Dev Mode. Emulators used.

Select Budget Committee Meeting Session II 11-16-26

Publish Date: 11/17/2026
Description:

Agenda: Call to Order; Approval of the Agenda; CB 121342: An ordinance adopting a budget for 2027; Adjournment.

SPEAKER_99

[13s]

The November 16th, 2026 Select Budget Committee meeting will come back to order.

It is 1.22 p.m.

I'm Dan Strauss, chair of the committee.

Any council members not yet present are excused until they arrive.

Clerk, will you please call the roll?

Council member Foster?

SPEAKER_24

[2s]

Here.

President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_11

[2s]

Councilmember Juarez?

Councilmember Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Here.

SPEAKER_11

[1s]

Council Member Linn?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Here.

SPEAKER_11

[6s]

Council Member Rink?

Here.

Council Member Rivera?

Council Member Sanka?

Here.

And Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Here.

SPEAKER_11

[1s]

Six present.

SPEAKER_15

[44s]

Thank you.

We are gonna jump right on into group B.

Clerk, do I need to read anything into the record?

We're good to go.

So we will be going in the similar order in which I'll move the item.

It will require a second.

We'll have central staff provide a brief overview I'll hand it over to the council member who pulled the item I think my notes are correct but if I get them wrong No problem, just correct me in real time, please.

And then we'll go to the sponsor, discussion, back to the sponsor, and then vote on it from there.

So with that, without any further ado, I will move Arts 6B.

Is there a second?

SPEAKER_22

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_15

[12s]

It has been moved and seconded to adopt Arts 6B, and we have Council President and Council President Emeritus with us now.

and so over to you central staff and then I'll turn it over to Council Member Foster and then Saka.

SPEAKER_25

[12s]

Art 6B adds $235,000 in both 2027 and 2028 to the Office of Arts and Culture to support a art wall pilot program in Delridge.

SPEAKER_15

[4s]

Thank you, Council Member Foster.

You pulled this amendment and then we'll turn it over to Council Member Saka.

SPEAKER_01

[54s]

Thank you so much, Chair Strauss.

And as I stated on Friday, I pulled this amendment because I had questions around whether or not this was actually an ongoing cost given the way that it's structured.

I also had questions that got answered about the approach here and who would be covering the maintenance and operations of this project.

And as I stated today, I have sort of a general disagreement with the approach that we are taking in terms of council directed ads to arts at a time when the arts department is otherwise losing, or excuse me, at the time when the admissions tax revenue was otherwise projected to decline compared to our previous projection.

So that is what I have here.

And I appreciate council member Saka for the conversations that we had just around my intent.

I understand especially what you're wanting to do here.

So thank you for that.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you, council member Saka.

SPEAKER_22

[3m24s]

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Colleagues, the CBA was originally included in the chair's consent package and appreciate the direct offline one-on-one conversations I've had with Council Member Foster and we've had some, you know, great healthy spirited conversations about broader, you know, issues here at the dais publicly as well and, you know, so I'm exercising my right to continue to fight for this investment for the benefit of Delridge and the broader arts community.

This proposal would create Seattle's first city-supported free art wall intended to support creative expression while reducing unauthorized graffiti.

And wanna say, extend a special shout out and thanks to renowned Seattle artists and West Seattle light, Desmond Hanson, whose vision helped shape this proposal and whose work has turned everyday spaces into sources of community pride throughout our city.

This is a very simple idea.

Instead of painting over creativity, provide a legitimate canvas for it.

This project can help transform a graffiti challenge into an arts pathway, connecting youth with established artists, materials, mentorship, while creating a dynamic destination in Delbridge.

Colleagues, I think this proposal is particularly important in light of the mayor's proposed cuts of $500,000 from the broader citywide graffiti abatement budget, which also does not renew the one-time $950,000 investment for a third-party contract that provides graffiti abatement services on non-city assets.

So collectively, when we're talking about a either cut or non-renewal of $1.5 million in graffiti abatement services.

I think this is a critical investment for keeping unwanted graffiti under control.

And really wanna extend my sincere thanks to council members Hollingsworth and Lynn for being our initial co-sponsors of this exciting investment.

And no, no, no, no, no, hardly.

And I also wanna thank council members Juarez and Kettle for recognizing the citywide impact of this and also adding your name as a co-sponsor as well during that stage of the process and joining the thousands of other community voices who raised their hands to support this investment and really appreciate that work.

The five of us who have our names on this amendment, Again, really excited for it, honored to, this was a high priority item in the chair's package and really appreciate the, again, spirited conversations we've had about, you know, broader investments publicly and on an individual one-on-one basis and ask for your support, support of this for Delridge.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[8s]

Thank you, Councilmember Socket.

Colleagues, any further discussion?

Any further discussion?

I have Council Member, Vice Chair Rivera and then Council President.

SPEAKER_04

[32s]

Thank you, Chair.

Just wanting to know, because this is one time, how the sponsor envisions this will work.

It seems to me this is something that would need to be, it's a two-year investment.

would need to be cleaned up every time and the work, you know, so that other folks can paint on it.

You know, how will all that work?

Do you know?

SPEAKER_22

[1m47s]

Council Member Sacco.

Thank you, Chair.

Thank you, Council Member Rivera.

And for clarity, it's not intended to be cleaned up by the city.

The whole purpose of this art wall is to basically provide a canvas that community can go on top of and paint new depictions and new art on top of.

The city is not intended to have a role in that, but to your broader question on on sort of management on an ongoing basis.

Yes, you're right, it's intended to be a pilot, as the express words of the CBA indicate.

There's a pilot in there, I think at least once.

But on a two-year basis, so one-time funding on a two-year basis, We'll evaluate the program.

My intention as the sponsor of this is we'll evaluate the efficacy and effectiveness of the program.

There's a lot of important policy rationales that we're using that are at play here.

you know, creative expression, there's economic development, neighborhood vibrancy, there's graffiti abatement, all those things.

And so we're gonna have some good data at the, my hope is at the end of the two years, no different than any other sort of pilot, we'd have some good data to evaluate the effectiveness and efficacy of this program, determine whether it's worth continuing in that specific location or winding down in that specific location and starting up again in another location citywide or just pulling the plug on the program altogether.

I don't have strong feelings on that, but I do think it's a worthwhile investment in the near term on a one-time pilot basis.

SPEAKER_15

[5s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Rivera, you still have the floor.

Thank you, Council Member Rivera, Council President Hollingsworth.

SPEAKER_18

[1m01s]

Hey, thank you, Chair, and thank you, Council Member Sokka, for your advocacy on this and your...

1,000% supportive of the Delridge wall.

The one thing, and I know I originally became a sponsor, because I know I was trying to figure out, and I don't want to say trade-offs, but supporting the last minute $800,000 ad that you have for the t-shirt on you, and wanting to support that and this.

And I had to make a tough decision.

I know I originally am going to be I think originally was a sponsor of this.

I'm gonna abstain today.

I'm not gonna vote no, but I have to abstain today.

But I will be supporting your $800,000 ask for your, that you brought last minute.

So just wanted just to state that for the record, completely supported, but I will be abstaining from this today, not voting no, but abstaining and voting supporting the, for the $800,000 ask that you brought as well.

SPEAKER_15

[10s]

So thank you.

Thank you, Council President.

Colleagues, any further discussion?

Any further discussion?

Any final discussion?

Council Member Saka, you got last word.

SPEAKER_22

[5s]

Thank you.

Yeah, just ask for your support, colleagues.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Thank you.

Will the clerk please call the roll on Arts 6B?

SPEAKER_13

[5s]

Council Member Foster?

No.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_18

[0s]

Abstain.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Council Member Juarez?

Yes.

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Lynn?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council member Rink?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Council member Rivera?

No.

Council member Saka?

SPEAKER_23

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[6s]

Chair Strauss?

Aye.

Five in favor, three opposed, one abstention.

SPEAKER_15

[9s]

Thank you.

The measure passes.

Art 6B will be added to the budget.

We'll now move on to the next item.

I move CBO 6SB.

SPEAKER_01

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_15

[18s]

Thank you, CBO 6SB has been moved and seconded.

This was a slide, Council Member Foster had more than three slides, which is why her additional ones were brought to Group B. With that, we'll turn it over to central staff for a quick introduction and then straight over to you, Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_25

[14s]

CBO 6SB is a statement of legislative intent asking that CBO develop a plan to appropriate 50% of jumpstart payroll expense tax revenue to housing and the Equitable Development Initiative.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[1m56s]

Thank you so much, Chair, and thank you to Jen LeBrecq and folks at Central Staff who helped work on this slide.

This is something that my office spent a lot of time engaging with folks from the affordable housing community and EDI community on and working to put forward a plan that I felt is a reasonable request.

The background here is that we all know that we're looking at a really difficult budget year and one of the most significant things in the budget that was proposed by the mayor was the $65 million reduction in carry forward of jumpstart appropriations in the Office of Housing.

I know that's not the first or the last time that colleagues you've heard me say that.

And when looking at that and looking to the out years, I know that we've built a really significant amount of affordable housing in our city because we've had consistent revenue through JumpStart and the housing levy, and that provides certainty for the Office of Housing.

And looking backwards for the years 2022, 2023, and 2024, we were able to achieve 50% of JumpStart revenue being invested into housing and the Equitable Development Initiative.

However, the current proposed budget would allocate about 35% of JumpStart in 2027 to affordable housing and EDI.

So this slide is simple.

It is a request to the executive that they provide a plan to council that would allow us to reach a 50% appropriation to housing and EDI in the out year of 2033. We requested two different versions of that plan, one that shows us how we could achieve that with new revenue, and one that shows us how we could achieve it without new revenue.

And simply put, colleagues, I want us to be afforded the opportunity to make this decision to see if we can get what I would say is back to those previous goals or those previous numbers that we hit in 22, 23, and 24. So colleagues, I ask for your support.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Thank you, Council Member Foster.

Council Member Kettle, I see you have your hand.

SPEAKER_07

[2m11s]

Thank you, Chair.

Thank you, Council Member Foster.

It's interesting.

I was thinking about this earlier because there was a different item that we were discussing and related to the payroll expense tax, it's almost like we need a new name.

I recognize half a decade ago that there was a need for a jumpstart but does anybody has a car?

If you're still jump-starting your car every year, five years in, it's probably time for a new name.

And I would add too that today's jump-start, as called by many, as I call the payroll expense tax, you know, we're in a different place than we were five years ago.

You know, one of the things to highlight is You know, five years ago we didn't have a housing levy.

We didn't have a social housing levy.

We didn't have these different pieces.

But for me, my position on this is related to good governance and budgeting.

I think flexibility is a key.

Today's payroll expense tax is not yesterday's payroll expense tax because we're in a different place.

And from a good governance point of view, we do need this flexibility.

And this is why even, you know, like with the mayor, to have this, you know, essentially a companion to the general fund to give that flexibility as conditions change.

And having that is really helpful.

If we silo ourselves into certain areas, I think that's problematic.

And again, from a good governance perspective, flexibility is key.

And, you know, just to note, as I said before, We've had a lot of changes in the last number of years related to the housing levy, the social housing levy.

There's been different pieces.

And I should also note, because it hasn't been really discussed, but the Human Services Department has been increased under the mayor's proposals.

And maybe that's the avenue that we need to go to.

And this kind of reaffirms the idea that we have to have this flexibility.

The good governance and budgeting is going to basically drive my position on this slide here.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you, Councilmember Kettle.

Vice Chair Rivera.

SPEAKER_04

[1m33s]

Thank you, Chair.

And thank you, Councilmember Foster, for always centering your highest priority is housing.

And I understand that.

I respect it.

And, you know, I think writ large, we all support housing and EDI and the other investments that were initially proposed like the, what's not contained, I didn't read in here, but the Green New Deal investments, et cetera.

I do agree, however, with my colleague about the flexibility of the payroll expense tax.

We've seen over the years we've had to rely on the Jumpstart funds as well as general funds.

So to me, I feel like we should be looking at PET as a general fund piece and then having the flexibility and then prioritizing what we're gonna spend in general between Jumpstart and general fund.

because I think from a, as Council Member Kettle said, from a good governance standpoint, I think it is the best way to handle both of the, or handling the Jumpstart funding.

So for those reasons, I'm not going to be supporting this today, though I support the underlying pieces of it.

Thank you so much.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you, Council Member Rivera.

Colleagues, any further discussion?

SPEAKER_14

[1s]

for further discussion.

SPEAKER_15

[10s]

Just want to thank the sponsor for the conversation that we had on Friday about percentages.

Don't need to rehash it today.

Councilmember Foster, you've got last word and then we'll take it to a vote.

SPEAKER_01

[14s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

I want to just take a quick opportunity to ask some questions to central staff just to clarify comments that were made.

Jen, did we have a housing levy five years ago?

Sorry, Chair.

I meant to direct that to you.

Yeah, Jen.

SPEAKER_20

[19s]

In 2020, when Jumpstart was passed, we did have a housing levy.

The housing levy at that time was much smaller.

It was $290 million over seven years.

And then in 2023, voters passed a larger housing levy, which was $970 million over seven years.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[19s]

Thank you so much, Jen.

I just wanted to clarify that.

I know that we've, I believe it was the other council members' intent to speak to the fact that we have a significantly larger housing levy.

So just wanted to ensure that the record reflects that accuracy.

And then second, is there anything in this slide that requires that we're bound to this percentage?

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Jen, thank you.

SPEAKER_20

[16s]

No, this is a statement of legislative intent, which is always really a request to the executive.

And in particular, in this case, it is requesting a plan from CBO on options for how to achieve this, which would then be for council's consideration in the future.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[12s]

Thank you, and then final question here.

Could you just speak to the increased costs in the housing sector over time, operations, maintenance, construction?

Jen, thanks.

SPEAKER_20

[1m25s]

As you referenced, there have been a number of increases in the affordable housing sector, both on the capital and the operating side, I would say really since 2020 and the start of COVID, and of course that includes things like increases in construction costs due to supply chain disturbances, tariffs, a number of factors, but there have also been substantial increases in operating costs for affordable housing providers.

A lot of those are around increased insurance costs and increased security costs are the two that often get cited the most.

I'll add to that that we have seen since the beginning of Jumpstart that an increasing amount of Jumpstart is being used to support operations, affordable housing projects.

And yes, that includes operating maintenance and services contracts for our permanent supportive housing projects.

But increasingly, we're also looking, the city is also using Jumpstart to pay for operations at non-PSH projects or sort of your typical affordable housing projects.

for things like the urgent operating support request for proposals or things like debt restructuring for affordable housing projects, which are helping them to increase their cash flow and be able to deal with some of these increased operating costs.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Foster, you still have the floor.

SPEAKER_01

[20s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

Colleagues, I'll just once again ask for your support.

Thank you for that summary, Central Staff.

You know, my belief is that good governance is also about providing transparency, even if the original intent has changed, ensuring that we are responsive to our residents and getting back to what we originally promised and intended.

So with that, colleagues, I ask for your support.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[10s]

Thank you.

Council Member Juarez, I see a new hand.

I know we just gave Council Member Foster last word, but- I know, I apologize, Mr. Chair.

I'll pass it back to you if you need to, Council Member Foster, but Council Member Juarez, take it away.

SPEAKER_21

[2m41s]

Thank you.

Thank you, Sharon.

Thank you, Catherine Foster.

Sorry.

There we go.

So I know you guys don't want to hear this, but I'm going to say this.

I was around when this happened, and when we passed it, whether you want to call it the jump start, the Amazon, the PTE tax, whatever, and it was a big slog, nine or ten months.

of negotiations and initiative, then it getting pulled back, and then it put it back in, renegotiated, and the original intent, and I believe that this is probably a long time coming.

I want to thank Council Member Foster.

I know we've had some discussions about this offline.

Going back to the original intent of why we passed this.

Now, if you look at the record, and I will own it because that's who I am, I voted no, me and one other council member.

Other than I, seven people voted yes, two voted no.

And this is where I get to say I told you so.

Exactly what I said would happen has happened.

I said if we don't put this out to the people and let the people decide like we did with parks, there's no voter mandate to say this money is going to X and that's where it's going to stay.

We did that with the Mitch Felton Park District money, we do that with REIT, we do that, I mean we can list the things where that's how it started.

So it's kind of like a bait and switch.

I voted no because, not that I didn't believe in this, I wanted it to go on the ballot, I wanted the voters to tell us this.

Because my concern at the time was this, What's gonna happen is you're gonna pass this and the original intent, I don't care how many resolutions you pass, it's the city treasury.

It will go to the general fund and it'll get used for other stuff.

And people are not gonna be happy about that.

They will do that Christmas tree effect.

So first it was housing and then it was gonna be for climate.

Then it start backfilling the general fund and then people are taking out 10 million here and 5 million here.

So my hat is off to you Council Member Foster for probably saying the quiet part out loud.

that we need to talk about, revisit, and stay true to these principles.

They're not progressive.

They're not democratic.

They're not.

I mean, let's not label it.

This is about a need.

And seven people on Seattle City Council voted yes that we wanted it to come.

At the time, I got a little snarky, I'll apologize, from the ivory tower.

and again, that's why I said I don't think nine people should impose a tax unless we have more than the will of the people, that that money is going to that thing.

And so I am wholeheartedly supporting this and thanking Council Member Foster and I apologize for raising my hand late.

Thank you.

No problem at all.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Council Member Foster, any last words?

SPEAKER_01

[1s]

No, thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[4s]

Thank you.

Would the clerk please call the roll on CBO 6SB?

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Foster?

SPEAKER_01

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[7s]

Council President Hollingsworth?

Aye.

Council Member Juarez?

Yes.

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Lynn?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Rink?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[10s]

Council Member Rivera?

No.

Council Member Saka?

Aye.

Chair Strauss?

Aye.

Seven in favor, two opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[20s]

Thank you.

The motion passes and CBO 6SB will be added to the budget.

We're going to move on to Deal 3A.

I move Deal 3A.

Is there a second?

Second.

Thank you.

It has been moved and seconded.

This item was placed in Package B because it utilizes the Federal Reserve as its funding source.

With that, over to you, Central Staff.

SPEAKER_25

[15s]

Deal 3A would add $800,000 to the Department of Education and Early Learning.

as one-time support for Seattle College's parent education and cooperative lab preschool program using federal backfill reserve funds.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Sacca, sponsor the amendment.

You are recognized.

SPEAKER_22

[6m15s]

Thank you, Chair.

Look, I stood up the other day ago for Del Ridge.

I'm damn sure gonna stand up for kids.

I'm gonna stand up to support working families.

I'm gonna stand up to support parent education.

So for almost 80 years, the Seattle College's parent education and preschool programs have supported Seattle families, creating a community asset that would be difficult and costly to rebuild if we lost it.

During the 2025-26 school year, these programs served approximately 1,686 parents at 21 specific preschool site locations across the city of Seattle.

These programs help parents build critical life skills, parenting skills.

They support children development and connect families with vital community resources during critical early years.

As a proud parent of three, I'll tell you there's no playbook, there's a lot of resources out there and books, self-help books, not one of them.

is truly helpful in terms of helping you be a better parent.

But you know what is helpful in terms of our individual ability to be the best parents we can be?

Community, leaning on each other, leaning on these vital programs like the preschool co-op programs.

And two dozen state legislators, the Seattle Colleges, labor organizations, and many other groups are working hard to see a fix put in place in the next year's legislative session to save these vital programs.

And we need to, the budget chair's point earlier last week, we need the state to step up and we hope that they do.

And that also doesn't absolve us of our responsibility to do what we can and step up from a city of Seattle perspective and provide this one time emergency funding in order to get this program in a better financial state, so it can be saved once and for all.

Again, what we're talking about is bridge funding here.

Colleagues, earlier last week, my office circulated with each of you in your respective offices a packet of printouts, and apologies for killing a bunch of trees and paperwork, but this is important stuff.

Among other things in that packet was a letter from AFT Seattle the American Federation of Teachers, who obviously indicated their support, and they were obviously here.

Multiple of their locals were here last Friday and sharing with you directly more than just a letter.

We saw a letter from the organization dated July 21st, 2026, towards the tail end of the FEPP Levy Implementation Plan conversations, supportive of pleading for help from the city.

There's something from, I think, Seattle's Child magazine, a great report, periodical, dated August 2026 about the story.

A resolution from the MLK Labor Council dated March 18, 2026, asking for support, asking urging continued program resources being directed towards this co-op.

And last but not least, in this stack of paperwork, my apologies, colleagues, but there was a letter from the chancellor and presidents of both the North Seattle and South Seattle Colleges dated November 5th, 2026, urging continued passage and adoption.

This is his paperwork.

Of course, I'm gonna stand for my constituents in such a critically important thing, but don't take it from me.

Take it from the members of the community who took the time, their busy days to show up and come in and pack the chambers.

By the way, on multiple days, multiple occasions, it wasn't just Friday.

It was, you know, take it from AFT, One of the AFT members said, she's not demanding, she's not urging, she's begging, begging us to take action.

Take it from great community organizations like Via Communitaria who showed up, who have affiliation with this great program.

Take it from people like mom and West Seattle resident, Nikki Wolf.

Take it from people like former legislative candidate, Mary.

Take it from future leaders like Mimi.

Remember that beautiful little girl who stood right there?

And one of the best council speeches, certainly one of the best public comments that I've seen in almost three years, this four-year-old girl.

Three-year-old, brilliant.

Urged us to support this exciting investment.

Don't take it from me.

Proud to wear this t-shirt.

A couple of weeks ago, in some of the public comment, they were seeking just a champion.

to bring this proposal forward.

Honored to be that champion alongside my colleagues, Council Members Rink and Lynn.

And special shout out to Council Members Lynn, because the truth is it's really hard sometimes, especially the later stages of this process, to get council sponsor, like co-sponsors.

We need at least two.

This is one of the first times I've actually seen where a council member came to me and said, if you put this forward, I will co-sponsor it.

Council member Lynn, shout out to you.

Really appreciate you and your partnership on this and your willingness to get this done.

I don't know where the chips are going to fall, but they were asking for a champion.

We have that at the sponsorship stage.

Colleagues, now I'm asking for all of us to be a champion and support this vital community need.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you, Councilmember Saka.

Councilmember Lynn.

SPEAKER_06

[3m29s]

Thank you, Chair.

Thank you, Councilmember Saka, for bringing this forward.

And, you know, I know this was a tough one kind of coming at the last minute, even though this has sort of been on the radar for many months, you know, I don't think it was necessarily seen as the city's role to step in here, but I think when there were no other options, we're the backstop.

and I do think that this is one of the, hopefully if this passes, one of the most impactful things we can do this budget season.

We heard such powerful testimony about how this really saves lives.

and that's because it can be incredibly difficult to be a parent for many reasons.

We often hear about the difficulty, financial difficulties of what it means to be a parent in this city.

But I think we heard through testimony about the difficult, how hard it is from an emotional standpoint, from a community standpoint to be a young parent.

And just, you know, I reflect on my time I remember coming home from the hospital with our first newborn and just being shocked that we were able to leave the hospital.

Because as you said, there's no manual for this or there are books, but they do not prepare you for what it means to be a parent.

And I remember my wife had to immediately go back to the hospital because of a medical issue, and there I was left alone with a brand new newborn.

And again, feeling totally unprepared.

I also remember when my second was born, and I got to be a stay-at-home dad for about four months.

And on the one hand, it was time that I will never forget, and I also remember how hard that was, how it was supposed to be this wonderful time, but it was deeply difficult for my self-esteem, and isolating.

and I think that is true for so many parents who don't have a sense of community and we saw how this co-op program really created that sense of community.

And I think especially in our city where we have so many young families who might not be from here or young families who maybe their families have been displaced and so they might not have that same strong family support system that you otherwise would rely upon.

and so again we have many parents who don't already have a built-in safety net and this preschool program provides that and what I heard was a strong commitment to go down to the legislature I hope we can add this to our legislative agenda to get funding back from the state.

And I'll just say one last point.

I think this was cut from the state funding because of changes to how they allocate funding at the state level for their community colleges.

And they're really focusing on things that are recognized workforce credentials.

And I just find that a little and I think it's all disappointing because I think it just reinforces the sense that somehow caregiving, childcare giving, parenting is not valuable or is not the most important job of all jobs.

And so hopefully we can get that fixed next year and that this provides that bridge funding in the meantime.

Thank you, colleagues.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you, Councilmember Kettle followed by Rivera.

SPEAKER_07

[2m03s]

Thank you Councilmember Saka and Lynn and Ring for bringing this forward.

I'm thinking about, as it relates to Olympia, that when I retired from the Navy, I often talk about public safety, public health, and homelessness.

And in terms of mental health spending, when I retired from the Navy and became a Seattleite, we were like 46 out of 50 states.

And over the years, talking to Representative Barry and others, they increased it, but then we're like 32nd.

And we may be a little bit higher than that right now, but really the state really hasn't been doing its duty as it relates to mental health, which has impacts across the board.

And I think about the county, which has the public health responsibility, you know, and in terms of that area, like we should have three crisis care centers, or are soon to have the third one up and running, but we don't.

partly because of some inflationary pressures that are not limited to one area of public spending.

But the point here is we need, as a city, for the state and the county to do their parts.

And we need the state to do its part here with education, particularly when we're doing so much with the FEP levy, as worked by Councilmember Rivera and really all of us.

This isn't important to Councilmember Lynn's point.

It is kind of unique in the sense that to try to do a restart would be very difficult.

So I will support this, but with the caveat, I mean, really this is a one time.

And sadly, I don't really have a lot of faith in Olympia.

So if this comes up next year, I'm sadly gonna have to be a no.

And again, my faith in Olympia, is not really that high as seen in those examples I just gave.

But I think if we do highlight these pieces, I think that maybe we can help it be successful, because at the end of the day, education is so key.

Thank you, Chair.

Thank you, Council Member Kettle.

Council Member Rivera.

SPEAKER_04

[4m27s]

Thank you, Chair.

Colleagues, this program at the state level Actually, with the limited resources, my understanding was that the program was changed, the parameters of the program changed in order to prioritize individuals who were taking classes to get certificates to actually work at a preschool, whether it's a co-op or otherwise.

And that's why then, prior to that decision, parents could take these classes who had kids at a co-op so they could help in their child's co-op preschool because being a co-op parent there's a requirement that you have to give us some certain number of hours to the co-op because that's what makes up the co-op all the families working together to take care of the preschool needs at that co-op preschool.

So that is why we are where we are today.

I did follow up with Council, excuse me, with Representative Paulette because I wanted more information about where the state, you know, where this might be at the state and whether this is something that is going to be included in in the budget in Olympia for this coming session.

It's about a 50-50 chance that this is going to get funded is what Representative Pellett said back to my office.

So, you know, this is of a concern.

It's a state program.

It's not a city program.

We're now being asked to backfill You know, again, this is one of those on the merits of it, that's not the issue.

The issue is whether or not we can sustain this funding today and ongoing, because I think that if the state doesn't fund this, then folks are going to come back next year to want us to continue to fund this ongoing.

And therein lies the issue is that you know this isn't something that I just I don't know where we would do the ongoing funding from for this particular program.

So like my colleague Councilmember Kettle I will support this today as a one-time add to hopefully have Olympia reconsider and or come to how else the state can help support the parents.

But I do find it a little bit, you know, I'm a parent, obviously, and so I understand that the parents that came here today, this is not a childcare program, nor is it helping support parents.

There is a PEPS program in town, the Program for Early Parenting Support.

They do provide that.

early support to parents when they first become parents.

It's a great program.

This isn't that.

Obviously, this is a preschool program.

We fund preschool and childcare, and I'm really so grateful that we have those investments at the city.

This is for co-op preschools that are important as well, and I'm grateful that parents come together to create those co-op preschools.

So this isn't, again, I don't think anyone up here is not for children and not for parents and not for supporting people and still in community.

And I don't know of anyone up here who wouldn't provides support.

It's a matter of can we, and that becomes tricky on a state program that then there's so many state programs that then don't get funded and then folks look to the city to be that backstop.

As one of my colleagues put it, I think that will be hard, but we'll see where this goes.

And like I said, I'll support it today as a one time, but we'll have to see what happens at the state level.

and hopefully colleagues, some of you will advocate in Olympia to make sure that this continues at the state level so that we're not having to be that backstop because it's a sizable contribution.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you.

Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[19s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

I wanted to ask, I know there have been a number of numbers that were floated in terms of supporting the program, and I've also heard that this is a bridge.

I'd love to know just how much additional time we're able to support the program with 800,000.

Jasmine?

SPEAKER_09

[10s]

Yes, my understanding is that to make it to the end of the school year, they needed $1.6 million.

And so $800,000 is about half of that.

Won't get them another quarter or so.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Councilmember Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[50s]

Thank you so much.

So I take that to mean the sort of the January quarter is what this would support.

and just noting I'm seeing Jasmine from Central Staff nod affirmatively.

The other thing I wanted to just confirm and affirm, we heard some of the speakers who came on Friday, I heard someone say they anticipated that they would be closing in four weeks without additional support in their public comment.

and that raised a question for me that I just didn't have the time to answer which is how quickly we'll be able to get these funds out of the door just given our own budget timeline and that these are $20, $27.

Are we taking some different steps in terms of contracting to ensure that they are not closing and reopening or have we had conversations with Seattle Colleges about that?

SPEAKER_09

[38s]

My understanding is that there have been no specific conversations between the department and the Seattle Colleges about this yet, but I did confirm that this wouldn't necessarily need to go through a competitive process that could be directly allocated to the Seattle Colleges because we're contracting with another government institution for a specific program and services.

So theoretically the money could get out the door pretty fast in 2027. I don't know if it's January 1, 2027. And so those conversations I think would have to happen once this funding was approved, if it's approved.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[14s]

Thank you.

And I appreciate the comments from Councilmember Rivera in terms of the state.

Is there any additional information that wasn't already stated in terms of the state's commitment or their anticipated commitment to be the other side of the bridge?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Jasmine?

SPEAKER_09

[6s]

I don't have any information about the state's commitment thus far, but I don't know if any other council members have been having conversations.

SPEAKER_15

[5s]

Anyone want to share anything?

Council Member Foster, you still have the floor.

SPEAKER_01

[35s]

Thank you.

Those are my questions.

I just wanted to understand that a little bit more.

I think I, like all of us, was really touched by all of the folks who are in chambers on Friday and the folks who are worried about losing their access to childcare, and I think it's a worthwhile effort to help extend that for them.

I just want to make sure that we are kind of monitoring it and that we're able to get the resources out of the door quickly enough.

So I will be following up.

I follow up with a bill sponsor of the department afterwards, depending on this vote today, just to make sure that we've got all of those components in order.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[8s]

Thank you kindly.

Council member Lynn, is that a new hand?

Council member Rivera, is that a new hand?

SPEAKER_14

[0s]

Okay.

SPEAKER_15

[5s]

Council member Rivera and then Lynn.

He already spoke as well.

SPEAKER_04

[1m48s]

Thank you.

Just Jasmine, I know sometimes we do have a contract with the colleges for other investments, but this is a new program for us, so there will be some time.

I know it'll take, I just want to level set expectations.

I know it'll take the department a minute to, it's not as simple as just increasing the contract and that's it.

Here's the money.

because there are things that we're going to need back from the colleges in terms of reporting.

How are we going to set this up, et cetera?

So to your point, Council Member Foster, and I appreciated the conversation over the weekend about this is, you know, I know we both have concerns about how quickly this can get stood up in order to actually help the families.

And I don't want folks to have the expectation that this can get done super quickly, not because we don't want to.

I just want to underscore that again.

And I do think that having a little extra time to let parents and the state hopefully figure out, is there a path, a different path forward than the city, than starting this new program?

Because I don't know that we'll be able to identify future funding fund for will be important.

I think sometimes giving a little extra time to figure out on the back end what hopefully the state can do is really important.

So I think, you know, but I do want to level set expectations because I know that this will take the department, you know, a minute to actually do.

So hopefully it could get done in time, but, you know, we'll see.

And I'll certainly work with the department to lend my support to see how best we can accomplish this.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Lin.

SPEAKER_06

[59s]

Thank you so much.

And I just want to pass on, I did briefly chat with the AFT folks that were here on Friday.

And they were aware that it was going to take some time.

And they were hopeful that the colleges could do some internal accounting or something.

As long as they knew it was coming eventually, that perhaps there would be a way to make this work for them.

I think the other part of this is just that this just shows if this passes that we are sending a message that this is a valuable program that helps them to go fight for these funding in Olympia and or to find other philanthropy or other funding sources.

So this just, I think it makes it more likely that they will be able to get those funds not only because it allows a program to continue but sends a strong message that we value it.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[1m15s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any further discussion?

Further discussion?

I'll just say that the Federal Reserve is not a state reserve.

I think that this is an important use of these dollars.

I do wanna be just, I'll say this for my own amendment in a few minutes.

We originally set this reserve up after we spent a million dollars a week for four to six weeks when SNAP benefits were retracted by the federal government.

And so while it feels like there's quite a bit of funding in this bucket, it only takes one poorly thought out action by the federal government for us to spend a million dollars a week.

This again, we are the backstop for the federal government right now.

We're being the backstop for the state.

We are funding the homelessness response, that is actually the state's responsibility.

We are funding the housing response, which is actually the state's responsibility.

We are funding through Department of Education and Early Learning.

We are funding the Seattle Public Schools, which is the state's responsibility, at which point in time is the state going to take their responsibility.

I'll be supporting your amendment today though, Council Member Sacco.

Councilmember Saka, you got last word, and let's take this to a vote, please.

SPEAKER_22

[4m04s]

Thank you, Chair, and I agree this is principally a state responsibility, and that's in large part why I chose what the community has identified as the most impactful lesser amount, as opposed to the 1.6, and in addition to the fact that I didn't think there would be strong of support for the full amount for the reasons already mentioned.

But I think this is a great amount that would give them, get them to that next critical stage and to pile on Council Member Lynn's comments earlier.

I think the thinking here is that, you know, obviously, ideally, the sooner that this could be paid out by the city, the better.

But the understanding is that Seattle colleges could be comfortable, more comfortable carrying the budget in the near term as long as they know reimbursement from the city is coming at some point.

And this investment in down payment and commitment as reflected in the final adopted past budget from the city could help and would help unlock additional non-city investment from the county, from the state, from private philanthropy, et cetera.

Again, it is intended to be one time to pile on everyone else's comments.

Yeah, I agree.

This should be part of our Olympia legislative agenda.

And I'll note that just a few days ago, someone asked me randomly, like, what do you consider to be your political base?

And it's a great question.

And I think this investment falls neatly within that category.

And whether people agree with me politically on any number of topics or not, I think this is an important investment to support working families, parent education, building community, all those things.

That was who I originally considered to be my base.

The dozens and dozens and dozens of people who showed up and testified in favor of this and the hundreds who heard about it and wanted to and maybe planned on showing up and testifying or sending things, but the vagaries of life and parenting and the struggles of parenting caught up to them and they weren't able to for any number of reasons.

but I appreciate all the feedback that we did here on this.

Here are some examples that we heard, more, more.

Again, all this is part of the record and it has been documented, circulated in digital format.

These great handprints, we need this program, beautiful handprints.

More beautiful handprints.

I'm a personal fan of this one.

I don't know what it says.

but it's a bunch of letters arranged in no particular order, but it's cute, AF.

And more, more, there's more, plenty more where this comes from.

Really appreciate everyone who showed up and I'm hopeful, irrespective of, I know you all support the things that we all talked about, regardless of whether you vote, but really appreciate all the time that was taken which I had three hands right now to hang this up.

Anyways, to support this community, I ask for your support.

And again, I wanna thank my council member co-sponsors, Lynn and Ray.

SPEAKER_15

[4s]

Thank you.

Will the clerk please call the roll on deal 3A?

SPEAKER_13

[5s]

Council member Foster?

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_18

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[6s]

Council member Juarez?

Councilmember Kettle.

Councilmember Lin.

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Rink.

SPEAKER_00

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Rivera.

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Saka.

SPEAKER_22

[1s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Chair Strauss.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_99

[1s]

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[21s]

Deal 3A is added to the budget.

We'll move on to, and I'll move FG2B.

Is there a second?

I'm sorry, I wasn't using the microphone.

Deal 3A is added to the budget.

Moving on to the next item, I move FG2B.

Is there a second?

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_15

[20s]

Thank you, it has been moved and seconded to adopt FG2B to the budget.

Central staff, would you provide a quick overview?

This one is new, which is why it's in B and I'm the sponsor, so I'll speak to it.

Yeah, I'll speak to it second and then we'll have discussion.

Over to you, Jen.

Jennifer.

SPEAKER_20

[55s]

Thank you.

This amendment would decrease HSD by 3.5 million in 2027 and in 2028, and then increase HSD Finance General and FAS by 3 million in 2027 and 3.6 million in 2028. and imposed provisos, all related to implementation of the Vehicle Resident Assistance Program.

And I do wanna take a moment to just note that the initials for that are VRAP, but I wanna note that there isn't the word permit there.

So this is the Vehicle Resident Assistance Program, slightly different than the language used and FG002A trying to signal that these are for services or for costs that are related broadly to supporting vehicle residents and not specific to a permit program.

SPEAKER_15

[2m34s]

Thank you, Jennifer.

Colleagues, As we've heard a couple times, I developed an amendment for the VRAP program in partnership with the Mayor's Office.

That amendment was withdrawn earlier today.

This amendment here is for the VRAP program.

The permit part of the VRAP program was very small in consideration of the entire program.

From our discussion earlier this week, It's clear that outreach services and resources that we provide to people who live in their vehicles, any vehicle of any kind, has been systemically underfunded.

In the VRAP program, we currently have one shelter storage lot within there.

We may need more.

we may need another safe lot.

I've been very clear that having safe lots just in Soto does not serve Seattle's population in the way it needs to.

I would be very interested in having a safe lot up in the north end, especially in District 6. We also know there's also safe parking provisions within the VRAP program.

This is for the truck drivers who are coming to and from the port.

There may be other industries that need to be expanded to this.

We talked about the need for potentially a safe lot just for veterans near the VA.

This is what that money could or would fund.

In addition the mayor has copied and pasted my legislation into her executive order and that workgroup may have costs that they need to They may have programs that they see that need to be funded This is where that funding would come from the permit aspect of the legislation was under a million dollars As I've stated this type People who live in their vehicles make up about 25% of the population of folks experiencing homelessness and yet we've been systemically underfunding them.

We've been overlooking people who live in their vehicles in any and all types of vehicles.

This funding takes the first step in ending our overlooking of 25% of the population experiencing homelessness today.

And so I look forward to working with all colleagues, with the mayor's office, with their work group to figure out how we best spend this funding to assist people who are experiencing homelessness while living in their cars and vehicles on the streets of Seattle.

Colleagues?

Discussion?

Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[42s]

Thank you so much Chair Strauss and thank you again for the addition in the budget for the safe lot and I just I really appreciate your leadership there.

I do have a couple of questions and I don't want to relitigate obviously what we've been talking about here but I'm looking at the CBA and I want to just make sure that we have clarity on what this CBA does and then the separate I believe the separate resource that's included in the year-end supplemental So, as I read this, it states that the year-end supplemental has a carry forward for $4.8 million, and I understand that to be separate from the resource that this CBA contemplates.

Is that accurate?

SPEAKER_20

[36s]

That is correct.

There is 4.8 million in the 2026 adopted budget.

And there were pre-introduction changes made to the 2026 year and supplemental that automatically carries forward that 4.8 million in HSD.

There are also about $4 million of provisos on that funding that also automatically carry forward.

So they keep the money in HSD and the addressing homelessness BSL and limit it to uses such as really around sort of programs to support vehicle residents, including but not limited to outreach.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Councilman Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[17s]

Thank you.

And then, so there's 4.8 million in carry forward, 4 million of that is provisode.

And then can you, and I believe my understanding is that resource that is provisode is a one-time resource, whereas what we're looking at here is ongoing.

Is that accurate?

SPEAKER_20

[12s]

That is correct.

So the 4.8 million, the entire 4.8 million is one time because it's just being carried forward from 2026 into 2027. And then the CBA FG2B provides ongoing resources of 3 million in 2027. And then in 2028, that's 3.6.

So the ongoing amount in the out years is 3.6 million.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Councilmember Fosser.

SPEAKER_01

[17s]

Thank you.

And then can you differentiate the proviso, and I apologize if this is repetitive to the conversation we're going to have with year-end supplemental, but if you can differentiate how that $4 million is provisoed in the year-end supplemental from what is contemplated in this budget action?

SPEAKER_20

[1m19s]

There is some overlap.

So there's three provisos in FG2B.

The first proviso is 1.5 million in HSD for outreach to vehicle residents.

The $4 million under proviso the provisor that will carry forward from the year-end supplemental also includes money for outreach and then also contracted and city outreach and then other things like potentially a recreational vehicle buyback program or services to help vehicle residents be able to just move their vehicle and be compliant with code like jump starts or tire repairs.

But I would say for the HSD one, there's quite a bit of overlap between the two.

and then there are two other provisos in FG2B, one with FAS that restricts funding to be used for either having a new RV storage lot, setting up that new program or other costs related to increased impound and storage and then a proviso on funding and finance general which is really just sort of using it as a parking lot while other details are figured out coming out of the working group that will be stood up.

Thank you, Councilman Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[37s]

Thank you.

And then if I can just get clarity for the way that, now looking at the CBA, for the way that these resources are provisoed and the relationship between this proviso and the working group, I'm looking to kind of understand what is the mechanism for lifting this proviso or is it contemplated that that will be action we take when recommendations come from the working group?

I'm not sure that it was spelled out in that way in what I read on paper, so I want to make sure, because as the chair has stated before, there's some decisions that may come to us in January.

SPEAKER_20

[1m14s]

So I'm gonna walk through each one of the provisos because I think it will depend.

So for example, looking at FG2B, there's a proviso on 1.5 million in the Human Services Department.

They could spend that at any time, as long as it was on the uses that the proviso states, which is...

contracted outreach, right?

Or sorry, City of Seattle or contracted outreach.

So they could, the executive could at any time in 2027, if this amendment passed, spend 1.5 million on outreach to vehicle residents.

Same for they could at any time in 2027 choose to spend this money either on setting up a new RV storage lot or even the way the proviso is written, for example, just stand up a new impound lot or pay for increased towing cost.

The money in finance general, that's about a million dollars.

that would need, there would need to be legislative action to appropriate that out to other departments in order for that money to be spent.

This is really truly just kind of a parking space for it right now.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[12s]

Got it.

So thank you so much, Jen.

So as I understand it, the resources that are in finance general, I heard you say that some of it could be used for storage or impound lot or other components.

Oh, is that accurate?

SPEAKER_15

[6s]

I'm going to let you finish your statement and then I'll come back to Jennifer in just a minute.

Sure.

Thank you.

Unless you want to just stop and then I'll turn it over.

SPEAKER_01

[6s]

I'll stop there.

I just saw an indication of a response from the table.

Thank you, Chair.

Thanks.

Jennifer?

SPEAKER_20

[14s]

It's a little confusing because we have Finance and Administrative Services, FAS, and then also Finance General, FG.

So it's FAS, Finance and Administrative Services, where we have funding, for example, for an RV storage program or a new impound lot.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[25s]

Thank you for that clarification.

So it is, if I'm looking at the proviso, the FAS resource can be used for the storage lot or for in-pound.

The resources in the Human Services BSL can be spent at any time in alignment.

And then the resources that are in FG and Finance General, which is in the middle of this little sandwich on the proviso, those are the resources that would require further legislative action in order to release them.

SPEAKER_20

[2s]

Jennifer?

That is accurate.

SPEAKER_01

[1s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[4s]

Any further questions?

Councilmember Foster, any further questions?

SPEAKER_01

[0s]

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Councilmember Lin.

SPEAKER_06

[14s]

Thank you, Chair.

I'm just following up on that last point.

Is there any sort of anticipated timeline for releasing that sort of middle bucket if a good use for those is identified?

Jennifer?

SPEAKER_20

[5s]

I don't have that.

I think that would in part depend upon recommendations coming out of this new work group.

SPEAKER_06

[25s]

Thank you.

Well, in general, I am supportive of this.

I appreciate the need for all of these funds for better serving our vehicle residents.

And I appreciate having some sort of funding available to implement, potentially implement recommendations coming from the work group.

And so for that reason, I'll be supporting.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you, Council Member Rivera.

SPEAKER_04

[34s]

Thank you, Chair.

Jen, can you tell us, so how does this, it sounds like there's a lot of unknowns with how this and when this money will be implemented.

I'm just wondering, how does this marry with the mayor's plan?

I know she announced she's gonna have a plan for vehicle, for RVs, and I just don't know specifically what the plan is, and I don't know how this will be utilized in furtherance of that plan.

Do you have any info about that?

SPEAKER_20

[32s]

I don't think I have probably much more info than you do, which is really that she has announced that she'll have a work group, that it will develop recommendations for how to address vehicle residents or problematic vehicles in the city.

and I think we could see this CBA and additionally the 4.8 million that's getting carried forward automatically as being potentially available resources for recommendations coming out of that plan should they need to be resourced.

But other than that, I don't have more details.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Rivera.

SPEAKER_04

[19s]

And do we know when the mayor's going to have, it's okay if you don't, I don't know when she will announce actually what the plan is.

Do you have a sense?

I mean, are we looking at the end by the year's end?

Are we looking by Q1?

I'm just wondering.

SPEAKER_20

[16s]

I believe that it is a fairly expedited timeline and that she was talking about having recommendations, maybe, and this goes to Councilmember Lynn's question now too, I'm remembering, as early as the end of Q1, 2027. Thank you.

Councilmember Rivera?

SPEAKER_04

[22s]

Thank you, Chair.

And so this money will be set aside to help implement, then I imagine, whatever the exec's plan is. or we can decide at the mid-year to lift the proviso and use the funds in a different way, depending on how the plan comes to fruition.

SPEAKER_20

[30s]

I think the most accurate way to answer that question would be that there's a million dollars in finance general, and that truly is being held in reserve until the executive proposes and council adopts specific purposes for that, but there's also money in the human services department and finance and administrative services, which could be used, you know, should this be adopted or passed by council on January 1 purposes in the proviso.

So it's a combination.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you.

Council Member Rivera.

SPEAKER_04

[26s]

Thank you, Chair.

And then there's some positions attached to this CBA.

And so is it that we're going to hold off?

Are these going to?

I mean, there's seven, looks like seven counselors and one permit technician, although I guess we don't need the permit technician if we're not actually permitting.

So is this still moving forward or?

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Jen, and if you want me to jump in at any time, just let me know.

SPEAKER_20

[40s]

Okay, this is actually, so these positions were actually created and approved by council with the passage of Council Bill 121282 back in September.

That was the appropriations bill related to the VRAT program at that time.

They are in here in the CBA purely as a technicality.

Like we're not creating them, we're not approving them.

Ed and could tell you more about why they're here, but this is truly, truly a technicality.

Council already took action to approve those eight positions when it approved Council Bill 121-282 back in September.

Council Member Rivera?

SPEAKER_04

[4s]

Are they in process to be hired?

Do you know?

SPEAKER_15

[2m31s]

And may I, which is just to say, this all has been moving very quickly, right?

With, I did not want to overlap the RV, and actually I'm gonna stop calling it the RV legislation because the Vehicle Residency Assistance Program is designed for people who live in all vehicles.

There was one set of regulations that came along with permitting, and that was specifically on RVs.

I am not intending that these positions are hired at this time because I don't know that the mayor knows what they're doing.

I've been working in close partnership with the mayor's team until we weren't.

This is simply stating we are going to move forward with funding the things that we know we've been systemically underfunding when it comes to addressing homelessness for people living in their vehicles.

for the rest of the money.

The mayor's office still has not reached out to me at this time about what's going on with the work group.

I am simply saying, I know that whatever their recommendations are will probably cost money This is me remaining in good partnership despite everything that's happened over the last few weeks.

This is me remaining in a cooperative and compassionate, we have to be in cooperation if we're gonna do this work.

This amendment before us simply presses pause until all of these details can get figured out.

Because at this point, I'm not sure what the mayor's doing.

I know that there are needed funds.

And when I was in conversation with the mayor's office, there's a clear knowing that there's a bow wake of resources and services people need because we've been systemically underfunding them.

So I thank you Council Member Foster for identifying the one-time versus ongoing.

We can't run any programs without ongoing funds, which this is.

The one-time funds also need to address that backlog of services that we have not been providing for far, far too long.

And so all this is, is it's a simple reset.

The mayor's office still has not been in communication with me about how they want to move forward.

All I know is that we do need to move forward to help the people that we've been overlooking for far too long.

So to answer your question really directly about hiring positions, I don't expect them to hire them.

This funding is set to the side under proviso, so I don't believe that they can hire them.

But it's all just to say the conversation continues.

Jen, did I get any of that wrong?

SPEAKER_20

[52s]

I would only say that the 1.5 million is under proviso, but it is under proviso for both city staffed and contracted outreach.

So it's a possibility it could be used to fund these positions.

But again, I would agree that the executive has not given any indication that they plan to do that in the short term.

I also have a little bit more information about timing of the recommendations, if I could just share that.

Okay.

Thank you to Cal for sending this over.

So the executive order does say that within 60 days of the executive order, which was I believe last week, the working group will deliver recommendations to the mayor, Recommendations will include any executive transmitted legislation needed to change city laws to effectuate the intent of this order, and legislation will be transmitted by March 31st, 2027. Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Council Member Rivera, you still have the floor.

SPEAKER_04

[22s]

Sorry, thank you.

So if we were not to pass this, because these are provisos of HSD's funds for this certain purpose, correct?

Jen?

Yes.

So if we don't pass this, then we're looking at the mid-year.

If there is a need, then we're having to find money for that need.

SPEAKER_20

[40s]

I think two things will happen.

So the pre-introduction changes me to the year-end supplemental, which automatically carry forward 4.8 million from 2026 into 2027. So if the year-end supplemental passes as it was introduced, that 4.8 million will be available in 2027. for work to support vehicle residents.

This CBA would then provide an additional $3 million in 2027 and $3.6 million in 2028 to support vehicle resident work.

So if this did not pass, there would still be resources available, one-time resources available in 2027. Councilmember Rivera?

SPEAKER_04

[45s]

Thank you.

So you're saying there's going to be seven point something million available if this passes for 2027 and then the 3.6 in 2028?

Yes, that's right.

I'm thinking there is money in the year end for 2027. Is it necessary to continue the 2027 investment in this CBA rather than just include the 2028?

Because it's in essence almost doubling the investment for and we don't yet know what the plan is and we probably won't know until the end of March.

SPEAKER_15

[56s]

Thank you, Councilman Rivera.

It is important that we move both investments forward.

And the reason is programs that are ongoing in nature cannot be sustained with one-time funds.

And so that's the importance of this ongoing CBA.

It is also important that we move forward the one-time funds to address the bow wake of services that we have not been providing.

And I say that because, and I was very clear with the executive that if when we implement this program to assist people living in their vehicles, that if there was money that was not needed, that we could send that to other parts of addressing homelessness or other parts of the city functions that we needed.

But what we don't know is what is the total cost.

And until we know that, that's where I am not comfortable necessarily releasing funds because we need to address this issue.

Over to you.

SPEAKER_04

[1m35s]

Thank you, Chan.

I understand one time versus ongoing, but it is true that there will be 24.8 million in 2027 already if we pass the end of year supplemental.

So this is just another 3.5 on top of that when we don't even know what the plan is until sometime at the end of the first quarter.

So I do think this is more money than then we know maybe what we're going to be doing.

What am I trying to what I'm trying to get at is we already have 2027 funding in that end year supplemental to the tune of 4.8 million and we don't even know what that's going to fund.

So I appreciate you saying about one time versus ongoing.

I understand the difference.

and also I'm not sure we need 7 point something million next year when we don't even yet know what is needed.

And I don't know what you mean by bow wake because we have folks living in tents and RVs, et cetera, that all need services.

And we are trying to provide as many services as we can for folks to get folks housed.

so I'm not really sure what the extra would provide at this point.

I feel like we're tying up funding that could be used for other purposes since there's already money in the year-end supplemental for this program or what will be a program.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any further questions?

Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[22s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

I just had one final question here, and that is on the positions, on the final page of the budget action, it references the permit technicians.

And I just wanted to understand, are those permit technicians part of what the CBA provisos the resource for?

I missed the final page.

I apologize, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Lish?

SPEAKER_25

[24s]

Yeah, so because you adopted legislation in September that added those positions, this is basically a technical action to reflect what the council did in September.

It doesn't create new positions, and it's probably unlikely that the executive will fill that permit technician position until a plan is set.

Amen.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

And Jen?

SPEAKER_20

[18s]

to that this CBA does not provide any funding to SDOT.

And additionally, one of the pre-interchanges that was made was backing out the SDOT funding, the money that was given to SDOT in that prior appropriation bill I talked about.

So at this point SDOT is not receiving any funding to implement this program.

SPEAKER_01

[26s]

Councilmember Foster.

Thank you so much, Chair.

I just wanted to clarify that.

I appreciate the discussion today, and I appreciate the difference in the need for ongoing funds to support ongoing needs.

I will be voting no on this today because some of the things around the finance general hold, but I appreciate the clarity, Chair, around your intent here to make sure there are resources available once decisions are made in 2027, so thank you for speaking to that.

SPEAKER_15

[24s]

Thank you.

Any further discussion?

Final discussion?

I'll close this out with just saying again, we've been overlooking people who live in their vehicles and that is any type of vehicle for far too long.

This funding takes the first step in ending our systemic overlooking of 25% of the population experiencing homelessness on city streets today.

With that clerk, will you please call the roll on FG2B?

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council member Foster?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_13

[29s]

Council President Hollingsworth Councilmember Juarez Councilmember Kettle Councilmember Lin Councilmember Rink Councilmember Rivera Councilmember Saka Chair Strauss Seven in favor, one opposed, one abstention.

SPEAKER_15

[10s]

Thank you.

FG2B is added to the budget.

Council Member Rink, did you withdraw FG3A?

Is this something that you still wanted to move forward with?

I can't recall.

SPEAKER_03

[5s]

Thank you, Chair Strauss.

I believe I withdrew this one.

I know there's a few amendments related to position authority.

SPEAKER_15

[16s]

Great.

You have withdrawn this.

We'll move right on to HSD19A.

Sorry, moving HSD 19A.

Is there a second?

SPEAKER_25

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you.

It's been moved and seconded over to central staff.

SPEAKER_25

[8s]

HSD 19A would restore two positions to HSD to support the unified care team.

No funding is provided.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Councilmember Foster, you pulled this amendment.

Over to you.

SPEAKER_01

[13s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

I know we've talked about this a lot during the budget process.

My position here is around adding position authority for positions that are not funded.

It's something I don't agree with and I wanted the opportunity to vote no.

SPEAKER_15

[15s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any further discussion?

As sponsor of this, I will just say that it is important to retain position authority even if we don't want to fund or fill them historically or any time.

Over to you, Council Member Rink.

SPEAKER_03

[2m13s]

Colleagues, I'm going to use this opportunity just to speak to the multiple amendments that pertain to position authority for the unified care team.

I will be voting no on all of them, and I'll just use this time to speak to this altogether.

Colleagues, I know we've talked at length about the need to balance public space management and access for everyone to our public spaces while also addressing unsheltered homelessness.

I know there's a lot of history here and there's a continued evolution for the unified care team.

What I do want to elevate today is my concern about the category of sweeps known as obstruction removals and that our quarter three report that was delivered on Friday indicates that there have been 1,780 obstruction removals so far this year.

Only 48% of those removals included offers of shelter.

So I'm concerned by this, but what has heightened my concern are the recent reports repeatedly coming now out of Cal Anderson Park and community members in the Capitol Hill neighborhood about the lack of coordination between UCT units, between UCT and SPD, and the apparent UCT conduct in contradiction of their own policies and procedures.

One particular piece of that conduct to note is the fact that UCT is supposed to safely store people's belongings.

And what I am hearing is that some members of UCT are saying the opposite to people involved in obstruction removals.

This is understandably making people scared.

scared for the little belongings that they may have left.

And this feels particularly cruel during cold season.

these people's personal belongings are often life-saving gear.

And so outside of this, I have made formal requests from the mayor's office to get more information about what is happening here and considering pausing activity until we get to the bottom of exactly what kind of communication challenges are happening.

But until I have clarity on what is happening here pertaining to unified care team conduct, I cannot support granting additional position authority at this time.

SPEAKER_15

[21s]

Thank you.

Thank you, Council Member Rink.

And just clarifying, this is not granting, it is not removing position authority, and it's not funding these positions.

Colleagues, any further discussion?

Seeing no further discussion, those were last words.

If the clerk could call the roll on HSD 19A, please.

SPEAKER_13

[10s]

Council Member Foster?

No.

Council President Hollingsworth?

Aye.

Council Member Juarez?

Aye.

Councilmember Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[1s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Lin?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Rink?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Councilmember Rivera?

Aye.

Councilmember Saka?

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Chair Strauss?

Aye.

Six in favor, three opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[23s]

Thank you.

HSD 19A is added to the budget.

Moving on to HSD 29SA.

This is one of council member Kettle's amendments that he had more than three, which is why it moved to group B.

We'll have central staff brief.

First, I'll move HSD 29 S A. Is there a second?

SPEAKER_18

[1s]

Second.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[11s]

It has been moved and seconded.

You guys made me a little nervous there.

Central staff, if you'd like to brief it, council member Kettle, if you'd like to share words, I know you've spoken on it before.

Anything you'd like to share?

Over to you central staff.

SPEAKER_25

[9s]

This is a statement of legislative intent that requests the Human Services Department to report on opportunities to set up a city-sponsored sobering center.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Kettle, you are recognized.

SPEAKER_07

[1m22s]

Thank you, Chair.

As I said before, this slide is based on the lessons learned from working the challenges that we see on our streets.

It builds on the work we did earlier this year related to alternative response and public drug use and possession, the legislation, pieces of legislation that we passed.

Basically, one of the lessons learned is that we need a bridging function from when SPD, law enforcement, and others find an individual in need and to get that person the help and connection that's required.

And we're a 24-7 city, but the system is not necessarily 24-7.

And that, in combination with the idea of giving individuals the opportunity to sober in the sense of having the ability to make a decision in terms of steps forward.

Oftentimes, the individual's not really in a position to do so in the sobering center.

could be a way to do this.

I know there's work with other jurisdictions going on.

There's obviously the example in San Francisco and so forth.

But this lie, I think, is needed to look into the possibility and what it would take and where it could be helpful in terms of addressing the challenges, those individuals that are in crisis.

Thank you, Chair.

I ask everybody for their support.

Thank you, Council Member Kettle.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Council Member Rivera followed by Lynn and Rank.

SPEAKER_04

[1m22s]

Thank you, Chair.

As I said last week, thank you, Councilmember Kettle for bringing this forward and, in essence, reviving HSD031SA from the 2025 budget.

It was a sly asking for pretty much similar in terms of the sobering center.

We've heard from folks from our fire department actually who assist folks and identified a need really for a place where folks can sober up so that they can then be able to consent to treatment, which is really important.

As you all know, colleagues, we all care very much about treatment and appreciate that in the balancing package, there is money for treatment and we wanna make sure that we have a safe place for folks to sober up and perhaps get other services so that they're able to consent to treatment because that's very much needed as you all know.

So thank you, Council Member Kettle for putting this in and I was happy to.

co-sponsor, and as I said last week, or perhaps, yeah, last week, I hope that we get a better answer from HSD this time around on this possibility here in Seattle.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Council Member Lin.

SPEAKER_06

[43s]

Thank you, Chair.

Thank you, colleagues.

I just want to highlight that the statement of legislative intent recognizes that King County has secured a temporary location for a sobering center and then acquired a building in Soto for a permanent sobering center.

And I just think it's always good for us to know what other levels of government are doing and to partner when possible.

Council Member Kettle, I'm not sure if you're sly, precludes us looking at partnering with King County, but I just think it's, you know, that could be one option of how to move forward with this is partnering with them.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[6s]

Thank you.

That was not a question.

Council Member Foster and then Rivera.

SPEAKER_01

[51s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

And Councilman Berlin just spoke to a fact, which is actually at the center of my question, which is I just would love to seek more information around what the intent is behind this sobering center in terms of who would be served that is not served by the county sobering center.

So I know right now they're operating on limited hours, but with intent of 24-7 operation, in 2027 and the location that they're operating at right now, I believe it's just down the street at the King County Administrative Services Center and that the permanent location I believe they're looking at is in Yesler.

So I'm just wanting to understand a little bit more about, you know, obviously this is county operated within the city of Seattle.

So what would be done in this slide that is different from the service that the county is operating?

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Central staff or I can turn it over to the sponsor.

SPEAKER_24

[37s]

I can speak to that briefly.

I would call council members' attention to the third bullet point, for instance, that's highlighted here.

The SLI asks for proposed approaches for the interaction of all city public safety departments with sobering center operating partners and clients.

including drop-off protocols.

And I'm not positive that that's something that the county sobering center has.

In a sense, this slide contemplates a more bespoke facility that's tailored to city partners and providers.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Council Member Foster?

SPEAKER_01

[21s]

Thank you.

So, if I'm understanding that correctly, the intent is to have a HSD provider report on a sobering center within the city of Seattle that would only be accessible to city-operated SFD fire care departments to bring them, no external partners?

Is that the intent?

SPEAKER_24

[16s]

That's not explicitly stated in the SLI, no.

But that is something that is contemplated in the hypothetical sobering center that this SLI considers and is not contemplated in the current King County sobering center.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[1m14s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

I think that's helpful, but I'm still, I suppose, under the belief that if the county, with the county's responsibility, for public health and as the person who sits on the public health board for King County, it's unclear to me what this slide would do that the county's operation doesn't do outside of, and thank you so much central staff and Anne for pointing us to bullet three, but it seems to me that that could also just be served by an operating agreement between city departments with the county operated facility rather than a plan for a separate center that the city would need to incur a cost for if we have one down the street.

So unless there's something else there, this looks like something I'll be voting no on.

I want to say I'm really happy with the proviso, and thank you, Councilmember Rivera, for your support and for all the work around sobering and treatment.

I see that we have something down the street that we can use, and I'm not seeing why we would send the department to create a report back to us.

especially knowing how tight the budget is, it's hard to imagine that we're gonna stand up a separate facility other than the one that already exists and should be 24-7 in 2027. Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Thank you.

Council Member Rivera followed by Hollingsworth and then Lynn.

SPEAKER_04

[2m02s]

Thank you, Chair.

I will say Council Member Foster, thank you for the great question because in my original slide for the sobering center, we talked about King County and making sure that HSD was partnering with the county on their sobering center.

at the time, now this again was for a 2025 slide, the county had their own plans for what they had envisioned for their sobering center.

And it's my impression from those conversations then that the county there were some things that, some conversations that needed to happen, but the response basically led back to us exploring our own sobering center.

I had anticipated are there beds that we can pay for, for Seattle can pay for, for Seattle residents that we utilize the King County, but they had their own plans for their sobering center.

So part of the slide was, can we work with King County to your point, Council Member Lynn, your point, is there a way that we can utilize some of the spaces at the King County?

And I think at the time that wasn't is going to be a possibility perhaps.

And so this is why it was the, well, let's explore citing a sobering center in Seattle so we can take care of our then folks that are in Seattle if we're not able to tap into the county.

So I still think it's important.

And I think council member Kettle, you can speak to this.

It's your actual sly now, but I would advocate for continuing conversations with the county to see if that we can partner together and if not, then HSD can come back and say, well, that's not gonna be a possibility.

So we're gonna have to, here's what it looks like for us to do our own.

It's a slide, right?

Like give us information.

But I think both of those things should be part of this slide.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[8s]

Thank you.

Any, I see Anne's got a couple of comments and then Councilman Rivera, if you have anything else to share.

SPEAKER_24

[32s]

Thank you, Chair.

I would just add that one component of the requested report is a cost-benefit analysis of the operations of a new sobering center by city staff, by contracted providers, and by making use of county facilities.

So the facility that is referenced in this slide would not necessarily be entirely duplicative.

There's some room to examine different approaches.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Anything else?

SPEAKER_04

[28s]

Well, yes.

Thank you, Ann.

That was, yes.

HSC go look.

How could this work?

Do we need one here?

Can we tap into it?

Can we partner with the county?

Does it have to be a full site?

Is there something we, you know, can we contract part of a site?

You know, all of that is on the table, but the point is there is a need for some type of sobering facility that we can bring folks to.

And so what, what would that look like?

So all of that's on the table.

SPEAKER_15

[4s]

Thank you.

Thank you.

Council Member Saka and then Kettle for last word.

SPEAKER_22

[28s]

Thank you, Chair.

Just want to say thank you to Prime Sponsor Councilmember Kettle, along with your co-sponsors, Councilmembers Lynn and Rivera.

I think this is a great thing, and it's a sly, so it's worth a look.

And if we're...

I don't know, Mr. Chair, if we're doing additional co-sponsors, but to the extent it's possible, would love to add my name as an additional co-sponsor, if possible, on this.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[16s]

Thank you, I'd love to not open that hand doors box today, but I'll, as noted here, and if we, if there's any objection, hearing no objection, we'll see what we can do, but would love to leave that door closed today.

Fair enough.

Thank you.

Council Member Rink, new hand.

SPEAKER_03

[1m01s]

Thank you, Chair Strauss.

I share in some of the concerns that Councilmember Foster has raised in terms of our coordination with the county.

And to that end, I understand this is a statement of legislative intent.

This will get us more information.

I do think information will help us on the basis of future decision making on this matter.

However, I do want to uplift this is a report from the Human Services Department, but it is being directed to the Public Safety Committee.

And so I'm just offering up as Human Services Chair.

It is my hope and I would hope that the sponsor of this slide could commit to some type of joint session.

I do think it's important that the Human Services Committee is involved in this discussion, particularly since it is from the Human Services.

The report will be coming from the Human Services Department.

So I'm willing to support the slide today to help get us some information to continue a policy discussion and would love to get more information as well from the county on their work.

But I want to ensure and really hear that the Human Services Committee will be involved on any ultimate report.

SPEAKER_15

[12s]

Thank you.

On behalf of the Seattle City Council, welcome Council Member Elect Elu Jenks.

Welcome.

Colleagues, any further conversation on this?

Council Member Kettle, any last words?

SPEAKER_07

[1m48s]

Thank you, Chair.

I just wanted to note, again, working these public safety challenges that we see on our streets, that's what drove, like, our work this summer.

You know, it's the, you know, diversion.

You know, what's inhibiting our officers to do what needs to be done in terms of diversion.

The medical decline issue at KCJ Health and KCJ overall, King County Jail.

So we're working with the county on that.

And another thing is that this bridging need, second, third watch, I've talked to service providers, all the precincts I'm remembering conversations with two lieutenants at the North Precinct and they have an issue, a person who's in need, it's the third watch, nobody's answering the phones.

That's what happens.

and then we don't get a solution.

We don't get a good solution.

And so this is where this is coming from.

As noted in that one bullet, I'm happy to work with the county.

I'm working with them right now on medical declines.

Happy to do so.

And of course, without saying, working with the Human Services Department too.

So the bottom line is we need to address the problem and in order to drive a solution to the problem, we have to have some facts on the table, which is a big challenge that we have in this city, getting the true facts on the table, and to get solutions.

And I'm totally open working with the county.

I mean, I'm doing it in different ways already and happy to do so here, but I just want to start driving the conversation, start driving getting the facts on the table so then we can work in partnership.

This is the same issue between public safety and, in this case, human services, and looking to see what we can learn from that to support courses of action moving in the future.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[4s]

Thank you.

Clerk, please call the roll on HSD-29SA.

SPEAKER_13

[5s]

Council Member Foster?

No.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[3s]

Councilmember Juarez.

Aye.

Councilmember Kettle.

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Lin.

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[8s]

Councilmember Rink.

Yes.

Councilmember Rivera.

Aye.

Councilmember Saka.

Aye.

Chair Strauss.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[2s]

Eight in favor, one opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[6s]

Thank you, HSD 29, SA is added to the budget.

Moving on, I move A, HSD 34A, is there a second?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_15

[10s]

Thank you, it has been moved and seconded.

This was an item put into Group B because it pulls on the Federal Reserve funds.

And so we'll turn right over to central staff and then directly over to you, Council Member Rank.

SPEAKER_25

[19s]

This CBA adds $1 million in 2027 and 2028. for gender-based violence programs and services, and would decrease Finance General by $2 million in 2027 from the Federal Backfill Reserve.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Council Member Rank.

SPEAKER_03

[1m13s]

Thank you, Chair Strauss, and thank you for that overview.

Colleagues, last year when we developed the Seattle Shield Initiative, we were being responsive to a changing federal policy landscape, and we've continued to unpack that in the Select Committee on Federal Administration and Policy Changes, and this has enabled us as Seattle city government, specifically this body via the budget process, to step in and step up.

for our most vulnerable sectors and constituents who the federal government has walked away from.

We've reduced the local impacts of federal food cuts to food access, immigrant legal services, shelter and homelessness prevention, and as with those areas, we've seen federal funding cuts across the spectrum of gender-based violence services in response.

from cuts at the Department of Justice to policy changes at HUD that have had devastating impacts on our ability to support survivors of sexual assault and commercial sexual exploitation.

This ad will build on the funding that was included in the chair's package.

Colleagues, I want to thank everyone who has been in support of this effort.

The actions we are taking in this budget really is a step towards working towards a larger, sustained, ongoing investment in addressing gender-based violence in our community.

and I ask for your support.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[8s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any discussion?

Council Member Rivera, then Saka.

SPEAKER_04

[1m04s]

Thank you, Chair.

Thank you, Council Member Rank for your focus and for that add of $5 million that's in the chair's package.

I do also really appreciate the slide regarding getting information back on how the overall $17.1 million is being implemented.

And also, Councilmember Kettle, really appreciate you adding money to the city attorney's office to manage for the backlog of many of these cases.

So, I really appreciate all of us who are working together.

All of that's in the Chair's package.

Because this is hitting the Federal Reserve money, and because we have information we're going to get back by which to make future decisions, the Federal Reserve money will be there.

If in the midyear we need to do more, I think we can do more.

And for those reasons, I won't support this one today.

But like I said, I'm glad that we have the $17 million in the budget overall.

to be able to address this important need.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_22

[52s]

Thank you.

Council Member Saka?

Thank you, Chair.

Just wanted to thank Council Member Rink for your leadership in bringing this forward, both the original amount that was included in the Chair's balancing package to support gender-based violence programs, and also this, recognizing that it's a great investment, it's a great down payment, but it's not quite enough.

So thank you for your leadership in helping to close the gap.

between community need and what resources available and appreciate your leadership.

Excited to support this today and also co-sponsor it and really looking to you and your leadership on this, you know, recognizing how difficult it must be to take away from the Federal Reserve as sort of one of the chief architects of that effort, you know, to begin with.

So, but happy to support this today.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Thank you.

SPEAKER_06

[35s]

Thank you, Chair.

And I just want to say thank you to Council Member Ring for all your work on the gender-based violence.

As I think about public safety issues, I can't think of a better way to spend some of these critical dollars to help our community.

And when I think about unreported crimes, I think about gender-based violence and especially want to thank you for working so closely with Councilmember Juarez to include the focus on missing and murdered indigenous women and relatives.

Thank you.

Councilmember Rivera.

SPEAKER_04

[2m39s]

Thanks and I should have said thank you Councilmember Juarez for your focus on the missing and murdered indigenous women and girls and regardless of whether this passes or not I know that in that 5 million and overall the 17 million we are and should be making and it is my expectations and you have my commitment to follow up on that because I know and I'm sad you're leaving us.

You have my commitment to make sure and keep my eye on that as well so that that money, that 17 million is going to the missing and murdered indigenous women and girls.

regardless if this were to pass today or not, because that is really important and something that we need to be putting more focus on.

And I should also say I'd like to know, and part of the report is what are we doing on Aurora and how is the $17 million that we are already spending going toward helping the girls that are being raped on Aurora mainly and many of which are black and brown girls and indigenous girls.

And also not that we, if a child is being raped, it doesn't matter who the child is.

And the fact still remains that a lot of those children that are being exploited and raped on Aurora are black and brown.

of kids.

So I want to know how this money is going to help those kids.

And this is why I really want to see the report back, hopefully in quarter one next year.

so that then we can make future decisions about what we do and then what is needed and for what purpose.

Because right now I've asked many questions of HSD and I'm not getting satisfactory answers on what is happening on Aurora.

And this is part of what we're talking about here.

So before I go supporting additional funding, I want to know that that money's actually going to help those girls on the ground.

So you have my commitment on that.

and I want to make it very clear that this is an issue that I care very much about and that I also want to make sure we're doing our accountability piece because to the point of it's not enough, I don't even know what this money is currently doing to be able to say how much we need, what do we need?

So that is really important to me.

Thank you, Councilmember Juarez.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Council President Hollingsworth.

SPEAKER_18

[21s]

I'll be quick.

I want to thank both Council Member Juarez and Council Member Rink for your leadership on this.

I'll be supporting this and just thanking to Council Member Rivera for highlighting that.

That's all I wanted to say.

I'll be using my platform every time talking about 50% of the girls that are on Aurora are black and brown and 71% of the people that are buying them are white men.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[7s]

Thank you.

And clerk, do we need to move version two or is there a parliamentary thing that we have to do at this moment?

SPEAKER_11

[7s]

I'm just not aware if there's clarity that we are discussing version two versus the one that was on the agenda.

SPEAKER_15

[42s]

Thank you.

I have found clarity.

Just want to clarify, does anyone think It seems like we all have clarity.

Great.

So I'll pass it over to you, Council Member Ring to close us out.

I'll be supporting your amendment today.

I do just in your closing remarks, if you can explain how your spend plan for the $5 million included in the chair's package, the $2 million in this amendment and the $17 million in the budget already, how that amounts to over $20 million.

Can you help us understand how this money is being spent and why this additional $2 million is needed now in addition to the $5 million that was just appropriated during chair's package.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_03

[2m11s]

Thank you, colleagues.

I want to just start with a lot of gratitude for every conversation I've had with a council member, a part of this body.

I think it's an overstatement to say every single one of us has been touched by or impacted by or know somebody who has been impacted by gender-based violence.

And I know this is deeply personal work.

and I feel like the entire effort has improved and really gained focus because of each of the conversations that I've had with your offices.

And so a huge thank you to Council Member Juarez for being a good teacher and improving on this work.

Thank you.

A big reason that we were pushing towards, you know, beyond what was just included in the chairs back and why we've also included a statement of legislative intent here is so we can really align our approach and make sure that these dollars are being spent in a thoughtful but also strategic way.

We've worked alongside the coalition ending gender-based violence to survey their 30-member coalition to better understand where gaps and needs are.

That is where we've identified that there are DV housing programs that may be at risk where clinics have had to cut hours in response to different forms of cuts.

And the just current status quo leaves caseload ratios at a very high level.

We've heard some reports from organizations that some organizations have a caseload ratio of 50 to 1. We know that is a lot of people to be walking alongside and being able, by encouraging this investment now, one, we would be able to address some of the federal funding cuts that are coming our way, have already happened and be able to restore some services, but also to be able to improve the staffing levels at many of these organizations so folks have bandwidth and capacity to show up at every step.

and so I'm really encouraged by the support and wanna be clear, this is an ongoing effort.

I look forward to bringing this work into my committee next year to have these robust discussions and ensure that we are providing oversight and really moving forward in a thoughtful and strategic way as we look at where we put the additional dollars.

So colleagues, I thank you again for your support and I ask for your vote.

SPEAKER_15

[4s]

Thank you.

Will the clerk please call the roll on HSD 34A version two?

SPEAKER_13

[7s]

Council member Foster?

Yes.

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_18

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Councilmember Juarez?

Aye.

Councilmember Kettle?

SPEAKER_18

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[3s]

Councilmember Lin?

Yes.

Councilmember Rink?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[9s]

Councilmember Rivera?

No.

Councilmember Saka?

Aye.

Chair Strauss?

Aye.

Eight in favor, one opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[18s]

Thank you.

HSD 34A version 2 has been adopted to the budget.

Moving on, I move HSD 43A.

Is there a second?

Second.

Thank you.

It has been moved and seconded.

This is also drawing on the Federal Reserve, so I'll turn it over to central staff to brief the item, and then I'm the sponsor.

SPEAKER_25

[15s]

This CBA would allocate $1 million, reallocate $1 million from the Federal Backfill Reserve to the Human Services Department.

to support coordinated care and insurance enrollment assistance for residents at risk of Medicaid disenrollment.

SPEAKER_15

[1m26s]

Thank you, sponsor of the amendment.

I'll just state briefly, last year the federal administration passed that so-called beautiful act, which is not so beautiful.

That bill introduced new eligibility requirements for Medicaid enrollees starting October 1st, 2027 that could kick millions of people off of their health insurance.

Estimates project 22% of Washington Medicaid enrollees could lose their coverage as part of the Big Ugly Act.

This funding would help combat that.

It would be used to fund Healthier Here to create better data integration between larger Medicaid service provider network and city social service programs to track and respond when patients fall through the gaps between care settings and navigate residents to insurance enrollment resources more effectively.

Funding data integration work could help support the collaboration between the city of Seattle, local clinical programs, community-based providers and King County funded programs.

Seattle did not create this program, the federal government did.

and if we don't do anything to address it, the impact will be on our Seattleites who are most in need and could pose significant impacts on our hospital systems.

I'm proposing this also in part because Aging Disability Services is part of Human Services Department is the pass-through agency for federal dollars and already engages in this work.

Colleagues, I hope to earn your support.

Open for discussion.

Council Member Foster, followed by Lynn.

SPEAKER_01

[53s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

I just want to express my sincere gratitude to you for bringing this forward.

I had met with Healthier here earlier this year, and I think this is just, it's such a huge issue with the Medicaid disenrollment.

I won't say a ton about it.

I think you've spoken to it really well already, but I just want to express my gratitude to you for bringing this need forward to try to help prevent so many people from getting disenrolled and all of the impacts that that's going to have on Seattle residents.

And I'll just use this as another opportunity to express my gratitude for your leadership and support when it came to the work on medical debt.

And I just want to uplift you.

Sorry, Councilman Juarez, I said uplift for your leadership.

I want to center and uplift you, Chair Strauss, for your leadership on this really important issue when it comes to health access and health equity.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you, Council Member Lund.

SPEAKER_06

[59s]

Thank you, Chair.

Well, I guess somewhat of a question.

One, I don't think there's any doubt for the need for this type of work to make sure that as few as people as possible lose or disenrolled.

I think that is money very well spent.

The impacts of disenrollment are gonna be enormous, unfortunately.

and any way that we can reduce that, I think, again, will be more than payback and dividends.

Just one question about Healthier Here, I just know that there's a lot of organizations out there that are gonna be helping our community to try to stay enrolled and just wondering how Healthier Here was chosen and or if there are other organizations that also are doing similar work, how do we help the larger community?

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Thank you.

Is that a question directed to me?

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Sure, that'd be great, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[21s]

Yeah, Healthier Here, it's my understanding, already works with the city of Seattle, already works with this population.

I'm not agency specific, but it's my understanding that they're the ones already doing the work, so.

Thank you, colleagues.

Further discussion?

Further discussion?

Final discussion.

Will the clerk please call the roll on HSD 43A?

SPEAKER_13

[7s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

Aye.

Excuse me?

SPEAKER_18

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[5s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Juarez?

Yes.

Councilmember Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Lin?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[8s]

Councilmember Rink?

Yes.

Councilmember Rivera?

Aye.

Councilmember Saka?

Aye.

Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[2s]

Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[35s]

Thank you.

HSD 43A is added to the budget.

We'll move on.

The next two are slides.

I am gonna ask that we move quickly through slides.

We are right now at 320. We're gonna have a choice point to make in about 40 minutes on whether we stay late today or come back tomorrow morning at 9.30.

I am seeing 9.30 tomorrow does not work.

So we will have a conversation in just a couple minutes.

But my ask is for statements of legislative intent, please speed up.

We'll spend as much time on the budget actions as we need.

Move ITD 1SA.

Is there a second?

SPEAKER_10

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_15

[12s]

So it has been moved and seconded.

This is a slide.

Council Member Rank already had three in the chair's package, which is why this one comes separate.

I'll go over to central staff for their briefing and then we'll move to Council Member Rank.

SPEAKER_25

[3s]

Quarterly Reports on the City's Use of Artificial Intelligence.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Maureen.

SPEAKER_03

[20s]

Thank you, Chair Strauss.

Regardless how each of us may feel about AI use, I believe we can all agree that transparency matters, and our constituents deserve to understand how AI is being integrated across departments.

This is a repeat slide.

IT is already doing this level of reporting.

I found these reports tremendously helpful, and I believe they should continue.

SPEAKER_15

[6s]

Thank you.

Thank you.

Further discussion?

Further discussion?

Council Member Rivera.

SPEAKER_04

[21s]

Yes.

Thank you, Chair.

Council Member, or sorry, excuse me, Central Staff, how is AI defined for the purposes of this lie and the report that maybe IT's already been doing?

related to AI.

Is there a definition?

I'm just curious.

SPEAKER_23

[14s]

Good afternoon.

Brian, good night.

Council central staff.

The slide certainly doesn't define what artificial intelligence is.

I would have to go back and look and see if their report defines what it is.

But typically it's using...

Well, I won't even try to define it on the spot.

It's not defined.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you, Council Member Varys.

SPEAKER_04

[51s]

Thank you.

Council Member Rink, I don't know if you're amenable, but would love to include a definition or, you know, how is the city using AI and what type?

Because it's such a broad term.

that'd be really great as part of this report to understand, you know, how we're defining that.

And I imagine in your report that you've seen from IT, they're already talking about how they use AI, but the use is becoming more expansive, and I just want to make sure that we're capturing, you know, what it is that we mean.

So I don't know whether you had already intended to I imagine this is not an exhaustive list for this report, but would love to ensure that this report also includes the definitions of.

SPEAKER_15

[11s]

Council Member Rink, I'm gonna pass the floor to you.

Although if we don't have amendments right now, I don't know that we will be able to move forward.

Hold on, before I pass it over to you, Council Member Rink, Cal, do you have something to add?

SPEAKER_16

[16s]

Yeah, I just very quickly looked at the city's website for a number of policies generative AI has identified, so there are some definitions.

It would take me a little while to find out exactly what they are, but broadly speaking, machine learning is the definition used.

SPEAKER_15

[6s]

I just want to make sure the department is clear on all the pieces that they would have to address, given the expanse definition of AI these days.

SPEAKER_16

[11s]

I think that there is a broader U.S. definition that's been used that the executive references, and I think that's where they're at.

Okay.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Okay.

SPEAKER_04

[1s]

Thanks, Chair.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[5s]

Thank you.

Any further discussion?

Will the clerk please call the roll on ITD1SA, please.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_18

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[3s]

Council Member Juarez?

Aye.

Councilmember Kettle.

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[12s]

Councilmember Lin.

Yes.

Councilmember Rink.

Yes.

Councilmember Rivera.

Aye.

Councilmember Saka.

Aye.

Chair Strauss.

Aye.

Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[8s]

Thank you.

The motion passes.

ITD1SA is included in the budget.

Moving on to...

I move OED15SA.

Is there a second?

SPEAKER_22

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_15

[7s]

It's been moved and seconded.

Central staff, will you please provide the briefing?

And then Council Member Saka for quick overview.

Council...

SPEAKER_25

[10s]

This is a statement of legislative intent asking for a report on opportunities for grocery store access improvements in North Delbert.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Council Member Saka.

SPEAKER_22

[37s]

Thank you, Chair, colleagues.

This is a slide that I introduced last month in October.

I did not happen to make it in the balancing package, so here I am advocating for it again.

North Del Ridge residents have waited far too long for reliable access to a full-service grocery option, and so it just explicitly requires North Del Ridge to be included in OED's grocery market evaluation work, among other things, evaluating at least three potential sites and the final report must recommend a viable strategy.

Thank you.

Or clearly identify what needs to change in order for the neighborhood to make it viable.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[6s]

Thank you.

Any further discussion?

Seeing no further discussion, will the clerk please call the roll on OED 15 SA.

SPEAKER_13

[26s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

Aye.

Council Member Juarez?

she said yes.

Thank you.

Council member Kettle.

Council member Lynn.

Council member Rink.

Council member Rivera.

Council member Saka.

Chair Strauss.

Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[28s]

Thanks, OED15SA is added to the budget.

Moving on, the next two are OED provisos.

They were put here because OED had provided specific information previously, but nothing that they've shared since indicates any reason not to pass these.

That is why they are in Group B and not the Chair's package.

I'll move the first one, OED19A.

I move OED19A, is there a second?

Second.

It's been moved and seconded.

Will Central Staff please brief the item and then Council Member Saka, it's over to you.

SPEAKER_25

[20s]

This would provide $200,000 in OED's budget to support occupancy of upper floor commercial spaces in Pioneer Square.

$100,000 was added for this purpose in the consent package, so this would provide an additional $100,000.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_22

[1m00s]

Councilmember Sacco.

Thank you, Chair.

So, first off, I want to thank you chair for including some funding for this investment in the chairs balancing package.

And the original community asked was for $200,000 and that's a great down payment.

This would secure the rest for that funding.

There's a challenge in Pioneer Square with vacant commercial upper floor space.

And so this is both an economic development investment It's also getting more people and visitors downtown and workers down in that specific area.

You know, I view this in activating, therefore activating those spaces.

I also view this as a public safety investment as well in the area.

So I want to thank my council co-sponsors, Councilmember Kettle, and Council Member Rank as well for your leadership in this and I humbly ask for your support.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[8s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any further questions?

Any further questions?

Any further questions?

Will the clerk please call the roll on OED 19A?

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Abstain.

SPEAKER_13

[3s]

Council Member Juarez?

Aye.

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Lynn?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Abstain.

SPEAKER_13

[15s]

Councilmember Rink.

Yes.

Councilmember Rivera.

No.

Councilmember Saka.

Aye.

Chair Strauss.

Aye.

Six in favor, one opposed, two abstentions.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[11s]

OED 19A is added to the budget.

We'll move on and I will move OED 21A.

Is there a second?

Second.

It has been moved and seconded.

Will central staff please brief the item and then I'll turn it over to Councilmember Lin.

SPEAKER_25

[10s]

This item would impose a proviso on OED's budget of $250,000 in 2027 to support neighborhood business district improvements in Southeast Seattle.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Thank you.

SPEAKER_06

[35s]

Councilmember Lin.

Thank you, colleagues.

This is to fund basically to ensure that funding that goes to groups like Beacon Business Alliance, Mount Baker Hub Alliance, Rainier Avenue Business Coalition, they basically serve small businesses up and down the Rainier Avenue corridor throughout the district through the Only in Seattle program that that funding is protected.

In the past, they've actually gotten more than 250,000, and so this is just to ensure a minimal level of support for this critical work, and I would love your support.

SPEAKER_15

[7s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any discussion?

Any discussion?

Any further discussion?

Any final discussion?

Will the clerk please call the roll on OED 21A?

SPEAKER_13

[5s]

Councilmember Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_10

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Juarez.

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Kettle.

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Lin.

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[3s]

Councilmember Rink.

Yes.

Councilmember Rivera.

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[5s]

Councilmember Sacca.

Aye.

Chair Strauss.

Aye.

Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[7s]

Thank you.

OED 21A is added to the budget.

We'll move on to the next slide.

We have Statement of Legislative Intent.

So I move SCL 2SA.

SPEAKER_14

[2s]

Second.

It has been moved and seconded.

SPEAKER_15

[14s]

Will the central staff please brief this item?

This is again, it looks like Council Member Saka, you've got three, how many slides do you have?

So this is the third one today.

So we'll go to central staff and then over to Council Member Saka.

SPEAKER_25

[7s]

This is a request for a report from CLC Light on their practices related to connections to schools and preschools.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Council Member Saka.

SPEAKER_22

[53s]

Thank you, Chair.

Yes, I am a stickler for transparency, I suppose, and accountability.

But colleagues, this slide here would support schools, you know, preschools, public schools and private schools, and as it relates to seasonal academic calendars, you know, helping them make timely utility connections, especially important and relevant.

Delays can mean misconstruction windows, postponed openings and reopenings and disruptions to student learning.

So this slide would help evaluate the impacts and facilitate better planning across preschools, private schools, and public schools.

Simply ask Seattle City Light to evaluate whether current service connection policies and practices are producing equitable outcomes for these three different types of schools.

I ask for your support.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any discussion?

Councilman Rivera.

SPEAKER_04

[12s]

Thank you, Chair.

May I ask Councilmember Saka, I'm sorry, so what are we solving for with this slide?

What's the underlying concern?

SPEAKER_15

[4s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Saka, and then I'll also check in with central staff if they've got anything else to add.

SPEAKER_22

[1m08s]

No, over to you.

Okay.

Thank you, Chair.

Yeah, so the seasonality of schools, whether it's a public school, a preschool, who operate at different sort of schedules and and different set of frequency and cadence than other schools, like public schools whose calendars are well-known and published and documented.

And even then, there's gaps at the individual site level for schools.

So just allow the schools better planning, access to planning and facilitation of these critical utility upgrades when they're not always engaged early and upfront in the planning process for these major kind of utility repairs, especially with City Light.

So just allow better planning, just reflecting that various schools, whether public, private, or preschool, have various seasonality schedules that we need to endeavor to do our best to work around.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you.

Council Member Rivera, are you still on the floor?

SPEAKER_04

[15s]

Thank you.

So it's just as the City Light is doing upgrades and repairs that they consider the schedule so they're not doing it during the school year, maybe off during a vacation time or something.

Okay.

Thanks for the clarity.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[9s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any further discussion?

Any further discussion?

Final discussion?

Final discussion.

Will the clerk please call the roll on SCL 2SA?

SPEAKER_13

[7s]

Council Member Foster?

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_18

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[3s]

Councilmember Juarez?

Aye.

Councilmember Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Lin?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Rink?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[3s]

Councilmember Rivera?

Aye.

Councilmember Saka?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Eight in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[24s]

Thank you.

The motion carries.

SEL 2SA is added to the budget.

We now have another unified care team poll, but I will move SDOT 11A.

Is there a second?

Second.

Been moved and seconded.

If you want to just do a quick brief, I think myself, it sounds like Council Member Rinks already said her piece.

I don't know if Council Member Foster said her piece.

We don't need to repeat ourselves a whole bunch of times.

SPEAKER_25

[5s]

We just need to take the votes, but over to you.

Adds two positions to SDOT for the unified care team, no funding.

SPEAKER_15

[17s]

Thank you.

It's an unfunded position.

They're not adding positions.

It's just that they're not removing them.

Council Member Foster, you pulled the amendment.

Do you have anything more to add?

Council Member Rank and I are not sharing anything else at this time.

Nothing more to add.

Will the clerk please call the roll on S.11A?

SPEAKER_13

[10s]

Council Member Foster?

No.

Council President Hollingsworth?

Yes.

Council Member Juarez?

Aye.

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Lin.

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_13

[7s]

Council Member Rink.

No.

Council Member Rivera.

Aye.

Council Member Saka.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Chair Strauss.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Six in favor, sorry, five.

Six in favor, three opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[16s]

Thank you.

SDOT 11A is added to the budget.

We'll move on SDOT.

So I move SDOT 15A.

Is there a second?

been moved and seconded.

We'll have central staff brief this.

I believe Council Member Foster, you pulled this item, or was it Council Member Rink?

SPEAKER_01

[4s]

I believe it was Council Member Rink, but I have notes on it, so happy to go either way.

SPEAKER_15

[5s]

Sounds good.

We will take central staff, we'll go Council Member Rink, I'm the sponsor, and then we'll open up for discussion.

SPEAKER_25

[8s]

This week provides a $2.5 million of transit funds in the Seattle Department of Transportation to support service on bus route 15 or 17.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Thank you.

Council Member Rink, you are recognized.

SPEAKER_03

[1m15s]

Thank you, Chair Strauss.

Colleagues, I pulled this amendment and I will not be supporting it today.

And to be clear, I think it's consistent with the position that I've had throughout all of our negotiations and discussions on the Seattle transit measure.

I feel a lot of hesitation towards a preemptively taking steps to proviso money for specific routes.

I pushed back on those proposals during the STM deliberations and I'm doing so again today.

I am fully in support of improving transit access to Ballard and doing our part to push to make sure we're building out the Ballard Link extension and purely this is a matter of my deep discomfort again with provisoing bus service funding broadly and holding off money for routes that are also out of our control or inactive.

From the prior discussion here in committee, it's my understanding too that the Route 15 is no longer active.

So in order to really activate and make use of the funding that's set aside for it, King County Council would need to take a vote to bring that route back.

And so for these reasons, I will not be supporting this amendment today.

SPEAKER_15

[1m54s]

Thank you.

Thank you sponsor the amendment.

I'll speak to it just briefly in our last Seattle transit measure that we voted on in over the last summer SDOT's slides themselves demonstrated that Ballard does not benefit from the same frequency that other parts of the city do.

And what they didn't show was the travel times, which are comparable to traveling from downtown Seattle to Tacoma.

That's what we're working with here.

We have two different routes that we could add service to.

The Route 40 that's already had its bus lane upgrades, reducing the travel time from 55 minutes to 45 minutes.

The other option is the rapid ride D, which at the Nordic Museum, the mayor suggested that we add more bus lanes.

However, it's a one lane road.

I don't know where the bus lane goes on a one lane road.

All that to say is just looking for direct service between downtown Seattle and downtown Ballard that does not take the amount of time as it takes to get Tacoma.

This is new funding.

This is not already spoken for funding.

The city missed our opportunity just a few weeks ago to improve the service this coming spring.

So the motion before us brings service online in fall.

And when we had a sound transit event at the Nordic Museum that was packed standing room only, the loudest moment of excitement was for better bus service now, not later.

I'll also just say, I wouldn't bring this amendment if it wasn't a regional growth center, if it wasn't a place where the city has chosen to put density, but has chosen not to put the transit service that is comparable to other parts of our city.

So if you have voted for density in the area before, or if you're gonna vote for density in Ballard again, I ask you to vote for this amendment as well.

Councilmember Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[2m28s]

Thank you so much Chair Strauss and I want to thank you, I think I mentioned this when we were talking about this before, for the amendment that you had when we were doing STM that allowed, I don't have my notes in front of me, I think it was the regional transit centers to be included in the analysis and the equity analysis that SDOT does so that we could get better prioritization of places where we have built for density in the city and I think that was really the right thing to do.

So thank you for that and I was happy to support that.

I wanted to share just some response that we got back from SDOT and part of the reason that I have concern around this approach with provisoing the investment here at the city.

So in response to some of the questions that we asked SDOT, we heard back that if we were provisoing this, it would require King County Council approval before implementation, as this proviso would increase service levels by more than 25% on these routes, which I understand to be part of the Chair's intent because there's not sufficient service from your perspective and from what you're hearing from your constituents.

And because of that, these investments are unlikely to be implemented until 2028. And if these funds remain restricted to Routes 15 and 17, approximately $2.5 million of other transit investments could not be advanced in 2027. So that was part of the department's response.

Something else that I think we heard back from the department was, and I've asked this question in a couple different areas today, was just sort of around trade-offs and other impacts to service.

And so it's my understanding that if we're proviso-ing this and prioritizing these two routes over other routes, that it could have impacts on other places that SDOT is looking at as they take on their prioritization.

So none of this is a question.

It's just more of a statement here from what we got back from the department that is influencing, I guess, my position here.

And so seeing, you know, routes in districts one, two, three, seven, four, five, and six, and it feels to me like we are sort of putting that ahead of the work that the department needs to do.

So for those reasons, I will be voting no on this today.

I think it's important that we have the transit centers as part of the prioritization criteria, but I don't believe that we should be proviso-ing this resource ahead of the county taking on their service realignment work.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[48s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, further discussion?

Further discussion?

Final discussion?

Any final discussion, colleagues?

I will just say, yes, the King County Council approval, I've been aware of that this entire time.

I believe I brought it up at the first iteration of the conversation.

I will also say that the SDOT response that we received, they did not update their matrix to include regional growth centers.

They're still going off the old matrix.

And so I think that their information is outdated and All of that leads me to the statement of now I think people have a better understanding of why Ballard does not have direct bus service.

Colleagues, if final statements, no final statements, will the clerk please call the roll on S.15A?

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Foster?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_18

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[9s]

Council Member Juarez?

No.

Councilmember Juarez.

No.

Councilmember Kettle.

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Lin.

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Rink.

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_13

[9s]

Councilmember Rivera.

No.

Councilmember Saka.

Chair Strauss.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[2s]

Four in favor, five opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[53s]

Motion does not pass and is not included in the budget.

We'll move on to SPD.

We have, and I'm actually gonna ask for us to take at ease.

So that means you all cannot leave.

You can't move.

So we are gonna go into ease.

I'm gonna go confer with central staff and the clerk about how we're moving forward this evening because I've received, so only council member Juarez can leave.

Yeah, we will, we're gonna take an ease for us to figure out how, if we have to move forward this evening, because I will be right back and I will, the last time we did a five minute recess, nobody came back in five minutes.

So I'm gonna ask us, we will, I will be right back.

We are at ease for the moment.

SPEAKER_10

[1s]

Sorry Greg.

SPEAKER_18

[58s]

FYI, the mics are still on for those of us that are remote.

So people can hear us on the Seattle channel right now.

Do you need to stretch?

Thank you, Jody.

I'm also the finest city council president ever.

As you're talking.

Thank you.

So people can hear you.

Rob Sokka has the best glasses.

Bob Kennel has the best suit jackets.

They heard that.

Councilmember Foster has the best biceps and triceps.

SPEAKER_10

[1s]

I can hear you.

SPEAKER_18

[9s]

Thank you.

Eddie Lynn has the best smile for his non-innocent self.

SPEAKER_13

[3s]

Hey, what do I have?

Kidding.

SPEAKER_18

[21s]

Jody has the best voice for the city clerk online.

Council member Juarez has the best boots.

Alexis is always wearing the sharpest G.

These mics are live, by the way.

So they can all see.

SPEAKER_10

[19s]

Okay, well, no, I'm just saying, sir.

Okay, well, people can hear you online.

I love my mama

SPEAKER_17

[3s]

We also have the best security in the country.

I concur

SPEAKER_18

[22s]

We have the best central staff in the country.

So...

Anybody else needs to go right now, we're at six.

Anybody taking a break?

SPEAKER_15

[7s]

Oh, sorry.

Anybody?

It's a Milka Max Choco and Biscuit.

SPEAKER_18

[4s]

So the mics are hot.

Is that U.S. or Japanese?

It's imported.

Imported?

What does that mean?

Where?

SPEAKER_22

[2s]

Thank you.

I'm sure it's amazing.

Austria.

SPEAKER_18

[1s]

Kimmy King Kimmy King Kimmy King

SPEAKER_10

[3s]

We are back.

SPEAKER_15

[5s]

We are back.

Hello?

Will the clerk please call the roll?

SPEAKER_11

[5s]

Councilmember Foster?

Here.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_18

[0s]

Here.

SPEAKER_11

[5s]

Councilmember Juarez?

Here.

Councilmember Kettle?

Councilmember Lund?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Here.

SPEAKER_13

[2s]

Council Member Rink.

Here.

SPEAKER_11

[6s]

Council Member DeBetta.

Present.

Council Member Sanka.

Here.

And Chair Strauss.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Present.

SPEAKER_11

[1s]

Eight present.

SPEAKER_15

[7s]

Thank you, colleagues.

And the clerk mentioned that we need to change, make a correction to the last item.

SPEAKER_11

[12s]

Yes, thank you, Chair.

For the last item, S.15A, I just wanna correct the record.

The vote was three to six with Council President Hollingham's voting in favor, Council Member Kettle voting in favor, and Chair Strauss voting in favor.

SPEAKER_15

[3m03s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, I'm gonna have a bit of discussion and then we will choose to take a break or continue through SPD.

It has come to my attention through conversation.

This morning, I stated we could come back tomorrow morning.

I thought that was true at the time.

did not intend to lie to you.

It is the fact that the standalone legislation, there are only maybe three, possibly four total items that are not necessary for us to vote on for us to enter into quality control.

And so those are the council generated pieces of legislation.

It seems I would not want to set up a situation where we come back tomorrow just to vote on three pieces of legislation.

So we have some choice points.

If we want to finish voting tonight, I recommend that.

We stay on schedule.

We could choose to leave in about an hour and move voting till tomorrow, that changes the entire schedule.

And that would most likely push us into final adoption next week because we have quality control that needs to be done for balancing between now and Thursday.

The implications are that we will have a new council member that has not participated in the budget, voting on the budget.

I think that that's a pretty big one this year.

It's happened the last number of years, but it's happening again this year.

And it also just moves us into meeting likely Monday and Tuesday of next week.

And so I am going to look for just thumbs up to run long tonight, thumbs medium if you don't feel strongly or thumbs down.

So I am, Council Member Saka, you're a medium, everyone else is a thumbs up.

With that, I am going to say that we take about a 20 minute recess right now for us just to get reset.

And then we're gonna be in session for probably two hours until the next break.

just so we're all clear.

I'm not intending to rush everyone.

Everyone has given me their feedback here.

And so we will come back and start with SPD.

We have two more slides, one more UCT, one amendment, and then we're into the consent agenda for legislation.

And then we have a number of standalone bills to vote on.

Everyone feeling good?

We're just gonna pound through this work.

Everyone feeling all right?

Moderate, all right.

With that, if there's no objection, the Select Budget Committee will be in recess until 4.15 p.m.

Hearing no objection, the Select Budget Committee is in recess until 4.15 p.m.

Thank you, colleagues.

SPEAKER_99

[9m39s]

music plays you can see.

I'm going to go to the top of the top of the top Apoid using all capitals'

SPEAKER_15

[37s]

we good yep we're gonna go at ease that means you can't move please until sale channel can bring our audio online and then I see councilmember rank you've got your hand Great.

I'm not gonna ask to call roll again, cause we haven't moved.

We are coming back from ease.

All council members are present.

Council member Rink.

SPEAKER_03

[23s]

Thank you, Chair Strauss.

If I may, I'd like to direct a couple questions on this to central staff.

Thank you.

Greg, thank you so much for being here.

Am I correct in my assessment right now that this request for SPD to prioritize patrol staffing, this would mean that there would potentially not be ads to the Criminal Investigations Unit.

Is that correct?

Greg?

SPEAKER_17

[49s]

Thank you, Council Member Rink.

First, I should acknowledge that this statement of legislative intent is a request to the executive specifically for this upcoming year, and the chief with charter authority to deploy troops however he or she sees fit ultimately will do whatever they think is best from a public safety standpoint.

But in the purest sense, If the Council requested that the Chief focus on growing patrol to the detriment of other units, then in a strict, strict interpretation, one could say that, yes, that it could affect folks going into criminal investigations or specialized positions or other kind of support functions.

SPEAKER_03

[28s]

Councilman Wray.

Thank you.

Thank you for that response, Greg.

That's helpful to understand that there could be impacts to Criminal Investigations Unit folks going into the Criminal Investigations Unit.

And if this request passes and SPD does end up prioritizing patrol staffing growth, these new added officers would be placed on patrol duties.

What do these new officers then, what kind of impact does this have on overtime currently stated for the department?

SPEAKER_17

[1m06s]

Thank you.

Yes, so there are about 135 to 150 officers that are in the student final phases of being student officers over the next six months or so.

Those folks will move into patrol positions, and ultimately that will enhance the department's availability to answer 911 calls and to deploy more folks at hotspots.

To the extent that they can deploy more folks at hot spots on regular time, it can help with overtime.

A caution there is that whenever new police officer positions are added, those new positions can also create their own overtime at end of shift reporting that they would need to use overtime for if they take somebody to the hospital.

So it could and probably would reduce over time, the largest category of which for the department is patrol augmentation.

However, just a caution that there's another side to the equation.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you.

Council Member Rink, you still have the floor.

SPEAKER_03

[2s]

No further questions.

Thank you for those answers, Greg.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Council Member Lund.

SPEAKER_06

[15s]

Thanks, Chair.

Just wondering if we've heard any feedback from SPD.

I'm assuming, or maybe I was wrong, that when we were doing this hiring, the majority of folks were already going to or expected to go to patrol.

But anything you can share?

SPEAKER_17

[32s]

Greg?

I have not heard anything from SPD on this particular statement of legislative intent, all student officers start out in patrol.

It's a matter of whether as student officers are coming in, SPD takes experienced officers and moves them out into specialty positions or criminal investigations, other kinds of positions.

Under this direction from the council or request, I should say, they would, SPD, prioritize building patrol first rather than moving folks in and out, if you will.

SPEAKER_15

[9s]

Thank you.

Council Member Lin.

That's all, thank you.

Thank you.

Colleagues, further discussion?

Further discussion?

Final discussion?

Council Member Kettle will close us out and then we'll take a vote.

SPEAKER_07

[42s]

Yes, thank you, Chair.

To Council Member Lin's point and to what Mr. Doss was saying, it's the roll-off piece, slowing down the roll-off piece, ensuring that we're good on patrol.

To ameliorate the situation, as noted in Council Member Rink's question, we have the five civilians for the Criminal Intelligence Bureau.

I would add the real-time crime center also helps in that respect as well.

So yes, it's about again looking to address the chronic challenges that we're seeing on our streets.

And this is just to kind of show intent and what's important for us as each of our neighborhoods are dealing with this challenge.

Thank you and ask for your support.

Thank you.

Will the clerk please call the roll on SPD 103 S.A.?

SPEAKER_13

[5s]

Councilmember Foster?

No.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Councilmember Juarez?

Aye.

Councilmember Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Lin?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[9s]

Councilmember Rink?

No.

Councilmember Rivera?

Aye.

Councilmember Saka?

Aye.

Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[2s]

Seven in favor, two opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[17s]

Thank you.

The motion carries and SPD 103 S.A.

will be added to the budget.

Moving on to SPD 110 A.

I move SPD 110 A.

Is there a second?

Second.

It's been moved and seconded.

And this is also, we'll hear from central staff and then Council Member Rank.

SPEAKER_25

[6s]

This is a proviso that would limit SPD spending of $400,000 on closed circuit televisions.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you, Council Member Rank.

SPEAKER_03

[1m58s]

Thank you, Chair Strauss.

Colleagues, I am bringing back the proviso that I brought forward in the previous round during the budget.

The intent of this $400,000 proviso is to request that the Seattle Police Department implement the recommendations from the Office of Inspector General to the use of the real-time crime center.

I want to reiterate the three recommendations from the Office of the Inspector General and they are as follows.

First, require that RTCC analysts provide a case number and justification for each time that they view CCTV footage.

Second, adopt criteria for integrating privately owned cameras, including where they may be used, monitoring and remediation processes and retention guidelines, and third, ensure users of automated license plate readers, the ALPR database, provide both a case number and a search justification.

So I do want to state on the record that this proviso and language was written before our office had received the NYU Policing Project audit and that does have similar, if not some overlapping recommendations.

I will note that that Audit finding has 19 additional recommendations beyond what the OIG has covered.

But OIG's recommendations requesting Axon develop features for FUSIS requiring case numbers and developing uniform policies related to all cameras, including private cameras, that does line up with two of the 19 recommendations presented by the NYU Policing Project.

So, colleagues, I do hope that the recent announcement by the mayor and the results of this audit, we can come to an agreement that we need the Seattle Police Department to comply with the recommendations from our own Office of the Inspector General.

It has always been my posture that I'd like to resolve and address some of the outstanding issues on the table when it comes to having this particular kind of technology and systems, and I hope I can get your support on this proviso.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_07

[5m44s]

Thank you, Council Member Kettle, followed by Lynn.

Thank you, Chair.

As the blinds are going up, sorry.

Chair and colleagues, thank you, Council Member Rink.

This CBA, to be frank, has been eclipsed by the Mayor's decision following a comprehensive review of the, as we call it, technically it's called the Technology Assisted Crime Prevention Program via the NYU Law Audit.

It was comprehensive, even viewed by those that are skeptical of the program.

I think this speaks volumes.

The review done by the executive, and I was part of this as part of the draft report that came out before the embargo copied.

and it was definitely reviewed by the executive and by those again that were skeptical of the program.

This review and those by the OIG and the City Auditor in terms of the SDOT will be brought to the Public Safety Committee either in December or January, you know, so within a month or so.

And we will add the, you know, the OIG review and its pieces because Basically, I wanted to highlight that the OIG review particularly, the city auditor too, but specifically the OIG review shows that our accountability system is working.

And this was by design.

You know, this is by design in terms of how it was set up.

And so we take these recommendations and then we work them.

And that's what we will do.

And I will do that in partnership, as I said many times, with the executive, with the mayor and her team.

because I think that's important.

And I thank her for her decision following the NYU Law Audit to move forward.

Separately, you know, I've heard comments in reporting and so forth against the Real-Time Crime Center, noting that like how police officers can track their girlfriends, I would add it's never the other way around, or possibly officers taking information to federal law enforcement.

I want to note that the real-time crime center was designed to have only one sworn officer with vetted civilians, and the system where the information flow was to go directly into the real-time crime center.

It doesn't go to the individual officers.

Again, this was by design.

And separately, I also keep hearing about FLOC.

There is a difference between FLOC and Axon.

I know different people say different things on that.

But we were very deliberate on the parameters of the system, and this was part of the issue with the FLOC program, and not like the other jurisdictions that have been having their challenges.

And we should note, and to be blunt, When I read the Seattle Times talking about FLOC, and given that it's the Seattle Times, and they don't caveat the reporting to note that Seattle does not have the FLOC system, I think that is a dereliction in their reporting because it creates this idea that we have the FLOC system when we don't.

And I would admit that is frustrating.

But on FLOC, it was a deliberate decision.

It was a decision by design.

And I've also been supportive of Connect Seattle, which I described as a block watch program to assist the rapid contact to businesses, for example, that may be co-located to a crime scene to get information to include possible camera coverage.

And we will work this hard.

Again, we will work this hard regarding any additional features that may be to this.

And something that I've said to the mayor's team following the review of the NYU Law Draft Audit Report, So this kind of goes to, you know, number two.

I will be blunt.

I worked initially with SPD and, you know, and so we're going to make sure that the integration of privately owned cameras is done right and is in keeping with all the protections and all the different pieces that we've built into the system thus far.

On ALPR, it's not operative at the moment due to capability issues that are, you know, for us having a mobile system related to the state law.

And I would note that basically we're waiting on Attorney General Brown and his team to work through and basically implement the law, basically bring it into the system.

And so regarding in terms of the timing of the CBA, I have zero expectation that the Attorney General's Office is going to get it done in a time.

So basically right now, ALPR is off the table.

And again, from reporting and comments that I've heard, you would think that there were zero safeguards.

And like these recommendations were like the start of safeguards, some start of guardrails.

That is not the case.

Things that you're reading in the various reports, whether it's OIG or the auditor or now with the NYU Law Report, they're additive to the guardrails that we have in our system right now that are working right now.

And there's different ways that you can point that out.

Again, just to close, those guardrails were put in place by my colleagues here on the dais, plus my team, central staff, the executive, and other stakeholders.

And I just want to say, related to the mayor's decision, I thank Mayor Wilson for that decision and the agreement to work together.

between the executive and legislative as we move forward, and we're gonna do that in partnership.

So at the end of the day, this CBA has been eclipsed, and I will be voting no on it.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Thank you, Councilmember Lin, followed by Saka, Foster, and Rivera.

SPEAKER_06

[2m31s]

Thank you, Chair.

First, I want to thank Council Member Brink for bringing this forward and Council Member Kettle for all your work on CCTV, our Realtime Crime Center.

and your commitment to working on oversight and privacy protections issues.

I believe the one thing that I think we all have in common is a belief in strong oversight and strong privacy protections.

And obviously, we got a lot of recommendations out of the most recent report that I look forward to working on right away next year.

The other thing I think, as we have this conversation around cameras, I think one thing that we don't talk about enough is the difference between privately owned cameras.

And when I say privately owned, I even mean cameras that might be owned by the school district, or by King County Metro, or just different entities that are not connected to our real-time crime center.

I know we've had discussions about like, well, for privately owned cameras, SPD has to go out and collect that data and that's a burden.

And I understand that that is a burden and after the fact burden, but there are also real concerns and costs of integrating these cameras into our system.

And I think that that's something that we need to, it's not just yes cameras or no cameras, it's also a question of whether we are integrating them.

And the benefits of doing so are, is it so critical that we have this footage immediately?

Is it urgent that we are solving that crime immediately?

And in some cases, perhaps that is urgent.

but I think in many cases it's an after-the-fact.

And I know that that came up in the report of whether we should require warrants when it's not a real-time issue but it's an after-the-fact issue.

I just say that in the sense of, as part of our work, I really think we have a more in-depth conversation about the costs and benefits of integrating cameras into our system versus, again, there's gonna be lots of cameras in our city, and whether that's homeowners or other agencies, but that doesn't mean that we have to have them all connected to our system because there are real privacy and other concerns related to that.

Thank you, colleagues.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Thank you, Councilmember Saka, followed by Foster and Rivera.

SPEAKER_22

[1m14s]

Thank you, Chair.

Just want to thank the sponsor for bringing this forward.

I know she cares about public safety and important civil liberties, and so recognizing that, just want to say thank you for bringing this forward.

I tend to agree more with Councilmember Kettle on the notion that this has been, I'll say, superseded to a large extent by last week's announcements, but also validating of the specific verbiage and language used from the sponsor in this as well.

But I guess my question to central staff would just be, Can you clarify, I tend to agree more with, like I said, what was just said in terms of what Council Member Kettle said, but can you just clarify from a central staff perspective, what are the impacts of this proposal based off of the Mayor's announcement last week about the, including the expansion and plan to immediately turn on cameras in Soto.

How would this directly impact last week's announcement?

SPEAKER_17

[58s]

Thank you, Councilmember Saka.

It would withhold $400,000 from the Technical Service Bureau at SPD that has been identified as money that would be used to expand the cameras, not expand them, build them in areas that the Council has already authorized.

From a practical standpoint, all this CBA does is provides over $400,000 until there's a future appropriation.

It doesn't have the policy effect of stopping the executive from building out the camera system.

However, it is clear that the council is proviso-ing this money with the intent to hold the system until these criteria are satisfied.

So technically, it won't stop the mayor, but it sends a clear message and withholds the money that the mayor would have otherwise used.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Saka, you saw the floor.

SPEAKER_22

[29s]

Thank you.

I'll just close.

Appreciate that, Greg, and I'll just close by saying, you know, I appreciate the mayor's announcements last week and I've had a chance to since speak directly with the mayor about this and I trust her judgment and partnership and looking forward to working with Public Safety Committee Chair Kettle and my Councilmember colleagues working this issue up further in committee and making sure we achieve all of our shared goals and desired outcomes here.

Thank you.

Thank you.

Councilmember Rivera.

SPEAKER_04

[1m43s]

Thank you, Chair.

Greg, you may remember, I actually was trying to look online, but when we back in, I think, 24, I actually put privacy protections for the real-time crime center, where one person could be the only person that was in charge of looking for the information.

If you wanted to look at it as an officer, you had to go to that person, and I believe a log had to get created.

I don't know if you remember off the top of your head, like I said, I was trying to look for the amendment that I put in, but I did have these concerns, which is why I worked with the mayor's office at the time and SPD to make sure that these provisions were and privacy protections were part of this legislation.

And it's okay if you can't remember.

I know I put that in.

I just can't cite to the amendment.

But to your point, Council Member Kettle, I know we did that because I'm the one who proffered the amendment to make sure because I had I very much had privacy concerns at the time, and I still do, and that's why we put those privacy protections in place.

So, all to say, I think there is alignment on the privacy piece, it's just there isn't necessarily alignment on the use of the tool, but I do think the tool is important in terms of investigation of crimes and helping with crime.

So, all that to say, support the RTC and also support privacy protections, which this council did do.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[6s]

Thank you, Councilmember Rivera.

Colleagues, any further discussion?

Any further discussion?

Councilmember Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[1s]

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thought it was a whole hand.

Go for it.

SPEAKER_01

[1m05s]

That's okay.

Thank you, Chair.

I think I just got missed in the order there.

I wanted to just ask, I've heard the statements around this being redundant or eclipsed by the Mayor's Office decision.

When I looked at the report that we got from NYU, I know that that report lists, I believe it's 19 recommendations for ways to improve privacy and civil rights in the context of CCTV.

And what I saw in the mayor's announcement was a statement of intent to implement the majority of the recommendations with a few highlighted recommendations.

However, it's unclear to me if we have knowledge of what the full set of recommendations are that the mayor's office intends to implement and which ones fall outside of the majority that she noted that they intend to implement.

That's my understanding.

So I'd like to ask to central staff, is there any further information available at this time about which of the 19 recommendations from NYU the mayor's office intends to implement?

Greg?

SPEAKER_17

[9s]

Thank you, Councilmember Foster.

If there is, I'm not aware of it.

It is probably a topic that would be best addressed in more detail in the Public Safety Committee next year.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Councilmember Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[11s]

Thank you.

And is there any information available regarding the timeline upon which the mayor's office intends to implement the recommendations identified in the NYU report?

SPEAKER_17

[14s]

Greg?

All of the recommendations, no.

They provided rough timelines for the three recommendations in this particular CBA, but no, I'm not aware of timelines for all 19, yes.

SPEAKER_15

[4s]

Councilmember Frost, are you still on the floor?

SPEAKER_01

[54s]

Thank you so much.

I just wanted to clarify that.

It's my perspective that the requests that are made in this proviso, which came from, and we've said it a few times, but I think it bears repeating, came from OIG, SPD concurred on these recommendations that are in the proviso.

So I take that to mean these are recommendations that the department can implement, and it's the intent of the proviso to ensure that those recommendations are implemented and that we are executing our oversight and accountability actions to ensure that implementation.

I, and speaking to the bill sponsor, rather the proviso sponsor here, you know, I find that to be kind of a modest approach to the implementation here.

So we'll be obviously co-sponsored and we'll be supporting, but felt like it was important to clarify what is and is not known about the implementation of the recommendations and the timeline.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[4s]

Thank you.

Greg, anything to add there?

Nothing?

SPEAKER_17

[27s]

Just one thing.

It is possible that the last recommendation, ensuring users of the automated license plate reader database provide a case number.

That is something that SPD will have to negotiate with the vendor.

So that one is a little more open.

They don't have a definite date on that.

But yes, everything Council Member Foster said about SPD agreeing with these and getting on them in short order is true.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you.

Anything further, Council Member Foster?

SPEAKER_01

[2s]

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Council Member Rivera, old hand?

SPEAKER_01

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_15

[9s]

Thank you.

I'll just make my...

Council Member Kettle, you've got a follow-up.

And then Council Member Rivera.

SPEAKER_07

[1m55s]

Okay, I was just gonna add...

First, on the City Auditor related to SDOT, that's gonna be fairly simple.

A lot of misinformation on that one as well.

On the OIG, as noted, SPD's basically going to be, they're all basically in some level being worked already.

And on the NYU audit, that's where the most of the work, they're going to be implemented, but not all.

This comes down partly to the discussions with SPD and city attorney's office.

There's some legal questions.

But we're going to bring all those to committee.

December 8th, January 12th, I'm working, you know, that along with some other topics.

We also have the Bight of Seattle OIG reports going to be coming out soon too.

So working that, but basically 8th December, 12th January, we'll be digging into these three reports, NYU Law, OIG, and City Auditor.

And everybody is welcome to attend committee as we do that.

I do want to say though, on Councilmember Lynn's question or comment.

It is urgent because there have been crimes in action where the CCTV and the Real-Time Crime Center has come in and assisted.

When a 78-year-old, I think she was a 78-year-old woman gets hit.

There was another one with a homicide.

and there's others as well.

So the urgency is quite clear because there has been instances where the crimes are ongoing and the Real Time Crime Center CCTV has made a difference in that.

And as I noted separately, very important as related to the King County Prosecuting Attorney's Office as well.

And again, colleagues, I ask that you join me in voting no on this.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[59s]

Thank you.

And Council Member Marine, as I've discussed with you previously, if this was a motion to remove cameras from Capitol Hill, I would be right there with you.

In the last camera expansion, I voted against the expansion because I did not have faith that Capitol Hill was the correct location.

I know that there are people that disagree with me out there.

I had questions about whether Garfield was or was not the right location and I strongly supported the stadium cameras.

So that's how I took my last vote on this.

I still have great concerns about Capitol Hill and I have I have my other concerns have been reduced so Council Member Rink if this was a motion to remove cameras from Capitol Hill I would be supporting you that is not what this is before us so unfortunately I will not be voting yes I see Council President Hollingsworth and then Council Member Rivera one more time Council President Thank You chair and I want to thank Council Member Rink for bringing this I really appreciate your engagement on this

SPEAKER_18

[2m07s]

on this subject and I also want to thank the mayor's office as well as I trust they've done their due diligence as well on the technology program because that program was paused and the cameras were turned on in Soto but were not expanded to Capitol Hill or Central District.

And colleagues, as you know, I voted to redirect $250,000 in the mid-supplemental budget, not knowing if the cameras were going to go on or off, and that money has been redirected to have ambassadors at night currently that are on Capitol Hill.

They work directly with our care team, with Chief Barden, and really appreciate that was voted on in August and they were up and running during Halloween in October.

So really appreciate them expediting that.

I know the executive has done an extensive review and I also don't know how much of a delay this would be.

I'm not trying to open up the can of worms of are we for cameras, are we against them, all that because I know those were really tough votes.

We have all had really, really hard and tough conversations with each other regarding this.

And my posture has always been to listening to everyone in neighborhoods, including those who are also sometimes nervous and scared to come to Council and those who speak with me directly.

And it's hard juggling everyone's voices and trying to listen to people and trying to understand what's going on.

and I know that this issue has been made very, very political.

And so I'm looking forward to moving forward on this, supporting the mayor and their decision, the executive as well.

And so unfortunately I'll be voting no on this and I have to trust that the seventh floor and what they have done already with the study and what they intend to do with the next steps, that they have the best interests, just like I do with all of the things that I might agree on and might disagree, but I trust that they have the best interests in the lens that they bring to the city.

So thank you, colleagues.

SPEAKER_15

[4s]

Thank you, Council Member Rivera.

One last statement and then we'll go to Council Member Ring to close.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_04

[15s]

I just wanted to correct the record.

I meant to say ALPR, not our real-time crime center, but those privacy protections were for the ALPR because we had those concerns.

So just to correct the record, thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[6s]

Chair.

Thank you.

Colleagues, any further discussion?

Final discussion?

Council Member Rink to close this out.

SPEAKER_03

[2m33s]

Thank you, Chair Strauss, and thank you colleagues for engaging on this.

I've appreciated just the candid discussion on this matter, even if we are in disagreement.

To really hone us in, the spirit of this proviso is the belief that we should be addressing these now known issues first before proceeding with the expansion of the RTCC and CCTV cameras.

And this proviso is fundamentally about getting our own house in order first.

and if the timing had lined up differently and the NYU report came out earlier, I would have reconsidered this proviso and tied it to the 19 recommendations.

But to that end, I believe still what has been put forward here is a modest proposal.

and I do believe that we need to be taking steps and I look forward to hearing more from the mayor's office and how they'll proceed with addressing all of the recommendations from the OIG report as well as from the NYU policing project report.

I do believe this is a modest proposal and provides a reasonable incentive to SPD to get an alignment with these three core recommendations.

And to close out, I do wanna take this opportunity to just say on the record that Axon and Flock are one in the same.

They're companies that have their roots with one another.

They have a deep and long history, but they started together.

And I don't want us to think that we're necessarily choosing the lesser of two evils.

I know Flock has gotten a lot more bad press with the challenges of their system.

It's important to note that Axon has a fair share of their own challenges and in fact holds a nearly $32 million contract with ICE.

And so this is to say we set up a system that relies on a private company and that in itself bears risk, us being able to provide that oversight of a private company.

This would be a different matter if we were talking about a municipally owned system that was stored fully here on municipally owned technology within the state of Washington, but structurally how this is set up, I mean, so long as we hold a contract with the private company, whether it be Axon and Flock or whoever, there's going to be risk there and I'm gonna continue working to make sure that we are mitigating risk where possible and providing the critical oversight that I believe we need over these systems given the threats that they can pose.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you.

Will the clerk please call the roll on SPD 110A.

SPEAKER_13

[9s]

Councilmember Foster.

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth.

No.

Councilmember Juarez.

SPEAKER_21

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Kettle.

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Lynn.

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[8s]

Councilmember Rink.

Yes.

Councilmember Rivera.

No.

Councilmember Saka.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Nay.

SPEAKER_13

[7s]

Chair Strauss?

Three in favor, six opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[10s]

Thank you.

The motion does not carry.

SPD 110 is not adopted to the budget.

We have SPD 111. So I will move SPD 111. Is there a second?

SPEAKER_22

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_15

[15s]

It has been moved and seconded.

This is again, a new item.

So I'll send it to central staff for, and if you all can get maybe a little bit more in depth briefing than you've been given just a tiny bit more.

And then I'll pass it over to council member Rink as the sponsor.

SPEAKER_25

[18s]

Right.

This council budget action would provide $100,000 in the SPD budget to hire a consultant to review SPD's investigative practices for sexual assault, domestic violence, and commercial sexual exploitation cases.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you, council member.

SPEAKER_03

[1m14s]

Thank you, Chair Strauss.

Colleagues, I'm bringing back this budget action.

I think another modest proposal I hope you can get on board with.

I brought this forward during the first round of budget, and this budget action imposes a proviso on the Seattle Police Department to hire a consultant who would review their investigative practices sexual assault, domestic violence, and commercial sexual exploitation cases.

This review would provide information on whether there is any backlog in these cases and then recommend best practices for process improvements.

So the context of this is that in 2022, an internal SPD memo reported that understaffing in the department led to the sexual assault unit to stop assigning new cases with adult victims.

The results of that memo led to the mayor's office to convene a panel of experts and victim survivors that recommended trauma-informed training, case reviews, and a public dashboard on sexual assault and domestic violence unit investigations.

This review would extend to domestic violence as well as commercial sexual exploitation cases, and it would assess current caseloads.

I want to thank my co-sponsors on this, Council Members, Lynn and Foster and colleagues.

I asked for your support and I want to make sure that survivors can really get the justice and accountability they deserve.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[8s]

Thank you.

I see we've got a couple of hands.

I'll just start with one question to you, Council Member Rink.

Is there a reason we are using a proviso and not new money at this time?

Council Member Rink.

SPEAKER_03

[16s]

Simply the approach that I decided to take.

I know I've talked at length about perhaps my feelings about the dramatic increases to SPD's budget.

I would hope they can find $100,000 within the budget to be able to do this critical review a part of their work.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Okay, thank you, Councilmember Kettle, followed by Rivera.

SPEAKER_07

[1s]

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you, Council Member Rank for bringing this forward.

SPEAKER_07

[1m05s]

I do believe gender-based violence is an area of great importance and I do believe it's a major area for public safety and we have to have an understanding of what is happening on the traditional public safety side of things to include SPD.

so I am supportive of this and I do believe that for the committee and for the council itself that we should be looking into this area in terms of how we're doing just like I'm looking at now diversion and it's an area where again it's a seam issue but we have to have it from the traditional public safety side as well and this is a way to do that to augment as Councilmember Rivera noted, the same kind of review on the human services side to ensure that we're in a good place as it relates to gender-based violence, whether it's sexual assault, domestic violence, or commercial sexual exploitation, all three of which are serious problems throughout our city.

So thank you.

Thank you.

Councilmember Rivera.

SPEAKER_04

[8s]

Thank you, Chair.

Is this not something that can be done by the OIG?

I'm just wondering.

SPEAKER_17

[52s]

Thank you, Councilmember Rivera.

That's a difficult question to answer.

It is something that the OIG could do if it was part of their work plan.

They would likely ask for funding to be able to do this.

They don't have sufficient funding for new audits or investigations to be able to keep taking them on in addition to their existing work plan.

and I think that they would want to get in experts on these type of cases to be able to help inform SPD on trauma-informed practices and other investigative techniques that SPD might use with these kinds of cases.

So I would say yes, it's something that the OIG could do.

It would likely still require the Council to provide money to OIG.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Councilman Rivera?

SPEAKER_04

[18s]

Thank you, Chair.

And would it be advantageous then to have OIG do this work rather than a consultant?

I know sometimes consultants can be even more expensive.

I don't know.

I mean, I've seen that be the case.

So just wondering.

SPEAKER_17

[16s]

I think it would cost probably the same either way, whether the OIG does it and has to receive funding to be able to hire a consultant or whether SPD does it and funds the consultant out of their own budget.

Thank you, Greg.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[7s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any further questions, comments?

Seeing none, Council Member Wink, anything to add to close this out?

SPEAKER_03

[7s]

Just to close this out, I want to express my appreciation to Public Safety Chair Kettle for your comments and your support on this.

I appreciate it.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Thank you.

Will the clerk please call the roll on SPD 111A, please.

SPEAKER_13

[5s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[3s]

Council Member Juarez?

Aye.

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[9s]

Councilmember Lin.

Yes.

Councilmember Rink.

Yes.

Councilmember Rivera.

Aye.

Councilmember Sacca.

Aye.

Chair Strauss.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[7s]

Thank you.

Motion carries.

SPD 111A is added to the budget.

We are moving on.

I will move SPD 117A.

Is there a second?

SPEAKER_10

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_15

[7s]

It has been moved and seconded.

We'll move to central staff to brief the item and then over to Councilmember Kettle, the sponsor of the item.

SPEAKER_25

[28s]

This CBA would impose a proviso on $4.1 million in the SPD for the technology-assisted crime prevention program, including closed-circuit television cameras, access to SDOT traffic camera feeds, and upgrades to the capabilities and staffing of the real-time crime center.

SPD expects to spend $4.1 million on these activities.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you, Councilmember Kettle.

SPEAKER_07

[1m17s]

Thank you, Chair.

It's interesting because obviously this CBA was written before the Mayor's announcement as well.

So there's an interesting dynamic there.

Colleagues, I'm going to ask for your continued support of this, even in light of that, for a couple of reasons.

as noted by Council President, and it was never really discussed last week, but there was a decoupling of Capitol Hill from a budgetary perspective with last year's mid-year supplemental, something again that wasn't really discussed.

And if there were the to make decisions to move in that area, I think it would be good for the executive to work with the council, to work with my colleague, council president, and others, in terms of a moving head on that front, as opposed to the central district, the Garfield pieces, and or any augmentation of the previously approved areas.

And also, to be frank, to encourage continued cooperation between the executive and the legislative branch in this area, because it is important that we do this together across those three reports, and for those reasons, colleagues, I ask for your support.

SPEAKER_15

[13s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Rivera, then Lynn.

Hold hands.

Great, I'm gonna take that as the last word then, unless Council Member Lynn, you do have something.

Over to you.

SPEAKER_06

[23s]

Thank you, Chair, I'll be quick.

Just wanna say I was supporting this and continue to support it.

I do wanna make sure that SPD has the resources to do any, implement any of the recommendations, those privacy protections that we were talking about.

And I'm not sure if those are gonna require resources or not, but this ensures that if there are resources needed that hopefully they'll be available.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[6s]

Any further comments?

Good point.

Further discussion?

Further discussion?

Final discussion.

Councilmember Kettle, any last words?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[4s]

None here.

Will the clerk please call the roll on SPD 117A?

SPEAKER_11

[2s]

Councilmember Foster?

No.

SPEAKER_24

[1s]

President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_18

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[3s]

Councilmember Juarez?

Aye.

Councilmember Kettle?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[1s]

Councilmember Lin?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_11

[6s]

Council Member Rink?

No.

Council Member Rivera?

Aye.

Council Member Sacca?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[1s]

And Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[1s]

Seven in favor, two opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[15s]

Thank you.

SPD 117 is adopted to the budget.

We'll move on to SPD 119 SA, which is another slide.

We'll turn over to central staff and then over to Council Member Sacca as the sponsor.

SPEAKER_25

[12s]

This is a request that the Seattle Police Department prepare a surveillance impact report for CCTV cameras to be located at Seattle Center.

SPEAKER_15

[5s]

Thank you.

I forgot my parliamentary procedure.

I move SPD 119 SA.

Is there a second?

SPEAKER_22

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

It's been moved and seconded.

Now over to Councilmember Saka's sponsor.

SPEAKER_22

[1m22s]

Thank you, Chair.

Colleagues, when thousands of people gather for games, concerts, and civic celebrations, the public safety stakes change dramatically, and we simply can't ignore that.

Seattle Center is one of our region's premier gathering places.

People who visit should have confidence that appropriate safety measures are in place.

I think the tragedy at the BITE from July of this year demonstrated how quickly violence can unfold in crowded public spaces and how difficult it can be at times to facilitate investigations when critical video footage evidence is unavailable.

So this proposal would not authorize cameras expressly by its terms.

Instead, it simply advances the public review process needed to evaluate whether event-focused safety cameras are an appropriate tool for Seattle.

And again, what we're talking about is major event safety cameras to close out public safety blind spots like at the Seattle Center today.

I want to thank my council member colleagues for joining me in supporting this effort, or sponsoring this rather, council members Rivera, Juarez, and Kettle, and ask for your support.

SPEAKER_21

[1s]

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[8s]

Thank you.

I see we've got a number of hands.

Remember this is a sly.

We're not even halfway done yet.

So with that, council member Kettle and then Lynn.

SPEAKER_07

[1m42s]

I appreciate that point, Chair.

Thank you.

Just really quickly, I do support this.

I do think, however, we should center this with the idea of major venues, major events, as opposed to the Seattle Center solely, because for one thing, we don't have to have that tag in terms of what happened with the BITE of Seattle, but to bring it into a broader umbrella where the Seattle Center is part of that, you can also go to the adjacent areas like Climate Pledge Arena, for the Pacific Science Center, the Space Needle, and so forth.

But also for like music venues, Benaroyal Hall or sports.

I mean, Lumenfield and T-Mobile Park are already part of this, but the Arch and the Summit Convention Center.

Anytime, as Council Member Saka rightfully noted, when you bring in large numbers of people, it changes the dynamic in terms of the security.

review of this and the aspects of it and I think in of itself it's important to do this and to do it separately too because the current CCTV program is designed and focused on crime hotspots.

That's the rationale.

This is a different rationale so I think we should do work this as part of an overall major venues, major events review because it's a different dynamic and different justifications and to ensure that we've got those T's and I's crossed from that perspective and I think I think that is important.

But overall, this is a very, you know, a good first step in that as well.

And colleagues, this major venues, major events piece is something I've also engaged with the executive on.

I haven't really had a back and forth yet, but I think this is an area that we can work again in collaboration with the mayor and her team.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Lin.

SPEAKER_06

[26s]

Thank you, Chair.

And just adding on to what Councilmember Kettle said, I do believe these major events, major venues have sort of different considerations, including different privacy implications, especially around political speech.

Oftentimes Seattle Center is a place where there's rallies and so forth, and so I'm just concerned about potential chilling impacts.

So I would hope that if this does pass, that SIR includes a close look at those implications.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[7s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any further discussion?

Council Member Saka, anything to close?

Will the clerk please call the roll on SPD 119 SA?

SPEAKER_13

[5s]

Council Member Foster?

No.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Juarez?

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Lynn?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Abstain.

SPEAKER_13

[7s]

Council Member Rink?

Abstain.

Council Member Rivera?

Aye.

Council Member Saka?

SPEAKER_22

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_22

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Six in favor, one opposed, two abstentions.

SPEAKER_15

[10s]

Thank you.

SPD 119 SA is added to the budget and we will continue on.

I move SPD 121 A.

Is there a second?

SPEAKER_22

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_15

[7s]

It has been moved and seconded.

This is, again, we'll turn to central staff and then to Council Member Rank.

SPEAKER_25

[38s]

This is a proviso on $300,000 of state forfeiture funds restricting their use until they can be spent, but until authorized by a future ordinance.

The intent is to focus spending on council priorities such as training for detectives who investigate sexual assault, crowd control training, training or equipment that could advance the department's use of tasers or rifles and noise suppressors.

SPEAKER_15

[6s]

Thank you.

Council Member Rink does sponsor the amendment.

You are recognized.

We moved and was seconded, correct?

SPEAKER_17

[48s]

Mr. Chair, may I add one thing to Director Woodson's description?

And that is that the proviso also requests a report on how SPD would intend to use these funds consistent with the state forfeiture guidelines and RCW.

and that the Council would consider that report, which would be due on May 3rd before potentially lifting the proviso.

So it would be clear that the proviso locks up the money until SPD sends a report requesting expenditure.

It also, separate and apart, specifies Council's preferences for the money.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you, Council Member Rank.

SPEAKER_03

[2m39s]

Thank you, Chair Strauss.

Colleagues, this is the second amendment I have brought forward related to Seattle Police Department and forfeiture funding.

You might recall on Friday, we briefly discussed the federal forfeiture funding proviso that I did need to pull and I intend to bring forward legislation next year to address and allow council to be able to move forward to be more directive to those funds and address the issues there.

But I want to really start with also huge appreciation to Greg Doss as well as Lauren Henry for their hard work with the Law Department unpacking what our legal options are when it comes to addressing state and federal forfeiture funding.

So this budget proviso is in relation to forfeiture funds allocated to SPD by the Washington Uniform Controlled Substance Act through Washington State.

Now, there are a few similarities to the federal forfeiture funding, but I wanted to highlight the main difference between the state funding and the federal forfeiture funding.

So, under state statute RCW 6950505, proceeds retained must be used exclusively for the expansion of controlled substance-related law enforcement activity.

and like the last budget amendment, we worked closely with our in-house legal staff and central staff, which led to this amendment being different than the federal forfeiture funding amendment.

So while the priorities stated of training for detectives, crowd management and training or equipment to advance the use of tasers as a less lethal option remain, we also added a fourth priority.

and that fourth priority ties to Council Member Lynn's Budget Amendment, SPD 106B, which is adding the potential usage of these funds for expediting the noise suppression of weapons used at the range that can be heard in Rainier Beach, South Beacon Hill, and South Park, as I understand it.

So, colleagues, I think as a part of this broader discussion related to forfeiture funding, I think I'm putting this forward because I know that there are council priorities and areas that we'd like to see investment in within the department.

I tried to honor things that I know I've heard from many of our discussions and I think being a bit more directive with this funding.

So it is not just sitting there, but rather being directive for how this funding could advance and improve some of the work within the department would be prudent.

So I ask for your support in this amendment to ensure that SPD uses these funds in a way that is consistent with council priorities.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[12s]

Thank you, colleagues.

Questions, comments, discussion?

Additional discussion?

Any final discussion?

Will the clerk please call the roll on SPD 121A?

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Foster?

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[7s]

Council President Hollingsworth?

Aye.

Councilmember Juarez?

Aye.

Councilmember Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[3s]

Councilmember Lin?

Yes.

Councilmember Rink?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Rivera?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[6s]

Councilmember Saka?

Aye.

Chair Strauss?

Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[23s]

Thank you.

The motion carries and SPD 121A is added to the budget.

We're gonna move into the next two items, which are both slides.

And so I will ask for this to be a briefer conversation, just there, but over, and I will move the first one, SPR 3SA.

Second.

It's been moved and seconded, Central Staff and then Council Member Saka.

SPEAKER_25

[18s]

This is a request that the Seattle Department of Parks and Recreation deliver a report to Council on opportunities for creating youth recreation projects and programming.

Thank you.

In the Dalvard neighborhood.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Sacco.

SPEAKER_22

[33s]

Thank you, Chair.

I'm bringing this back because we heard loud and clear over the last few months from community that there's a need and desire for increased investment as it relates to youth recreational capital projects.

Less strong opinions.

So at a high level, less strong opinions around what those specific projects could look like exactly.

So this was a way to develop that even more and work with community to figure out and then fund it next year.

So ask for your support of Delridge.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Thank you, colleagues.

Any comments, Council Member Foster?

SPEAKER_01

[27s]

Thank you so, excuse me, thank you so much, Chair.

And thank you, Councilman Bersaca, for bringing this forward.

I know we've talked a lot about the needs and the gaps in Delridge.

My question is just around, I don't sit on the Parks Committee, and I know we're coming up here soon-ish on the Parks Levy renewal.

And I just wanted to understand that timeline for Parks Levy renewal and when they're doing their kind of assessment and planning and how that fits with this statement of legislative intent.

SPEAKER_02

[21s]

SPR will be engaging in their information gathering stage during 2027, most of that happening around the mid-year report and after the mid-year park district report.

And then in 2028, there will be a proposal and then whatever funding proposal is adopted would go into effect in 2029. Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Council Member Foster, you still have a floor.

SPEAKER_01

[2s]

That's it, that was my only question.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[7s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any further discussion?

Any further discussion?

And will the clerk please call the roll on SPR 3SA?

SPEAKER_13

[5s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_18

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[3s]

Council Member Juarez?

Aye.

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[17s]

Council Member Lynn?

Yes.

Council Member Rink?

Yes.

Council Member Rivera?

Councilmember Sacca.

Chair Strauss.

Aye.

A10 favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[8s]

Thank you.

SPR 3 SA is added to the budget.

We will now move on to the next one.

SPR 5 SA.

I move SPR 5 SA.

Is there a second?

SPEAKER_22

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_15

[5s]

It's been moved in second.

And central staff, if you'd like to briefly address the item and then we'll turn it over to Councilmember Sacca.

SPEAKER_25

[7s]

This is a request that the Department of Parks and Recreation deliver a report on recreational programming in Alki.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Sacco.

SPEAKER_22

[31s]

Thank you, Chair, colleagues.

This goes hand-in-hand with the investment for Alki, because in part the Alki community safety and recreation package would restore, at least on a one-time for two-year basis, community programming at the Elki Community Center and the bathhouse.

And this important companion slide looks for, would help us look for a more sustainable funding path to keep more of that programming open more permanently beyond that.

Thank you.

I ask for your support.

SPEAKER_15

[8s]

Thank you, colleagues.

Any questions, comments, discussion?

Further discussion?

Final discussion?

Will the clerk please call the roll on SPR5SA?

SPEAKER_13

[5s]

Councilmember Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Councilmember Juarez?

Aye.

Councilmember Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Lin?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[6s]

Councilmember Rink?

Yes.

Councilmember Rivera?

Councilmember Saka?

SPEAKER_22

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Chair Strauss?

Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[26s]

Thank you.

SPR 5SA is added to the budget.

We'll move on to the next item.

I move SPR 19B.

Is there a second?

Second.

It's been moved and seconded.

This is another one of the Unified Care Team Position Authority, no funding associated.

I am looking at Council Member Foster and Rink.

You're not gonna say anything.

I'm not gonna say anything.

We're just gonna keep moving.

Fair enough.

If central staff would like to quickly just describe it so that we have consistency and then we'll call for a vote.

SPEAKER_25

[6s]

This adds two and a half maintenance positions to the Parks Department for the Unified Care Team.

No funding.

SPEAKER_15

[5s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any other questions?

Seeing none, will the clerk please call the roll on SPR 19B.

SPEAKER_13

[5s]

Council Member Foster?

No.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Council Member Juarez?

Aye.

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Lin?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Rink?

SPEAKER_11

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_13

[7s]

Councilmember Rivera?

Aye.

Councilmember Sacca?

Aye.

Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_14

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[2s]

Six in favor, three opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[29s]

Thank you.

Motion carries.

SPR 19B is added to the amendment.

added to the budget.

Clerk, this is where I'm gonna check in with you about CARE 9S.

I just need to move CARE 9S, is that correct?

So I'm gonna move CARE 9S, is there a second?

Second.

Thank you, it has been moved and seconded.

We have two, if central staff wants to briefly speak to it, and then I'm gonna call on Council Member Rivera and then Foster as co-sponsors, and then we'll have discussion.

SPEAKER_25

[8s]

Care 9S is a request that the Community Assisted Response and Engagement Department provide two reports on LEAD and Co-LEAD.

SPEAKER_05

[49s]

The only thing I would add is this is fairly similar.

There's overlapping subject matter to CARE 7S and 8S, which are on the agenda for Friday and on today's agenda for Group 4. I understand this CARE 9S to be a compromise item that combines elements of both of those.

I would say that the primary distinguishing factor of 9S is that there are two reporting deadlines at end of April 27 and October 1st, 27, and at both of those deadlines CARE 9S is asking for reports on both LEAD and co-LEAD with a number of enumerated characteristics in the slide.

SPEAKER_15

[5s]

Thank you, Tommaso.

Mr. Johnson, my apologies, and Councilmember Rivera, then Foster.

SPEAKER_04

[1m23s]

Thank you, Chair.

Colleagues, I had put in this slide as part of, it didn't make it in the balancing package.

So then I know both Councilmember Kettle and Foster, I had conversations with them separately and I incorporated some feedback from both.

And so rather than have Councilmember Foster and I have competing CBAs, that did very similar things, went ahead and tweaked the original.

And I would say one of the main differences I had originally requested quarterly, we compromised on twice a year because it was important to me we have a point of comparison to see how well we were doing and then allow for the time to actually see how well we were doing.

So I want to thank both colleagues for separate conversations on this CBA.

and the whole intent of this colleagues is to see how we're doing with lead and co-lead.

You know, between the two, we spend $20 million on diversion and I want to make sure that we're actually doing what we say we're going to do and that we're helping folks that are part of the diversion program because ultimately that's what we want to do is make sure that folks get the services, the treatment that they need, you know, to be in a better place.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Thank you, Councilmember Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[55s]

Thank you, Chair.

I'll just say thank you to Councilmember Rivera for your very gracious response to my competing sly, and thank you for working with me on this amended version.

I think we had a lot of shared intent here.

So mostly just want to express my gratitude to you, Councilmember Rivera, for that work and collaboration, and to your staff, because I know they worked really, really hard on this and developing this proposal.

to express my appreciation to your team as well.

And the only thing I wanted to also add, you pointed out one difference on the reporting.

The other thing that I thought was important, and we talked about this, was just number 10, which just acknowledges there might be proposals for the statistically valid comparisons, because I wanted to acknowledge that lead and co-lead have already begun seeking a statistically significant review utilizing, I think it's Princeton University.

So that was the other thing that we changed was just knowing that may be in progress next year.

So that's it.

Thank you so much.

SPEAKER_07

[51s]

Thank you.

Thank you, Chair.

I just wanted to note my first thank you, Councilmember Rivera and Councilmember Foster for your work on this and the intent would be in honor about June to have the parties come to committee to speak to this in open committee venue and to speak to the changes because we've had a number of changes since January 1st of of this year, and so to ensure where we are in diversion, and I would also add to see where care is.

We also have to look at the department, not just the program, but to ensure that care as a department is set in terms of moving forward and overseeing and executing on this process.

So thank you for your work, and colleagues, I ask for your support to this.

SPEAKER_15

[14s]

Thank you.

Final comments or can we move to voting?

Let's move straight into voting.

I am calling, I'm requesting the clerk call the roll on HSD, sorry, CARE 9S.

SPEAKER_13

[5s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_18

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Council Member Juarez?

Aye.

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Lynn?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[9s]

Councilmember Rink?

Yes.

Councilmember Rivera?

Aye.

Councilmember Saka?

Aye.

Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[41s]

Thank you.

Carat 9S is added to the budget and we are going to now move into the next section of Council Bill 121342. So at this time I move to amend Council Bill 121342 as presented on Amendment 1. Is there a second?

It has been moved and seconded to amend the bill as presented on amendment one.

Central staff, can you please provide us an overview and just noting that we are now moving out of the council budget actions and we are now moving into amendments on the bill as a whole.

With that, we've got Jennifer Labreck with us.

Jennifer, at your convenience, please feel free to walk us through this amendment.

SPEAKER_20

[23s]

Hello, good evening.

This is Amendment 1 to Council Bill 121342. It would require that any unspent jumpstart payroll expense tax fund appropriated to OH in 2027 be automatically carried forward into subsequent fiscal years until the funds are exhausted or otherwise abandoned by ordinance.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Thank you.

Council Member Foster, sponsor the amendment.

Would you like to speak to it?

SPEAKER_01

[44s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

This amendment, along with my amendment to the year-end supplemental bill, which we will consider later, would require, as just stated by central staff, unspent Jumpstart dollars at the end of the year to carry forward.

I want to state these amendments would not impact the $65 million carry forward in the mayor's budget.

Instead, they are an acknowledgement that as we make this one-time use of funds in OH in order to help address our deficit, that this should not be an ongoing practice until we have further information about how this practice works and functions within the department.

I believe that through preserving these remaining unspent funds, we can provide time for OH to assess their ability to make awards for housing projects without diverting any remaining unspent funds from housing.

So, colleagues, I ask for your support.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any further discussion?

Any discussion?

Councilmember Rivera.

SPEAKER_04

[1m14s]

Yes, thank you.

And as I said earlier, when we had a conversation about that last CBA, really appreciate you, Councilmember Foster, for your support of housing.

I, too, support housing, but I think, you know, sometimes we come at it a little differently.

But on the Jumpstart funds, I know that every year we've had to use some for other purposes.

And I feel like at this point, you know, It is almost used as general fund in that fund.

And so I feel like we shouldn't limit ourselves because we need the flexibility.

This is going to keep coming up.

So while I appreciate you bringing this forward and I very much respect where you're coming from and know that I care about housing too, I'm going to vote no on this.

But, you know, we can and keep talking about it and make sure that whatever housing developments that we fund, we definitely want to make sure those funds are available to do that work.

And at the same time, I just know the flexibility has been very important in the last number of years since we passed Jumpstart.

So thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you, Council Member Kettle.

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Mr.

SPEAKER_07

[32s]

Thank you, Chair.

Similarly, as each year passes, different considerations come forward.

We just had it with President Trump and what he was looking to do and our need to protect ourselves.

And again, for that, the ability to do so can really require some great flexibility.

And for that reason, we need to maintain that flexibility and that will be the rationale for my no vote on this item.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[20s]

Thank you, Council Member Kettle.

Colleagues, any further discussion?

Any further discussion?

With that, if the clerk can please call the roll on amendment- Chair, I thought you were going to send it back to me to close out.

Apologies, sorry.

Councilmember Foster, close this out and then we'll call the roll.

SPEAKER_01

[1m06s]

I just I want to reiterate that right now OH makes awards to projects based on the amount of money that is appropriated to them and that those projects do take years to get built and that means it takes a little while sometimes for those funds to be dispersed.

So we've deviated a bit, we've deviated $65 million from our normal practice this year with the forward funding and I do want to clarify and I totally understand I understand some of the places where we diverge, Councilmember Rivera.

I just do want to clarify, this proposal speaks only to the funds that are already appropriated for the Office of Housing.

So it is not the broader jumpstart pool.

It is ensuring that resources that were previously appropriated to OH are carried forward and remain within the Office of Housing.

That may have been clear, but there was just a few things I heard in the comments that made me unsure.

so I just wanted to clarify that.

And then I'll just ask Jen if you can just speak on average to how long it takes a project to fully secure funding and for OH to disperse funds.

Jennifer?

SPEAKER_20

[22s]

I think that does depend on projects, but the first step is a project is awarded and it can take really anywhere from maybe two to five years for a project to go from initial award to actually having construction completed and the project opening up, depending on how long it takes them to line up other financing and complete their construction.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Frost, you still have a floor.

SPEAKER_01

[41s]

Thank you so much, Chair, and thank you for that response, Jen.

I just wanted to highlight that because I believe that's why it's important, once we've appropriated those resources to OH, that those funds stay there.

And again, I'm putting this forward for 2026, and well, this one in front of us is 2027. I have another separate one.

and the intent here is as we have this $65 million forward fund shift that's happening this year, I want to ensure that we are not taking that practice up in the year immediately following as we seek to understand the impacts of this change on the department.

So I just wanted to clarify that.

I know that there's been a lot in front of us today, so thank you, Chair, for the additional time there.

SPEAKER_15

[5s]

Thank you.

Will the clerk please call the roll on amendment?

Sorry.

Councilmember Rivera?

SPEAKER_04

[23s]

Thank you.

I just want to further point a clarification because I'm understanding this to mean the money that gets appropriated to OH's budget, not what they are awarding.

So this doesn't impact just their award amount, but the actual what gets appropriated in total to the department.

SPEAKER_20

[29s]

Let's see if I can make sure I can answer this correctly.

So OH has appropriated a certain amount of funding each year.

For example, in 2027, it's about $140 million.

And then each year, they either contract or award that full amount of the funding.

So there is a relationship between the two.

OH will award funding that they've been appropriated in a given year for projects.

So I hope that answers your question.

SPEAKER_10

[2s]

Chair.

Council Member Rivera.

SPEAKER_04

[11s]

So apologies that this is their new way of doing the work where the full amount they get appropriated is what they're either contracting or awarding.

Jen.

SPEAKER_20

[52s]

That's a good question because things have changed.

So up until 2027, OH would get an appropriation and then they would either contract that amount out or they would award it out through a competitive notice of funding availability process.

In 2027, OH will get an appropriation of 140 million that will either be used for sort of annual contracts for services or operating support.

And then they will utilize they will also utilize their appropriation actually to pay for expenditures for awards made in prior years.

That's the big change.

So in 2027, OH will be using its current year appropriation to pay for expenditures that are coming in for past year awards.

And generally, if they want to make new awards, they will need to do that with future year appropriations.

SPEAKER_15

[10s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Rivera, you saw the floor.

Thank you.

Thank you.

You're good to go.

Council Member Foster, would you like to have a last word since we've had continued discussion?

SPEAKER_01

[10s]

Thank you, Chair.

Nothing further at this time.

Oh, I'm sorry.

I just saw a note from my staff.

I want to remind us that this is how we take our approach with the Office of Housing levy dollars, where those levy dollars stay in housing.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[7s]

Thank you.

Will the clerk please call the roll on Amendment 1 to Council Bill 121342 as presented.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Foster?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[7s]

Council President Hollingsworth?

Aye.

Councilmember Juarez.

Aye.

Councilmember Kettle.

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_13

[6s]

Councilmember Lin.

Yes.

Councilmember Rink.

Yes.

Councilmember Rivera.

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Saka.

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Chair Strauss.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[2s]

7 in favor, 2 opposed.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[1m03s]

The motion carries and Amendment 1 is adopted to Council Bill 121342. Are there any further comments on Council Bill 121342 as amended?

Thank you.

We're gonna move on to the next item of business.

So if there's no objection, Council Bill 121342 will be postponed to the November 19th Select Budget Committee meeting.

Hearing no objection, the bill is postponed for further consideration until November 19th.

We're gonna move on to items three, four, and many others.

With that, I have a note that items three and four were not discussed on Friday, but I believe that we generally touched on them before moving forward.

These are a resolution endorsing a budget and position modifications, and then further the city council changes to the proposed budget.

I'm going to just check do I need to clerk do we need to read these items into the record at this time?

SPEAKER_11

[4s]

They don't officially need to be read I just the determination as to how you like to move forward at this point

SPEAKER_15

[19s]

Okay, and the technical aspect that we, these are the two items that we will take, that central staff are working to do quality control on between now and Thursday, and that's why we'll vote on these two items on Thursday, is that correct?

Fantastic.

I'm gonna look to central staff to see if you've got anything to add on these items, otherwise we'll just keep on ticking on.

SPEAKER_25

[0s]

Sounds good.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Nothing to add?

SPEAKER_25

[1s]

No, I'll ask her questions.

SPEAKER_15

[11s]

Okay.

Let me just confirm this correctly.

These are not the clerk files that are contained within the consent package.

Is that correct?

SPEAKER_25

[0s]

That's correct.

SPEAKER_15

[1m02s]

Okay.

So I'm gonna just move on to the consent calendar of legislation.

Clerk, do I need to read anything into the record?

Yep.

Nope.

Okay.

I'm just checking.

So with this, we are gonna go through the consent calendar.

We did this.

Friday twice.

And so this is where if you'd like to pull an item out, just say so.

So we're gonna have central staff read through them and then I'm gonna call on council members to pull anything out or if you really have your heart's desire to speak to something that's in here, the drainage and wastewater system bonds are quite exciting.

We'll do that now.

So I'm gonna turn it over to central staff.

If you could walk us through Just the title, if there's a short summary, please feel free to, then we'll turn it over to council members to pull things out should they desire to.

Over to you, Director Woodson, Deputy Director Chow.

SPEAKER_16

[5m13s]

So item five on the agenda is the clerk's file that records the proposed budget as transmitted by the mayor.

Item number six is the clerk's file that records the proposed capital improvement program as transmitted by the mayor.

Item seven is the 2026 year end grant acceptance ordinance.

It accepts grants that have come in since the middle of the year approximately that need to be recorded in this accounting year.

Item number eight is an increase in the monorail fare ceiling.

So it adds, it raises the potential fare cap from $4 to $7.

It was last, I believe it was last amended about 12 years ago.

Item number nine is the facility fees for Seattle Center.

There are a number of fees that have changed, including the International Fountain Pavilion and also acknowledges an existing surcharge that's passed through from Ticketmaster.

Item number 10 is the fire permit and service fees.

This is largely driven by the services provided by the Fire Marshal's Office.

Item number 11 is the parks and recreation fees changes.

There's a number of broad fees, including the Amy Yee Tennis Center Court fees and a number of gross receipts across a number of buildings.

Item number 12 is a resolution for City Light that authorizes, well, that I forget the term, but it is related to their clean fuel use contingent budget authority and essentially blesses their program.

This funds essentially clean fuels for transportation electrification funding.

Item 13 is the short property tax.

This establishes the property tax for general government.

Item 14 is the long property tax.

This establishes the property tax to pay for debt indebtedness.

Item 15 is the finance fund closure ordinance.

It largely closes out a number of accounting funds that are no longer needed to go forward.

Item number 16 is the actuarial rate to the retirement fund.

So this basically blesses the 13.48% contribution to the SCURRS program.

Item number 17 establishes the rate of interest that is credited as part of the SCURRS program.

It would be an interest rate of 4.83%.

Item number 19 is cleanup legislation related to the fire pen and the actuarial account that we discussed earlier in the morning.

Item 19 is an increase in the commercial parking tax.

It raises the tax by 2.5% to a total of 70% effective in January 1st.

Item 20 is the transportation network company tax, and it essentially extends a expansion of the use of those revenues that had been in place for a long time.

Item 21 is an extension of the healthcare extension for the Jumpstart Fund, the payroll expense tax that applies to non-profit healthcare entities.

Item number 22 is an update to the business and occupation tax code to align with state law and the model business license tax ordinance.

Item 23 is a extension of an existing loan for Workday.

This loan was intended to be paid back out of a 2026 bond issuance, but that bond issuance was delayed and so now the repayment is expected to occur next year.

Item number 24 is legislation to establish a new UTGO fund in anticipation of a potential bond measure for the Seattle Center.

And this would establish the fund and also create an Interfund loan to allow for early spending to develop that proposal.

Item 25 is the LTGO bond ordinance.

It is about $114 million.

Item number 26 is the City Light bond ordinance.

It is for about $500 million.

Item 27 is the drainage and wastewater bond, and it is for about $160 million.

And item 28 is for the water system.

It authorizes a bond sale of $106 million.

SPEAKER_15

[9s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, are there items that you would like to pull or discuss?

Councilmember Rivera.

SPEAKER_04

[12s]

Thank you, Chair.

I would like to remove Resolution 32222. These are all for individual votes, CB121320.

SPEAKER_15

[8s]

Hang on, hang on, slow down.

Yeah, so Council Member Rivera just pulled the Clean Fuel Contingent Budget Authority.

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Yep.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

It is item number 12.

SPEAKER_04

[2s]

I don't have the number, I'm sorry.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

What's your next number, Council Member Rivera?

SPEAKER_04

[17s]

CB121320, the OFC 2026 Fund Closure Ordinance.

Okay, item 15, OFC 2026 Fund Closure.

CB121319, the FPIN account cleanup.

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

18.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Number 18, okay.

SPEAKER_04

[2s]

And the, sorry, the year-end CB121337.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

That's already been pulled.

SPEAKER_04

[1s]

Oh, great.

Okay.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[33s]

So I have from you, item 12, the City Light Clean Fuel Contingent Budget Authority, resolution 32222. I have item 15, the OCF 2026 fund closure ordinance, CB121320.

and I have the CBO 2026 FPEN account cleanup ordinance number 18, CB121319.

Is that your entire list?

SPEAKER_14

[0s]

Correct.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Okay, thank you.

SPEAKER_14

[1s]

Colleagues, any others?

SPEAKER_15

[33s]

All right, well then at this time, I'm gonna bring my script back up.

I'm gonna confirm that central staff, you've got those three numbers, number 12, 15 and 18, great.

So agenda items, 12, 15, and 18 have been removed and will be addressed separately.

I move to adopt the consent calendar excluding items 12, 15, and 18. Is there a second?

SPEAKER_22

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_15

[8s]

It's been moved and seconded to adopt the consent calendar excluding those items.

Is there any discussion at this time?

SPEAKER_05

[2s]

That's already for an individual vote.

SPEAKER_15

[15s]

Any further discussion?

It has been moved and seconded to adopt the consent calendar excluding items 12, 15, and 18. Will the Cork please call the roll?

Sorry, I didn't give you much heads up.

SPEAKER_11

[8s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

Aye.

Council Member Juarez?

Councilmember Kettle.

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[6s]

Councilmember Lin.

Yes.

Councilmember Rink.

Yes.

Councilmember DiVetta.

Aye.

Councilmember Sacca.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[1s]

And Chair Strauss.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[1s]

Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[24s]

Thank you.

We will move into Group A2, essentially.

First, I will move Resolution 32222. Is there a second?

Second.

It's been moved and seconded to adopt resolution 32222. Central staff, would you like to give us a quick overview?

And then council member Rivera is the puller.

I'll pass it to you.

SPEAKER_19

[1m35s]

Hello, council members.

I'm Eric McConaughey, council central staff.

This resolution goes with the authority that's actually in the proposed budget.

So to keep it kind of straightforward, there's a new budget summary level dealing with transportation electrification that's proposed by the mayor in her budget.

There's $12 million appropriated in the budget to do that.

The budget ordinance would be the place where that authorization is actually provided, the actual approval for that spending.

And it would be constrained for spending on transportation electrification efforts.

The intention that is being expressed through the mayor's budget in the budget book, but also in this resolution, is that the funding for that spending would come from City Light selling clean fuel standard credits.

They receive those from using clean fuels, that means electrifying, and they can sell those in a market that's established by the state.

Those dollars then would be put back into the Light Fund.

The Light Fund can only be used for things that serve the utility.

So the resolution is sort of showing their work.

It does not grant them a budget authority in the sense of being able to spend the $12 million that's granted by the budget, but this puts everything so above board, talks about reporting, talks about how the utility would put on its request to the city budget office at the end of the year for any carryover and those sorts of things.

So that's the quick rundown.

I'm happy to answer any other questions or add some more details.

Yeah.

Thank you.

Council Member Rivera, you pulled this item.

SPEAKER_04

[40s]

Yes.

Thank you, Chair.

I pulled this item because I believe it gives away Council authority for unutilized funds.

It gives contingent budget authority for that purpose, and I'm mindful that we keep chipping away at council authority.

And I don't perceive under the, sorry, the unutilized funds, City Light coming to us and telling us what they're using it for and then having us giving them the authority to do that as onerous.

Maybe others feel like it's fine, but I don't feel comfortable with that.

And so that's why I pulled this.

SPEAKER_15

[9s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, further discussion?

Further discussion?

Will the clerk please call the roll on resolution 32222?

SPEAKER_11

[6s]

Councilmember Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

No.

Councilmember Juarez?

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[1s]

Councilmember Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[1s]

Councilmember Lin?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_11

[6s]

Councilmember Rink?

Yes.

Councilmember Rivera?

No.

Council Member Sacca?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[1s]

Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[1s]

Seven in favor, two opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[17s]

Thank you.

Resolution 3222 passes and will be sent to the November 20th full council meeting.

Moving on, I move Council Bill 121320, the OCF 2026 fund closure ordinance.

Is there a second?

SPEAKER_04

[1s]

Second.

SPEAKER_15

[8s]

It's been moved and seconded.

will central staff brief this item and then we'll turn it over to you, Councilmember Rivera.

SPEAKER_25

[11s]

Very briefly, this bill would close a number of city funds that are no longer in use, including the fire actuarial fund.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Rivera.

SPEAKER_04

[18s]

Thank you.

I don't agree with the way that this was proposed in this budget and the lack of transparency around this, and I wish we had done it in a different way, so I just pulled this because I'm going to vote for this one and the next one, so I don't need to talk about it.

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

1, 2, 1, 3, 1, 9.

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[16s]

Thank you.

My only question for central staff, for this item and the next item that we will vote on, I understand one of them is the bill that Director Panucci was referring to that would require us to rebalance this budget.

Is it both of these next two bills or is it just one of them?

SPEAKER_25

[24s]

So if the Fire Pension Actuarial Fund were to be retained, Actually, this bill is needed to balance the budget because it transfers money from some of the extant funds into more appropriate current funds.

SPEAKER_15

[17s]

Okay, thank you.

And so if this bill does not pass, then that means that we will need to rebalance the budget and we'll all have to step into the green room for another ease to figure out where we're going from here.

Is that a generally correct understanding?

SPEAKER_25

[0s]

Yeah.

SPEAKER_15

[13s]

Okay.

Thank you.

Colleagues, any further discussion?

I'll just ask the clerk, is this a majority or three-quarters vote?

This is majority, so in committee.

Council Member Foster, did you have a question?

SPEAKER_01

[2s]

Chair, just we're on item 15. Is that correct?

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

That is accurate.

SPEAKER_01

[11s]

Oh, okay.

I'm just looking at what I have in front of me in the budget package, and that states this legislation requires approval by three quarters vote of the council.

In full council.

Aha, thank you chair.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Thank you.

SPEAKER_14

[1s]

Colleagues, any further discussion?

SPEAKER_15

[5s]

Will the clerk please call the roll on clerk CB121320.

SPEAKER_11

[8s]

Councilmember Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

Aye.

Councilmember Juarez?

Aye.

Councilmember Kettle?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[1s]

Council Member Lund?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_11

[6s]

Council Member Rink?

Yes.

Council Member Rivera?

No.

Council Member Sacca?

SPEAKER_01

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[3s]

And Chair Strauss?

Aye.

Each in favor, one opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[18s]

Thank you.

The motion carries.

CB121320 will be sent to the November 20th full council meeting.

I move CB121319, the CBO 2026 FPEN account cleanup ordinance.

Is there a second?

Second.

It's been moved and second.

Central staff, will you brief the bill and then Council Member Rivera?

SPEAKER_25

[13s]

This bill would update the policies related to the firefighters' pension fund, including removing references to the actuarial fund.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Rivera.

SPEAKER_04

[2s]

We've talked about it.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[4s]

Thank you.

Any further discussion?

Will the clerk please call the roll on Council Bill 121319.

SPEAKER_11

[3s]

Councilmember Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[3s]

Councilmember Juarez?

Aye.

Councilmember Kettle?

SPEAKER_10

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[1s]

Councilmember Lin?

SPEAKER_10

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_11

[8s]

Councilmember Rink?

Yes.

Councilmember Rivera?

No.

Councilmember Sacca?

And Chair Strauss.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[2s]

Seven in favor, one opposed, one abstention.

SPEAKER_15

[44s]

Thank you.

The motion carries.

Council Bill 121319 will be sent to the November 20th full council meeting.

We're gonna now move into the other items that were not part of the consent calendar.

And I am gonna just check my parliamentary process.

We removed civil service code revisions from the agenda entirely.

Thank you.

So we will now move on to item 30. So I move Council Bill 121307. Is there a second?

Thank you.

This is the 2027 annual grant acceptance ordinance.

There is one amendment from myself.

Central staff, would you please brief the bill and the amendment together?

Yeah.

SPEAKER_25

[21s]

This is the annual acceptance ordinance for 2027 accepting various funds from outside organizations and the amendment is to add the budget adoption council bill number because it amends the budget adoption ordinance.

SPEAKER_15

[15s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any questions?

I will move Amendment 1 to CB121307.

Is there a second?

Second.

It's been moved and seconded.

Will the clerk please call the roll on Amendment 1 to CB121307?

SPEAKER_11

[3s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_18

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[2s]

Council Member Juarez.

Aye.

Council Member Kettle.

SPEAKER_18

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[1s]

Council Member Lin.

SPEAKER_18

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_11

[5s]

Council Member Rink.

Yes.

Council Member DeVetta.

Aye.

Council Member Sacca.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[1s]

And Chair Strauss.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[1s]

Any in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[12s]

Thank you.

The motion carries.

The bill has been amended.

Colleagues, any final comments on the acceptance and ordinance?

Not seeing any, will the clerk please call the roll on CB121307 as amended?

SPEAKER_11

[3s]

Councilmember Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[5s]

Councilmember Juarez?

Aye.

Councilmember Kettle?

Aye.

Councilmember Lin?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_11

[6s]

Council Member Rink?

Yes.

Council Member Rivera?

Aye.

Council Member Sacca?

Aye.

And Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[1s]

Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[46s]

Thank you.

The motion carries.

CB 121307 will be sent to the November 20th city council meeting.

I move Council Bill 121337. Is there a second?

Second.

Thank you.

It's been moved and seconded to move CBO's 2026 year end supplemental ordinance.

We have three amendments here.

I will ask the central staff to brief the base bill Pause, I'm gonna check to see if there's questions.

I really hope there's not and then we'll move right into amendment number one and then vote on it, move into amendment number two, vote on it into amendment number three, have discussion on the whole package and take a vote on the bill.

So at this time, if you could brief what the underlying bill is and then we'll move each of these amendments individually, please.

SPEAKER_12

[44s]

Good evening, Council Central staff.

So this is the 2026 year and supplemental ordinance bill, and this legislation would make several adjustments to the 2026 adopted budget, including adjusting appropriation authority and operating in capital budget control levels, modifying departmental position authority, adding a CIP project and amending and lifting provisos.

Overall, the legislation would increase general fund appropriations by $38 million and decrease appropriations across all other funds by around $96 million.

And this legislation requires three quarters vote of a council.

And I can go into some more specifics, but I'll leave it at that for now.

SPEAKER_15

[5s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, are there any questions about what the underlying bill is at this time?

Councilmember Rivera.

SPEAKER_04

[39s]

Thank you, Chair.

I have a couple of questions.

Hopefully it'll be quick, but just, I didn't notice in this year-end legislation or even in the proposed budget, I know that we have some funding that we're on the hook for, for KCRHA, that 16.7 million, I don't know how much the city parts, is because I know this is something that the city and the county have to manage for.

So can you tell me a little bit about whether, or not a little bit about, but can you tell us whether that funding is in either the year end or the budget?

SPEAKER_20

[7s]

I'll actually answer that one if that one's okay.

That is not in the year end supplemental, that would be in the 2027 budget.

SPEAKER_04

[1s]

It is in there.

SPEAKER_20

[3s]

Yes, it is accounted for in the 2027 budget.

SPEAKER_04

[4s]

Sorry, Chair, one question.

How much was that, Jen, for our part?

SPEAKER_20

[18s]

It's part of the planning reserves over like a four to five year period.

And I don't recall the exact amount.

Okay.

But I do know it's sufficient to cover the 17. Well, I shouldn't say that actually.

I'm thinking now.

I don't know the exact amount.

SPEAKER_04

[12s]

Jen, can follow up and see how much that is.

I mean, for transparency's sake, I would love the public to also know what we're on the hook for in terms of the KCRHA 16.7 most recent development.

SPEAKER_20

[17s]

Oh, looks like she...

And I'll just say, too, that there is currently negotiations ongoing between King County and Seattle about how to split responsibility for that 17 million, so I don't think there is a figure available at this point in time about what Seattle's share would be.

SPEAKER_04

[36s]

Thank you, Jen, but we're thinking it's coming out of the reserves.

planning.

Thank you.

And then, Chair, I just have one other question, and it's actually more of a daylight.

I was surprised to see that there was an increase of 21.8 million for judgment and claims on top of the 2026 baseline of 46 point, almost 47 million, and then a 17.5 carry forward.

So my understanding is for 2026, our judgment and claims total is almost 86 million.

Is this correct, Edin?

SPEAKER_12

[32s]

That is correct, yes.

There's a $21.8 million increase in Judgment and Claims Fund, and this is from the planning reserves to support anticipated payments accrued in the account for expenditures paid by the fund, and it's exactly what this reserve is for, and sufficient funding is available in the reserve.

to cover expenditures, not just from this year, but also from prior years that have settled.

So in short, yes.

SPEAKER_04

[30s]

Thank you.

Council Member Rivera, any further questions?

Thank you.

Just noting that this is a very significant amount and would love to know why this particular year the judgments have been so high.

And then also noting for the public that in 27, there's a 66 million and then 28, a 72 million allocated for judgment and claims.

I feel like these are some of the highest I've seen, but just noting that that's a lot.

So thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[13s]

Thank you.

Further questions, comments?

Seeing none, I move Amendment 1 to CB121337.

Is there a second?

Second.

Thank you.

It's been moved and seconded.

If you'd like to brief the amendment and then I'll turn it over to you, Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_12

[18s]

So Amendment 1, version 1 to Council Bill 121337 is sponsored by Council Member Foster and it would automatically carry forward unspent 2026 Jumpstart Office of Housing appropriations into subsequent fiscal years.

Thank you, Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[14s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

Colleagues, we just voted on a version of this and I spoke to it with my amendment to CB 121342. This amendment that is in front of us currently would ensure that Jumpstart dollars at the Office of Housing are carried forward for 2026, and I ask for your support.

SPEAKER_15

[11s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any questions, comments, concerns, discussion?

Further discussion, final discussion, Council Member Foster, anything else?

Will the clerk please call the roll on amendment one to CB121337.

SPEAKER_11

[3s]

Council Member Foster.

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[3s]

Council Member Juarez.

Aye.

Council Member Kettle.

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_11

[1s]

Council Member Lin.

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_11

[3s]

Council Member Rink.

Yes.

Council Member DeVetta.

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_11

[1s]

Council Member Sanka.

SPEAKER_04

[1s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[1s]

And Chair Strauss.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_11

[1s]

Seven of favor, two opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[16s]

Thank you.

Amendment one carries and CB121337 is amended as such.

I move amendment two to CB121337.

Is there a second?

Second.

Second.

It's been moved and seconded.

Will the central staff please brief amendment two and then Council Member Lynn, you'll be recognized.

SPEAKER_12

[14s]

to version one to Council Bill 121337 is sponsored by Council Member Lin and it would reduce Washington State forfeiture revenues by $800,000 general fund in 2026 to fund items into 2027 proposed budget.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you, Council Member Lin, you're recognized.

SPEAKER_06

[1m50s]

Thank you, Chair.

Thank you, colleagues.

This budget item or this amendment would support CBAs that were already included in the balancing package that was adopted.

You know, essentially there is this fund, a forfeiture fund that can only be used for certain purposes, whether that's to expand or improve drug-related enforcement activities.

So one of these would be to fund $300,000 for suppressors, which is supported by the Seattle Police Department over two 27-2028 appropriations.

And then the other one would be for $500,000 for hotspots for law enforcement-related activity in Little Saigon, North Beacon Hill, Yasser Terrace, and Belltown.

and I just want to clarify that in my opinion, a law enforcement activity doesn't necessarily mean arrests.

It could mean things like diversion.

We've had a number with increased SPD presence in Little Saigon.

We have seen a significant improvement in the law enforcement-assisted diversion referrals because SPD has been going out with LEED in a code deployment and with sort of increased presence they've gotten to know both the LEED folks as well as people that they're meeting on the street that they've improved their referrals.

I also, I think it could be used for, we know that the jungle on North Beacon Hill has been a trafficking hotspot for over a decade and continues to be an area that needs attention.

So the overtime costs could be related to a number of different activities.

And with that, I'd love your support.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Thank you.

SPEAKER_03

[35s]

Thank you, Chair Strauss, and Councilmember Lin, thank you for bringing this forward.

I know we don't have Greg at the table, otherwise I would direct this question to him, but I wanted to ask you just a clarifying question on the CBA.

Since the nature of state forfeiture funds is similar to the one that I brought forward, it's my understanding that this CBA, in essence, kind of functions as a proviso, since the money can only be spent on eligible purposes, and in this case, identifiable uses identified by SPD, such as equipment and a number of the things you just talked through.

So could you confirm that that's the case and anything else you'd like to share?

Bless you, Chair Strauss.

SPEAKER_06

[40s]

Councilmember Lin.

Yes, Councilmember Rank, you know, my understanding and I appreciate the mayor's office.

You know, this fund, my understanding is in prior years, it was not sort of in a sense tied down and the mayor's office has sort of in a sense by putting it into the finance general basically made it so that we have actually a little bit more say over these funds which I appreciate.

And so this action would allow it to be used only for these specific purposes.

So in that sense it is similar to a proviso but also makes it eligible to be used for these specific purposes.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Thank you.

SPEAKER_03

[9s]

Thank you, Chair Strauss.

And thank you for that explanation.

That's tremendously helpful.

And to that end, I will be supporting for those reasons.

I am seeing a hand from central staff.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Director Chow.

SPEAKER_16

[17s]

Yeah, just for clarity, the restrictions are on the source of funds.

That's a legal restriction from the state.

And this is putting it in, not putting it aside in finance general where we would need additional appropriations to make use of it.

This is putting it into play for it to be used in this budget.

SPEAKER_15

[8s]

Thank you.

Council Member Wink, do you have any further questions after that?

Council Member Wink, any further questions?

Nothing further?

Council President Hollingsworth.

SPEAKER_18

[10s]

Thank you, Chair, and I'll be quick.

Could you confirm, Council Member Wink, these funds would only be used for the neighborhoods that you had just stated?

SPEAKER_15

[5s]

Council Member.

Actually, I'm going to go to central staff because that's a technical question.

Deputy Director.

SPEAKER_16

[12s]

These funds are used in the proposed package for SPD 106B, which is the noise suppressors, and for SPD 122A, which is the place-based public safety.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you.

Council President, you still have the floor.

SPEAKER_18

[6s]

Sorry, I might be confused.

Is it specific to neighborhoods, Cal?

I'm sorry.

You're fine.

SPEAKER_15

[12s]

We're 10 minutes away from our next break, so everyone's starting to feel it.

Council President, can you ask the question one more time, whole context, and then Cal will answer one more time.

SPEAKER_18

[12s]

Yes, my whole context, are these funds specific to the neighborhoods in which Council Member Lynn had talked about North Beacon Hill, North Beacon Hill 12th and Jackson?

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Deputy Director.

SPEAKER_16

[6s]

Yes, so that was the CBA that established that.

This just frees up the funds to fund that CBA.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Council President.

SPEAKER_18

[25s]

Understood.

Thank you, Council Member Lynn.

I will be supporting this.

first week of December, I actually have to go to elementary school that is right next to 12th and Jackson and talk to the kids because they have very serious questions about why they have to walk through a lot of hard things just to get to school.

And so I want to be able to say that we're investing in trying to do something to make it better for them to get to school safely.

So I will be supporting this.

Thank you, Council Member Lyon.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[15s]

Hi.

Thank you so much, Chair.

Thank you, Councilmember Lin, for bringing this forward.

I just wanted to understand, if Amendment 2 were to not pass, would that mean we would have a gap of $800,000 in funding the CBAs that we already passed?

Is that accurate?

That is correct.

There would be a gap.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Foster, you still have the floor.

SPEAKER_01

[1s]

Thank you, Chair.

That was my only question.

SPEAKER_15

[9s]

Thank you.

Any further questions?

Councilmember Lin, close this out, and then we'll call the roll.

Thank you.

Nothing further.

Thank you.

Will the clerk please call the roll on Amendment 2 to CB121337, please?

SPEAKER_13

[6s]

Councilmember Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_10

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Juarez?

SPEAKER_10

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Councilmember Kettle?

Aye.

Excuse me?

SPEAKER_07

[2s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[8s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Lin?

Yes.

Councilmember Rink?

Yes.

Councilmember Rivera?

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[6s]

Councilmember Saka?

Aye.

Chair Strauss?

Aye.

Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[15s]

Thank you.

Amendment 2 to Council Bill 121337 is adopted and we'll now move on to, I move Amendment 3 to Council Bill 121337. Is there a second?

Second.

It's been moved and second.

Central staff, will you brief the item and I'm the sponsor.

SPEAKER_12

[12s]

Amendment 3, version 1 to Council Bill 121337, sponsored by Council Member Strauss, is a technical correction to the total appropriation decrease in Section 1 of Council Bill 121337, correcting the amount.

SPEAKER_15

[10s]

This is a technical amendment.

Thank you, Edwin, for catching the technical change.

Colleagues, any questions?

Seeing no questions, will the clerk please call the roll on Amendment 3 to Council Bill 121337?

SPEAKER_13

[10s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

Yes.

Councilmember Juarez?

Yes.

Councilmember Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[6s]

Councilmember Lin?

Yes.

Councilmember Rink?

Yes.

Councilmember Rivera?

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[6s]

Councilmember Sacca?

Aye.

Chair Strauss?

Aye.

Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[10s]

Amendment three is adopted to Council Bill 121337. We now have the Council Bill 121337 as amended before us.

Council Member Rivera, I understand you have a question.

SPEAKER_04

[18s]

I do.

Apologies, Chair.

I noticed in the year-end there was a item related to school meals and funding and I was hoping that Jasmine could take us through what this proposal is.

SPEAKER_25

[7s]

And I think she should be joining us very shortly.

She's now working from home.

SPEAKER_04

[1m46s]

So how about I try to, I will give some of the information while we wait and see if she can hop on because I'm not sure she Full disclosure, we asked a question, but I'm not sure I'm understanding the answer.

But there's 3.6 million in the mid-year from Jumpstart Fund for school meals.

But it looks like the executive is including funding from FEPP underspend for risk reserve for the same in 27 and 28. It's about 772,342.

and then there's some plus some of the 1.2 million under item one in the end of year supplemental.

And I thought we were only adding the school meals for 26, 27 school year that we added with the jumpstart that would have gone to SHA, but then we worked all that out.

Thank you, Chair, on that.

But now for...

and we only passed it for one year.

So is there a second year going to be proposed?

I'm trying to figure out why.

And here's my concern colleagues.

The Levy Oversight Committee is unaware of these, the mayor's putting money in reserves related to school meals.

So this is why, and neither was I aware until I read it in the year end.

So I'm just trying to get more information about why the executive is transferring money for school meals in the FEP levy reserves.

I'm just trying to better understand this for full disclosure and transparency.

Okay.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Central staff, anything to add at this time?

SPEAKER_12

[21s]

So I could read the description of the item if you haven't already.

It seems like it's mostly just realignment of the funding from 2026 into 2027 to ensure that they have enough funding.

It's actually a reduction, not an ad that you're seeing in there.

It's a negative number.

So maybe there's some confusion.

SPEAKER_04

[8s]

I saw it as a risk.

It was transferred to risk reserves, but maybe I read it incorrectly.

which is why I'm asking.

SPEAKER_12

[27s]

Yes, and then the other item, I believe you had questions for two of the deal items that you're referring to.

The other one is more of a technical, the $2 million and that was just a technical error that was not supposed to be in the budget, and so the city budget office is removing that item from appropriations because it was never supposed to be appropriated to begin with, so it's purely technical.

SPEAKER_04

[1s]

That's a preschool one.

SPEAKER_12

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_04

[15s]

Yes, I understood that one.

I understood there was some under spend that was getting transferred into a risk reserve for 27 and 28. and that's the amount that school meals is mentioned.

SPEAKER_15

[15s]

Thank you.

Council Member Rivera, we have Jasmine on the line.

Jasmine, I understand you're calling in from your phone.

I appreciate you being incredibly flexible to answer our questions here.

I can't tell if you're on or off mute, so if you can just start talking at any time.

SPEAKER_08

[4s]

All right.

I am here.

Can you hear me?

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Yes, we can.

SPEAKER_08

[45s]

Oh, perfect.

Okay, great.

My apologies.

My outlook is not working from home.

I'm not sure why, but here I am on the phone.

So what I heard of Eden's answer is correct in my understanding as well.

Basically, it is rebalancing because there was 2026 funding allocated, you know, before the IME plan had passed, right?

So it was allocated in last year's budget process.

and so much of that adjustment that you see in the year and supplemental is meant to adjust for the IME plan and then to add, to take away from 26 and add, I believe it would be rebalanced in 27.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Thank you.

Council Member Rivera, any further questions at this time?

SPEAKER_04

[13s]

Thank you.

Jasmine, thank you for getting on.

Apologies, I didn't know you'd gone for the day.

So you're saying this is not actually money that's getting put into risk reserves?

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Jasmine, over to you.

SPEAKER_08

[41s]

Thank you.

Some of it may be to comport with the spend plan, but I believe it's a multitude of things, risk reserve, as well as the, I think I read in the bill, the preschool waitlist and the public service career pathways.

They're just rebalancing things too because not all of it was spent, not all of it was anticipated to be spent in last year's budget process for 26 was spent.

We passed the full spend plan in July and August of this year.

and so now it's just sort of reallocating things so they can be deployed in 27.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Council Member Rivera.

Got it.

SPEAKER_04

[2s]

Thank you.

Thank you, Jasmine.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Any further questions?

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_15

[28s]

Jasmine, thank you so much.

I think that's all we need for right now.

We'll call you back if we need more.

With that, colleagues.

I'm standing by.

You're the best.

Look at that.

Central staff at its finest.

Got a good team out there.

Thank you for sticking with us, central staff.

Colleagues, any other comments, questions on the year-end supplemental ordinance?

Seeing none, will the clerk please call the roll on CB121337 as amended.

SPEAKER_13

[12s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

Yes.

Council Member Juarez?

Aye.

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[7s]

Council Member Lynn?

Yes.

Councilmember Rink?

Yes.

Councilmember Rivera?

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Sacca?

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[2s]

Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[57s]

Thank you.

Council Bill 121337 as amended passes and will be sent to the November 20th City Council meeting.

Colleagues, it is 6.16 p.m.

I told you when we started at 4.15 p.m.

that we would take a break in two hours.

We are at that two hour mark.

We have one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, 10, 11, 12, 13 more votes to take.

I recommend that we take a 20 minute break right now and that we come back and finish the rest of our evening.

Does anyone have objection to that?

Thank you.

With that, at this time, if there's no objection, the Select Budget Committee meeting will be in recess until 6.35 PM.

Sorry, I'm stealing a minute from us.

Actually, now I'll give us the full.

6.36 PM, hearing no objection, Select Budget Committee meeting is in recess until 6.36.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_99

[12m56s]

This is the same.

I have no idea.

You can see that you can see it you I'm going to put it in my hand.

you know.

SPEAKER_15

[19s]

Welcome back.

The November 16th, 2026 Select Budget Committee meeting will come back to order.

It is 636 PM.

I'm Dan Strauss.

Do we need to clear call roll clerk?

Will the clerk please call the roll?

All not present are excused until they arrive.

SPEAKER_13

[6s]

Council member Foster?

Here.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

She said present.

SPEAKER_13

[7s]

Present.

I see.

Thank you.

Council Member Juarez?

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Here.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Lynn?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Here.

SPEAKER_13

[14s]

Council Member Rink?

Present.

Council Member Rivera?

Council Member Saka?

Here.

Chair Strauss?

Present.

Seven present.

SPEAKER_15

[17s]

Thank you.

We will move to the next item.

We have, I move Council Bill 121310. Is there a second?

Second.

Thank you.

It has been moved and seconded.

We do have an amendment here.

And so central staff, if you could brief the underlying bill and then I'm going to move us right into the amendment.

SPEAKER_25

[26s]

Yeah, this bill is the annual Seattle Department of Construction and Inspections fee ordinance.

It includes a 10.7% fee increase for land use and building fees, permit fees.

The proposed amendment from Council Member Foster would exempt

SPEAKER_15

[24s]

Hang on real quick.

Before we move into the amendment, this is just the fees that are related to the mayor's bill that we passed earlier this year that changed the SDCI rental junk fee ordinance.

Is that correct?

Can you speak a little bit more to that?

And then I'm gonna pass it over and then I'm gonna move the amendment.

SPEAKER_00

[2s]

Are you asking about the ordinance generally or the amendment?

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

I'm speaking about the underlying bill right now.

SPEAKER_25

[8s]

The underlying bill is all SDCI fees, including building permit and land use permit fees.

SPEAKER_15

[7s]

Wonderful.

Colleagues, any questions on the underlying bill?

Seeing none, I move Amendment 1 to CB121310.

Is there a second?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_15

[4s]

Thank you.

It's been moved and seconded, and now let's jump right into the amendment.

Thank you for your patience.

SPEAKER_00

[21s]

This amendment would add an exemption such that buildings that receive funding by Office of Housing would be excluded from paying the fee for implementation and administration of Chapter 724 rental agreement regulations, which is that new fee as part of the enforcement of CB 121254. The per unit rental agreement fee has increased $1 to offset this exemption, bringing the total to $12 every two years for non-exempt units.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Fantastic.

Councilmember Foster, response for the amendment.

You're recognized.

SPEAKER_01

[51s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

As just stated, this amendment exempts affordable housing units and buildings that are funded by the Office of Housing from paying the rental regulation enforcement fee.

These affordable housing units are still subject to the rental regulations included in the recently passed junk fee legislation that I was proud to sponsor and thank you colleagues for your support of that earlier this year.

I will just clarify as HB just stated that $1 fee shift is in the biennium so it is 50 cents a year difference.

We took this approach because we heard from several affordable housing providers around their the impacts of this potential fee legislation to them at a time when they are already managing a lot of costs related to operations and maintenance.

So we put this forward as a way to ensure that we are still able to implement the legislation as originally intended without having that impact on the affordable housing units.

With that, colleagues, I ask for your support.

SPEAKER_15

[5s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any questions?

Discussion?

Additional discussion?

Councilmember Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[1m43s]

Yes, thank you, Chair.

I just wanted to note that, you know, earlier this year we passed this bill, which is a fee increase.

And I've been talking about, again and again and again, state, county, local regarding property tax, sales tax, utility rates, the various departmental fees like permit fees.

And I should have added fares because we just did one on fares.

And here we are not even, I don't know how many months out, and we're already increasing it.

and the frustrating bit is, and I'm sympathetic to the affordable housing community, but then again, I also remember not too long ago that we had a number of bills that were supposed to be passed in support of the affordable housing community related to landlord-tenant and then nothing happened.

kind of in protest, if you will.

I'm not gonna support this, just in that fact, in the sense that we're already increasing something, that we're not even a year out from passing that bill.

We're already increasing it.

And it's backdrop by we didn't do anything and 24, 25 related to landlord-tenant, which would have helped the affordable housing community.

But here we are at, you know, end of 26 going into 27 and still nothing's happened.

But we're doing this, an increase right after.

So I support Council Member Foster, I see what you're doing, but same time, you know, in terms of the broader, you know, landscape, I think we should, you know, take that into consideration.

and particularly because each time that we do these increases, whether it's property tax, sales tax, utility rates, departmental fees, now fares, we're adding to the affordability challenges that we face in our city.

So thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[7s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, further discussion?

Colleagues, further discussion?

Any final discussion?

Council Member Foster?

Anything else?

SPEAKER_01

[12s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

I'll just say this along with this lie around the 50% goal with PET were some of the things that I heard as the highest priorities from the affordable housing community this year.

So once again, I ask for your support.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[4s]

Thank you.

Will the Clerk please call the roll on Amendment 1 to Council Bill 121310?

SPEAKER_13

[5s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_18

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Council Member Juarez?

Council Member Petal.

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_13

[8s]

Council Member Lin.

Yes.

Council Member Rink.

Yes.

Council Member Rivera.

SPEAKER_04

[1s]

Abstain.

Take them, I'm done.

SPEAKER_99

[1s]

I can't eat anymore.

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Wait.

SPEAKER_13

[17s]

Council Member Saka.

Council Member Saka.

Aye.

Thank you.

Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_15

[51s]

Aye.

And before you finish the roll call, I want to make sure that we've got everything correct on our end.

Just one second, Jody.

We can go back.

I'm just gonna have us take one step back.

I'm gonna have us recall the role in just one second and Council Member Rivera, if you'd like to have the floor for a second and then I'm not gonna do any more comments on the bill and then we're gonna vote on the amendment once more.

So back to you.

So I'm about to revote.

Would you like to make your statements for the record?

SPEAKER_04

[19s]

Sure.

I'm disqualifying myself from this vote, the amendment and the underlying vote.

As I've said before, I own a small townhouse with some family members, and so I'm disqualifying myself from this vote.

Thanks.

SPEAKER_15

[8s]

Thank you.

And we'll call the roll on amendment.

If the clerk can call the roll on amendment one to Council Bill 121310, please.

SPEAKER_13

[6s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_18

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[5s]

Councilmember Juarez?

Yes.

Councilmember Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Lin?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[5s]

Councilmember Rink?

Yes.

Councilmember Sacca?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[3s]

Seven in favor, one opposed.

SPEAKER_11

[6s]

Corrections, six in favor, one opposed, one, Council Member DiVetta disqualified, but present.

SPEAKER_15

[6s]

Thank you.

Thank you.

Amendment one to Council Bill 121310 does pass.

SPEAKER_11

[8s]

Let me redo my math here.

Seven in favor, one opposed, one Council Member present and abstained, Council Member DiVetta.

SPEAKER_15

[10s]

Thank you.

So now we have the underlying bill in front of us.

Any final comments?

Seeing none, will the clerk please call the roll?

Council Member Rink?

SPEAKER_03

[1s]

Council Member Foss.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Hold on.

Jody, sorry.

Council Member Rink, you have the floor.

SPEAKER_03

[1m23s]

Thank you, Chair Strauss.

Thanks for catching me there.

Colleagues, I was happy to support Amendment 1 on this, and I want to commend Councilmember Foster for bringing it forward.

I will not be supporting the underlying bill, and I want to speak to why very briefly.

We're reaching, and we're not reaching, I should say, our housing goals in the current economic climate.

that we're in, we're stuck between a rock and a hard place.

We know that permits are down and they have been down for some time now, so much so that our core staffing reserve funding within SDCI is nearly depleted.

So the solution on the table right now is to increase permit fees to fund positions, but my concern is the continued increase to fees further discourages folks from building, which in turn drives down our permit fees more and and honestly it feels like at times we are a snake eating its own tail.

Last year we also increased permit fees to address this issue but I think we need to start moving towards a more structural solution and that's why I sponsored a slide to request SDTCI present us with more options to address long-term budget concerns and to maintain a core staffing reserve.

So I'm hopeful that we can work in future budgets to address the ideas that result from that statement of legislative intent and put SDCI and permit fees on a path towards meeting our housing goals in the near future.

But at this time, I can't support raising permitting fees at a time where we desperately need to be incentivizing housing in our city.

SPEAKER_15

[9s]

Thank you.

Thank you.

Colleagues, any further discussion on the underlying bill as amended?

Seeing no further, Council Member Kettle.

SPEAKER_07

[33s]

Thank you, Chair.

I just wanted to note, you know, Council Member Rink makes a very, I'm going to vote for it, but she makes a very good point, because these are having an impact, you know, across the board, whether it's the various sales taxes and the like, and it is a challenge, and it is kind of, you know, and conundrum, if you will, in terms of what we're trying to do.

And at the same time, it does play into the decision calculus, whether something pencils out.

So thank you for raising the point, Council Member Rink.

SPEAKER_15

[9s]

Thank you.

Any final discussion?

Seeing no further discussion, will the clerk please call the roll on Council Bill 121310 as amended.

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[30s]

Council President Hollingsworth Council Member Juarez Council Member Kettle Council Member Lin Council Member Rink Council Member Rivera Council Member Saka Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Seven in favor, one opposed, one abstention.

SPEAKER_15

[27s]

Thank you.

Council Bill 121310 passes and will be sent to the November 20th full council meeting.

We're going to move on to the next item.

I'm going to move Council Bill 121313. Is there a second?

Second.

It's been moved and seconded.

And just to move right along, I'm gonna move Amendment 1 to Council Bill 121313. Is there a second?

Second.

Thank you.

This is a technical adjustment based on our comprehensive plan changes.

Central staff, would you like to brief this item, please?

SPEAKER_25

[29s]

Yeah, this is the Seattle Department of Transportation Street Use Fee Ordinance.

It increases street use permit issuance fees by 30% increasing rate recovery to cover costs for the street use division in SDOT.

The amendment would make technical corrections to align the ordinance with our comprehensive plan place categories.

SPEAKER_15

[19s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any questions on this?

Just simply changes urban center to regional center, urban village to urban center, urban center to...

And it just does that change again.

Seeing no further questions, will the clerk please call the roll on Amendment 1 to Council Bill 121313, please.

SPEAKER_13

[11s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

Yes.

Council Member Juarez?

Yes.

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[7s]

Council Member Lynn?

Yes.

Council Member Rink?

Yes.

Council Member Rivera?

SPEAKER_24

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Council Member Saka?

Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[2s]

Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[7s]

Thank you.

The amendment is adopted to Council Bill 121313. Will the clerk please call the roll on Council Bill 121313 as amended.

SPEAKER_13

[10s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

Yes.

Council Member Juarez?

Yes.

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[14s]

Council Member Lynn?

Yes.

Council Member Rink?

Yes.

Councilmember Rivera?

Aye.

Councilmember Sacca?

Aye.

Chair Strauss?

Aye.

Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[50s]

Thank you.

Council Bill 121313 passes as amended and will be sent to the November 20th City Council meeting.

Moving on to the next item, I move Council Bill 121325. Is there a second?

Second.

It's been moved and seconded.

We have two amendments on this item.

I forgot to mention when we got back together, we started at 6.36 PM.

We will stay in committee until 8.36 PM, at which point we'll take another break.

and come back if we need to.

With that, we've got two amendments before us.

I'm going to move...

Actually, I'm going to just bring up...

If you could brief the underlying bill, what does the Interfund loan do?

I know that we've had a number of pretty robust discussions here, but if you could just refocus us on the underlying bill and then the amendment from myself and Saka will go through.

Cal?

SPEAKER_16

[22s]

Yes, the underlying bill for Council Bill 121325 would authorize a 10-year revolving loan in the transportation fund of up to $63.5 million.

This is essentially to provide bridge funding for the department to resolve some of its revenue and cash balance issues and the house hold off until the amendment.

SPEAKER_15

[18s]

Thank you, colleagues.

Do you have any questions about what the bill is that we're working on right now?

Great.

We're going to move into the First Amendment.

I move Amendment 1 to Council Bill 121325. Is there a second?

Second.

It's been moved and seconded to adopt Amendment 1. Cal, would you like to brief this amendment, please?

SPEAKER_16

[19s]

amendment one from council member Strauss would modify the terms of the loan to reduce the term to two years and request a report on the use of the loan funds.

It would also request that SDOT establish where they are in their ability to repay the loan for the council to consider a new loan in two years.

SPEAKER_15

[60s]

Thank you, Cal.

This amendment was worked on in conjunction with the CBO and our city finance director to make sure that this was all working well and that we were all, we were doing two things simultaneously.

One, we were support, we were bailing out SDOT in the way that they needed to be bailed out.

And then secondly, we know that we've had five, I can't remember what the count is, maybe seven SDOT directors in the last decade.

And if we are looking a decade out, we need to have some more checks and balances.

If they are able to get on a more healthy fiscal path in between there, we can give them longer Interfund loans, but until they're on that better path, this two-year checkpoint is important.

Colleagues, is there any further discussion on this amendment?

This is an amendment that has been worked through all levels, through collaboration and compromise.

So this is the city working together.

I urge your yes vote.

Will the clerk please call the roll on Amendment 1 to Council Bill 121325.

SPEAKER_13

[10s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

Yes.

Council Member Juarez?

Councilmember Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Lin?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Councilmember Rink?

No.

Councilmember Rivera?

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[7s]

Councilmember Sacca?

Aye.

Chair Strauss?

Aye.

Eight in favor, one opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[14s]

Thank you.

The amendment passes and it amends Council Bill 121325. At this time, I move amendment two to Council Bill 121325. Is there a second?

Second.

It's been moved and seconded.

Central staff, would you like to brief the bill, the amendment, and then I'll pass it over to Council Member Saka.

SPEAKER_16

[12s]

Amendment 2 from Councilmember Saka would require annual reporting on loan repayment and request to report on the interdepartmental team workgroup that is working on the financial causes and strategies to resolve SDOT's financial issues.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Saka, you're recognized.

SPEAKER_22

[26s]

Thank you, Chair.

Colleagues, this is just another good governance feature in light of the current predicament that we are in with the Interfund loan transfer request to promote transparency, promote accountability, and improve our decision-making ability going forward by establishing both one-time and periodic reporting requirements going forward.

I ask for your support.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[13s]

Thank you, Council Member Sokka.

Colleagues, any discussion?

I think this is a pretty straightforward reporting mechanism and I appreciate you bringing this forward.

Council Member Sokka, will the clerk please call the roll on Amendment 2 to Council Bill 121325.

SPEAKER_13

[26s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

Yes.

Councilmember Juarez Yes Councilmember Kettle Aye Councilmember Lin Yes Councilmember Rink Yes Councilmember Rivera Aye Councilmember Slaka Aye Chair Strauss Aye Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[19s]

Thank you.

The motion passes and Council Bill 121325 is amended as presented in Amendment 2. Colleagues, is there any further discussion on the underlying SDOT transportation fund inter-fund loan?

Seeing no further discussion, will the clerk please call the roll on Council Bill 121325 as amended.

SPEAKER_13

[8s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_18

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Council Member Juarez?

Yes.

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Council Member Lin?

Yes.

Council Member Rink?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Rivera?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Sacca?

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Chair Strauss?

Aye.

Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[14s]

Thank you.

Council Bill 121325 passes as amended and will be sent to the November 20th City Council meeting.

We'll move into the next item, voluntary separations ordinance.

I move Council Bill 121322. Is there a second?

SPEAKER_17

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_15

[9s]

It's been moved and seconded.

Central staff, if you could give just a brief overview of the underlying bill and then we'll move into the amendment from there.

SPEAKER_25

[22s]

The proposed legislation would grant the director of the Department of Human Resources authority to propose a voluntary separation program where eligible employees would be able to receive benefits for leaving service from the city.

SPEAKER_15

[21s]

Thank you, Director Woodson.

And the underlying bill does not describe how the program operates, simply it provides the authorization to do so.

Is that correct?

Correct.

Thank you.

And in the past three times that we've used this mechanism since 2000, has there ever been a situation where the authorization does not have a sunset?

SPEAKER_25

[3s]

Do you want to...

SPEAKER_02

[11s]

The previous author, well, there have not been previous authorizations, but the previous early retirement incentives were just singular episodes.

So there wasn't a delegation of authority.

SPEAKER_15

[9s]

Thank you.

And that's what makes this bill different is that there is no sunset or no time period allotted.

It is simply authorization forever.

SPEAKER_11

[0s]

Correct.

SPEAKER_15

[18s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any questions on the underlying bill?

I'm going to move into the First Amendment.

I move Amendment 1 to Council Bill 121322. Is there a second?

Second.

Thank you.

It's been moved and seconded.

Karina, welcome.

Great to see you.

Would you like to brief this amendment?

SPEAKER_02

[17s]

Sure thing.

At Karenable, Council Central staff, and this amendment would establish a time-limited period for the SDHR director to offer a voluntary early retirement separation program.

It would automatically sunset that authority after three years of the effective date of this ordinance.

SPEAKER_15

[24s]

Thank you as sponsor of the amendment.

Every other time we've provided this authorization, it's been periodic.

It would be different to allow this to be ongoing.

I believe if I recall correctly, the last two episodes were a year or two at maximum.

This allows for three years, which is a little bit more than those past episodes.

Am I getting this correct?

I'm gonna turn it over to central staff.

SPEAKER_02

[16s]

My understanding is that the previous incentives were just one year.

They were authorized for the next year, and council had to approve it, so there was no delegated authority.

Council received the proposal.

Council approved it.

It was offered for the next year.

SPEAKER_15

[8s]

Thank you.

So even with these sideboards on the voluntary separation, it is still a greater allowance than has been allowed in the past.

SPEAKER_02

[1s]

Absolutely.

SPEAKER_15

[9s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any discussion on this amendment?

Seeing no discussion, will the clerk please call the roll on Amendment 1 to Council Bill 121322.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Foster?

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Council Member Juarez?

Aye.

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Lynn?

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Council Member Rink?

Yes.

Council Member Rivera?

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Councilmember Sacca?

Aye.

Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[2s]

Nine in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[11s]

Thank you.

The amendment passes and Council Bill 121322 is amended as presented on Amendment 1. Colleagues, any final discussion on Council Bill 121322?

Yes.

Councilmember Rivera.

SPEAKER_04

[37s]

Thank you, Chair.

I just want to say that I don't take lightly giving SDHR this authority and probably why it hasn't been done in the past.

I appreciate the chair bringing guardrails and I understand that because of some other actions that were in the balancing package, it may impact the ability for SDHR to actually offer this next year, maybe until the end of the year or the following, which is why I'm agreeing to the three years, but this isn't something that I would be advocating for in the future, delegating our authority to SDHR to do.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[13s]

Amen.

And Council Member Rivera, it was your comments that rang in my ear when I asked for this amendment to be written.

Thank you.

Colleagues, final discussion.

Seeing no further discussion, will the clerk please call the roll on Council Bill 121322 as amended.

SPEAKER_13

[9s]

Councilmember Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

Aye.

Councilmember Juarez?

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Lin?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Councilmember Rink?

Yes.

Councilmember Rivera?

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Sacca?

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Chair Strauss?

Aye.

Nine in favor and none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[10s]

Thank you.

Council Bill 121322 passes as amended and will be sent to the November 20th City Council meeting.

Moving on to the next item, I move Council Bill 121340. Is there a second?

Second.

SPEAKER_13

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_15

[8s]

It's been moved and second.

Will essential staff please brief this item?

We've had extensive conversation about it today.

SPEAKER_25

[9s]

This is the bill that would apply the city's 0.01% sales tax for additional services for children and their families.

SPEAKER_15

[38s]

Thank you, Councilmember Strauss as the sponsor of the bill, I'm recognized.

This is the conversation that we had.

This county passed a sales tax that the city has right to portions of.

We did not increase people's sales tax, the county did that, and yet still there is funding to fund the things that the city wants to do as far as supporting youth and families.

Colleagues discussion.

Seems like we had the discussion earlier.

Will the clerk please call the roll on Council Bill 121340?

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Foster?

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_13

[2s]

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_18

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Council Member Juarez?

Yes.

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Lynn?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Abstain.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Council Member Rink?

No.

Council Member Rivera?

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[5s]

Council member Sacca?

Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[3s]

Five in favor, two opposed, two abstentions.

SPEAKER_15

[13s]

I'm triple checking that the motion passes.

The motion passes and Council Bill 121340 will be sent to the full city council.

I just want to check with the clerk.

Does this require three quarters vote at the city council?

SPEAKER_11

[11s]

I don't believe it would at this point because unless we're amending the budget, I would ask such a staff to look at the title.

Correct.

Yeah, it does not.

SPEAKER_15

[13s]

Great.

I'm just checking to get us ready for Friday.

With that, we're going to move into the next item.

I move Council Bill 121341. Is there a second?

Second.

It's been moved and seconded.

Will central staff please brief the bill and then I'll turn it over to Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_25

[15s]

Yeah, Council Bill 121341 is related to penalties for the do not solicit ordinance.

It would state that at least 70% of the penalty revenue be used for legal defense, home retention, and repair, and assistance filing fair housing complaints.

SPEAKER_15

[4s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Foster sponsored the bill.

You're recognized.

SPEAKER_01

[56s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

I was really proud to pass the homeowner privacy and protection legislation earlier this year, and thank you colleagues for your support there.

that legislation established a do not solicit list for homeowners who are tired of unwanted and predatory solicitation practices.

At the time that we pass that, I want to call out and appreciate Council President Hollingsworth for directing me to this notion that we should ensure that any revenue generated from the fines and fees from the do not solicit legislation should be put back into the communities who are most impacted.

Based on that feedback from Council President and input from the Black Homeowner Policy Council and other community leaders, this legislation directs revenue collected from the violations of the Do Not Solicit List towards helping existing homeowners fight displacement with support such as legal assistance for estate planning, support filing fair housing complaints, and home retention and repair assistance.

So, colleagues, I ask for your support.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[20s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any questions on this bill?

This is a bill that in future budget years, I'll ask to go through committee, but I appreciate this coming forward at this time.

Seeing no further questions, will the clerk please call the roll on Council Bill 121340?

Oh, sorry.

Will the clerk please call the roll on Council Bill 121341?

SPEAKER_13

[3s]

Council Member Foster?

SPEAKER_01

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[10s]

Council President Hollingsworth?

Aye.

Council Member Juarez?

Aye.

Council Member Kettle?

Aye.

Council Member Lin?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Rink?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Rivera?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Saka?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Chair Strauss?

Aye.

9 in favor, none opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[11s]

Thank you.

Council Bill 121341 passes and will be sent to the November 20th City Council meeting.

I'm going to move on to the next item.

I move Council Bill 121339. Is there a second?

Second.

SPEAKER_18

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_15

[8s]

It's been moved and seconded.

And Central Staff will debrief the item and then I'm going to call on Council Member Kettle and Foster.

SPEAKER_14

[1m02s]

Tom Maxwell, Central Staff.

So, Council Bill...

1-2-1-3-3-9 would amend the existing fiscal transparency program to include the Jumpstart Fund and to also include for the financial plans submitted for the general fund and the payroll expense tax fund that the mayor submit balanced projections.

The current standard up till this year has been that the budget is balanced according to state law.

However, the future projections could show unbalanced results.

B&O restructure bill approved by voters last year, also called Seattle Shield, implemented a new standard that was used for financial planning this year whereby the Payroll Expense Tax or the Jumpstart Fund and the General Fund were both showing balance projections in the future.

That was a one-year standard only applicable for this budget cycle.

This change would make it an ongoing permanent standard.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Thank you, Councilmember Kettle and then Foster.

SPEAKER_07

[49s]

Thank you, Chair.

On this one, this was basically a follow-up to our B&O tax amendment that basically put in place what we're seeing in this budget submission.

The idea then was to have it ongoing.

It turns out it wasn't so we needed to do so and hence this amendment here, I mean this bill here in order to basically affect what was the intention with the B&O tax.

I think it's really important, although I'll speak to this a little bit later, I think it's important for the executive to do this to ensure that long term, kind of going to the lessons learned over the last number of years in terms of some of the budgetary practices that we've seen.

Thank you, Chair.

Thank you, Councilmember Kettle, Councilmember Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[1m06s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

I appreciate you, Councilmember Kettle, for your leadership here as well.

My goal with this proposal, as well as the one that will follow, is to make permanent the requirements that councils imposed last year and to also expand them, which we'll talk about in the next piece of legislation.

My bottom line is this.

I don't believe that we can, in good faith, keep paying for this year's bills with next year's paycheck.

I know that restraint and budgeting is hard, but it is also necessary.

I believe that when we use one-time funding for ongoing expenses, we risk creating unfunded mandates and increasing our structural budget and the deficit in future years.

I know that many folks here have been here before.

We've seen it over the last decade.

that every year we've entered into the budget process with significant deficits.

And I believe that we can all agree that starting from a place of crisis makes the entire process more difficult.

This is legislation that I know a majority of council members signed on to, so thank you, and I ask for your support.

SPEAKER_15

[43s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any further discussion?

Any further discussion at this time?

I will just say that requiring the budget to be balanced for four years is passing that amendment last year was an incredibly important thing.

And one of the reasons why I think that we have a four year sustainable budget this year.

It's not a small deal at all.

I don't know that anyone would, I don't know that the mayor would have done that this year without being required to.

And so with that, any final comments?

Will the clerk please call the roll on.

Council Bill 121339.

SPEAKER_13

[17s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

Yes.

Pardon me?

Council President Hollingsworth?

Abstain.

Thank you.

Council Member Juarez?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Lynn?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Rink?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Rivera?

SPEAKER_06

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Councilmember Sacca?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_13

[3s]

Eight in favor, none opposed, one abstention.

SPEAKER_15

[19s]

Thank you, the motion carries and Council Bill 121339 will be sent to the November 20th City Council meeting.

Moving on, I move Council Bill 121338, is there a second?

Second.

It's been moved and seconded to adopt Council Bill 121338. Would Central Staff like to brief the bill and then Council Member Foster, you'll be recognized.

SPEAKER_14

[20s]

Council Bill 121338 would impose a new standard for consideration of council budgets whereby the aggregate of council budget action expenditures would not exceed the aggregate sum of ongoing council budget action revenues.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Tom, could you say that a little?

Maybe the key takeaway.

SPEAKER_14

[4s]

Key takeaway is that the ongoing spending cannot exceed ongoing revenue.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[1m10s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

Thank you for that final short sentence there, Tom.

Very well said.

Colleagues, I think I said this when we did an overview here.

My looking at this and looking at the requirement that we have for the mayor's office to send us a budget that is balanced in the out years, I believe it makes sense to hold ourselves to the same standard and to ensure that we are practicing the same kind of fiscal responsibility and sustainability that we are requiring from the executive.

So Tom said it well, ongoing expenditures should not exceed ongoing revenue.

And colleagues, my intent here is to ensure that we have alignment.

And I believe, candidly, that this alignment will allow us to have greater predictability not just for ourselves, but for the organizations, the partners, the things that we are investing in so that we can do better planning.

I do have a couple of questions that I'd like to direct to central staff.

And so really briefly there, I know there may be other comments here.

If you can just share, the mayor sent us a budget and the budget that the mayor sent us is balanced until what year?

Tom?

Including the financial plan.

SPEAKER_14

[10s]

Right, the budget is balanced for the current biennium 27-28 and the financial plan projections show positive ending unreserved fund balance in all future years through 2030.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Councilmember Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[23s]

Thank you.

And then the budget, I know we have not, we don't have a final budget in front of us, but it's my understanding that some of the actions that we're contemplating right now as Council would shorten that horizon for which we have a balanced budget in the out years.

Can you affirm if that's true?

And if so, share how long the budget that we are contemplating with Council adds remains balanced.

SPEAKER_14

[13s]

Tom?

At this time, the current biennium is similarly balanced.

The projections for all future years are balanced as well.

Positive, unreserved fund balance in all years.

SPEAKER_01

[16s]

Councilmember Foster.

Thank you.

And I think it's my intent to ensure that we are holding ourselves to the same standard so that we have, as an ongoing basis, a balanced budget that comes from the executive and that we pass a balanced budget that meets those same standards.

So with that, colleagues, I ask for your support.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Thank you, Councilmember Kettle, followed by Lynn.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_07

[1m56s]

And speaking to this and following up the previous one, I do think it's important for the executive to do this.

I do note, you know, the idea of the executive and the legislative or executive versus the legislative that, you know, we're a co-equal branch, but we are in a disadvantaged position.

We're disadvantaged from being outnumbered in staff and resources, but not quality for the record in terms of the support that we get.

And we've also seen where the executive doesn't implement and the laws as passed and so forth.

So these are some of the challenges that we face, and this is in terms of doing our responsibilities of oversight, developing legislation, and most importantly is budget, the power of the purse.

and so I support the idea in a sense but I'm concerned because, and it goes back to the word of flexibility in the budgeting process.

I think it's important to me in that flexibility.

I think of over the decades, years, decades, where Red State, Red County, America has been waving the fiscal restraint conservative flag and inadvertently they butt themselves in a straitjacket which then hurt them in terms of their ability to carry out their responsibilities.

And so while I appreciate Everything that's behind it, and my initial reaction is to yes, but upon reflection, thinking about the challenges that we have, you know, relative to being, quote, unquote, a co-equal branch, but importantly in terms of the budgetary, because I talked about this before in terms of flexibility as a good governance model, that we do need to have some flexibility, and I hate to see us replicate what I've seen in other parts of the country, states, and basically put themselves in a straitjacket, which then in turn actually hurt them.

So with that, Chair, thank you.

Thank you.

Councilmember Lin followed by Rivera and Sacha.

SPEAKER_06

[15s]

Thank you, Chair.

A few questions.

One, so if this ordinance passes, would it apply to this year's budget or future budgets?

SPEAKER_14

[4s]

I would not apply for this year's process.

SPEAKER_06

[17s]

Okay, thank you.

But hypothetically speaking, based on, and obviously we haven't finalized our budget yet, but based, do you think if it did apply to this year's budget, there would be, could you describe what the impact would be, hypothetically speaking?

SPEAKER_14

[21s]

In the strictest sense, the ongoing ads are fairly closely balanced with the ongoing revenues.

There is some slight deviation where expenditures are higher than revenues.

But for the most part, fund balance is used similar to the way that the executive used fund balance in their financial planning in both the general fund and the payroll expense tax fund.

SPEAKER_06

[5s]

Councilmember Lund.

Chair, I see Lisch.

SPEAKER_25

[5s]

So basically the Council's actions would comply with the ordinance, is that correct, Tom?

SPEAKER_14

[1s]

Yeah, very close, yes.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you for the key takeaway.

Council Member Lin.

SPEAKER_06

[29s]

Thank you.

And I guess speaking a little bit to Councilmember Kettle's concern, or just if there was some sort of issue where we needed to kind of supersede this in a kind of an unexpected or some sort of emergency scenario, could you just talk to us, you know, what kind of flexibility would there be in the future if we needed to, if this passes but we needed to change it because we think for some reason we can't meet the requirements of this?

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Tom Orlish?

SPEAKER_14

[10s]

And so during any budget process, council ultimately would make the final call as to how the standard is applied.

And so that's how the ordinance is currently structured.

SPEAKER_06

[4s]

Thank you so much.

Hang on.

Cal and Lish?

SPEAKER_16

[12s]

Just to add to that, I mean, there have been examples of financial constraints that have been put that the Council has acknowledged and notwithstanding determined to do something different.

So that has happened in the past.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Lin, you still have a floor.

SPEAKER_06

[47s]

Yeah, thank you so much.

I just appreciate Council Member Foster for bringing this.

I do support it.

You know, I think it's kind of, you know, what's good for the executive, I think it's also good for us to follow a similar standard.

I do, as we just heard, you know, if we need to sort of deviate from this, we could do so as far or a future council could do so as far as part of a future budget scenario, but I think it's just kind of sets the expectation and good practice.

And, you know, I also think that, you know, I know that we could do this on a voluntary basis, but I also just think, again, it's good to signal for future councils that this is the expectation.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_04

[3m51s]

Thank you, Chair.

I appreciate you, Councilmember Foster, for bringing this forward.

I will say my concern is this.

Council has two responsibilities, to pass laws, and we have the responsibility of the budget.

This is hitting at one of our core responsibilities.

As you know, colleagues, the mayor creates their budget in private with no public discussion, no public hearings, and no transparency into decisions about what to fund or how to fund it.

This is how Seattle's government system was designed.

The council and the public only know what the mayor has funded when the mayor transmits their proposed budget to council, and only then can we as council weigh in and try to fund our constituents' priorities.

Those priorities may be different from the mayor's.

To do this, council has to cut funding from somewhere, which would be appropriate, or add money to the budget if, of course, the forecast, October forecast is more favorable than was expected when the mayor proposed her budget.

So I will say yes, sometimes that means proposing one-time funding with the understanding that that funding might not be ongoing.

And we need to hold ourselves accountable for that.

The hope is that the mayor sees the value of the investments that we include and that that funding is made ongoing if needed.

And of course, there's no guarantees that the mayor will do that.

I will say colleagues that I've always advocated for us spending the money that we do have and if we had made the decision to just use what was coming out of the forecast which we know was the extra that we could allocate without having impacts to the budget and then utilized provisos or cuts to the budget to include our priorities I would have been all in favor of that.

because to me, that's the responsible way to budget.

I've yet to see a council do that, but I will state it here for the record.

I would be in favor of that.

The chair knows this.

I've advocated to him the same in our prior conversations.

So all that to say, I wish that that is how we did budgeting, but here we are.

And as I said earlier, sometimes this means that we're going to have to put one time ads to address and everyone's done that to address some of what constituents need.

And we need to be able to have, as my colleague said earlier, Councilmember Kettle, the flexibility to be able to manage for this, as is our responsibility to pass a balanced budget every year, which we do.

And I would like four years out to be balanced.

I also would like not to raid reserves.

I would like to use the money that we get coming out of the forecast and then I'd like to utilize either just additional, you know, if the forecast is better using that and then provisos.

I would advocate for that into the future, but in the absence of that, I think that this would be something that is not something that I could support today, though I support the underlying the underlying intent.

I can't, for the reasons I've stated, support this today.

But I look forward to working with everyone last year and getting to, next year rather, and getting to a place where we're doing more fiscally responsible budgeting.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Thank you.

SPEAKER_22

[6m18s]

Thank you, Chair.

First off, I want to thank Councilmember Foster for bringing this forward.

I appreciate the approach that you've taken overall to this budget and helping us think about how we can be truly more sustainable on a going-forward basis.

And I appreciate your sense of fiscal responsibility in making sure that the taxpayer is getting the most bang for their buck and also making sure that we avoid these kind of setting, minimizing the scenarios where we're setting potentially unreasonable expectations with community.

So that I know is true regardless of however this thing, whether it gets passed or not.

So I just want to name that and say I really appreciate that.

I also think that the council is, well, I know that the council is the legislative branch, and it serves as the final check on the executive's budget proposal.

The final check on the executive's proposed budget.

While it is absolutely appropriate for the mayor to propose a financially constrained budget, the council, I also believe the council should retain maximum flexibility to modify that proposal in direct response to community priorities and needs.

At the end of the day, we still must pass a balanced budget, but we also need flexibility in the three-month intervening time between the time the mayor finalizes her proposed budget and transmits it to council and the time council passes the final, community needs and priorities can rapidly change and evolve and show up in that time.

As council, we need flexibility.

Again, we are the final, the final check on the executive as this legislative branch.

And I think this ordinance and the intent and purpose in terms of being, you know, sustainable, and I support those broader goals.

I also think it would voluntarily restrict one of our most sacred constitutional and charter level responsibilities, deciding how public dollars are spent.

Every council faces different economic conditions, community needs, and policy changes.

could constrain, would constrain future counsel's ability to exercise independent judgment by imposing rules that limit budgetary options before future policy makers even enter office.

Elected officials should preserve, not surrender legislative discretion.

and I think, again, what this ultimately amounts to is an abdication of our principal powers in the legislative branch, looking after the purse, recognizing again that we still have to live within a balanced budget at the end of the day.

I don't want to limit our flexibility to address emerging needs.

Ultimately, some of this boils down to, and by the way, by not passing this, it does not impede or restrict our ability to voluntarily implement this or similar things on a going forward basis.

But I don't want to bind future councils to a standard that, in my view, is tantamount to abdicating our principal power of the purse.

Ultimately, some of these conversations, some not all these conversations hinge around this.

Who decides what investment, where, when, and why?

Not how, but who decides what investment, where, when, and why?

I personally am a strong supporter of a balanced approach.

The executive has a lot of expertise within the various executive department bureaucracies.

They have a lot of expertise and know-how.

But just because many but not all of those decisions arise from subject matter experts within the department, that's not the same thing.

as saying that the mayor's proposed budget is without influence from an elected official, i.e. the mayor.

It's not the same thing.

And so I strongly support a balanced approach where we have executive prerogatives, executive priorities, Whoever the executive is, by the way, this is agnostic of, this is bigger than any one of us currently sitting on these bodies, currently sitting upstairs on the seventh floor.

But I support a balanced approach of the executive deciding what, when, where, why, and they actually get to decide how.

That's literally the province of the executive branch.

And I also support council additions because we have a different perspective.

And it's neither better nor worse.

Neither better nor worse.

It is just a fact.

It is a different perspective.

And we also need to demonstrate responsiveness to our communities.

And so I don't want to unduly or unfairly infringe and restrict our abilities on a going forward basis.

Again, we still have to balance, live within the confines of a balanced budget at the end of the day.

But I view this again as advocating our principal power.

And for that reason, I cannot support it.

I do really appreciate all the work and the broader goals that went into this.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you, Council Member Sock, Council Member Lund.

SPEAKER_06

[12s]

Thank you, Chair.

I'm just a little bit confused, so I just want to clarify something with central staff.

Does this affect our ability to revise or do anything with the mayor's budget that gets sent down?

SPEAKER_14

[4s]

Tom?

No, it does not apply any constraint to that process.

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

Okay, thank you.

No further questions.

SPEAKER_15

[32s]

Thank you.

Colleagues, any further discussion?

Any further discussion?

You've got last word, Council Member Foster, don't worry.

Colleagues, further discussion, final discussion?

I will just say, I've got a couple questions.

I think you have already answered these, but I'm just going to be a little bit more direct.

Does the chair's package that I presented, let's say this proposal was law today.

Would the chair's package and the budget as it is right now meet the legal requirements that are contained within this bill?

SPEAKER_14

[27s]

Chair Strauss, I believe that the ongoing spending is slightly higher than the ongoing revenues in the general fund, in the chair's package.

Though as I said, it's bridged with use of fund balance, similar to the way that the executive did.

So that might be an area where there could be some flexibility, given that the fact that the intent of sustainability is still met in that way.

But I believe there is a small, I don't know what the margin is, but it's a small margin.

SPEAKER_15

[10s]

and if I recall correctly, it's about $100,000 because the ongoing was 4.4 and the increased ongoing revenue was 4.3 million.

SPEAKER_14

[8s]

I believe it's a bit higher than that in both cases, but it is fractional in that kind of order of magnitude with regards to the difference.

SPEAKER_15

[10s]

Thank you.

So your direct answer to my direct question is it's unclear if this law would, if we would meet the letter of this law today.

SPEAKER_14

[6s]

If the strict standard of ongoing spending and ongoing revenue was met, then it would be slightly off, yes.

SPEAKER_15

[26s]

And the four-year financial plan is still balanced as was required by the mayor to send down, is that correct?

That is correct.

And so we are demonstrating fiscal sustainability with a balanced ongoing budget in a way that has not been balanced in the past because we've never been sent a budget that is balanced for four years.

Would you say that those are generally correct comments?

SPEAKER_14

[1s]

That is correct, yeah.

SPEAKER_15

[1m57s]

Okay, and so I guess what I would say is I don't need a law to do what's right in this situation.

I don't need a law or an executive order to tell me how to do my job well.

What I know is that we need to have these budgets balanced four years out.

I think it's a good idea.

I think that's why you might not, y'all weren't in the chairs package weekend, but the question that I kept coming back to Tom and to Cal and to Lish and actually there were some changes that were made to some amendments without my full knowledge, just because I gave a certain set of priorities and said that the most important thing is that the four-year financial plan is balanced.

That's the most important thing.

Council Member Saka even had an amendment this week about cameras being added to Alki.

The reason he didn't have that added in the first time was because I was concerned that we would be out of balance in the out years, and so when that amendment was presented to me again, the only question I had are we balanced in the out years?

We were, which is why I was happy to support your amendment, Council Member Saka.

But I just, I share, colleagues, that's the level of commitment to being balanced four years out.

And the mayor has five months to put their budget together, and the budget chair has five weeks to put the package together.

the ability for any council to get boxed in by a mayor.

We don't have the power to implement budgets.

We don't have the power to implement laws.

We only have the power to pass them.

And so I believe that the spirit of this is incredibly correct.

That's why I balanced the budget in the way that I did.

But I have some deep concerns.

Councilmember Rivera, I see a new hand.

Is that correct?

And then I'll pass it to Councilmember Foster for last word.

SPEAKER_04

[4m32s]

Thank you, Chair.

You know, as I'm sitting here listening to everyone speak, I want to remind everyone that the mayor sent down a budget appropriating about $9 billion for 2027 alone.

While I very much appreciate that the mayor sent down a balanced budget through 2030, it was a budget that didn't fund important chartered responsibilities like the fire department overtime and the ability to hire the number of police officers that we need.

we're going to feel the repercussions of the mayor's decisions.

And so this is why it was important to me to restore the fire funding, but that fire funding is not going to necessarily be ongoing.

And there were some things that this council had to do in order to restore what isn't our chartered responsibility.

So when we're making these decisions, we got to keep in mind the real life world examples of things that we as council have to do because the mayor didn't do it.

So when we talk about the one-time funds, this is a one-time piece that we're trying to address and we're going to have to figure out how to address it beyond 2028. So this is, I wanted to give a concrete example because these things are important so I very much believe and I don't think I've been I've been called a budget hawk and I will wear that proudly because everyone knows fiscal responsibility is really important to me and we all know that the flexibility that is afforded council as as us holding that power, the person having to make these tough decisions, as Councilmember Saka said on the back end, is really important.

So I just want to be clear, it is not that I don't want to hold us accountable to ensuring we have balanced budgets years out, but it takes a certain kind of fiscal responsibility that, as I said earlier, I have not seen in Council in many years in order to do that.

And part of that, at least for this year's budget, this police piece, I'm sorry, the fire piece was really important to do.

So this is what we have to grapple with at council, not the same as the mayor, because I said earlier, the mayor gets to do her budget, not in a public process the way that we do.

So she's able to leave fire over time out and not have people come to chambers or call about that, get calls about that necessarily if no one, because no one knows about that until it is released.

So for those reasons, I do think that this piece about Council Member Kettle, you were talking about flexibility, Councilmember Saka, you talked about it too, you know, is really important.

And I do hope we will hold ourselves accountable and do balance budgeting moving forward, Councilmember Foster, because you and I are aligned on the fiscal responsibility piece.

I don't think anyone would accuse me of that at this point.

But it is limiting ourselves in a way that I think this goes to the core of one of our key responsibilities and we do, because of that, need that flexibility.

And I wanted to give an example because I think for folks watching, I want folks to know, you know, I don't want folks to leave the, whoever may be watching, turn off the channel to think that somehow those of us that might not vote in favor of this are somehow saying we're not wanting to be fiscally responsible.

We do.

I do.

and I also know the reality is that we need to manage for these things and sometimes our real world example gets to the point of why it's important to have that flexibility and that fire over time is a very, very concrete example from this year's budget.

And that's just one of other examples I could think of for this year, including there's not a lot of funding in this budget to hire officers to the level of we've been hiring in the last couple of years to get our police force up to the numbers that we had pre-COVID.

So thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you.

Council Member Foster, closing comments.

SPEAKER_01

[32s]

Thank you so much.

I don't think I was expecting this much of a spirited discussion at 7.30 tonight.

So thank you so much, colleagues.

I wanna just ask a few questions to central staff before I provide some closing comments.

I know there's just been a lot of discussion around the budget being balanced in the out years.

And I wanna clarify, in recent years, has the budget that the mayor has sent down to council had the six-year financial plan balanced for four or six years?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Tom?

SPEAKER_14

[10s]

Councilmember Foster, now for the last number of years since 2019, at least, the financial plans have included significant deficits in the future.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Councilmember Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[18s]

Thank you.

And in those previous years, have the actions taken by Council done anything to reduce those defi- Let me say that differently.

I don't want to say done anything.

That's not right.

What I want to say is the budgets that Council have passed, have they also included those deficits in the out years, in recent years?

Tom?

SPEAKER_14

[17s]

Council Member Foster not having all of the records in front of me.

It's difficult to make such a broad assessment though.

They always work within the resources that are available, but they have not solved the deficits that have been proposed given largely because they're so significant.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Councilmember Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[1m58s]

Thank you.

I think it would be fair to say and I want to say this because I do appreciate being at a place now where last year we requested the mayor to balance the budget not just as required by law but to also provide these balanced financial plans and I appreciate that now As the chair has stated, we have balanced financial plans.

But I also believe that it goes without saying, we have not had those in recent years or else we would not have been staring down the significant deficit that we were staring down this year.

So that has not been a standard or an ongoing practice because were that the case, I don't believe we would have a $175 million deficit at the start of the year.

And I don't say that with any intention of pointing fingers at any of my colleagues who have been here in previous years.

I say it with an eye towards the future, and with an eye towards the fact that as we have started off on a new leaf with the requirements, and thank you Council Member Kettle for passing this last year, as we passed the balancing requirement for the mayor last year, I think it's important that we are not holding ourselves to a different standard, or to say differently, if a standard is good enough to ask that we are requesting that another branch of government to meet it, I believe it's fair that we ask ourselves to to fall in line with that same standard.

I do have a couple of closing questions here, and I know there's been, I wasn't going to ask these initially, but there was some back and forth around one-time ads.

And so I do want to just speak, have you speak to those a little bit now.

So just in my own review of the balancing package, there were 13 items that were originally proposed as ongoing expenses.

but show up as one-time expenses.

And again, my count here is that the total of those one-time expenses is $21.5 million.

And my question is, if those programs which were originally sponsored as ongoing were reflected as ongoing in the Council's budget, how would that impact our projected deficit in 2029?

SPEAKER_14

[14s]

Council Member Foster.

So if we assume $21 million more ongoing spending than is currently in the Chair's package in 2029, the deficit, kind of the difference between revenues and expenditures would be $38 million.

Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[37s]

Thank you.

And then I want to ask another question.

So there were the items that were originally proposed as ongoing expenses and then now show up as one-time ads.

And then I think there's some other items that I look at and I would say they could potentially be ongoing.

So, for example, FTE positions in departments that might appear as one-time costs in 2027 and 2028. but where we might assume there's an ongoing staff need in 2029. So do you have a sense of, looking at the package, how those one-time ads in this budget, if they were treated as ongoing expenses, how they would impact the deficit in 2029?

Tom?

Sure.

SPEAKER_14

[20s]

Essentially, that equates to about $41 million of ongoing expense, and so that nets out the impact of the fire pension contribution, which is truly one time in nature.

And if you added that as an ongoing expense, the projected deficit absent fund balance would be basically $59 million.

SPEAKER_01

[30s]

Thank you so much.

I appreciate that.

And colleagues, I will say I'm certainly not innocent of having proposed ads to this budget for things that I am passionate about and things that I believe are actions that we should take.

And what I am looking to do here with this proposal is to have a proposal that sits alongside the one with the mayor's office and ensure that we continue to have alignment and that we have high standards.

so that those are not dependent on who sits in these seats in the future.

Thank you, colleagues, and with that, I ask for your support.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Thank you.

Will the clerk please call the roll on Council Bill 121338?

SPEAKER_13

[5s]

Council Member Foster?

Yes.

Council President Hollingsworth?

SPEAKER_18

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Council Member Juarez?

Yes.

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Lynn?

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[7s]

Council Member Rink?

Yes.

Councilmember Rivera?

No.

Councilmember Saka?

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Nay.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Chair Strauss?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

Four in favor, five opposed.

SPEAKER_15

[19s]

Thank you.

The bill does not, is not recommended.

It does still go.

and it will still go to November 20th full council meeting for final consideration.

We have our final item, Council Bill 121336. So I move Council Bill 121336. Is there a second?

SPEAKER_10

[0s]

Second.

SPEAKER_15

[9s]

It is moved and seconded.

Central staff, would you like to brief the item and then we will have Council Member Foster speak to her bill.

SPEAKER_25

[18s]

Earlier this year, many police officers were overpaid.

This bill would create a fund to recapture those overpayments with the purpose of providing resources for multifamily and affordable housing.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Foster.

SPEAKER_01

[1m28s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

As was just stated by central staff earlier this year, the city inadvertently overpaid around $13.1 million due to an error.

And I'm putting forth this legislation for a few reasons.

And I just want to say sort of first and foremost, I think this fund allows for fiscal transparency.

coming off of the conversation around fiscal sustainability, and I believe that at a time when there are questions about public trust in our institutions, we ought to make certain that we have an accurate accounting of the collection of these overpayments, and that that is administered in a manner that's consistent with city and state law.

So that's part one.

Part two of this, as colleagues, as you've heard me discuss previously, is around affordable housing.

And for anyone who may think that that's too much of a dotted line, part of the reason I'm putting this forward is that in the same year we have, again, the $65 million forward commit in the Office of Housing.

I see that as one of the most significant impacts to departments in the budget this year.

And so looking at where we're at, where we see the Jumpstart helping to support General Fund, where we see the Office of Housing taking this forward funding shift, I believe that as we move forward on approaching these repayments to the General Fund, that it makes sense and that there's strong alignment to have a clear and dedicated commitment of those resources to housing.

That is why I am putting this forward.

And with that, colleagues, I ask for your support.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Thank you.

Council Member Kellell.

SPEAKER_07

[53s]

Thank you, Chair.

I will admit, I think I was misreading this previously.

Maybe I was influenced by our CBA action that we had taken earlier.

there's a little bit of a disconnect.

Now, I don't know how this impacts the ordinance, but, you know, we, on the CBA, we'd switch from having the police department report and change it to the mayor's office because what we really have is FAS, SBD, there's a lot of different players in this.

And so I'm a little bit surprised that this wasn't updated to say the mayor's office, you know, because the mayor's office is the one that has the responsibility because there's multiple departments involved in this.

and one could argue too in terms of creating an overpayment fund that this should be in the finance committee as well.

I'm just noting that because in actuality I think this ordinance in a lot of ways is not in sync with what we've already done on this question.

SPEAKER_15

[7s]

Thank you.

Council Member Kettle, further discussion?

Council Member Rank.

SPEAKER_03

[1m11s]

Thank you, Chair Strauss, and thank you, Councilmember Foster, for bringing this forward.

In many ways, I do find this complementary to the prior action that we took to have a statement of legislative intent, really directing the mayor's office to report back to us on the repayment.

As I understand and see this particular piece of legislation, we are simply making a essentially a pot for as we receive those dollars back for it to live in one spot.

And I think it's an important transparency measure as we recoup the taxpayer dollars that are associated with this overpayment.

I do wanna take this opportunity to ask on the record, and I know I've talked at length about my frustration with the overpayment situation and the fact that there are $13.1 million that could have been spent on community priorities, many of which we've discussed throughout this budget process.

But at this stage, there is still an open question about the timeline for getting that funding back.

I'm wondering, I just wanna ask on the record, do we have any updates at this time about the status or the process, anything that the executive has shared with central staff?

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Central staff.

SPEAKER_25

[2s]

I haven't heard any updates.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Thank you.

SPEAKER_03

[33s]

Thank you.

So colleagues, I want to thank you for your support on the statement of legislative intent so we can get the regular reporting back because I do think it is critical that we have the oversight and make sure that we are holding the executive's feet to the fire to pull together all relevant departments and get folks to the bargaining table so we can ensure the rightful return of these taxpayer dollars.

And in tandem, I think it is really important that we create this space, essentially the pot for funding to land.

and so I will be supporting this and I wanna thank you again, Council Member Foster for bringing this forward.

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Thank you.

SPEAKER_10

[1s]

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Colleagues, any further discussion at this time?

I see Council Member Rivera.

SPEAKER_04

[13s]

Thank you, Chair.

Just to say, it's my understanding that these are general fund dollars.

So when we recoup them as we very well should, they would just go to the general fund.

No?

SPEAKER_14

[4s]

Tom?

by this ordinance, they would go to this newly created fund.

SPEAKER_04

[9s]

No, no, I meant before this, like just in general, they're general fund dollars.

So they would just go to general fund to be used however we think they should be used.

SPEAKER_14

[0s]

Correct.

SPEAKER_04

[1s]

Yes.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you.

Councillor Sacco.

SPEAKER_22

[1m25s]

Thank you, Chair.

I like this amendment, this, excuse me, piece of legislation overall, certainly the intent behind it.

I am on the fence about it right now, just for the reasons, namely that Council Member Kettle pointed out a moment ago in terms of it arguably being in sync.

Well, the extent to which it's in sync with the previous budget investment that we passed, I'll say that.

to get me really over the fence, would really love to see if it's possible to amend the reporter instead of being SPD and having it tag the mayor's office to the extent that's possible.

I view that as a technical alignment.

tweak that's consistent with higher level corresponding changes in budget investments we've already made.

So I don't know, Chair, what's next at this point.

I don't know if that would be a friendly amendment to the sponsor or if that would be something we could revisit.

But I do think that is an important piece, tagging the appropriate reporter.

and that is the mayor's office on this.

SPEAKER_15

[3s]

Thank you.

Councilmember Foster, what's your feeling here?

SPEAKER_01

[50s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

I did want to state and thank you, Councilmember Kettle and Councilmember Saka for your mention of the previous budget action.

I believe you're both referencing the slide that Councilmember Rink put forward.

I see head nods.

Councilmember Rink and I were in close communication and communicated with central staff around her, Sly, and this piece of legislation.

And we, I think Councilman Marie gets fair to say, see them as a belt and suspenders approach.

And in previous conversations with central staff did ask if they were in conflict with each other or presented any opportunity for conflict, and we were advised that they do not.

I will ask that question.

I'm happy to ask that to the table, Chair, if that's okay, but we'll just say from my perspective, we don't have a conflict between these two budget items.

SPEAKER_15

[6s]

Thank you, Council Member Foster.

That was not the question.

The question is, are you open to verbal amendments on your legislation or not?

SPEAKER_01

[13s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

I was providing background about the work that we did prior to bringing this in front of committee to explain why I do not believe a verbal amendment is needed.

If Councilmember Saka would like to bring a verbal amendment, that's certainly his prerogative and I'd be happy to hear it.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Councilmember Saka, would you like to move forward?

SPEAKER_22

[2s]

Sure, I'll...

SPEAKER_15

[28s]

Hang tight.

Then we are going to have to suspend the rules to bring a verbal amendment.

So if there is no objection, the rules will be suspended.

Are there any objections?

Literally, if you don't like this, all you have to do is object.

So seeing as there are no objections, the rules are suspended.

Councilmember Saka, would you like to explain line by line what you would like to have changed?

SPEAKER_22

[13s]

Yeah, well, thank you, Chair.

So I move to amend the bill such that the reporting authority is not Seattle Police Department, but the Mayor's Office.

SPEAKER_15

[35s]

Okay.

and so this can go one of two ways.

I can say no objection or we can take it to a vote.

So I'm gonna say if there's no objection, the reporting authority will be changed from Seattle Police Department to the mayor's office.

If you object to that, you need to say that and then I will call for a vote.

So if there's no objection, the reporting body will be changed from Seattle Police Department to the mayor's office.

Are there any objections?

SPEAKER_01

[2s]

Not an objection, just a point of clarification, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

Okay.

SPEAKER_01

[13s]

Thank you.

So, I see where this is highlighted on the screen.

I just want to make sure we're just changing Section 5, where it says the Seattle Police Department, to the Mayor's Office, and that is the only change that Council Member Saka is suggesting at this time.

Is that correct?

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

That is correct.

Lish?

SPEAKER_25

[2s]

I would recommend Office of the Mayor.

SPEAKER_15

[1m04s]

Office of the Mayor.

Okay.

Thank you.

So if there's no objection, that change will be made.

This is, hearing no objection, the change is made.

I will share, Council Member Foster, you've just described a long stakeholder process.

I found out about this legislation on the dais.

This is a piece of legislation that I think needs to have, having your committee as being the reporting body seems a little out of step.

If I had had the chance to review this with you before you submitted it, I think we could have worked some of this out.

Is there a way that we either change this to the council at large or to reporting to both of our committees?

This is, This is financial policy in and of itself.

I understand you want the money to go to housing.

I support your desires to spend more money on housing because it's desperately needed.

You've seen that through and through.

We're just having some technical challenges here.

Do you have a preference?

SPEAKER_01

[4s]

Chair, I appreciate the question and the comment.

Can you restate what your question is, please?

SPEAKER_15

[7s]

The reporting body of the Housing Arts and Civil Rights Committee is not, in my opinion, the appropriate reporting body as this is financial policy.

SPEAKER_01

[1m01s]

Thank you.

I think what my question would be, if this is going into the Finance Committee, which I believe is what I hear is your intent to amend this to reflect, my question to you, Chair, would be how you see the ongoing nexus and whether or not there are other ways we may want to look at updating this legislation to clarify what is my intent, which is after the resources come back to the city, that they are dedicated to housing.

So from my perspective, Chair, what I'm looking at with this and my proposal here is not so much about attempting to subvert anybody's committee, but it is about attempting to express my intent that when these dollars are recaptured, these dollars are committed to housing.

Chair, I'd be happy to work with you if there is a way to find that alignment.

I do want to just state, you know, I did submit this piece of legislation by the required deadline that was provided to me through central staff.

Thank you, Chair.

SPEAKER_15

[22s]

Thank you.

Do you have an objection to changing the reporting body to the Finance Committee?

Because, and like said another way, is I've been trying to find as much money to go to housing as possible.

There's no separation from us there.

It's that this is financial policy.

SPEAKER_01

[14s]

Thank you, Chair.

My question to you is if the reporting goes to the Finance Committee, will the commitment for the overpayment recapture funds remain dedicated as they are in Section 2, which is to provide resources for multifamily housing and affordable homeownership?

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

That is enumerated in Section 2.

SPEAKER_01

[15s]

Thank you, Chair.

And as we're doing verbal amendments, I'm just seeking to understand the scope of those verbal amendments.

So what I take your comment to mean is that you would only be changing Section 5, and you would be changing the Housing, Arts, and Civil Rights Committee to the Finance Committee.

Is that correct, Chair?

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

That's correct.

SPEAKER_01

[2s]

Thank you, Chair.

I'm happy to accept that change.

SPEAKER_15

[23s]

Thank you.

If there's no objections, the rules will be suspended to add a verbal amendment.

Hearing no objection, the rules are suspended.

I am proposing to change the Housing Arts and Civil Rights Committee to the Finance Committee or Successor Committee.

Are there any objections?

Hearing no objections, the change is made.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Excuse me, sorry, are you waiting for a vote?

SPEAKER_15

[6s]

No, thanks, Jody.

Gosh, darn it, you're good.

No, we were just letting central staff catch up.

SPEAKER_13

[2s]

Okay, just double checking, thank you, sorry.

SPEAKER_15

[20s]

We're so close, we've only got one vote away.

Just to recap, there were two verbal amendments, one that the reporting body is the office of the mayor, and the second is that the report shall go to the finance or successor committee thereof.

Councilmember Foster, I'm giving you the last word, and then I'm gonna call the vote.

SPEAKER_01

[21s]

Thank you so much, Chair.

I appreciate the alignment that I hear from colleagues that as these funds are recaptured, these funds will be recommitted to housing.

I appreciate where we have alignment there, and thank you so much, colleagues, for your engagement in this really important issue as we seek to restore and recapture these funds.

I ask for your support.

SPEAKER_15

[5s]

Thank you.

Will the clerk please call the roll on Council Bill 121336?

as amended.

SPEAKER_13

[4s]

It's the whole thing.

It's Council Member Foster.

SPEAKER_15

[1s]

Hold up, hold up.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Oh, okay.

Sorry, yep.

SPEAKER_15

[0s]

The whole thing.

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

Okay.

SPEAKER_15

[18s]

We're voting on the Council Bill 121336 as amended in the two ways as shown on the screen, changing the Office of the Mayor and the Finance Committee.

Thank you.

I see- Comment, I'm sorry.

Council President and then Council Member Rivera.

SPEAKER_18

[10s]

Thank you, Chair, and I wanna thank Councilmember Foster for bringing this.

I'm not trying to extend this longer.

I know we've been here for 10 and a half hours, y'all, so.

SPEAKER_10

[1s]

Nick Jagger.

SPEAKER_18

[44s]

Yeah, sorry, thank you.

I really appreciate Councilmember Foster for bringing this.

Today, I won't be supporting this, not because I don't want, for me, I appreciate the police overpayment recapture fund, but I believe it should just go to the general fund where then it can be decided where it goes.

No knock, I know your conviction for housing, and I think we all do, but I think it should go back into the general fund where then we can decide as a council or the mayor's office flexibility for where those funds should go.

So thank you, Councilmember Foster.

Thank you.

Council Member Rivera?

SPEAKER_04

[24s]

Thank you, Chair, and thank you, Council President, because that's exactly what I was going to say.

So thank you for bringing that up.

I, again, appreciate you, Council Member Foster, but I won't be supporting this today because it should go to general fund where then we can make a determination on how, you know, best to allocate it in line with our budget process, I assume, next year at this point.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[2s]

Thank you.

Council Member Foster, any last words?

SPEAKER_04

[1s]

No, thank you colleagues.

SPEAKER_15

[4s]

Thank you.

Will the clerk please call the roll on Council Bill 121336 as amended.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Foster?

SPEAKER_99

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[9s]

Council President Hollingsworth?

No.

Council Member Juarez?

No.

Council Member Kettle?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

No.

SPEAKER_13

[1s]

Council Member Lynn?

SPEAKER_07

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_13

[18s]

Council Member Rink?

Yes.

Council Member Rivera?

Council Member Saka?

Chair Strauss?

Abstain.

Four in favor, four opposed, one abstention.

SPEAKER_15

[24s]

Thank you.

The committee does not recommend approval, but this bill will still be sent to the November 20th full city council meeting.

Colleagues, that does bring us to the end of our agenda today.

I want to, before we take off, I want to check in with central staff.

Can you just remind us of the limited action that we have to take on Thursday and then we will reconvene Thursday morning at 9.30.

SPEAKER_25

[31s]

So over the next couple days, Tom in particular is going to be working hard to make sure that the budget that we discussed over the last two work days is in balance.

We'll be bringing any technical amendments needed to ensure that are correctly drafted and are in balance and we'll be bringing that back for a final committee vote Thursday morning.

SPEAKER_15

[17s]

Thank you.

So said another way is we cannot have any more amendments unless they are technical in nature, correcting any errors that we did not catch at this time.

Is that correct?

Correct.

And we only have four bills to vote on, on three bills.

SPEAKER_14

[1s]

We're down to three.

SPEAKER_15

[34s]

Down to three.

And the remainder of the bills that have been sent to the full city council, we will still have to vote on.

I was just asked, there were two bills today that did not.

meet the approval voting.

Council rules does say that committee work are recommendations to the full city council.

And so as per council rules, whether a bill succeeds or fails, it will still move to the full city council no matter what.

And so that's what's going on here.

Colleagues, any final questions or comments?

Council member Rivera.

SPEAKER_04

[6s]

Thank you.

Just to clarify, which bills then are moving forward for individual vote again?

SPEAKER_15

[12s]

but I believe these all will and we will...

All of the legislative ones.

And so in our quality control over these next two days, on Thursday we will present Friday's agenda in a very clear manner.

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Thank you.

SPEAKER_15

[26s]

Glish, anything else?

Colleagues, thank you for the marathon session.

I appreciate your attention to these matters.

This does conclude the Monday, November 16, 2026 Select Budget Committee.

We will meet again Thursday, November 19 at 9.30 a.m.

Thank you for attending.

If there is no further business, we will be adjourned.

Seeing no further business, we are adjourned.

Thank you.

SPEAKER_21

[1s]

Thank you, Chair.