central staff wants to add before I ask a couple of follow-up questions.

That's all right, Chair?

SPEAKER_09

[1m57s]

All right, I will add that there are a number of CBAs that are either part of Group A or part of Group B that do add funding for families and children, so are consistent with the proposed use of the sales tax under the RCW.

I don't wanna define those as a spend plan, for example, for the sales tax.

They're not that, but they are new funding that's been added that is consistent with the use of the sales tax.

And I can run through those if you're interested.

Yes, okay, I'm getting a yes.

So that includes HSD 026A, which is 300,000 for Family Works, which provides food resources or addresses food insecurity and provides resources for families.

I did not write down the amounts for the rest of these.

There's HSD041A, which provides health and wellness activities for Native youth.

There's HSD 056A for Bird Bar Place, which addresses disparities in maternal health outcomes.

There's HSD 057 for the Atlantic Street Center, which provides an afterschool program for youth.

There's HSD 058, which provides funding for the CD Panthers.

HSD, oh goodness.

I didn't write down this number.

This is the 167,000 proviso, also for Mary's Place, but not for the Glen Shelter, specifically to provide services for homeless families.

And then SPR 18, which provides funding for the Red Barn Ranch.

So those are all examples of new funding that is proposed by council that supports uses consistent with this new sales tax.

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[14s]

Thank you so much, Chair, and thank you, both Director Panucci and Jen LeBrecq.

Jen, for the ads that you just mentioned, and I'm sorry, I should have asked you this before, do you know if those are one-time or if those are ongoing?

Back to you, Jen.

SPEAKER_09

[8s]

Scanning through these, I'm going to look through them very quickly.

I believe that these are all one-time.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Back to you, Councilmember Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[20s]

Thank you so much.

And then I just wanted to ask, is there any work kind of contemplated in, let me look at the number here, in 905A or in the corresponding legislation that we need to adopt that speaks to sort of the long-term or ongoing spend plan?

SPEAKER_09

[9s]

At this time, there is nothing in the legislation or anywhere else that addresses a long-term spend plan for this funding.

Okay.

SPEAKER_01

[1m32s]

Back to you, Council Member Foster.

Thank you, Chair.

So my understanding of this right now is the following, and so I'm just going to state it as a fact and then make sure that it's correct.

So, you know, as we know, the county adopted this earlier in the year.

they developed their intended spend plan.

We have identified that we, you know, cities have the opportunity to take this revenue, return the revenue to the cities that's generated within our city for the county, as was contemplated by the way the legislature wrote this.

So what we're looking at today is the budget add and then later on we'll be looking at the legislation to return those resources.

And the reason I say that is I got a couple of constituent emails that said, please don't increase the sales tax.

And I think, as you already spoke to, this is action that has already been taken.

It's just a question of whether it's disseminated through the county or the city.

So important to be really clear about that.

And what I started off looking for was sort of a side-by-side comparison.

and just out of interest of trying to understand what the county was contemplated and what we're contemplating.

And my current understanding is we're taking the revenue and we're supplanting some existing spends for children and families to free up a general fund use for other uses.

And then we have some identified spends in 2027 and maybe in 2028 that also fall under the use of this sales tax.

Did I get that correct?

SPEAKER_06

[5s]

Sorry, I'm gonna go Director Whitson, Director Panucci, and then back to Jen.

SPEAKER_16

[24s]

I would say that the council budget actions contemplate spending more than $4 million on increased services to families and children.

and I wouldn't necessarily say that we're supplanting general fund expenses because our general fund expenses for those purposes is higher than the revenue that would be received through this resource.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Thank you.

Director Panucci.

SPEAKER_11

[1m04s]

Yeah, I would just clarify, if those increases are one time, this revenue is ongoing.

As a matter of business, we have to actually identify annually and be reporting on the use of these funds.

And so, absent a specific fund plan, I wouldn't tag it to one time spending because as a sort of audit and accounting issue, that will be more challenging to track year over year.

So while we can argue the semantics, I would say it is supplanting because it's an ongoing revenue source that is necessary to keep the general fund in balance in the out years without these new investments.

And if they're not ongoing, these new investments are not being funded in 2020. 29, existing ongoing expenses are being funded by the sales PAC based on the current financial projections.

So I just want to, for the record for clarity, I would likely tag these to ongoing investments that are in the base budget, unless these other investments are ongoing.

SPEAKER_06

[4s]

Well said.

Jen, do you have anything to add here?

Councilmember Foster, you still have the floor.

SPEAKER_01

[25s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

Just on the question of reporting, and I ask this, and I'm happy to yield to the Chair of Human Services, but I ask this with my Vice Chair hat on here, is I believe that reporting that Director Panucci you mentioned is reporting to the state, but are we contemplating currently any reporting to committees in terms of the spend plan prior to when that is provided to the state?

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

Anyone at the committee table at this point?

SPEAKER_09

[5s]

There's no reporting being contemplated at this time at a local level.

SPEAKER_06

[5s]

Thank you.

Director Panucci, anything else to add here?

I can send it back to Council Member Foster.

Floor is still yours.

SPEAKER_11

[14s]

Yeah, I don't typically report at that level of detail, but would be happy to come to committee next year and talk about how we are doing it without needing to have a formal reporting requirement added to the legislation.

SPEAKER_06

[7s]

Thank you, Director Panucci, enunciating the point that we do not need to have slides to receive information.

Back to you, Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[19s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

Those are my questions.

This was very helpful in terms of understanding how we're contemplating the use of this sales tax revenue.

I appreciate you spending your time returning to the table this morning, Director Panucci.

And Chair, thank you for allowing us to have Director Panucci back at the table.

That's all.

SPEAKER_06

[5s]

Thank you, Councilmember Foster.

And Councilmember Foster, do you need Director Panucci for any other points today?

SPEAKER_01

[15s]

I'm not anticipating that.

I think I said either this or the legislation, and I think these questions answered.

I mentioned two, but it was both related to the same bill.

Good to go.

Thank you.

Councilmember Kettle, followed by Rivera.

SPEAKER_03

[1m31s]

Thank you, Chair.

I just want to take the opportunity, because I've said this before, and this just highlights it once again.

that in terms of state, county and local action, governmental action, across property tax, sales tax, utility rates, departmental fees like permit fees and the like, that they have a cumulative effect.

I recognize this is very small, but then again, it's the cumulative.

Earlier this year, I had an amendment to make it basically a councilmanic reserve, not take it away, just make it a reserve to lower the immediate impact on the sales tax.

That failed.

It's really important because we're gonna see later, particularly the departmental fees, so forth, and the various pieces of legislation.

And we need to keep the big picture on this combination.

And again, the only person I think that does that is State Treasurer Pellicciotti.

Otherwise, I don't think anybody in Olympia thinks about it, or else here in the county and the city.

The last thing, too, and to the points kind of made, The county is well down the track.

I had conversations with King County Councilmember Barone on this.

and I do think that we should be looking, and I think we have, in terms of doing right by ensuring that the areas that the county was looking to support are supported, and I think that's important, particularly because of the one-two combination that we have here.

So thank you, Chair.

Thank you, Council Member Kettle.

Council Member Rivera.

SPEAKER_17

[9s]

Thank you, Chair.

Apologies, can you confirm, so is youth care getting funding?

I just missed what you said earlier, apologies.

SPEAKER_09

[49s]

That's a good question because I didn't talk about that CBA.

So there is another CBA in addition to the list I provided, which is HSD 028B.

That does not provide additional funding.

It imposes a proviso on 2.8 million in the Human Services Department addressing homelessness BSL.

There's two intended uses of that funding.

One intended use is to fund in part or in whole the Glen Shelter run by Mary's Place, which is a family shelter.

And then the second intended use is to allow Covenant House to purchase or acquire four properties from youth care, which have about 90 to 100 beds.

And that would result in those beds becoming operational again.

They have not been operational for a period of time.

SPEAKER_06

[5s]

Councilman Rivera.

Director Whitson.

SPEAKER_16

[7s]

Yeah.

and that was part of the consent package that was voted on on Friday.

Thank you.

Councilmember Rivera.

SPEAKER_17

[1m16s]

Thank you.

I thought that was the case, but since we were talking about this, I wanted to really confirm that that was the case because YouthCare is or was in the D4, really appreciate the work they do on behalf of teens.

I know YouthCare ran into some issues.

They have since they had since restructured and are doing better and Covenant House, actually I worked at Covenant House many years ago when I was in law school in New York City and they do great work for teens and teens transitioning into independence which is really what Youth Care was doing but now if Covenant House is going to be doing that I think that's great and it's really needed in the youth district which is where youth care was before.

So I just wanted to confirm, and I know that that was what the county was looking as part of their budget deliberations to give support to, no guarantees on any of that, but that is, I know what they were looking to do.

So I wanna make sure that that is supported now that we're taking the funds back from the county to implement here.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_06

[5s]

Yeah, central staff, anything to add there?

Nothing more to add?

Councilmember Rivera, anything else?

SPEAKER_17

[1s]

No, that's it, sorry.

SPEAKER_06

[13s]

You're good?

Colleagues, any further discussion?

Any further discussion?

Last chance.

Seeing no further discussion, FG905A has been moved and seconded.

Will the clerk please call the roll on FG905A?

SPEAKER_19

[28s]

Councilmember Foster?

No.

Council President Hollingsworth?

Yes.

Councilmember Juarez Yes Councilmember Kettle Aye Councilmember Lin Yes Councilmember Rink No Councilmember Rivera Aye Councilmember Saka Aye Chair Strauss Aye 7 in favor, 2 opposed.

SPEAKER_06

[31s]

Thank you.

FG905A is added to the budget.

Moving on to the next item.

Ledge 1A is being withdrawn because of a memo that council president received from the mayor regarding how city side staff support the sound transit board of director.

So if there's no objection, ledge 1A is withdrawn.

Hearing no objection, ledge 1A is withdrawn.

We're gonna move right on to OED 8A.

I will move OED 8A, is there a second?

SPEAKER_00

[1s]

Second.

Second.

SPEAKER_06

[13s]

It has been moved and seconded for OED 8A.

And central staff, I see Jasmine is here with us.

If you'd like to provide a brief overview, and then I'll pass it over to Council Member Foster, and then I'm the sponsor.

Welcome.

SPEAKER_10

[27s]

Thank you.

Jasmine Marwaha, Council Central Staff.

OED 8A would increase the Office of Economic Development by $150,000 general fund in 2027 one time to support neighborhood activations in Ballard, including but not limited to seasonal lighting, installations, decorations, and charitable giving events to promote increased foot traffic in the business core in Ballard during winter.

This CBA is sponsored by Chair Strauss.

Yeah.

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

Thank you, Council Member Foster.

The floor is yours.

SPEAKER_01

[23s]

Thank you so much, Chair Strauss.

I believe we had a pretty robust discussion about this on Friday.

I don't have any further questions for central staff.

I will be voting no on this today.

I'm excited and I was really pleased to co-sponsor some other ads for Ballard, for Sip and Stroll and other pieces with you, Council Member Strauss, but I still have concerns about this ad and we'll be voting no.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_06

[9s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any further discussion?

Colleagues, any further discussion?

Sorry, I see Council Member Wink.

SPEAKER_02

[43s]

Thank you, Chair Strauss.

I will also not be supporting this today, and I understand I'm on as a co-sponsor, and I know I added my co-sponsorship at a different stage in the budget process, and now that we have come to hear in this moment on self-balanced amendments, having a broader look at what's on the table, I feel, is I'm not in a position to support for some of the reasons that were identified in the discussion on Friday.

however appropriate if I need to remove my name or simply vote no, I need to do so.

But just again, having a broader look at now how the final budget is shaping up, I will not be supporting this ad.

All respect to the Ballard BIA and the work of Ballard, but I will not be supporting today.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_06

[28s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any further discussion?

You've heard the conversation last week about the wool industry.

This is a one-time cost for a multi-year, not only enjoyment, but helping to run some clothing drives in the wintertime.

With that, colleagues, if there's no further discussion, will the clerk please call the roll on OED 8A?

SPEAKER_19

[5s]

Council member Foster?

No.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Council Member Juarez?

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Council Member Lin?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Council Member Rink?

SPEAKER_02

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_19

[4s]

Council Member Rivera?

Aye.

Council Member Saka?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[2s]

Five in favor, four opposed.

SPEAKER_06

[11s]

Thank you colleagues.

OED 8A does pass and will be attached to the budget.

Moving on to SDOT 3C.

I move SDOT 3C.

Is there a second?

SPEAKER_12

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_06

[11s]

I am walking us back from that.

I did not move it, did not second it.

We're going to move back because we have to do a different parliamentary procedure.

Central staff?

SPEAKER_14

[18s]

Council members, this was the item that was requested to be split into two separate items.

So S.003D is the new one for Councilmember Saka that is just on the district project fund.

and OSE004A is the new one just for Council Member Lin for the District 2 projects.

SPEAKER_06

[10s]

Thank you.

And clerk, do we need to move two different items or what is the next step?

So at this time, Council Member Saka, would you like to move yours?

I don't have your number right in front of me.

SPEAKER_12

[3s]

Yes, thank you, Chair.

I move to pass S.003D.

SPEAKER_06

[14s]

and I second that, so SDOT 3D has been moved and seconded, and I'll return now to central staff for a quick overview, and then over to you, Council Member Sokka.

SPEAKER_16

[21s]

SDOT 003D would provide $6.9 million for a district project fund, $1 million for each council district, except that in council district two, $900,000 would be provided in 2027 only.

SPEAKER_06

[7s]

Thank you.

And Councilman Roussaka, would you like to speak to this?

And thank you for understanding the error that happened and your grace with fixing it.

SPEAKER_12

[58s]

Thank you, Chair.

Briefly, colleagues, I'm obviously a big supporter of the District Project Fund.

It's an innovative safety investment, you know, focus throughout the various council districts.

Last week, we obviously, members of this committee obviously received a a letter from the Seattle Firefighters Union, Local 27, expressing concerns about a number of things.

Well, multiple letters expressing concerns about a number of things.

And for that reason, I pulled this amendment out of Group A. I did this for the purpose of giving this committee options for addressing these concerns.

I think that is good governance.

We have to be flexible and open to considering new options.

At this point, however, I've determined that the appropriate course of action is to continue to support the district project fund.

And for those reasons, I hope you can join me in voting to maintain funding for this critical program.

Thank you.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Colleagues, any discussion?

SPEAKER_03

[2m48s]

Any discussion?

Councilmember Kettle.

Thank you, Chair, and thank you, Councilmember Saka, for this.

I just wanted to speak because I think this district fund has been characterized in many ways, often negative, and for the record, as it relates to D7, I'm only speaking for District 7, The funds used in this district fund are solely used on essentially Vision Zero type projects and we work collaboratively with SDOT, my team does, usually pulling like off the shelf what SDOT has already been working and working again collaboratively with them.

So this is not like a burden on the department in the sense that this is a collaborative process using some of the work that they've done, which is in varying degrees of development.

But the other thing too is, and this is for all of us, but in terms of the districts, we are tied in to our districts.

to be frank, in a way that SDOT is not.

And so we work these things.

These are for concerns of the community, not some specific area in terms of some demographics or whatever.

It is for what helps our district as it relates to transportation.

For example, one for me relates to Thorndike, to create a safer Thorndike about coming down the hill from the Magnolia Bridge down to Dravis, to help create that kind of urban village feel, but also create a safer process for the neighborhood's residents.

and that's what we're doing.

You know, this is what it's being done for.

It's being done for like in Lower Queen Anne or basically Westlake, Uptown area in terms of the changes that the tunnel have brought in terms of traffic patterns.

You know, when the viaduct went down, the tunnel went in, it changed patterns and that created issues for the neighborhood.

because of that major change, plus apps on the phone that tell you to go this way or that way.

And so we needed to make some changes in order to support the residents in terms of creating a safer neighborhood.

That's what drives everything related to the district fund for me, and it's being tied into the district to ensure that we're in a better place.

So from across my district, that is how this is done.

I just want to say that, again, This fund has been characterized in a way that I don't think is, at least from a District 7 perspective, is not aligned with the reality of how it's been done and also the reality of the partnership between my team and SDOT to help work these issues.

So again, thank you, Chair, and also thank you, Councilmember Saka.

Thank you, Council President Hollingsworth, followed by Foster.

SPEAKER_00

[4m16s]

Thank you, Chair.

I'll be quick on this.

I wanna thank Council Member Saka for his leadership on this as well, and for fighting so hard for these funds, and I just wanna agree with Council Member Kettle.

What he said, I'll tell you this, colleagues, we received 40 different ideas for this fund from community, and 10 projects were chosen, all smaller ones, one from East Jefferson and let me also say this, all the projects that were submitted to our district were all pedestrian safety and traffic calming.

There was nothing that said, hey, we want cars to go faster.

It was like, yo, we want cars to go slower.

We want sidewalks to be better.

We want to improve our crosswalks.

We want bulbs.

We wanna make sure the corners are daylighting.

So those were like really, really important.

And I know that we were able to secure 10, projects for people where every neighborhood got something, and SDOT was able to send some of those project review summaries to our office, which I think were really great.

And I do know, I will say this, I'm voting yes on this, and if this passes, and I believe one of my amendments was pulled, I think Council Member Foster pulled, that one.

I see you coming for it.

I will be withdrawing that so we don't have to waste time.

If this passes, I will be withdrawing that and making sure that we can address some of the neighborhood's issues where that amendment was supposed to address within the Project District Fund.

So I just wanted to say that so you didn't have to you know, you can still do your thing, okay?

But I just wanted to say that, so if this passes, but if it doesn't, I'm still gonna advocate whichever way it goes for that neighborhood as well.

So I just wanted to thank Council Member Saka for this.

And second, I will say this, back in 2018, and I've lived on the same corner my whole life, everyone knows where I live, We would have accidents on that corner constantly since I was a kid.

But since 23rd Avenue was re-established and kind of went on a, they call it a road diet, we would have between 13 to 15 accidents per year on that corner.

It's all documented.

I called it Crash Corner.

It's on the videos.

the amount of advocacy I had to take to get that corner fixed took five years.

Five years.

Letters, trying to connect with council members, our council member person at the time, had to talk to SDOT, like all of the advocacy, and it took video footage to just get that corner revitalized and fixed.

And so I know that when we are representing districts, to be able to advocate for people, whether it's a small stop sign, we put stop signs over off of North Capitol Hill in this corner that would be blind.

We put traffic calming behind the QFC right next to the library.

There was a curb cut for some of elderly folks that had to walk 50 feet to a different, either north or south, to be able to get on to their access bus.

We repainted a sidewalk, or excuse me, a crosswalk where a girl got hit in Madison Park, Madison Valley, excuse me, got hit and wasn't able to walk and had to miss her whole season.

and we're able to repaint that and put lighting on there.

So I know that sometimes this can get characterized as pet projects and other things, but I know that I take it really seriously when people advocate and elevate a lot of their concerns regarding a lot of these projects and making sure that we can listen to community so stuff can get done and we give ESAT just a little bit of push on that, because I don't think anyone should have to wait five years for a corner to get redesigned for all the accidents.

And I want to tell you, when I reached out to SDOT, when I had all the accidents, they said that it was not a priority.

But we continued to make it a priority with videos showing all the people.

And the one thing that really put it over the top is when a kid got hit on a scooter from a moving car.

Car ran a red light, hit a kid on a scooter from Meany.

The video is up there for everyone to see.

Thank you, colleagues.

Thank you, Council President.

SPEAKER_06

[3s]

Councilmember Foster, followed by Rink, and then Rivera.

SPEAKER_01

[2m08s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

I'm just going to start with some appreciation.

Council President, you shared with me some of the projects that your office did previously and the focus on safety, and I really appreciated that conversation.

I just repeated it at the dais today, but I really want to thank you for that, because I think I will identify myself as one of those people who was kind of like, okay, what are we doing with this?

And I really appreciated that conversation, and I also want to thank Councilmember Saka.

I don't think I've talked about this.

Councilmember Saka had some leftover, I don't know if leftover is the right word, had some resources in his district project fund and reached out and offered to allow my office to direct some of those, provided they stayed in his district.

He was clear about that.

And I took him up on that out of curiosity and sort of a desire to have an impact.

And we were able to help get an area cleared in South Park that's known as the Scary Trail.

and this was an area that like when I had worked at the city a decade ago, we had heard from neighbors about their concerns walking back there.

I walked back there myself and was like, wow, this is aptly named.

And we were able to get that taken care of.

And so I really saw the impact that I think other council members and other district council members have spoken about.

And so I appreciate that.

And having said that, I'm gonna stick with what my concerns have been sort of consistently around pulling a significant amount of resources forward, whether it's for something that I think is impactful or not.

And Council Member Sokka, I know you pulled your own amendment here today for a different reason.

And I will be voting no on this, but I do think, I wanted to share for the record, I think that the impact that folks are having is tangible.

I still have questions about what happens to other projects as a result of council member projects being prioritized.

what impact that has on SDOT's delivery of other services.

I learned a lot through participating in this with you, though, Councilmember Saka, in terms of the responsiveness from the department and just so many things.

So maybe that's a hard truth to hold, both of those at the same time, but that's my truth.

So thank you so much.

SPEAKER_06

[3s]

Thank you, Councilmember Foster, Councilmember Rink, followed by Rivera.

SPEAKER_02

[1m03s]

Thank you, Chair Strauss.

Colleagues, I will be a very respectful no on this amendment today.

And I think you all have heard me speak a little bit just broadly about my concerns about the district project fund process and still wanting to, I understand it's a new program, still wanting to unpack how we go about that.

So it might be just a difference in policy opinion, but there is no question to the projects that have been able to be fulfilled upon.

using district project funds.

But the thing I really wanna focus on is appreciation to my colleague, Council Member Saka, in particular pulling this to open up and leave a policy option on the table in case we wanted to pursue an alternate option for funding firefighter overtime and addressing those issues.

And I think that shows real leadership in stepping up and being able to put this on the table for that discussion.

And so I wanna voice my appreciation to you for that matter.

Even if I'm a respectful no on this, I want you to know I appreciate you wanting us to really work together on putting more policy options on the table.

So thank you.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_17

[3m59s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Rivera.

Thank you, Chair.

I want to express my appreciation to my colleague, Councilmember Saka, for being such a champion of the district fund.

And this has allowed constituents across the district to identify safety projects in their neighborhoods and be able to apply for this funding.

And we can't fund all the projects that each of our districts have identified.

so we've had to do a prioritization.

Nevertheless, it does make folks feel heard and also like we're taking action.

For instance, there is one project that this will fund in my district.

There is a number of constituents that have been fighting for something like 10 years, if not 12, for a traffic circle.

I went out to look at where the location is because there's been increased traffic on 70th.

Folks are cutting through the neighborhoods now as you all know Seattle is very hilly so I watched in real time as a child on their bike was coming down the hill and if you were coming up the hill as a vehicle you would not have seen that kid and I kind of averted my eyes child was safe it was fine there was no actual vehicle but you can't see and that kid was flying down and there's no traffic circle there so if there were a traffic circle there that kid would have been protected because the car would have had to slow down to get around the traffic circle.

And they've been asking for this.

They've seen things I haven't by way of issues there.

And they've been asking for this for the last 10 to 12 years as I said.

So now they're finally gonna get the traffic circle there which is, it's a very small project.

It's costly.

It's stunning how much these minor, what I consider to be minor projects, cost.

But nevertheless, they're really important.

So that's just like one example.

And there are others in the district.

I too have had a kid in the time I've been here get hit by a car on their bike because there's a crosswalk, but cars don't stop at the crosswalk.

And so they needed a flashing beacon.

and even those, it just seems to take SDOT a really long time to respond because the response back is oftentimes, there are not enough incidents there to warrant it.

And I'm thinking a kid got hit by a car, like do we need more, has been identified by many people.

So I understand the prioritization, I do, and I'm not saying we forego that.

I'm saying in addition to that, it is important to have this fund to be able to address the number of things that our constituents see on the ground every day.

And thank you, Council President Hollingsworth, because you, with the cameras and it's on footage and for SDOT to say, well, no, it's not a priority because not enough incidents have happened there.

You know, to constituents, one person getting hit is enough of a reason to fix something there.

So I do appreciate these funds.

I will be voting for this for this reason.

I think in the scheme of a $9 billion budget that we take 1 million for each district to be able to address traffic safety improvements that we can't otherwise do is important and it's addressing our constituents' needs and it's what we can do as council if it's not already baked into the budget that the mayor sends down to us.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

Thank you, Councilmember Rivera.

Councilmember Lin.

SPEAKER_04

[6s]

Thank you, Chair.

And quick procedural question.

Are we allowed to abstain from votes at this stage?

You are.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

You are.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_04

[1m30s]

I believe I'll be abstaining from this one.

This one's a tricky one for me as a district council member who benefits from these funds in many ways.

and I just want to I believe clarify I think last time we had these it came from the levy this time it's general fund so it's not necessarily pulling from other SDOT projects unless you sort of you know think about it from a big picture you know the question would be what else could these funds be spent on and obviously there's a lot of good things that 7 million or 6.91 million could go towards.

I have seen the benefit of these and as a district council member learned a ton about how our projects are funded and what we can do and how expensive they are.

I do think on the one hand, the benefit of these funds.

We are able to move kind of quickly, probably quicker in some ways than I think Estop probably would because they would, I assume, probably go through a more kind of extensive process of prioritizing which projects get funding and so on.

I heard some of the concerns about how long it could take because of that process.

And on the other hand, I think I have concerns that I've heard from some of the citywide colleagues about sort of, you know, how are we prioritizing?

And so there's a tension there for me.

And for that reason, I'll be abstaining.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_06

[47s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Lin, colleagues, any further discussion?

You'll get last word.

Don't worry.

I'll never forget the last word.

I'll just say that as I went into the chairs balancing package weekend, I had hoped to find $18 million to put into this account because I do think that the citywide elected should also have their own money in this account because you all are also asked to do things.

we were not able to find that much money.

I was happy to fund one year of it.

And when we looked at both the citywide council members, you had very important asks that you asked for, and we chose to fund those instead of adding more money to the district council funds.

And so with that council members, council member Lynn Newhand.

SPEAKER_04

[17s]

Yes, sorry, I did forget just one last thing.

I just, if you don't mind, I just want to say thank you to SDOT.

They were extremely helpful in helping us choose which funds.

And so I do just want to clarify for the record that it's not like SDOT has no role in our use of these funds.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_06

[8s]

Thank you.

Yes, there is a full SDOT process for these funds.

Council Member Saka, Council Member Juarez wants to say one thing and then you'll have last word.

SPEAKER_07

[2m44s]

Thank you and I'll be brief and I apologize, I should have raised my hand.

I want to thank Council Member Saka.

This is a long time coming.

This is why we went to a district system and I don't want to be, you know, go after SDOT.

However, I think people in a district representation who live in the district and other who see these things all the time, every day, and it takes a death or something bad for us to just get them out there to put some paint on the street or put a sign or a button so hearing impaired can hear.

I don't think this is one of those, only for me.

And I'll say this and I'm sure I'll get some flack for it, but there are some lobbying groups that have more influence in SDOT than other groups.

and that's always been a concern of mine that some particular lobbying groups can get SDOT to do things because their ideologies line up and it isn't just bike lanes and I think we would probably avoid a lot of lawsuits as well if the people at SDOT listen to the folks that live in these districts and know, as Council President was pointing out and looking at the videos of people getting hit by cars.

And again, this is why we went to a district system.

And yes, I respect the SDOT system and their hierarchy and doing their study, but as Council Member Hollingsworth, the Council President said, and Council Member Rivera said, I've had the same struggles, sometimes taking nine, 10 years just to get a crosswalk up and it didn't happen until somebody got, an elder got hit and died.

And then there was a lawsuit.

So I'm gonna be supporting this and I wanna thank Council Member Saka for supporting, or for bringing this forward.

and I hope that this is a pattern that all the city departments start looking at.

Because once we went to a district system, we start asking OPCD, all these city departments, they start saying, can you just be a little bit more district specific?

And it isn't that I'm saying, hey, just do my stuff first.

It's more like, listen to us, because what we're telling you because we live there and we represent the district and those constituents.

We can tell you where the hot spots are.

We can tell you where people are getting hit.

We can tell you who's calling, what the letters look like.

We can even physically, we've done that on Aurora, go out there with you, what things need to get done.

And as it stands now, I still have seven or eight streets on Aurora with all these things going on.

There's no bike ops.

And I don't know when they're gonna get rid of the do-it-yourself or the things that the barriers.

We don't know.

We're still waiting.

So we'll just see how long that goes.

So I'll be supporting this.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_06

[4s]

Thank you, Council President Emeritus Juarez.

Council Member Socket to close us out.

SPEAKER_12

[4m10s]

Thank you, Chair.

Colleagues, I didn't anticipate this would engender such lively and robust but very healthy conversation, and I think we hit the bingo card here.

But all that is to say, really appreciate everyone's thoughtful contributions and point of view that you offered as it relates to this very important Policy conversation, I'll share that just from my perspective, this is a very healthy and transparent, 100% transparent program, 100% focused on safety, and the projects that my office has selected and put forward for this, we previously shared out exactly.

although now recognizing we might have to do an addendum to a previous newsletter that we did in light of Councilmember Foster's disclosures today about addressing the scary trail in South Park.

These are real-life actual concerns that impact people's everyday lives and experiences and how they navigate and interact on a daily basis with their transportation system and transportation infrastructure.

and it's another way for our city, capital C City, because irrespective of who the decision maker is on the executive side with the NSDOT or on the legislative branch side with respect to our council offices, the city.

to be and demonstrate responsiveness to the concerns of our shared constituents.

And I think that's a brilliant thing, I think that's an excellent thing, and I think it's something we need to continue to do and live up to.

And the final thing I'll share is that I am aware that this program, as Councilmember Kettle aptly noted a moment ago, is being unfairly characterized.

By the way, we're quite literally looking at some of the receipts from Council President.

She has opened on her desktop of some known crashes in her district at a specific intersection in her district that she chose to use these projects for to make safer.

And I did the same in mine.

For me, in my district, there's a lot of those flashing beacons for pedestrians.

In certain instances, for example, like SDOT, a specific project was on their radar.

It just fell below the existing objective evaluation criteria.

So there was a number of projects in my district where, for example, SDOT was able to leverage money from a district project fund, to get it over the top because they were able to use, for example, Safe Routes to Schools resources, and this just helped get it over the top to install either a pedestrian refuge island or a crosswalk or some paint signage, whatever it is.

But yeah, there may or may not be some...

some certain characterizations about this, and some of that may or may not be unfair.

Who knows?

Who cares, frankly?

It's a $7 million fund.

People are right to ask questions and scrutinize every single expenditure.

That said, for some of the advocates and activists and media partners who are lasering, you know, having laser focus on this one project, I would invite you to extend that same level of scrutiny and rigor and accountability and good governance or whatever you wanna call it to the dozens of other programs within SDOT.

to address traffic safety, including why is the department not able to spend tens of millions of dollars on safe routes to school?

We just had that conversation.

Target this, yes.

But all the other safety investments, why are we not getting it done as a city on those?

Thank you.

Ask for your support.

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

Thank you.

Will the clerk please call the roll on S.3D?

SPEAKER_19

[4s]

Councilmember Foster.

Excuse me?

SPEAKER_01

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_19

[2s]

Thank you.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_19

[8s]

Council Member Juarez?

Thank you.

Council Member Juarez?

Aye.

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Council Member Lynn?

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Epstein.

SPEAKER_19

[16s]

Council Member Rink?

No.

Council Member Rivera?

Aye.

Council Member Saka?

Aye.

Chair Strauss?

Aye.

Six in favor, two opposed, one abstention.

SPEAKER_06

[16s]

Thank you.

S.3D is attached to the agenda.

I wanna look at central staff.

Do we need to move the other item there?

And I am trying to find, Council Member Lynn, do you have your number ready?

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_06

[19s]

I got it right here, actually.

So I'm going to move OSE 4A.

Second.

Thank you.

OSE 4A has been moved in...

Oh, actually, I need to suspend the rules.

Nope.

Great.

So it has been moved and seconded.

Central staff, would you like to brief this item?

And then I'll turn it over to you, Council Member Len.

SPEAKER_16

[14s]

OSE 4A provides $50,000 for the Rainier Beach farmers market and $40,000 for safety work in the North Rainier area and Beacon Hill.

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

Thank you.

Council Member Lund, would you like to speak to your amendment?

SPEAKER_04

[50s]

Yeah, thank you so much, colleagues.

This is meant to address a couple priorities for our district.

One was the Rainier Beach Farmers Market, which is on right of way.

So it's a different type of public safety, which is to activate this space near Rainier Beach High School and the Safeway down there.

and then the other one is for security near the Mount Baker Light Rail Station where there's just a lot of vulnerable communities and some public safety concerns.

There's been a daycare there that has needed some security.

So we decided to pull from our portion of the district project funds to address kind of these public safety needs in a different way and would love your support.

Thank you.

Colleagues, any discussion?

SPEAKER_05

[0s]

Discussion?

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

Final discussion.

Any final words, Councilmember Lin?

SPEAKER_05

[2s]

Will the clerk please call the roll on OSE 4A?

SPEAKER_19

[27s]

Councilmember Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

Yes.

Councilmember Juarez?

Aye.

Councilmember Kettle?

Councilmember Lin?

Yes.

Council Member Rink?

Yes.

Council Member Rivera?

Aye.

Council Member Saka?

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[5s]

Thank you.

Eight in favor and none opposed.

SPEAKER_06

[25s]

Thank you.

And if we need to go back and take that vote again to include Council Member Kettle, who we know is supportive of this, we will, but seeing not at this time, OSE 4A passes and is added to the budget.

I heard Council Member Hollingsworth, you made comment about S.5B1.

Do you want to withdraw or do you want to move that?

SPEAKER_00

[6s]

I would like to withdraw.

That's okay.

I see Council Member Foster's eyes.

Thank you, Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_06

[40s]

Thank you.

That one is removed.

I am gonna move forward with my SDOT proviso and happy to have that discussion now.

So at this time I will be moving SDOT 14A.

Is there a second?

Second.

It has been moved and seconded to adopt SDOT 14A.

Central staff, would you like to provide your overview, and then Council Member Foster, you pulled this amendment, so I'll pass it to you.

14A, the $250,000 in SDOT for District 6 pedestrian and traffic safety.

SDOT 14A is a proviso for $250,000 in SDOT for District 6 pedestrian and traffic safety improvements.

SPEAKER_18

[4s]

is there a further question you need a clarification on?

SPEAKER_16

[3s]

And this is related to Stroud Avenue and 80th Street.

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

Thank you.

Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[40s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

I appreciate that.

I pulled this and I feel like we had a lot of discussion about this on Friday.

I think in part I pulled it because I had questions and I'll just restate them around where this project was in SDOT's vision zero prioritization and also why this project couldn't be advanced through the existing district project fund.

I don't know that I need to restate the conversation from Friday.

I think we heard back that this was a project that was not prioritized.

I know, Chair, you spoke to your conversations with folks in the district, so I don't know that there's anything new here since our conversation on Friday.

So no questions from me.

SPEAKER_06

[1m15s]

No further questions at this time?

No.

Okay, great.

And I'll just kind of summarize our conversation from last week, which is residents reached out about safety issues on their street.

I asked SDOT how they would like to be engaged.

I worked with the residents to engage with SDOT in the way that they asked.

SDOT went out and made changes, but none of the changes that the neighbors requested.

I am bringing forward one of the three items that the neighbors requested.

So I am also not telling SDOT to do everything that the neighbors are asking for.

Rather SDOT went out and made changes to the street that have not improved the situation and potentially made them worse, which is why I am bringing this forward.

Council Member Foster had brought up some questions about cost benefit.

Is this funding better used here or somewhere else?

I'll just ask, even if we were to...

I assume, Amanda, that every district has Vision Zero projects.

Is that correct?

That is correct.

Yes.

and so if SDOT wanted to do a cost benefit or prioritization, the likelihood that this proviso would have impact on another district, would you rank that high, medium or low?

SPEAKER_18

[10s]

I would imagine if you provide a direction that you wanted them to prioritize other projects in your district or not prioritize them, they could take that feedback.

SPEAKER_06

[7s]

Maybe let me ask that in a different way, which is if this proviso was to be held, would it impact other districts?

SPEAKER_18

[13s]

Overall, the Vision Zero program has a finite budget and allocating it outside of SDOT's prioritization would require them to redefine what projects they were going to accomplish.

SPEAKER_06

[15s]

Yes, and I guess the question here is, are these, every district has Vision Zero projects.

We heard an affirmative there.

We are hearing that, and so the question of, in Cal, I see a new hand.

SPEAKER_14

[39s]

Council members, I think while the department does do projects citywide and Vision Zero is smaller projects that probably do balance more, we don't know the specifics about how they've programmed their spending for the next year.

To know where that money is programmed from year to year, I think it is something that they do try to cover more broadly.

but that can be lumpy.

A project can be very expensive and it could have an impact.

So I think part of this is the budget gives them a lot of discretion to figure out what that project delivery schedule looks like.

And so I don't think that staff are able to say one way or the other what that impact would look like for next year.

SPEAKER_06

[1m35s]

Well, thank you.

And then with that, in my conversations with SDOT, should this proviso pass, I will be in, be sure to make it clear that this is not to impact any other district and only district six.

And I say that, and Council Member Foster, again, back to, I had looked into bringing an amendment to remove Vision Zero funds from my district to send them down to your neighborhood because the SDOT is not working on the priorities in your neighborhood fast enough, in my opinion.

And additionally, I would be bringing this through the district fund, except for the community and myself followed every direction that SDOT provided, the outcome made it worse, which is why I'm asking SDOT to not even do everything that the neighbors are asking for, but simply to fix one of the mistakes.

the real clear cost of this might not be 250,000.

It's about 20 pylons and two small signs.

In the conversation that we had last week, the crash data was also brought up as a question.

I can tell you four blocks to the west, the same treatment was provided because the crash data demonstrated it.

And so for all of those reasons, again, the neighbors had not followed the direction that SDOT provided and how to engage with them in the first place.

If every step wasn't taken in the right way leading up to here, I would not bring this amendment.

Any further discussion?

Any final discussion?

All right.

Will the clerk please call the roll on SDOT 14A?

SPEAKER_19

[5s]

Council Member Foster?

No.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[4s]

Councilmember Juarez?

No.

Councilmember Kettle?

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Councilmember Lin?

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Abstain.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Councilmember Rink?

SPEAKER_08

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_19

[4s]

Councilmember Rivera?

Aye.

Councilmember Saka?

SPEAKER_12

[0s]

Abstain.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_12

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[3s]

Four in favor, three opposed, two abstentions.

SPEAKER_06

[27s]

Thank you, the motion passes, S.18a will be added, 14a will be added to the budget and we will now move on to S.18a.

I move S.18a, is there a second?

Second.

Thank you, has been moved and seconded to adopt S.18a.

Central staff, would you like to brief this?

Council Member Rink, you pulled it and then Council Member Rivera, you are the sponsor and I'll go in that order.

Over to you, central staff.

SPEAKER_16

[11s]

This amendment provides us $1.4 million in SDOT for Sandpoint Way Northeast improvements south and adjacent to Magnuson Park.

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

Thank you.

Council Member Wink and then Rivera.

SPEAKER_02

[1m31s]

Thank you, Chair Strauss.

I spoke to this in depth on Friday, but I want to reiterate a couple of points.

Certainly understand the sponsors real intent here in representing the needs of her district.

I certainly appreciate efforts to improve safety on Sandpoint Way.

I remain concerned with provisos on Vision Zero funding broadly.

To reiterate, I understand Sandpoint Way is a higher tier emergency response route, mostly serving pediatric critical care transports along to Seattle Children's.

So it's my understanding that there are limited simple options on traffic calming for Sandpoint Way.

And to that end, I understand that Estat is also working towards installing new traffic safety cameras near Magnuson Park and along Sandpoint Way.

But my underlying concern is, again, the fact that this proviso, particularly the high amount associated with this proviso, could limit SDOT's ability to implement their 2027 Vision Zero work plan.

And as stated by SDOT in the response to Budget Question 109, Vision Zero provisos would collectively delay other projects and make the funds available to be used in other locations that do meet their pardon me, make the funds unavailable to be used in locations that do meet their prioritization criteria.

So again, I remain really committed to Vision Zero efforts and my concerns about this proviso approach are more about what it would pull resources away from.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_06

[3s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Rivera, sponsor the amendment.

You were recognized.

SPEAKER_17

[4m39s]

Thank you, Chair.

Colleagues, I've been trying to work with SDOT for three years to do traffic calming there because of the street racing that the folks, have had to deal with, and in particular, my constituents that live in the park.

All due respect, Council Member Rink, I'm not sure that SDOT's being forthcoming with the information to you.

The traffic calming that they're talking about there is not in the location that I keep talking to SDOT about.

that traffic camera is going north of the area in question, not in front of actually Magnuson Park but north of Magnuson Park.

I don't begrudge the camera there because I know getting closer to Matthews Beach and beyond there's some traffic issues as well, but that area of Sandpoint Way where they're putting the traffic camera, though folks have had concerns about the speeding, it's a narrower road and is not as wide of a road as in front of Magnuson Park.

which is advantageous to the folks that are engaging in the speed racing behavior.

And then to the point about Children's Hospital, I can assure you as a mom who's taken her kids to Children's Hospital more times than I would have liked, I have no intent here to delay any emergency vehicle that would be taking their kids to Children's Hospital.

My understanding is that there is some traffic calming that could be put in place that would not have an impact on whether it's the fire rigs or the emergency vehicles that are going through that state route.

And SDOT has not spoken to WSDOT or to our fire department or any other folks about potential impacts and what could happen on that road.

And this isn't a new proviso.

This is a proviso I brought last year to try to get the department to figure out what they could do there to deal with the speed racing.

There's two issues going on there.

There is speeding, and also street racing.

And the street racing has been very difficult for the folks there, especially the folks that live in the park.

And there are a lot of families now living in the park and I very much care about ensuring that it is safe there for the folks that are living in the park and across the street from the park.

and obviously visiting the park.

So none of this list in question 66 that we got back and our response to SDOT addresses what I'm talking about because most of this is either, like I said, the traffic camera is not going there and some of these other smaller things that they're doing might address regular speeding, but certainly not street racing.

and the constituents continue to experience this.

So to me, again, I'm trying to get SDOT to address the safety issue that is happening there, the traffic safety issue, the pedestrian safety issue that is being caused by not only the speeding but the street racing that's going on there.

We need to mitigate for that street racing and that's why I'm trying to again for the second year in a row trying to provide some of SDOT's funding.

The reason why it was a high amount was because I don't know what needs to happen there given it is a state road, it is an emergency road.

We need to make sure we're not having impact on those vehicles that are, as you said, council member in bringing kids to children's hospital, for instance.

I don't know what that will cost, but I do know something can be done there and they're not doing it.

And what's more is they never talked to washed out about it.

So I keep meeting with them about this.

They keep coming with the back, the same thing.

They just don't want to address it.

and what they do wanna address is not in front of the park where the issues are.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_06

[4s]

Thank you, Council Member Rivera.

I see Council Member Juarez, Kettle and Foster.

SPEAKER_07

[1m47s]

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

I want to thank Councilmember Rivera for bringing this forward.

At one point, we had moved the line between District 4 and 5, and we moved it 10 blocks south, I believe.

But either way, I'm just going to say, too, for the record, I, too, have been working since 2016 asking SDOT to do traffic calming measures along standpoint way besides the traffic calming and other issues that Council Rivera outlined, the speed racing, the drag racing, whatever you want to call it, Sandpoint Way is a rich transit spine.

So we also have, you know, obviously buses, King County Metro, we have the bus systems.

We have many, many public schools, elementary, middle schools and high schools and community centers.

And just so we're clear, both things can be true.

We can uphold the values in the spirit of Vision Zero, and we can also uphold the values in the spirit of public safety.

I want to make sure that everyone, whether they're on a bike or they're walking or they're pushing a stroller or they're with their kids, that they can walk down, ride down, bike down Lake City, I'm sorry, not Lake City, Sandpoint Way.

And I guess what you're hearing is some of the frustration because we hear it from, and I know you put it on here, the improvements along Sandpoint Way from 40th to 65th, It doesn't mean that the problems automatically go away.

I appreciate it as a proviso, but I guess we're just sharing in the frustration that these are not opposing values, public safety on the street and Vision Zero, that we can do two good things at once.

So I will be supporting this proviso.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_06

[3s]

Thank you, Council Member Juarez, Council Member Kettle, followed by Foster.

SPEAKER_03

[1m01s]

Thank you, Chair.

I just wanted to quickly speak to this as Chair of Public Safety because this is a major challenge that we see throughout the city.

My office, we're working with SDOT and SPD related to Belltown and street racing.

As you know, we've had over Labor Day shootings that were in part tied to street racing and it is a major challenge and so I can understand the frustration as we're trying to move forward, you know, trying to deal with this issue.

I would also add, and I'll take the opportunity to do so, is say, hey, if we had more officers that would be another way to address the situation, but we don't.

and to be frank, bike cops are not gonna help in this.

Not at all.

And so I just wanted to highlight this is a major challenge.

It's not throughout the city.

This is not just a D4, it's definitely a D7 and I know it happens in other districts as well.

Thank you, Chair.

Thank you, Council Member Kettle.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[33s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

I had a couple of questions.

First, as I'm looking at the proviso, it notes that SDOT identified a scope of changes that are $362,000, and I understand through the discussion today the differences of opinion on whether or not those changes are sufficient or insufficient, but I want to ask, is that intend that 362,000 intended to be included within the 1.2 of the proviso or intended to be separate?

SPEAKER_06

[3s]

Thank you.

Amanda?

SPEAKER_18

[7s]

I would imagine that if 1.4 million was under proviso that the scope of 362 would be allocated to fund that work.

Okay.

Chancellor Foster, right back at you.

SPEAKER_16

[2s]

Thank you so much.

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

I'm seeing Director Whitson and then we'll come back to you.

SPEAKER_16

[17s]

That's true to the extent that the improvements are within that area between 40th and 65th.

For example, the speed camera, as Councilmember Rivera has noted, is north of that area that would be under the proviso.

SPEAKER_18

[15s]

The radar speed feedback signs, the raised pavement markers, and potentially some of the no turn on red restrictions could fall under that proviso work.

Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[17s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

And I saw a nodding head from Council Member Rivera.

I take that to mean that the 362 is inclusive of the one, or excuse me, the 1.4 is inclusive of the 362. Chair, if you wouldn't mind allowing the sponsor to respond.

Sure, Council Member Rivera.

SPEAKER_17

[42s]

Thank you, Chair.

Council Member Foster, yes, thank you for the question.

That's my understanding.

And also because it's, we're just trying to manage for all a Sandpoint way, but I was trying to address that piece in front of Magnuson Park is my continued concern and toward Children's Hospital because that part of Sandpoint Way is wider and so we see a lot of that increased speeding and then in front of the park that racing.

So yes, it's my understanding that they were taking the 300 out of the original proviso from last year.

Same money.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Councilmember Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[1m09s]

Thank you so much, Chair, and thank you, Councilmember Rivera.

And I just wanted to state I've been, I've left Magnuson in the evening, and I've seen and heard the street racing, and it's a lot.

And I also, you know, I have a question with this proviso because it was proviso'd last year and unable to be completed, and in some of my review of the department's responses, I see the responses that reflect what Councilmember Rink stated earlier in terms of challenges implementing speed humps because of the route and so that is I just want to note I see that same concern so one of my questions is and I respect Council Member Juarez also saying like we've been at this for a decade here and and I guess my question is why do we anticipate that they'll be able to make these changes this year if they were not able to last year and I sort of asked that in the context of it's a really large proviso, 1.2 of the 14.4 million and I am really concerned about setting it aside and provisoing it and then that not being able to be utilized as envisioned.

SPEAKER_06

[5s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Rivera or did you need central staff to answer anything there?

SPEAKER_01

[8s]

That was an open question, so if Central Staff has a response or Council Member Rivera, I'd let you direct that as you'd like to, Chair.

SPEAKER_06

[4s]

Thank you.

Central Staff, anything to add?

I'm not saying anything.

Council Member, Amanda?

SPEAKER_18

[40s]

So in talking with SDOT about the work particularly that would involve Washington State Department of Transportation, they have been in conversation with WSDOT about these potential changes.

They have agreements in place about the types of things they would do to the network and the speed humps, which council member Rivera is interested is not one of the things that they are within the scope of our agreement with WSDOT.

So given that, I don't imagine that they would find a way to implement that in 2027.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Thank you.

Council Member Rivera.

SPEAKER_17

[2m48s]

Thank you.

So SDOT did not tell me they've had more recent conversations with WSDOT and the- there were speed bumps and then there were speed pads and there's some other things that can be done when there's emergency vehicles so SDOT has not followed up to say that some other alternatives wouldn't work and I met with SDOT a few months ago and they hadn't spoken to WSDOT and hadn't presented options for there So if they have, that is news to me colleagues because I think you know me well enough that in my Rivera due diligence I'm not, I am the most transparent.

So did not know that they were having conversations with WSDOT and also my understanding is that there are other things that they can do in that area for those emergency vehicles.

and none of that has been presented to me, nor what the conversations were, nor what was asked of WSDOT.

So I'm trying to get to what can be done there because they are not addressing that area with the proposed changes that they have.

And so to me, I'm trying to proviso the money.

So if there is something that can be done there, it be done there.

And I haven't heard that there's alternatives to speed bumps because I actually never asked for speed bumps.

There were like speed cushions that are different from speed bumps because speed bumps there are not going to work.

But there are other things that they can do there that they've done in other places is my understanding from speaking to two SDOT directors ago in terms of that would be gentler on those emergency vehicles that have been put in other areas that have similar issues with emergency vehicles coming through.

And that's what was intended there or the conversation to be had about placing that there.

not speed bumps.

So if they're talking to WSDOT about speed bumps, no, those are not going to be able to be placed there.

But there are other things that can be done there that I haven't heard back from WSDOT that they've had either conversations in general with WSDOT and let alone about the smaller things or the lighter things that can be done to both deal with the emergency vehicles with that state route and to deal with the speed racing.

SPEAKER_06

[7s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Foster.

Can I give you the last one in just one second?

Councilmember Foster, you technically have the floor.

Anything further right now?

SPEAKER_01

[4s]

One final question.

Is this location, is this on the high injury network?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Amanda?

SPEAKER_18

[19s]

I do not believe so, no.

Not as identified.

No, which was the reason why the speed cameras are being installed north of where Council Member Rivera's focused on at Northeast 74th Street and Matthews.

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

Thank you.

Council Member Foster, anything further?

SPEAKER_17

[0s]

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_06

[5s]

Thank you.

Council Member Rivera, the last word, and then we'll go to a vote.

Okay.

SPEAKER_17

[2s]

Does Council Member Juarez have her hand up?

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

I think that's an old hand, Council Member Juarez, is that correct?

SPEAKER_17

[2m35s]

Yeah.

So again, colleagues, you've heard earlier in our conversation about SDOT in general how often SDOT will not have something on their high-injury network.

but nevertheless the constituents that live there on the ground know what's happening and are reporting back our concerns to us and the need to do this traffic safety mitigation.

So to me this is really an important thing to address.

I am really, I have to say and I hope SDOT is watching because I am really disappointed that SDOT did not reach out to tell me they actually had talked to WSDOT and further disappointed to hear that in their conversations with SDOT, if they just limited their conversations to speed bumps and communicated that that's what I wanted there, that's inaccurate.

I want to hear that they had conversation about speed pads and other ways to mitigate and do the traffic calming there in a way that addresses all the things that need to be addressed there, both the fact that it's a state route, the fact that emergency vehicles have to go through there, and also the fact that there are a lot of pedestrians there getting to the park and then the pedestrians who live at the park that have to deal with the speed racing.

So to me, this is the point of this CBA.

If the 1.4 million doesn't, you know, it is not my intent to use money that we don't need.

Again, colleagues, I think you know I'm more fiscally judicious than that, but I do want to make sure that there's money available to address what actually can go there.

And if they don't need to use the money in full, then they don't need to do that.

But I haven't seen from SDOT what they're actually doing in front of the park to mitigate for the street racing and for the speeding there to address the issues.

And doing the right turn signals is not going to address the speed racing.

I mean, it's just not.

And putting a traffic camera north of the park at 74th and Matthews is also not going to address the speed racing and the issues that are happening in front of Magnuson Park.

So that is my intent, colleagues.

If the 1.4 is the sticking point, then I'm happy to do an oral amendment to do less.

I just don't know what the less would be in order to address what needs to happen there.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Rivera.

SPEAKER_17

[16s]

So it is my commitment to either if less is advantageous.

I can make that oral amendment or if this provides those passes, then you have my commitment.

We're not gonna be using more than is needed to address the issues that are there.

SPEAKER_06

[9s]

Amanda, sorry, that was supposed to be last word.

So Amanda, any new information at this time?

And then Council Member Rivera, you have last word and then we need to continue moving forward.

SPEAKER_18

[31s]

So I just wanna be attentive to Council Member Rivera's intent to impact in front of the park.

And as I'm reading this proviso, I'm concerned that the streets that we've identified do not impact that park.

So I feel like we might be falling short if we are implementing a proviso that only is between 40th Avenue Northeast and Northeast 65th.

We need to amend that.

SPEAKER_17

[6s]

Because the park entrance is north of 65th.

We would need to amend the CBA.

SPEAKER_06

[13s]

Hold on.

Hold on.

Yep.

Okay.

So we're going to take a quick pause here just to say it sounds like, Amanda, I'm hearing that the CBA is not written to the accuracy that we need for Councilmember Rivera at this time?

SPEAKER_18

[8s]

I'm concerned it's not.

If the Councilmember's really concerned, wants to include in front of the park, then we have not accomplished that.

SPEAKER_06

[48s]

Okay, we've got two and a half, so we've got to vote on this amendment and then two others before we can take a lunch.

I'm gonna ask us to tick a little bit faster right now just so that we can move through this.

I'm gonna ask to have the rules suspended.

Council Member Rivera, I'm gonna need the exact language to be read into the record.

Central staff, I'll need you to repeat that language back to us.

We'll change that language and then we'll take a vote on this item.

Any questions?

Seeing no questions, if there's no objection, the rules will be suspended to make a verbal amendment to S.18A.

Are there any objections at this time?

Hearing no objections, Council Member Rivera, please move whatever changes you would like to have made at this time.

SPEAKER_17

[32s]

Yeah, it's up to 74th Street.

Apologies, colleagues, since this was a CBA that was brought back from last year, we had been hoping that- Sorry, Council Member Rivera, what streets would you like them to be between, and can you move that?

74th down to 65th.

Well, south is 65th.

Yeah, 74th to 40th.

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

Okay, hang on real quick.

Yeah.

SPEAKER_17

[2s]

So 74th to 40th instead of 65th.

SPEAKER_06

[5s]

Okay, 74th to 40th are the two streets I'm hearing.

Central staff, can you confirm?

SPEAKER_14

[31s]

Just to confirm, 40th Avenue, Northeast and Sandpoint Way connects in two different spots.

It connects down at the south end, connects all the way up at the north end as well.

I'm hearing the intention is from essentially just north of- Magnuson.

Yep.

All the way to the past Magnuson Park up to 74th.

So it would be easiest to say from 74th South to 40th Avenue Northeast.

SPEAKER_17

[4s]

from 74th South to 40th Avenue Northeast.

SPEAKER_06

[20s]

Are there any objections to this being amended as described?

I'm hearing no objections.

So the SDOT 18A has been amended for new street, for new Northern and Southern borders.

Council Member Rivera, any last words or can we take this to a vote right now?

SPEAKER_17

[25s]

I do.

Sorry, Chair.

Apologies for these colleagues because we re, it looks like we used the same CBA as the last year's when we thought SDOT was actually going to be addressing the area right in front of the park and they're not.

So we should have, the CBA should have reflected the proper location.

So apologies.

Thank you for allowing me to amend that.

SPEAKER_06

[13s]

Thank you, colleagues.

We have before us S.18A as amended.

Any final questions?

Will the clerk please call the roll on S.18A as amended?

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Council Member Foster?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_00

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[4s]

Council Member Juarez?

Aye.

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_00

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Council Member Lynn?

SPEAKER_02

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Councilmember Rink?

SPEAKER_02

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Councilmember Rivera?

SPEAKER_02

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[10s]

Councilmember Sacca?

I'm staying.

Chair Strauss?

Aye.

5 in favor, 3 opposed, 1 abstention.

SPEAKER_06

[9s]

Thank you.

SDOT 18A as amended has been added to the budget.

We are going to move on to SFD 1B.

I move SFD 1B.

SPEAKER_17

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_06

[9s]

Thank you.

It's been moved and seconded.

Central staff, if you'd like to provide a quick briefing on this item and then Council Member Morinke, you pulled this.

We'll go from there.

SPEAKER_16

[14s]

The mayor's proposed budget would cut $7.1 million in 2027 and 2028 from the fire department overtime funds.

This council budget action would restore that funding.

SPEAKER_06

[4s]

Thank you, Council Member Rink.

You pulled this amendment.

Would you like to speak to it?

SPEAKER_02

[24s]

Thank you, Chair Strauss.

Just very briefly, and you've heard this already today, I pulled a series of amendments from the package last week to allow for opportunity to take a different policy path if that was of interest to colleagues, and that included pulling this.

I think we can all agree that funding overtime for firefighters to ensure that we have appropriate response times for every unit is tremendously important.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Rivera, would you like to share anything?

SPEAKER_17

[19s]

I mean, I think I've spoken about this before, but just the importance of this is our chartered responsibility.

Fire needs overtime to be able to have no negative impacts to their service.

This is an important chartered responsibility that we should be doing.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_06

[7s]

Thank you.

Further discussion?

I'm not seeing any further discussion.

Will the clerk please call the roll on SFD 1B?

SPEAKER_19

[11s]

Council Member Foster?

Council President Hollingsworth?

Aye.

Council Member Juarez?

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Council Member Lin?

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Council Member Rink?

SPEAKER_02

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_19

[5s]

Council Member Rivera?

Aye.

Council Member Saka?

SPEAKER_01

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Council Member Foster?

SPEAKER_01

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_06

[19s]

Thank you.

SFD 1B is added to the budget.

We'll now move on to SFD 5A.

I move SFD 5A.

Is there a second?

Second.

I think he's been moved and seconded to add SFD 5A to the agenda or to the budget.

Central staff, will you provide a quick overview and then Council Member Rancor, over to you.

SPEAKER_16

[3s]

This council budget action would add $850,000 one-time funds to repair the fireboat leshy.

SPEAKER_06

[3s]

Thank you.

Council Member Rink.

SPEAKER_02

[4s]

Thank you, Chair Strauss.

No additional comments.

I intend to support this today.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_06

[8s]

Thank you.

I've got no interest in time.

I've got no further comments.

Will the clerk please call the roll on SFD 5A?

SPEAKER_19

[5s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Council Member Juarez?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[3s]

Councilmember Lin.

Yes.

Councilmember Rink.

SPEAKER_02

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_19

[11s]

Councilmember Rivera.

Aye.

Aye.

Thank you.

Councilmember Saka.

Aye.

Chair Strauss.

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_19

[1s]

Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_06

[1m20s]

Thank you colleagues.

SFD 5A is added to the budget.

That does bring us to the conclusion of group A2.

We have remaining on this council bill, we have group B, we have no items for group C, but we then have one standalone amendment for the bill.

in total and then that will complete this bill, this section.

We still have the consent package of additional legislation and then we have individual votes on amendments and council member generated legislation which we would like to get through all today.

It is 12.36 right now.

I'm gonna ask us to take recess until 1.20 to give us 45 minutes but and I'd like folks to just kind of take a temperature of themselves this afternoon.

Do we need to get out by five?

Is six o'clock okay?

I'm taking your temperatures.

I'm not telling by asking, I'm actually asking.

So unless there's anything else to come before us, if there's no objection, the Select Budget Committee will be in recess until 1.20 p.m.

Hearing no objection, the committee is in recess until 1.20 p.m.

Thank you, colleagues.