All right, I've got a quorum here.
That clock says 429 though, so I'll wait one second.
All right, this is President Taup and I'm now calling the board's special meeting to order at 4.30 p.m.
Please note that this meeting is being recorded.
We would like to acknowledge that we are on ancestral lands and in the traditional territories of the Puget Sound Coast Salish people.
For the record, I'll call the roll, Vice President Briggs.
Here.
Director Lavallee.
Here.
Director Mizrahi?
Present.
Director Rankin?
Here.
Director Smith?
Here.
Director Song?
Here.
Director Mangelson?
Here.
Director Founce?
Here.
And this is President Taub.
Before we move to today's agenda I just have an exciting announcement I think I forwarded on to board directors I am pleased to announce that this board has been chosen as a board of distinction by the Washington State School Board Directors Association this is an honor and we're proud of the work we've done this past year we will be honored at WASDA so for those of you headed to the WASDA conference in a few weeks we will be announced as a board of distinction
Do we get a trophy or medals?
We get certificates and we're gonna hang it on the wall in the board office and our photo together, so dress your best.
All right, so there are essentially two items on today's agenda.
We have two informal study sessions, one focused on special populations and the other on educational technology.
I'm gonna try to say let's try to do an hour and a half for each or if we get towards an hour and a half on the first one I'm gonna try to push us along so we can kind of make sure we're good to go but with that I'm gonna turn it over to Superintendent Schuldner for the first presentation
Wonderful.
Well, good afternoon, everyone.
It is always a pleasure to see you.
As a reminder for all, we are really trying to do these ISS's, these informational study sessions, which I think are incredibly important for a school district.
Not only do you want to be very public about the work that you're doing, but you also want to engage the board in the direction that they want to see us go with as much information, as much conversation.
And really I'm thrilled that this week we're going to be able to do two very, very important ISS's.
So the first one today is about our special programs.
We really have so many great things that are happening in this district.
and I'm really honored to be able to have these three wonderful colleagues here with me representing ML, HC, Special Education, who really have done tremendous work in moving our district forward and moving our students forward.
So with that, I think we can probably move through.
You did a land acknowledgement, so...
I think we don't have to do another one but really I'm going to turn this over to Devin Gurley who's really been spearheading this incredible change in our special education program she has some wonderful and exciting news that I'm sure she will get to as well although I don't know if we get a certificate and pictures being taken but we do have some wonderful news about what special education is doing and with that I want to turn it over to Devin
Good afternoon, good evening everybody.
Here with, thank you, with Paul Montgomery, Director of Highly Capable, and Michelle Oda, Director of Multilingual Services.
And so the way that we're gonna be approaching this presentation today is thinking kind of like in a cyclical way.
and one of the things that we know about our students is that they don't all show up with one particular identity, right?
They come as full people who have multiple ways that they have needs and strengths within the district.
And so we can't treat services as separate and distinct things to be treated and supported differently.
We really have to think about it as inclusive and collaborative services.
and so that's what you're gonna see in terms of our approach that we're gonna talk about seeing the whole student, our priority on making sure that all students have access to high quality core instruction and the supports they need, that that instruction is high quality and very strong that leads to improved student outcomes with the specialized supports that they need and that we're constantly tracking and monitoring the results and how students are doing to inform our next steps in how we provide those supports to students.
And so, you know, within the district's framework, we have one common vision that all students receive high-quality, world-class education and graduate prepared for college, career and community.
And within that, our responsibility as a services team is to ensure that they have access to instruction, engage in the learning and demonstrate growth and experience and belonging.
and the reason that this is important because we know that access alone doesn't ensure appropriate inclusive instruction that we need to make sure that everybody has access, all of our students have access to rigorous learning and that they're growing and able to meet their goals and achieve everything that they want to do in college and career and life.
and so in addition to providing access which as a district for all three of our teams we have increased access to high quality core instruction in the general education setting with supports.
Those have been improvements that we've been making significant strides in over the last five years and partnering together with curriculum assessment and instruction and our other partners to make sure that the instruction that's happening in the general education setting does support all learners because we know that student variability is just a natural part of what we support in our classrooms and that we are constantly looking at results to make sure that we are progress monitoring, that we are building systems of improvement to constantly make sure that those services are effective and that we are meeting students' goals for growth and achievement.
So the first section we're gonna talk, we're gonna do a little bit of a deep dive in the number of students we serve.
So for special education, we currently have 8,906 students receiving special education services, which is 16.9% of our population.
This number might be a little bit higher than what you typically see, but those numbers often, the smaller numbers often include students who are in our K-12 pathways.
They're not inclusive of students who might receive private school services, students who are in our preschool programs or in our transition programs, and students who might receive therapy only, such as speech and language therapy, because they're not included, they receive services outside of our primary pathways.
and so for our multilingual services, we have 7,155 students currently receiving those services.
Thank you.
And that's about 14.3% of our student enrollment.
And then for highly capable, that number is 6,361, which is 12.6%.
We also know that students don't just show up to school needing one type of service or support.
So we wanted to show the overlay here of students who qualify in more than one or potentially all three areas.
And this is why it's so important for us to have coordinated supports for students because they have overlapping strengths, identities, and learning needs.
And they don't experience their needs in one program that need to be addressed separately.
We need to have a collaborative approach.
And so you can see that students who are dually eligible for special education and multilingual services, we have over 1400. Multilingual and highly capable, we have 81 students.
And special ed and highly capable, we have 470 students receiving both.
And students who receive all three, we actually have 11 students who receive all three services.
So it's just an interesting data point.
And then when we break it down for each of our departments, we'll start with the special education services.
You can see here the different pathway breakdowns and the number of students we serve through these particular pathways.
and we know that student needs don't fit neatly into pathways but these are ratios for how we provide that support in to students but this is really how the breakdown is of our pathways for how we're serving students and students can access general education to the maximum extent possible across all of these pathways as well.
All right, and the highly capable students.
As Devin said earlier, highly capable, we currently have 6,361 students receiving services.
Now you see a 15% here, whereas on the previous slide there was a different number.
15% is of SPS students enrolled grades 2 through 12. At this point in time, our highly capable identified students are only grades 2 through 12. Just some large 30,000, 60,000 foot numbers here are service delivery settings so this is where students are at this point.
We have a little over 3,000 students that are at HC specific sites and that's elementary, middle school and high school combined.
So about 55% of our students and families have chosen to be in an HC specific site.
Over 2,000 have chosen to stay at their neighborhood school and then we have about 4% or 260 have chosen to be at option schools.
And then again a high level look of how do these break out in terms of grade levels for the system.
Remember elementary is just grades two through five.
So we have 2,311 and that's 15% of our total population in grades two through five.
Middle school is interesting because we have smaller numbers, but we have a higher concentration of HC students at that level, 16.5% of all middle schoolers.
And this includes our middle schoolers in our option schools as well.
So that count is about 16.5%.
And then our high school students, 9 through 12, that's about 14% of our total high school students receive and are identified as highly capable.
Good afternoon, I'm Michelle Oda and I serve as the director for the multilingual department.
For our multilingual numbers, I wanted to show you this slide for the wide range of language proficiencies that we have within the multilingual population.
so you see that newcomers this is data that we pulled as of October 1 and so we had 66 newcomers and for us newcomers are defined as one year in the US and scoring a one in every language domain on the WIDA screener which is the state assessment for English language proficiency and then the next is our experienced MLs or sometimes referred to as our long-term MLs.
These are our students and we have about 2,138 students who have been receiving ML supports for more than five years.
and then our last category is classification would be our multilingual students who are less than five years who are building their language acquisition and there's about 4,951 students and I think that this is just to demonstrate for you the wide range of language proficiency and the need for differentiation in our schools.
There it goes, okay.
So for all three of our services, we have a set of common priorities that are set within a common foundation.
So across our three departments, we all have state and or federal guidelines.
Multilingual and special education have federal and state.
and highly capable has state guidelines that we have some compliance requirements that we have to meet for federal and state regulations.
But we also know that that's the floor, right?
That is the minimum expectation.
But what we want for our students and for our services is a much higher and supportive level than compliance.
But that is our floor.
and then core instruction is foundational because what we know is that when students have access to high quality core instruction rather than being removed for separate instruction, they achieve higher growth, they have higher rates of on-time graduation, and they have higher rates of post high school success in the secondary setting, whether that's career, vocational, or college programs.
And so that's why making sure that students have access to that core instruction, especially from the earliest years, is so foundational because the more that you separate students for separate instruction in the early years, the wider the gap grows.
and so we've been working really intentionally with our curriculum assessment and instruction team to make sure that our tier one or our supportive core is high quality and it's accessible to as many students as possible because we also know, as we mentioned, that access creates those opportunities.
For our common priorities, as mentioned before, every student needs to have access to that rigorous core instruction and for most students this means that rigorous core instruction happens and can happen in the general education setting.
We do know that for some students that rigorous core instruction happens in a separate setting as determined by their teams and their services and we also want to make sure that when that is a team decision for a student that those services and supports are high quality evidence-based instruction and that we're constantly reviewing and making sure that our instruction is gap closing and that our ultimate goal for students is to the extent possible if we can help them achieve that growth to be able to move into that high quality core instruction, that is our ultimate goal for all of our students.
but we also know that student variability is an expected part of every classroom and so those are some of the intentional designs through multi-tiered systems of support and universal design for learning that we've been co-designing and supporting alongside our CAI partners and making sure that our educators are equipped with the strategies ongoing support and data to be able to make educational decisions for students in their class We talk a lot about our top line measures and our goals of top five and five and the good news is that while for special education and multilingual we're already the top five and five in a lot of our areas but that doesn't mean we stop there because when we disaggregate our top line measures we see that there's still a lot of growth to be made for our multilingual students and our students receiving special education services in each of our areas.
And so what you can see here is that disaggregated percentile on our SBA scores and our graduation rate.
And so what we do is, based on having this disaggregated data, we target strategies and we do targeted and intentional planning to make sure that we are focused on not just gap closing for this one particular measure, which is the SBA, but that we're looking at constant progress monitoring and support to ensure that the services that we're providing and the instruction that students are receiving every day are actually helping students achieve.
So we know that this is work that we have to continue doing because while our overall rate might be top five, the number of students who are passing and graduating on time needs a lot of work for our two particular groups of students.
And just to be clear, those numbers are our goals, not our current standing.
So we're hoping to get to 67.5 and 66, and certainly it would be 94% graduation.
But what I really want to highlight, and I very much appreciate Devin saying this, even though we might be doing well comparatively to other school districts, we do know that we can do so much better for our children, especially our multilingual and special education children.
So we really are thinking about how do we move all these populations forward so that we can continue to hit are the goals that we want.
One thing to note, of course, is that, you know, if we are to get these higher numbers, we would have to move everybody up.
And so I know there's been some question about like, well, if we're already top five and five for, let's say, you know, special education or multilingual, you know, doesn't it mean like, well, you're not going to move them?
Well, of course we are because we're going to be trying to get our entire district to be going up I mean in math it's like 15 points so everybody's gonna rise up and so I just want to make sure that people watching at home really understand that I'm so thrilled that the team here at this dais is being very clear about the data about where we are and what we need to do because we very much believe that this is something we need to move on because we need to serve our children better and I will say this highlights something that Devin also talked about is it's possible that some of the models we have been using historically here like pullout actually are causing some of these concerns because if you're not in the tier one instruction for more hours of the day it is very hard to actually get students to grade level but having them make sure that they're in tier one instruction but getting supported and then not losing the classroom instruction but possibly getting other supports at other times and within the classroom that has been shown to really be able to get kids to proficiency.
So thank you so much for sharing this data.
Okay, so I've talked about all of these kind of separately in other slides just in terms of how we as leaders of our departments and our teams really drive action through continuous data review.
So looking at our top line outcomes and measures, disaggregating the data, not resorting to solution-itis where we come up with a solution before we really understand what the issue is that we're trying to solve so that we're really intentional.
And then based on that decision and those pulling together that data that we act and that we monitor.
We're really good at being able to look at data.
Being able to make decisions and move is something that I think that we can continue to grow in and that is something that we are working together as a collaborative team on.
So that not only can we make that growth, but we can also sustain that growth.
and just to kind of circle back to what this looks like for students who receive services and supports through special education, multilingual and highly capable services.
Rigorous instruction, it has one of the highest effect sizes for student achievement delivered by a high quality core instruction teacher.
that the services are intentionally matched to students' strengths and needs, and that we work through a capacity building framework.
So what that means in terms of capacity building is that our professional learning, our coaching, our family partnerships, and the way that we review and coach people how to review data is building everybody's capacity to do this work better to serve our students across the system.
Yeah, and what I want to add here is, you know, oftentimes people will say to me, to all of us, okay, Ben, we get that you've got these goals and we want to be the best urban school district in America.
We get that.
Well, how are you going to do that?
You know, people say pretty things all the time.
You know, why should we believe that you're actually going to make you know, good on these promises.
And what Devin is sharing in some respects is the roadmap, right?
So this is not rocket science.
It's difficult, but it is very clear.
How do you actually get kids to learn is you focus on core instruction with rigorous instruction for every student, for services matched to the needs of the child, and capacity building.
So this slide, almost more than any other, is really the roadmap that we are focusing on over and over and over again.
And that's why, again, when we talk about curriculum, we talk about time on task, when we talk about what children are going to do during the day, so much of this is about how do you do that.
Now, there's all sorts of other things.
There's SEL, and then there's you know times where kids need emotional and you know social supports all of that but if we don't make sure that all of our children and that's ML that's HC that's special ed that's every single child is not getting that strong and core instruction we're not serving them well and that's why this slide in some respects is probably the most important one and again when anybody asks well how are you going to do it it's this
and we're gonna give you some examples of how we've used this process to improve results in a few slides.
Okay, I feel like I'm repeating some of the same things.
Superintendent Schulzner kind of stole my thunder.
He said a lot of the same things and so did Devin.
I do want to take a moment to just recognize our ML team.
They're an exceptional group of educators and support staff that I get to work alongside and I'm just so honored to work with them and I also want to give a shout out to the HC team and special education team because they've been amazing collaborators with our department in looking at some systems and some supports for our students so I just wanted to recognize them.
This slide here kind of goes hand in hand with the slide that I showed you before around the wide range of language proficiencies that we have across the ML populations.
I wanted to show this to show you the wide range in number as well.
So you look at the high school, like Franklin is at about 348 ML students and then you have a school like Nova at three.
You can go down and, you know, elementary, Bailey Gatzert has, you know, close to 150 ML students and then you have a school like Decatur at one.
And this just speaks to our department around the need for flexible staffing and flexible support so that we can really give students and schools what they need because of that wide range of not only language proficiencies, but just also in the mere numbers.
And not that we need to bring up union negotiations, but I want to just highlight and really thank SEA for their understanding of the reality that we see.
This slide really exemplifies the disparate impact of where our students are.
but if we have a funding formula and a staffing formula that sort of treats schools kind of the same, you can imagine the disparate impact here.
Ballygatzert, 151. Decatur, 1. Broadville Thompson, 169. Licton Springs, 3. We want to make sure that we, and really Michelle and her awesome team is able to serve the children the best of their ability and not be hamstrung by a kind of antiquated funding slash staffing model that doesn't take into account where our children actually are.
So I'm really glad this slide is up here.
Please really understand that these are not just examples we picked to prove the rule.
These are the examples that are the rule.
So thank you.
Okay, and the next slide is probably my favorite slide.
I think that it doesn't get a lot of media attention, but this is our 24-25 exited ML SBA data for all tested grades.
So I'm really proud of our students and I'm just very grateful to our dedicated educators because I think this shows that we have students who enter into our system who need language supports and through rigorous instruction and access to rigorous instruction that they're able to exit receiving supports and this shows that they're outperforming in ELA and math with not only district but state averages.
so it's just one of my favorite because I think a lot of time gets spent on talking about current ML students and not looking at once students receive supports, what is their trajectory and I think this just is a huge testament for their hard work and the hard work of our educators.
The next slide.
There's a quote in the upper right corner and this is a quote from Cummings and Hakuda.
It's referencing some long-standing research around how much time it takes for students to acquire not just social language but academic language.
the research shows that for social language it takes about one to three years to acquire social language and that's with access to core instruction and having strong language supports and that's for academic language it takes approximately five to seven years and I think that this data where Seattle's in the blue and the state's in the yellow and what I like about this is just that it shows that it aligns with what the research.
You start to see at fourth grade through eighth grade that there are the exit rates are spiking at that point.
The other thing, though, I think that this chart shows that my team have been curious about and we reflect on and we're asking ourselves some questions is what's happening K5?
Because if you notice, Seattle is lower than the state average on an exit rates.
and I think Superintendent Schulner alluded to it and said it more eloquently than I'm gonna be able to say it, but we are wondering, like, what is happening?
What is causing the delay in the exit rates for our K-5?
Could it be that they are not getting access to core instruction?
Could it be that maybe they're being identified for intervention when it's language acquisition support?
concern.
So we as a team spend a lot of time thinking about what could be the reason and I think that the OSPI strategic plan for the state around ML has us moving in the right direction of looking at strengthening instructional practice, supporting educators, making sure that we have family and student engagement.
and then also, what's my fourth one?
I always forget.
Promoting positive mindsets, asset-based mindsets around what our students can actually do and being okay with that productive struggle.
Sometimes I think that when we see students sitting in a classroom and it appears that they're doing nothing or it's all going over their head, there is a lot processing and sometimes it's okay to have our students have some productive struggles.
So that's this slide.
Yeah, I want to add to what Michelle said, just to put some of these numbers in perspective.
So we're doing well.
I really want to be very clear.
We're doing well in the data that Michelle showed about how the kids that exit are actually doing extraordinarily well.
But I do think that the K-5 numbers do speak to a question of why are our children not exiting?
at the same rate as the rest of the state for the younger grades.
And I do think that some of that has to do with the way that we're doing core instruction, as Michelle said.
But I do want Michelle and the team to take a nice bow also that in our middle schools, you can see the kids are actually exiting at a pretty significant rate.
And I think a lot of that might start to be about how we then departmentalize education within junior high school and middle schools and things like that.
I think and I hope is as we start to really focus on that core instructional model my hope is that in two years we present this data and you'll see the blue being much higher than the yellow in K5 or not much one percentage points actually a big deal so hopefully K5 we should be above yellow in all of those and all of those bars.
So I really want to thank Michelle's team for really the work that's happening in terms of the kids that are exiting.
We know they're doing very, very well, and we hope that by really focusing on that core instruction early on, and I really do, not that I need to give a plug, The new K-5 English curriculum, I think, will be a huge piece to this.
Because though you might be hearing that it is hard and is difficult, that means that it is rigorous, and it means that it is on grade level, and it means that it's pushing kids.
And what we're seeing already three months in, the children really are able to do it.
So I look forward to seeing these numbers in a couple of years.
Thank you, Michelle.
but I understand what the exit rate is.
So this is, so for fourth grade it's 24.3% of our fourth grade ML students exit out of ML at the end of fourth grade.
Okay, thank you.
And I do wanna add that we just, I think that sometimes when we are trying to create systems and structures I just want to put out there that we want to make sure that we're not creating some unintentional barriers for our students.
Clarifying question, just on the slide.
Clarifying question, then we're going to go ahead.
Do we disaggregate for kids who are new to the country who move here in fourth grade?
How does that impact the numbers?
I don't know if we disaggregate it to that scale, but I could take it back and ask.
What we could do, and not to give Michelle more work, but we could certainly look at incoming WIDA scores.
So like all students that let's say start at a one, we could look at incoming new students to the country.
Those are all things that we can run an analysis on.
Well, I would be curious if that is impacting us being lower than the state, if more people are just moving to Seattle in fourth grade or whatever.
Yeah, no, that's absolutely a possibility.
Okay, now we're gonna transition to talk about our special education services and some bright spots we have here.
So I know some of us have been around this district for a while, a decade or more, maybe two, and our special education services are doing really well right now, but that's not always been the case.
So back in 2014, we were at what is called a Determination Level 4, which is an IDEA, or Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, which is our federal Oh, thank you.
People at home can't hear me, got it, okay.
That level four is the lowest rating you can get.
And so that's where we were in 2014. And back then, and I actually happened to be here at that time, we had state and federal oversight to the point that they actually had offices in the Stanford Center to help us with our improvement efforts.
and so over time we have made those improvements and then for the first time in 2425 we achieved determination level one which is that federal designation that OSPI issues out to every district.
So it was the first time we ever received that determination level.
Two days ago we just got notice that we received annual determination level one again.
So we've not just reached that level but we've sustained it.
And one of the things that is a significant kind of portion of that is our significant disproportionality.
And so what significant disproportionality is, or some people have heard the term CCEIS, is when you have a risk ratio of three times or greater for any particular subgroup who receives special education services for one of about 12 indicators.
It might be disciplinary removals from school.
might be over-identification, it might be over-restriction into special education settings.
So in 2020, 21 school year, we were identified for having six areas of significant disproportionality.
And so what happens is our federal funding, 15% of that gets set aside and we have to actually do activities to work towards elimination of that.
So what we did is we took, again, not going to solution-itis, but we actually took a dive in and we looked at a lot of root cause analysis.
And we made some action plans.
We put those action plans into place.
Those action plans were built alongside our educators, our school leaders, and most importantly, our families and our community.
because some of our areas of significant disproportionality were our black students with IEPs who had an intellectual disability category, our native and Latino students who were identified for specific learning disability when, as Michelle said, a lot of it could be language acquisition, it could be cultural pieces that are being misinterpreted by special education teams in terms of evaluation.
So over the course of about two, three years, we were eliminated.
We went from six areas down to four to two.
And then in the 23-24 school year, we had zero significant disproportionality.
And we also recently got our notification that we're a third year in a row of having zero significant disproportionality.
which is a really big deal because in a district our size and in our state, this isn't the most common thing that you see for states.
And if we can't get this turned around, this is where our annual determination level can often go backwards into two or three.
And that happened before we reached determination level one in one of our preschool indicators.
And you can see that we also had a targeted approach on that row below that looked at our preschool evaluation compliance ratings and so we were we were at a 53 percent on time preschool evaluation compliance rating and we've gotten that up to this year to 99 percent and so a lot of that has been partnering with families making sure that we have responsive evaluation teams that we're partnering with our community agencies that provide preschool services that are not part of the Seattle preschool program and so a lot of these gains have happened I want to really shout out not just my team my special education team here but the families who have worked in partnership with us for years to help us build these programs and these systems, that our educators are doing this work, our school leaders are doing this work, and it really takes that coordinated effort of every single person who shows up to support students with IEPs every day, but also really thinking about our intentional partnerships with multilingual, our intentional partnerships with highly capable, to ensure that we are designing something not just for special education, but that works for students who have intersectional identities and works for families.
And so as a result of these efforts, we have put in place guidelines and supports and handbooks that actually OSPI is considering adopting as some of our statewide practices for our evaluation guides.
Just wanted to shout out everybody who supports special education in the district for this incredible achievement.
So this is a little bit redundant, but this is some of the progress we've made over time.
So you can see our determination levels, our significant disproportionality, and our preschool evaluations have made significant growth, as well as our overdue timelines.
We reduced that by 82% over the course of two years in terms of expired IEPs and evaluations.
and so that 82% improvement is a pretty significant reason that we were able to achieve some of these other things.
And so what made that progress last, how we've been able to sustain it, is having a really clear problem definition and then making sure that our resources are aligned to support the measures and the outcomes that we want to get.
So that meant not just shifting how we fund certain positions, but actually changing what positions we have, making sure that all of our funding and financing and staffing supports are aligned to achieve our goals.
making sure that we have shared measures that everybody understands that we're reviewing and making adjustments as necessary regularly and that we've built in accountability and sustainability plans as part of this whole improvement process to be able to achieve and sustain these results.
I just really want to take another moment to congratulate Devin and the team.
This is a very, very big deal.
The fact that we went from a level four determination to level one, the fact that we have zero significant disproportionality, this is a big deal for the largest school district in this state.
there are school districts much, much smaller than us with many less cases with not nearly this kind of level.
So Devon, congratulations to you and your team.
But I also want to highlight those four points.
Those are the four points we use for everything.
clear problem definition, shared measures, regular review, accountability, and sustainability.
That's everything we're doing in this district so that we can continue to move the needle forward for our children.
So to the board, I just really want you to know the incredible work that was done by this community, especially Devin and the team, to getting to these numbers.
They're really, really impressive.
So congratulations.
Thank you.
And something really quick.
Very quickly.
Just related specifically to that, because I have been here for this journey, that the deep importance of the board's role also in daylighting the information and in asking and insisting and centering how are students with disabilities doing, where is this disproportionality, and using it for conversations with the superintendent.
and so like Devon and team have done, have truly done an incredible job and what the board focuses on is what the district will do and so when we focus on the needs of our kids, it changes everything.
All right, thank you.
I feel like I've had a lot of time with the board since taking this position in 2025. I'm trying to keep it high level and really think about what did we prioritize in the past year in highly capable services.
So very specifically, you know, thinking about systems, pieces that will strengthen our entire system, not just highly capable students, you know, and thinking about the things that needed some attention that, you know, a lot of things just didn't make sense even when I came into the position.
Specifically, our new to Seattle process.
We established pretty quickly a process to identify newly enrolled students for HC services and that actually had two different points to it.
We actually ran a brand new, you live in the city of Seattle, you're attending a private school and you want to enter Seattle Public Schools.
Prior to last year, you needed to enroll.
You needed to go to your local school.
You needed to wait for universal screening.
And then a year later, you might qualify for highly capable services.
So we developed a process.
And we ended up identifying, I have the numbers right here.
We identified actually a total of 16 students.
It wasn't a large number.
But we did have over 100 students participate in this process.
We used the NAGLERI, which the board just recently approved.
We used portfolios.
We looked at academic data similar to our students.
We had a total of 16 students from private schools here in Seattle come and join us at Seattle Public Schools.
And interestingly enough, the majority of them were at the elementary and the middle school level.
We also at the same time looked closely at our students who were living in Seattle and were new to the city of Seattle.
So this includes families that moved from out of state.
This could include families who were in our state, just moved into our district.
So we created a new process to really look at those students who were receiving gifted or highly capable services in their previous district.
and we were able to identify many of those students for highly capable services upon enrollment here in Seattle Public Schools.
And then something that I do think some of you are familiar with, previously if you left Seattle Public Schools, if you were in our school district, previously you were designated highly capable and for whatever reason you chose to go to a private school.
or to a different district.
When you came back to Seattle Public Schools, again, you had to wait a year in order to reapply for highly capable services.
And we developed a process so that upon re-entry, if Seattle Public Schools had identified that student as highly capable, we reinstated that.
And that also brought back, in our belief, our families to Seattle Public Schools.
So that's approximately 72 students.
The majority of them are at the middle school and elementary level.
And then one thing that I think folks aren't always clear about, our department also handles the early entrance to kindergarten process.
So we refined that process, we streamlined it.
That resulted in an additional 26 students in our kindergarten district-wide.
That's not associated with highly capable identification, but it was a recognition that we do have families whose children might have a September 1st birthday or September 15th birthday, and we wanted to make that process pretty smooth if they wanted to enroll in Seattle Public Schools, and their birthdays were after that August 31st timeline.
Identification processes and practices have been on everybody's mind.
I think, you know, historically they've been on the mind since the 1960s.
They've got a lot of attention since 2020. One of the things we did last year was we took a really deep look at the tools we were using and the tools we were not using.
And you heard me talk, I think just a month ago, about the DIBELS.
We were using the DIBELS previously to last year for identification, which actually was excluding many of our twice exceptional students.
It was a misuse of the DIBELS, so we removed that.
We pulled in something called WA Kids, which is used in the kindergarten assessment realm.
We weren't using that previously, but that allowed us to get some pretty good information on our first graders and adding it to what we were already using, which was the map.
Along with identification practices, we also started to do something and lean into something called local norming.
And so I won't go into all the details, but we were able to take a really close look at multilingual qualified kids, MKV qualified kids, free and reduced lunch qualified kids, and take a close look at those students and then think about their MAP scores in terms of are they outliers within that population?
And that local norming has some promising results that I'm going to show you in a minute.
Some other pieces that we used, we really leaned into the lack of representation from our special education students at a young age.
Specifically last year we pulled in special education evaluations and took a deep dive to see what did those special education evaluations tell us about a student that maybe weren't showing up on the map specifically.
And we have some promising data with that.
expanded highly capable access.
As the board knows, you are deeply involved.
We have opened two new elementary sites.
We have identified, starting last year, students in a single domain, so students could qualify in either reading or math.
previously students had to qualify in both domains to get a highly capable designation and then I think one of the things that I'm most excited about and it is we are currently in a really inquiry piece with this is expanding service for students who have special education services and highly capable services very specifically our extended resource identified students previously they were not permitted to enroll in certain HC sites.
And so for the first time this year, we, in working with Devon, we were able to break down that barrier.
So families had choice, that their coded disability service model didn't prevent them from receiving the same level of HC service that other students had.
Our advanced math program, I'm gonna move on.
somewhat quickly, but I think two years ago, you all were very supportive of us developing a summer math program that helps students who are at the fifth grade level accelerate into an advanced math pathway that was equivalent to our HC school pathway in middle school.
Last year we expanded that actually to be on students with an HC flag.
So any student who was at a certain high achieving mark was invited to attend a flexible online summer math program where they had a condensed or a fast paced sixth grade math program and they were able then to enroll in math 7-8 in sixth grade which is a path to algebra in seventh grade.
At this point we have over 400 sixth graders in our city across a ton of schools who are now in math 7-8 specifically because of that work with that summer acceleration program between fifth and sixth.
At the same time, we have heard from our families that they are appreciative of this model because it's another choice.
You can choose to stay in your neighborhood school, you can choose to go to an HC cohort where you jump ahead, and you can still get onto that math acceleration pathway starting in middle school at this point.
and then right around this time last year we had seven family engagement sessions all over the city, over a thousand people, what's going well, what's broken, what are your ideas for fixing it and some of those ideas very specifically we heard about the extended resource and the barriers for that.
We heard about the need for a gifted screener or a non-verbal screener or something other than the map.
And so there were some things we were able to put in place that we heard from our families last year.
There's other things we heard from our families that we are still, it's going to take some time, but we're pretty proud of how we were able to be responsive pretty quickly to some key areas.
And then just to highlight when we talk about identification, I just wanted to give you a little glimpse here.
So some of the new tools we use is a combination of using the WIDA scores.
We use a statistic called fast language acquisition.
Using local norming, we were able to increase representation and we see it pretty powerfully.
in grades one and four from last year, where that's where we did our universal screening.
So we looked at every single student in grades one and grades four.
And with that, of all the multilingual learners in grades one and four, five percent of them qualified for a highly capable identification, which is about three percent higher than the previous year.
Twice exceptional students are students with IEPs.
Again, between grades one and four, looking at all the students with IEPs, we were able to increase that representation to 5.4% of all the special education students.
Our MKV students, we were able to increase that representation.
We still have a ways to go with all three of these groups.
We did not see significant improvements with our free and reduced lunch population, and that's something that we're diving into to better understand what additional layers can we put into our identification processes.
but we know that some of the things we tried last year are resulting in us seeing students in a different light.
We're seeing some populations of students who are having access to highly capable services who maybe didn't show up in this way on the MAP scores alone or the DIBL scores alone.
And I see a hand up.
I just have a clarifying question.
Are those increases percentage point or percentage of the percentage?
percentage, how do I describe this?
So for multilingual, if it was a 3% increase of its percentage points, did it go from 2.1 to 5.1?
Correct, yes.
So last year amongst the previous year between all the students who were looked at with multilingual at grades one and four, it was 2% of that total population.
So I was going to ask the same question because then the follow-up way to think about this is,
the actual percentage increase is over 100, right?
Exactly.
So this is actually showing that we doubled or even tripled some of these things.
So I was going to ask the same question, and thank you, Director Smith, for being on the math plane that I am.
So if you think about MKV, if it went up by 1.8 off of a 2.3, you're talking about tripling.
I mean, that's a big deal.
And so I really want to highlight how the focus of making sure that we are identifying children at more times and more places can double or even triple the ways that we are serving our children.
So thank you for highlighting that, and thank you for that being the answer.
I was hoping that that was the answer.
So thank you.
Yeah, thank you for that.
I appreciate it.
And one of the things I'm actually really excited about, just finished another training for the NGAT or the Naguleri.
So I actually anticipate that these numbers are going to go up with that addition of that nonverbal screener.
That's the whole point of the nonverbal screener is to better recognize our students who have not had the same opportunities and access to really early learning and outside learning from schools.
So this is exciting for our department.
And then one final slide, and I'll be quick about this.
This is just, you know, we were looking, my team was looking between 2021 and 2026. We actually have additional data, but really looking at the impact of our highly capable students.
How are they growing?
It's eight points higher than the district average but it's still only 65% of our highly capable identified kids are meeting expected growth on the math map.
66% are meeting expected growth on the reading map and we are actually digging deeper into that to more fully understand some things in gifted education and the ceilings of the tool called the MAP.
But we wanted to just share this out as an academic measure.
I think there's some mixed thinking here.
Our top line measures for highly capable are just high, and some of that's by virtue of who we've identified for highly capable.
So we as a department are really looking at how are our students growing in specific programs?
Director Rankin.
Clarifying question.
When the MAP is administered to students who qualify as HC identified who are taking math and English classes at accelerated grade levels, do they take the MAP, I can't remember, I should know this, but do they take the MAP test at their at their grade level or the grade level of the curriculum that they're...
Well, the map, there's two different versions of the map.
There's K through two, and then there's two through 12 version.
And it starts at the grade level that the student is placed.
And so that's a great thinking...
receiving fourth grade math instruction is taking second grade math, but it's adaptive.
It's adaptive.
It goes up quickly.
And then when we look at the comparisons between groups, we're looking at two other second graders.
you're looking at second graders with that same RIT score.
So on a national level, all those students are compared to each other.
So it's a pretty fair comparison, but there's a lot of question and wonderings about is the MAP the best tool for our students who are already pretty high up there as a test tool.
Thanks.
Thank you.
I think that when I want to reference what Superintendent Schulner talked about earlier is our roadmap of rigorous instruction for every student along with services matched to strengths and needs and the capacity building.
For all three of our departments, I think that we really are focused on capacity building because we all know that there are students sitting in our classrooms that may not have the label.
they may be eligible, they may have the need, but they may not have the label and they can still benefit from really strong and rigorous instruction.
And so capacity building I think is something that all three of us are very passionate about.
This is just showing you the different ways in which we've tried to build capacity.
All of our departments can and do offer PLC facilitation for our schools.
we try to go out and connect our families and our students in the schools with different community partners and then we all have professional embedded learning happening within the schools and then system-wide on a systemic level I know that the special education department started a service institute a couple years ago, and we've all kind of jumped in on that, and so that's open to all educators that happens during the summer, so that's another way we try to do some capacity building.
And then within the ML department, we're really focused on GLAD and SIOP, and then I think Paula referenced the math project that HC is doing.
The next slide is going to be a huge infomercial on GLAAD, so I'm just going to warn you ahead of time.
This is the capacity building and kind of the focus, just some of the things that my department has or our department has focused on.
We talked earlier about what is causing the barriers, possible barriers, for our K-5.
and our team looked at that and talked about it and so we actually, up in the right corner, we had 23 schools who met as a PLC last year.
The reading interventions and ML staff met and read a book around English language learners and literacy we collaborated with the ELA department in running that PLC and it was very effective I think we got great feedback we also offer asynchronous so we try to meet you know educators where they are in their learning, so we have a couple asynchronous courses, but the one that I really want to highlight and I'm super excited about is the 43 schools in the last couple of years who have participated in our GLAAD training.
GLAAD is, for those of you who may not know, is a research-based approach to language acquisition.
I think it's great for all kids.
It really focuses on student discourse and engagement and community.
We're actually running a GLAAD professional development right now.
I was just at Kimball this morning.
But we have tweaked it over the years to figure out the best way that we can build sustainability and capacity.
So instead of just giving professional development to an educator, kind of in isolation.
We've been asking schools that if they would like GLAAD training that they need to send us a team of like two or three educators.
We really believe that that cadre of educators in your building helps build momentum.
It helps build support.
and sustainability, and so not only do we ask the principals to agree to send two or three, and not all of them would be the multilingual, some of them are just a grade band, gen ed teachers, and that's how we're kind of looking at that capacity building, but we also ask them to sign an agreement that they will do learning walks looking for that GLAD implementation when those teachers arrive back in building to kind of keep that momentum going, and we also offer that my team will go out and do the follow-ups as well.
But I think that it really speaks to our desire to have sustainability and capacity throughout our system because we want to be able to reach those students who may not have that label but would benefit from those supports as our job is to strengthen teaching and learning for all of our students.
Can you tell us what GLAAD stands for?
It's a new acronym for me.
I know and you're gonna test me, but it's Guided Language Acquisition Design.
And this is maybe less of a new infomercial and a bit of repeated information for how special education is reaching schools, educators, and students in a capacity building model.
So we've talked about the bottom two, but I want to highlight a couple things.
So number one is on the top left you see that 200 and plus.
And so we have a intervention tool that's an evidence-based instructional material, it's called Lexia Core 5. And so special education department has been using this and training staff and using this as an intervention tool, a gap closing measure for some years.
And it's had a big enough impact that we've actually been able to partner, Cashel and I have worked really closely together to make sure that we're actually seeing that this is a intervention support that works for more than students with just disabilities, right?
And so it's now become one of our adopted intervention tools.
So we have SIPS and we have Lexia Core 5 in addition to our core instruction.
And so we've already had over 200 educators trained in this evidence-based reading intervention strategy.
The other thing I want to mention about this is it's also a multi-sensory approach that does support students who have dyslexia in reading growth and achievement.
And so I think that this is evidence of a really great partnership in terms of being able to build the capacity of our educators to meet the needs of more of our students in the general education setting.
The other thing that we did, and again I want to shout out the Seattle Education Association for our partnership on getting to a shared value that we all have with the community, which is making sure that as many of our students as possible can access special education services in their neighborhood school.
Right now, that's not the lived reality for a lot of our students, and when you disaggregate the data, what we know is that overall, our students with IEPs, one in every 15 experiences a change of placement every year, and a lot of those involve changes of schools.
If you have an IEP and you are black, you have a one in four chance of experiencing a placement change every year.
And so what we know is that especially when those involve a change at school, you're not just changing a school, you're changing your entire community.
If you're a family, oftentimes your children are split between schools.
You have to rebuild that, you know, a new relationship with a new community and also it means that oftentimes if you're experiencing services in one school and you switch to another that's a pretty big change for student instructionally which also has a big impact that can also set students back so those are the unintentional consequences of the design that we have in our current staffing models.
So what we were able to get to with our collective bargaining agreement this year is a special ed partnership initiative.
So we know that this redesign can't happen in isolation.
We can't do it by ourselves as a district.
We can't do it just with our partners, our labor partners and SEA.
But we intentionally designed this to bring in our community partners and our families to help co-design ideal educational experience for our students together.
and we were able to make sure that by year three we have 30% implementation in all of our elementary schools of this redesigned model and so this is just an example of the building and establishing of greater trust and transparency with our labor partners, with our communities and knowing that we can't do this in isolation.
When we do this together we are better and we have better services and outcomes for our students as well.
Alright, I'll continue the infomercial going on about building teacher capacity.
About a year ago I talked to you all, I think it was October a year ago, where I talked to you about the shifts needed in our department to move from a department that was spending the majority of their time, their resources, their money on identification, to a department that actually was building capacity of educators in our schools.
We heard repeatedly from neighborhood school educators that they haven't received training, they didn't know what to do, they didn't know what to do with the materials.
And we heard actually from our HCE sites that they actually haven't received training either.
They were just given curriculum two years in advance in math, one years in language arts and told be happy, go forth.
So we made a big shift.
We reallocated resources this year.
We now have a total of four amazing HC specialists.
They're specialists, they're not coaches because they work with families, they work with teachers, they do some coaching, they work on our systems and they deliver professional development.
And then we have three technical people on that side of the house for a total of a small but mighty team of eight folks.
A couple of things that we just want to share and celebrate.
We started a very small pilot last year called the Inclusive Math Project where we were working with a handful of elementary schools, very specifically neighborhood schools where we were working with educators on having an understanding of how do we layer on enhancement and extension in math.
How do we help teachers implement what we call deep mathematical tasks in learning in real time?
That project has expanded this year to over 27 schools.
We actually at last count have 75 educators working on this project.
It's actually four release days throughout the year where teachers across the city are coming together as grade level teams at a specific school site.
They're trying on new strategies.
They're trying on lessons.
And similar to what Michelle was saying, with the agreement that those lessons and that series of lessons will be implemented in their home schools and we're seeing pretty great outcomes with teachers trying this on.
Our team actually will go and co-teach with these educators or even model that lesson in those classrooms.
The other piece, just some baseline training.
We started this last summer.
We continued it most recently.
Just HC 101 training.
What is this thing called highly capable?
What are some baseline foundational strategies that every Seattle public school educator needs?
over a thousand educators have been trained in this and this is in large part because we know our identification process are flawed.
On any given day in any given classroom you're going to have a student who needs a little bit more extension and they might not have that HC label but we want to make sure that our teachers are prepared to increase the rigor, the depth, the complexity when students need it.
And then, NGAT training.
We are about to launch starting on December 1st.
We are going to launch that Naguleri district-wide with our first graders.
And my team, my logistics team, wanted me to remind you or to update this.
We actually now have over 200 educators trained because we just did two trainings today.
So we are reaching out to every first grade teacher.
They are all being trained on this new tool.
And at the same time, they're learning more about highly capable services and what are the metrics that we're using to identify these students who might be in need of services.
Alright, getting a little closer to the end.
We really wanted to talk about how not only do the three of us work together, but how we have to work with other people in the John Stanford Center and in our system in order to get outcomes for all kids, but very specifically for the populations that are served by multilingual special education and highly capable.
So just to call out, we do a lot of work with our curriculum and assessment department.
Probably the highest or most recent one we can think of is we, all three of us, were collaborative in with our teams on the literacy adoption, the eMERGE adoption.
Each of our specialists are working in partnership with the CAI team on that implementation.
we're starting to learn some things in real time and we're the thinking partners and supporting that core tier instruction that might need to adapt in some ways to meet the needs of our students.
We also work, our teams work collaboratively, we showed you that graphic with those 11 students who ML special education and highly capable.
That's a small number.
Most of those students happen to be second graders by the way.
And so our teams are working together on some very intentional, very strategic problem solving and building the capacity of educators who are working with students with those intersexual identities and needs.
Universal Design for Learning is an instructional framework that crosses all three of our departments.
It really crosses the entire school system in terms of core instruction.
There's curriculum and then there's the strategies to deliver that curriculum.
And so each person who is working with students or with educators from our teams are well versed in Universal Design for Learning and it's a common language that our teams are using with educators.
And then one thing that really makes us, I think, unique and different is we are also, everyone is accountable to families, but our teams interact with families.
We provide guidance with families.
We are sometimes the advocate for families at times where the facilitator or the mediator between the teacher and the families, or the school leader and the families.
And those partnerships are critical for getting our students, you know, our students who qualify in just one service, it's critical.
Our students who overlap, it's even more critical for that.
Alright, we are at the end.
So, what are we doing moving forward?
So these are how our future priorities are aligned across our departments.
So we're continuing to work to reduce disproportionality.
We've made significant gains, but there's still a lot of work to do.
And so we're working hard across departments to make sure that students aren't disproportionately identified, disciplinarily removed from school, placed into self-contained settings inappropriately, and that there's better representation across highly capable services for students who receive more than one service.
As we've talked about regularly, we're continuing to work with our partners in CAI in Coordinated School Health to make sure that We not only strengthen rigorous instruction through UDL strategies, which are often those proactive plan strategies rather than differentiation, which is oftentimes when it's already built.
UDL is designing it and building it with that in mind.
But also making sure that students have the social emotional support so that they can actually access that rigorous instruction.
We do that through building our educator capacity, so you've heard some highlights of how we're working to do that.
We're continuing to track and monitor, we're listening to what families and communities and our educators need to continue to build that capacity and build programs and trainings and supports for that.
in order to increase student achievement.
So you saw that one page that had some of our gaps that we're still looking at.
Even though we're top five in a lot of measures, there's still a lot of room for growth and achievement.
So that's one of the things that we're really looking at to make sure that we're continuing to increase, that we're not just celebrating what we've done, but that we are continuing the good work.
So with that, that is our three services.
All right, well, thank you so much.
Again, really just a privilege to work with the three of them.
I hope the board enjoy the presentation, and I know there will be lots of questions, so President Topp.
Two questions.
We talked a little bit about an hour and a half, so that gives us about 15 minutes of questions.
I think we might go slightly over, but just keep that in mind as you're asking your question.
Who would like to kick us off?
Director Smith.
So my questions kind of are mostly centered on the highly capable academic impact slide.
And I think, Dr. Montgomery, when you were presenting it, you said that there were, I think you kind of, I forget your exact wording, but you did bring up that there are different ways to interpret these numbers.
I'd say as a parent of a first grader, wondering will he be qualified or designated as highly capable?
I mean, as his mom, I think he's amazing and smart and can do anything.
but what will the label say?
And then looking at this saying, if he gets designated highly capable, those students have this 65%, 66%, or is it 65% of the students meet their growth?
Versus if he doesn't, does that mean he doesn't have that opportunity to achieve the same growth?
And so that, it feels very concerning that, getting access to highly capable services would have such an impact on a student's opportunity for growth.
That's a great question, and I won't have all the answers.
I do think over the past, is it eight months, Superintendent Schillinger, that you've been here?
There has been a renewed focus on academic rigor in our entire system.
So I would anticipate that we start to see district-wide more of our kids growing.
When I said there's many ways to look at this data, We could have spent 90 minutes on each of our areas easily.
And I'm happy to share this information at a different date with you.
But we are seeing pretty significant growth, very specifically with our highly capable students at grade two in math at our HC sites.
which speaks to that two-year jump in math, that opportunity for that acceleration.
And we're seeing it actually in this data set also at grade seven at our HC sites which speaks to that algebra, right?
So we know that there's something about that opportunity around math that is significant.
We have tried to attend to that somewhat with our fifth to sixth grade summer programming, but we have work to do.
As we dive into that data, if we were to look at math versus reading and look at specific grade levels, you'll see some different stories with regards to general population versus highly capable populations, especially in reading.
You'll see some different stories with HC sites in reading.
and HC qualified kids at their neighborhood schools as well.
A presentation like this, it's how much detail do we put out there, but it's detail that is important to our team.
And I also, one of the threads that we kept talking about was the importance of core instruction, right?
So it can't just be highly capable.
That can't be the only place where our students encounter rigorous instruction.
What I know to be true when we're talking about map percentiles, they're based on a national.
level.
Seattle as a population our students perform significantly above that national level on the map and so there's some work to be done system-wide on core instruction in both reading and math and that's part of our partnership with our other departments as well.
Thank you.
I also want to apologize.
I feel like I meant to ask more of a question, and then I got a little bit caught up on what does this mean for whether or not children get the highly capable designation.
Can I add one other point?
This is a hard shift for us.
Our state, the state of Washington, has increasingly become very clear that highly capable services should be designed for students whose needs are so unique that their needs can't be met in core instruction.
The complicated thing is we have a lot of work to do in our core instruction, right, system-wide for all kids.
So I just want to put that out there.
We do see, we're even seeing at first grade right now, students who have such significant needs that the teachers are developing very individualized plans for these students at a very, very young age.
We want to make sure we can provide for those students, but we also have thousands of students who are high-achieving students.
We need to make sure we're continuing to provide challenge and rigor and see growth for them as well.
You know, I'm not particularly proud of our highly capable growth target data, and our district data, I'd like to see that also higher.
I'd like to see us growing all of our kids, including our high-achieving kids, our kids who are coming into kindergarten who can already read, what does their growth trajectory look like then with our educators?
And our educators are doing a great job, but I think increasingly we're becoming a district that's looking at data more carefully and holding ourselves accountable for growing students.
Thank you, and I feel like we could take well over the 15 minutes we have to talk about this data, but I do appreciate your sort of condensing the fact that there are so many more details that you're considering in this discussion.
Director Lavette, we'll just go around the U.
I have so many questions I want to ask, and I know I'm only going to get time for one.
So I wanted to ask, and I know others will have some about some of the other things that I want to cover.
So I want to ask for the multilingual students Congratulations on the incredible data set that you showed where it's 79% ELA kids who exited multilingual support services.
I'm assuming that if you're offering them over years that some of this data is from a number of years ago and it's the students who have exited are now doing better.
Is that correct?
What we track is after a student exit, the exit's ML supports, the state we're required to still track or support students for two more years.
So it's just two years.
How long are they in the ML supports, though, for usually?
until they exit the WENA annual.
It can vary.
It can vary anywhere from one to even six or seven years.
Okay, I'm just wondering, I know we, three, four years ago, we removed a bunch of our newcomer programs and the bilingual orientation centers.
And so that was something that was set up and was a change to our system.
And so are we looking at this data from kids coming out of those programs where they had that support, and now the system's shifting, and how are we continuing to see that affect the data?
So I'm wondering, are we looking at kind of an an old factor and we changed the system a few years ago and we just haven't seen that data arrive yet or how's that working out?
No, this comes from the state report cards and the Tableau data platform from the state.
They're tracking those two years so this would be like 24-25 exited students and 23-24 exited students.
OK.
Am I not?
So I think the question is saying, hey, look, we used to have a model.
The model probably produced these numbers.
These numbers look pretty good.
Now we have a different model.
Are we worried that the numbers are going to change?
Yeah.
I think that's your question.
Yes.
Yeah.
Yeah and it could be that the next model is also even better but as we're looking at the data that's impacted by the old model that we had, how do we know that it's going to continue with the new one?
Yeah, I think that that's a great question.
I don't know if I would have an answer to be able to predict that.
I will say that the newcomer supports that we had in place before, we were trying to align with the state and civil rights of our families, and we were giving families choices.
and many of our families would enroll online and they would get placed at their home school.
They would go, get screened at their home school, fall in love with their home school which I think is a great thing that our neighborhood schools are so welcoming and they would want to stay and they have a right to stay and receive language supports at their neighborhood school.
The newcomer population and numbers have decreased over time in just real time.
The last three weeks we've had zero that have come in from our reports.
But I do feel that it's our right to make sure that we're making sure that we're listening to our families and where they want to receive supports.
and we have been giving extra supports to those schools, the elementary schools, who have a higher number of newcomers coming.
So there are four elementary schools that we're also getting extra supports.
Yeah, and I think the question is, again, hey, look, we had this model.
Maybe that really helped us.
I think when you hear Michelle, that model was probably very good.
But right now, I think the number was 66 newcomer students in the entire district.
That's a lot less than I think what was happening earlier.
So even if there was still that program, when you look at the number of ML students, which is in the thousands, those students were already in the other programs.
So I'm not sure that that program existing or not existing would really move the needle one way or the other because it's just the denominator being so low.
Thank you.
Director Founce?
No.
All right.
Director Mizrahi?
Yeah, I would be curious if we have any data, obviously not in front of us right now, or if you can speak to it anecdotally or we can get it later too, is pulling out ML learners at dual language schools and how they're doing in terms of achievement and also exiting ML, but overall proficiency.
Any impact we see there?
We actually do, this OSPI school report card will give you the exit rate by school and so what I can tell you is almost all of the DL schools have a higher exit rate exiting the ML supports.
Yeah, and one thing if I might add, what I love about these questions is hopefully this will not be the last time these three wonderful individuals present.
The hope is that we have a cadence of these ISS's once a year where we're doing each of these things.
So what I would ask from both the board and the community, however many people are watching at home.
If there are certain aspects that you would like us to present next time, we're happy to do so.
And I think that data question, really interesting.
Is there something special about our dual language programming that's getting kids to exit earlier and doing well?
What a great question.
And so hopefully we see this as the first foray into this conversation about how we're helping support these three programs.
Director Rankin.
Thank you.
My first comment is just that this is what instructional leadership looks like and I'm so excited that we're actually spending board time talking about students and how our system is doing serving them.
It should be basic and not as exciting as it is but it's actually very exciting.
So I have a couple very specific, like, should be short questions.
One is that the highly capable students being served and participated by grade span, the HC designation by the state ends at eighth grade, but we have ninth and twelfth grade identified.
Is that just students who have already been qualified and still carry that designation?
So the HC designation carries through 12th grade, and in fact the state law requires that we have a referral process, an identification process, all the way through 12th grade, so 11th graders.
I'm sorry, I'm thinking of it was the cohort designation in SPS.
changed and then we have pathways.
Yeah, in Seattle Public Schools it's HC.
They qualify as HC and then families have school choice and they have very specific cohort at the elementary level.
Okay.
Are students typically being identified in high school or are they students that have the identification usually already?
It's a small number, less than 100, but we do have applications at the high school level and at the middle school level.
And once you get to high school, though, any student can take any high school class.
We're not limiting access to courses.
Absolutely.
Yeah, that's absolutely correct.
The motivation, perhaps, is we do have HC sites at the high school level.
So Lincoln Garfield and West Seattle High School.
And there's boundaries associated with those three schools.
And HC designated students have a pathway to those three high schools.
I would like to say this does highlight an interesting question for this illustrious board.
What is the purpose of an HC high school?
Because if all classes are open to all children at all of the high schools, that designation seems to be a nice two letters next to a child's name, but in reality doesn't seem to actually lead to anything.
Whereas in a K through 8 programming, that HC designation is two grades above in math and one in English, and it's possible a cohorted school like Cascadia or Decatur.
So I think it's an important conversation for us to have to really truly understand what does it mean to have an HC designated school rather than continuing with HC designated students?
But again, that's a conversation for another time, but I'm glad that you brought that up because I think it highlights the question about why does that even exist at the high school level?
so some classes are not available at some high schools and that's really not okay.
On the last page of a certain section before multilingual supports, strong core instruction plus specialized supports, I just wanted to highlight and deeply appreciate that on this slide stated very plainly is student variability should be an expected part of every classroom.
and that specialized services complement strong core instruction.
They do not replace it.
Again, this seems like kind of a basic thing, but those two sentences are things that this district has really danced around.
and it's just a matter of existence of students.
Any classroom, whether or not there are students that are identified or qualified for certain services, is going to have variability and different needs and that is just normal.
That is just life.
And so I'm happy to see that because we shouldn't have homogeneity versus services.
Within every group of students, within every classroom, there's a huge range of different experiences, abilities, all kinds of things.
So instead of pretending that's not the case, I just wanted to appreciate that we're stating that as a foundational expectation and understanding.
That's a really positive thing.
I'm curious about the eighth graders that took the advanced math courses to go into math, seven, eight, as sixth graders, and maybe you don't have the answer for this, just sort of idle curiosity.
How are they doing now?
Has this been something that now some kids are struggling to keep a pace of, or has this been a really successful opportunity, just out of curiosity?
Yeah, I'm happy to follow up with more exact data.
We are actually really excited.
So the first group of students who were in this program are now in seventh grade and they're taking algebra.
They did outstanding in Math 7-8.
We see it in their map data, we see it in their SBAS scores, we see it in their grades.
we see it actually on the curriculum embedded assessments they were achieving at a much higher level than the system and the same thing is happening for those students now that they're in algebra and then this current group of sixth graders again we pulled the data the quarter ends on Friday but we see their map data their map growth was substantial and this is what we know about high quality summer programming is it provides opportunity learning opportunity so we're seeing spring to fall map growth for these young people at sustained levels and then again we're seeing they're passing math 7-8 we've reached out to all the teachers of these students how are they doing and they're they are doing exceptionally well I think the key is they didn't skip sixth grade math they they took sixth grade math on a very condensed very rigorous way and they're ready for it they're ready for math 7-8 at a very high well-prepared level
Have you had anybody that has said, yes, I want to continue, but 7-8, my kid took 7-8, and it's a lot of material in one time.
Some kids are totally ready for it, but can kids who have done the math six just take math seven as a sixth grader?
Yeah, yeah, we have families that have made that choice.
We've had schools that have made it really clear in the spring that that's also the trajectory, and that's worked out well, and the students are doing very well.
The two-year acceleration's not for everybody.
and then part of this would also be that now we have to, we already should have had geometry at all middle schools.
They will need geometry in eighth grade and we're monitoring that.
Yeah, so one year and we're going to have groups of kids who are going to need geometry.
Great, and then my last comment is on the, I don't know, are we calling it CEPI, S-E-P-I, whatever the, I am, I just cannot, it's so long overdue for that, I just cannot wait to see it.
Of course, you know, 30% implementation by year three sounds great, and also for me it's not fast enough, but I just can't wait to see how that develops, and I just thank you all.
I have a comment slash question on each three of the categories.
I'm really excited to see the exit data on our multilingual students because I think that is a more accurate reflection of how our students are doing.
So I hope that we can continue to report on exit rates and how our students are doing academically when they exit.
Congratulations to this district on our audit results.
It's very exciting.
For future iterations of this session, I would really like to do a deeper dive in our resource students because that is the kind of bulk of our special education students.
It feels like that is a group of students where we can be really thoughtful about tier one instruction.
And so it would be helpful to know what kinds of supports are they getting?
Are we looking at more students with reading needs and maybe or is it math?
Maybe we should be investing more in math.
So future iterations, a deeper look into our resource students and what kind of supports and needs they have.
And then with highly capable, I'm wondering why have we designed it so that it's two years ahead in math and one year ahead in ELA?
It's what it's always been.
So since the 1980s, it was two years acceleration.
So it's...
Two years of math and one in...
Yeah, and about six years ago, they made the decision to change it from two years acceleration in LA to one year acceleration.
We're learning some things right now.
This year will be an interesting year with our ELA adoption, and especially to pay attention to our reading achievement and growth of students at our HC sites, which are one year ahead, and our HC students who are at neighborhood schools who are getting their reading instruction at grade level.
But it's a historical model.
I mean, I guess I'm the superintendent, so I can poke holes at my own self.
But how about let's ask the question, why?
Can anybody defend this?
I appreciate that it's the way it's always been, but lots of stuff has been the way it's always been.
It hasn't necessarily been the right one.
So I defer to Dr. Montgomery as an expert.
Is there a rationale, or is the answer, hey, this is the way we've always done it?
Because if that's the answer, then we should probably look at maybe this isn't the right way.
Or maybe it is, and we just don't know.
Can I ask a pre-question to that?
So when you are a fifth grader at Cascadia and then you go to Hamilton for middle school, what level ELA are you taking?
Are you taking sixth grade ELA?
You are.
You're taking sixth grade ELA with a different curriculum.
LA and math are very different in terms of the LA standards.
If you look at the standards and start to unpack them between really fourth grade and twelfth grade, the standards overlap with increased depth and complexity.
You know, the sixth grade and the revisiting of sixth grade LA is something that we need to look at.
But it's because it's always been that way.
I mean, this is, it's what makes them different.
One of the pieces I do want to come back to, what should we be doing or what's the why?
There is significant research that talks about math acceleration very specifically and where best to start it.
And it is right around the middle school level.
That is one of the reasons as we were trying to get clearer about HC specific sites and what they do, which we're using a historical model for.
And our neighborhood sites, one of the things that came out of that was the inclusive math project.
And it came from a research base that said if we can get students really strong on their conceptual knowledge, K through five, then it is appropriate for math to start to accelerate at that middle school level.
And that project is building the capacity of the elementary school teachers.
And then the summer math program is meeting that need of how do we accelerate at this time.
We are currently internally looking at different models.
The summer program, it's meeting a need of many students, but we also know there's probably something that we need to shift at sixth grade and not sustain the summer program.
But I think there's a lot of there could be a lot of thought in terms of why this model of acceleration.
Acceleration is needed though for gifted students.
Happy to send you a research article I was just reading about the different types of acceleration.
There's over 20 different types.
We're using one model which is a grade subject acceleration.
Director Mangelson.
Yeah, I was just kind of building off of what Director Rankin was asking about for high school, H.C.
I go to West Seattle High School and I didn't actually know that we were an H.C.
designated school.
So that raises the question of, you know, what does it really mean to be an H.C.
designated high school?
And I know that it's kind of changed.
So like I have a friend who her older brother was, he graduated a couple years ago.
I think he's like a sophomore or junior in college right now.
And he was designated at HCE in elementary and middle school.
And then at West Seattle High School, he was able to take physics B instead of physics A as a freshman, and then able to take AP Environmental Science as a sophomore.
And now that's not an option.
And I know that another thing is I have a lot of friends who wanted to take two maths because they weren't able to do advanced math in middle or elementary school.
Or another thing is even for my friends who were designated HC for English, once you get to ninth grade, you kind of just have the option for English to do honors, which is just a couple extra assignments every semester.
And so I'm kind of curious.
what, number one, what the difference is between my school and other AHC schools and schools that aren't AHC designated.
And if there is a difference between what I just talked about and other schools, I think that's a problem because I think what I've said should be accessible, just being able to do honors and take AP courses and whether or not There could be changes made to that, like potentially being able to take AP classes earlier, being able to do more sciences or more math, or being able to, I don't know, something other than the way honors is set up now.
So I'm just curious, is that in talk?
You're bringing up so many different models, history.
I love it, because everything you said is accurate.
And as you're talking, I can think back to the year, oh, yeah, that's when the middle school model changed, or that's when we started doing this, or this is when high school started to not have honors classes.
So all those things are true.
My work, has been some of the moves I've made while they appear to be structural at the elementary or middle school level will impact some of the experience that you're describing where students couldn't take an advanced math course or advanced science course in high school because their math wasn't high enough.
And we're trying to fix that, not just for students who have that HC designation, but for students at fifth grade are showing that they're ready for this and they want to do this.
I do think we have work to do with some alignment across high schools in terms of some of the things that you're talking about.
And part of my work, one of our slides talked about how we work with other departments.
That's a big part of my work, is working with other departments to try and get that alignment across our schools.
And then I want to come back to something Director Rankin, I think, said about to the question, what makes a HC high school an HC high school?
It's a big question, and she spoke to the availability of courses.
My hope is that all of our high schools have the availability of the courses.
We're not there for a variety of reasons, but that would be the hope.
Yeah, just a quick comment on what you said.
Yeah, I thought it was interesting to hear that my school was HC designated because I genuinely did not know that.
And I also, I remember a little while ago, it was West Seattle and a couple other schools got some sort of or recognition for a certain amount of students enrolled in AP courses.
And I thought that was really interesting because even for my peers, I hear a lot of them talking about how they wish we had more AP classes and that we don't have enough AP electives or that Yeah, I don't know.
I thought that was interesting.
So I think it disappoints me to know that there are schools where that's even less available when people in my school are already discouraged by the lack, when I think we do have AP core subjects and everything.
But yeah, that's really interesting.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Okay, so I just wanna say that it's like already quarter after six and I know we're running out of time.
So I'm gonna be very, very brief.
First of all, thank you very much for this presentation.
It was really lovely to hear about all of this amazing progress.
My question is actually somewhat related to Vivian's around the nature of acceleration and something that I have heard in other contexts, and I don't know how true this is, not being an education expert, but that what highly capable students need is less like racing ahead and more going deep.
and I'm wondering where we stand as a district on that, if that is true and if there are opportunities for students to do a deeper dive rather than just simply racing ahead to grades.
Yeah, I think the beautiful thing where we are right now at the elementary level is we have HC sites with a very specific model, two years acceleration in math when you're in LA and at our neighborhood sites.
For the most part, what we're saying is it's something different.
Now, my job and my team's job is to build the capacity of teachers so we're really clear about what is that something different because we're inconsistent.
Teachers are doing amazing things.
We have 64 elementary schools and they're doing different amazing things.
We need to have a real answer.
Our math project is one example of that.
And happy if you want to reach out to tell you more details about that, but that's a very specific answer at grades 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6, really training teachers and developing system wide materials to help students go deeper within those grade level standards.
and then I do think our eMERGE adoption is giving us an opportunity at the neighborhood schools to really lean in and think about what does it mean to work more deeply.
We also work with our HC sites and what we're hearing from our HC sites with the eMERGE adoption as well is it is rigorous for students.
Students are writing at a deeper level than they ever have and over the past two years we've been supporting our HC sites with that work.
The beautiful thing with our HC math project happening, our PD project, is that we actually have our HC sites and our neighborhood sites working together.
So these teachers are collaborating together.
So you'll have second grade teachers from Decatur working with second grade teachers from Hawthorne.
And they're looking at standards and looking at the depth of those standards, even though they're teaching different curriculum at this point in time.
I know we gotta go, but, you know, Director Briggs probably asked one of the most important fundamental questions about what anywhere else would call gifted and talented.
There are multiple models, but there really are two big ones.
One is, hey, you could just accelerate, go two, three, four, five grades ahead, or you can take the state standards or the grade standards and go very, very deep.
The issue with that is that it really depends on, a lot of times, the state standard itself.
So for instance, in something like mathematics, a lot of times it is acceleration.
Because mathematics, the way that it works, of course, is you have algebra 1, you have algebra 2, you have calculus.
A lot of that is kind of pretty scaffolded.
So if you go from algebra 1 to algebra 2, The deepness is actually that skill level of Algebra II.
But when you look at, let's say, state standard of social studies, learn about colonial America.
OK, well, great.
Well, you could learn about colonial America at a college level by reading a bunch of college texts, or you could learn about it at a grade level text.
So when somebody says, look, we need to go deeper into that grade level, a lot of times it's kind of subject specific, because especially with social studies, you could do that.
With science, it kind of goes back and forth.
Is there a sense that physics is somehow harder than biology?
Not really, because they could both go super, super in depth.
But when you're looking at a second grader, the problem is, do we even have a curriculum that says, here's the grade level, but it's the same standards, but you're going to go really, really deep?
Sometimes it's a lot easier to just say, we're going to go two grades, three grades above.
What I would say, and I appreciate Paula's point, with Emerge, you're finally at a level where it's pretty rigorous as it is, and then there are additional works within Emerge that you can then go deeper.
So the families that are coming to you saying, look, the best model of HC, of gifted, is to just go deeper, not necessarily accelerate.
A, it's dependent on the subject, and B, it's also dependent on the kind of curriculum that we're using.
Look, at the end of the day, the dream is you just differentiate, right?
You have an amazing teacher, and you have 25 kids in a classroom, and they all have different needs and different skills, and you do all sorts of stuff.
That's really hard.
So sometimes the answer is, hey, look, math, go two grades above because it's already kind of working on itself.
On English, maybe it's one grade above, or maybe it's the same grade, but going in deeper.
And I think that what Paul is doing, and I think what we're doing as a district, is really trying to figure out what do our individual children need and try to access that.
But this is a conversation that everybody in HC has throughout this country.
So I really appreciate you highlighting that.
All right, we'll go to our student director, Director Faust.
Oh.
So I go to Chief South.
We're an IB school.
And I was just wondering about the seventh grade algebra pathway, because if I was to take algebra in seventh grade, then at my high school right now, there wouldn't be a more challenging math option for me if I was a senior.
And along with that, our HL math class actually just got cut.
And I know that there is like a really big lack of consistency with course availability throughout the district.
So I just want to make sure that as you guys are implementing the algebra in seventh grade pathway, that there's a really strong focus on just like a similarity in math class availability.
Because for an IB school like mine, you need to take three HLs if you want to do full IB.
And then there's only four HL options.
So it's very limiting.
and especially my school is majority low income so I also want to make sure that for a majority low income schools that there are challenging classes and that those students have the ability to be pushed in the first place.
Yes.
We agree.
The nice thing is, at least we're doing stuff in seventh grade, so it gives us a little bit of time to go build all of this.
But again, not to go down a much deeper rabbit hole, there is some concepts of AP versus IB.
a full diploma-track IB program is actually quite intense.
And if you get a diploma from IB, that is considered one of the highest things a high school student can do.
But that is different than the APs that we do.
So I'm really glad you're highlighting it.
It's definitely something that we're thinking about because we have multiple IB schools, right?
And so I think we want to make sure that they have a robust diploma track so that you can actually get all of those high-level work.
So thank you.
All right.
Thank you so much for the presentation.
I like this new ISS format.
I really think that it allows us to go deeper, you know.
We've heard from you lots since I've been a board director, Dr. Paula, Dr. Montgomery?
Director Montgomery.
Doctor, Doctor, both, both.
But in my time here, like, sitting at these, having these discussions, I have not heard from Assistant Superintendent Gurley or Director Oda, Doctor?
Just Director Gurley.
Okay.
So this is helpful to get this deeper dive in this information and this new structure with the informational study session.
So thank you so much.
I think your presentation both had good news, things we can be hopeful about, as well as where we're working and where we're trying to go.
So thank you so much.
Board directors, we're going to take a short break because we're running over.
Five minutes only.
Five minute break.
We will be back at 625. Okay, so we have at least quorum here.
We're gonna get started.
Director Song, Director Mizrahi.
All right, next presentation is on educational technology information and I'm gonna pass it over to Superintendent Schuldner.
All right, I will say good evening now.
So we really appreciated all the ISS around the projects that we just heard.
Now I think we are here for really important, very, very I think thoughtful and hopefully robust conversation.
I know that this community and really this country has been immersed in educational technology conversations for a while now.
And I'm really happy that we have such great pedagogues here at the table to share.
But I do want to level set around a couple of things.
And I've been trying to say this really since I've been here, is that during COVID, the world changed and education changed along with it.
And one of the things that was so apparent was when you shut down schools, children didn't have access to curriculum, they didn't have access to teachers, they didn't have access to schools.
And so what almost all school districts in America did was they did everything they could to get technology into the hands of children with Wi-Fi so that they could continue their learning while schools were in session but not in person.
Well, then, of course, what happened is we came back to school.
And I think what the concern, of course, is that we then didn't change what was happening during the COVID era.
And a lot of the things that wended their way through to curriculum and to schools and to the ways that we kind of worked, we did not step back and say, wait a second, why are we still doing this?
And so what I, what we inherited was a system that was so firmly baked on a pandemic, on a huge change in this country, that we haven't had I guess the thoughtfulness around really rethinking what about that could be good?
What about that was problematic?
And what about it do we really, really need to change?
And of course, what you always realize is that sometimes when things like that happen, you have stuff be, so this just went out.
So I don't know.
Does that mean that the folks at home?
Well, again, this is where technology can be a good thing, where people at home can watch.
So are we good?
No, we're going to wait for just a second.
Aha!
All right, there you go.
See?
Technology can be a good.
Is that what we have to really level set around is what can we take, what can we learn so that we can do what's best for children, but not continue down a path without real thoughtfulness.
And what I was going to say before the lights went out, as it were, is that There's no question that there are companies out there that there's millions and really billions of dollars that's being spent on technology because of, in some cases, real need and in other cases because they've been able to wrangle their way into school districts.
And I think that what we need to do as a society and what we need to do certainly as SPS is to be very, very critical about the kinds of technology we use and also who we're letting in the building, both digitally and in the real world.
So what you saw previously was a conversation about special education and HC and ML, about how we serve different populations and different programs.
Now we're really needing to think about the technology that we use for all of our children, and some of them are really incredible.
I mean, there is some technology where children who are non-verbal are able to communicate that did not exist 20, 30 years ago.
And then there's an over-reliance on technology that is stopping kids from doing something like writing with pen and pencil.
And we know that there is research upon research that having pen, having pencil, writing on paper actually creates different patterns in your neurons and the synapses and how actually kids process things.
So again, this is a long-winded way of saying we're at the It's the beginning of rethinking how we do all of this.
And I really do want to commend all of the families that have been so kind of supportive in us rethinking this, rather than just throwing out the baby with the bathwater or somehow just continuing on without any real questions.
So I will give a big shout to the folks that had a, let's call it a rally.
outside at 3.30.
We really appreciate SFIT and all the work that they've been doing and really all of the families that are thoughtful around what does technology look like that can be good for children and how can we stop the bad technology from inculcating our children.
So with that, I will turn it over to Dr. Starosky, the Assistant Superintendent of Academics, who will lead us through this wonderful conversation.
I'm so sorry.
I just want, I have a brief suggestion, if I may.
Do we have a hard stop at eight?
We do not have a hard stop at eight.
Okay, I didn't know if our ASL interpreter, at nine, okay.
But again, I think it would be, that is a long meeting.
That's a really long meeting.
The goal was to try to do an hour and a half and an hour and a half each, so that's, That's the intention.
I don't know how long you all are gonna go for, but this is definitely a longer packet than the previous.
Yeah, this is a longer packet, and I notice that the first nine pages of it are slides that we've seen before in other presentations, and so I'm suggesting that we skip ahead, since we are running behind and we have a longer presentation this time.
That's just a recommendation.
Duly noted, and I think Dr. Skrowski will go very, very, very quickly through that.
Good evening, Mike Strotsky, Assistant Superintendent of Academics.
Tonight with me is Carlos Devalle, Assistant Superintendent of Technology, and also Deb Knickerbocker, who is our Digital Learning Manager for Seattle Public Schools.
And so, as an experienced educator, have no problem accelerating when we need to accelerate and slowing down when we need to slow down.
So the intentionality of tonight is really to share with everyone an issue that impacts all of us.
and so no matter the age, everyone sitting in this room interacts with technology intentionally on some things, unintentionally in others and what we want to make sure is that we just are grateful for the opportunity to be able to share some of the things that we've been doing.
A year ago at this time, me and some other team members came and presented about AI specifically and we've learned a lot in the last year and some of that learning we're going to be talking about tonight.
So tonight's focus is to talk about technology's role in supporting first and foremost student learning and also talk about the guidance that we are trying to be very consistent about for that when technology is used and technology is a choice that is developmentally appropriate, safe and purposeful.
and also that technology includes literacy technology that we'll be talking about, literacy media, AI literacy that we'll be talking about a little bit later here.
So our North Star is always to be the top five in five, to be the best school district in the United States.
Our goals are third grade reading, eighth grade math, and our grad plus.
This leadership framework is very important for our public to recognize and know because at the center of it is student achievement and the outer circles, the outer rings are some of the things that we're going to be speaking about tonight, which is very important, which is rigorous instruction.
And so when you combine student achievement and rigorous instruction, what we know about our educators is our educators will do everything that they possibly can for our students.
And we want to give our educators the tools that they need to be successful with our students.
And so when we're thinking about how we got here currently and thinking about student achievement, that if we keep student achievement of everything that we're talking about this evening at the center, we believe that this would be a productive conversation and one that demonstrates that we're in Seattle Public Schools and Central Office as a district that we're just We are responsive to what we're hearing from community.
We're listening to our students and our teachers and our educators and we're listening to community.
So as Ben already went over very well, prior to COVID was the digital divide.
And there was a very strong sentiment that Seattle Public Schools wanted to be a one-to-one district.
This is pre-COVID.
and what we had done was made a focus of moving to one-to-one devices in secondary.
That was a very intentional choice.
And then when COVID happened, we were forced to accelerate, as Ben has described.
So as a system we described, or excuse me, we responded to one-to-one devices.
And once we caught that rabbit, then what do we do with it?
And what we've been doing with it is the post-COVID.
And so you see to the right there is that we moved from just having access for students.
It was an equity issue for Seattle Public Schools.
It was an equity issue for our school board.
It was an equity issue for our community to make sure that our students had access to technology.
And it was a sentiment that we all rallied around, and now that we have those devices, we have other issues around centering around equity that we also need to address.
and when we look at just moving from use and discernment, one of the things that we completely heard back last year when we were doing our community engagement sessions, and this is data just from those sessions, and so what you'll see is student achievement at the middle, strong family and community ties.
When we were asking community at those engagement sessions, what are some of the things that you're concerned about?
One of the things that was a common theme was technology overuse and screen time.
Specifically, very strongly at elementary school.
And so families expressed concern about the excessive use of technology.
They were unclear what our expectations as a district were about technology use.
and some of the key issues that we heard from families were too much screen time, and was it replacing hands-on learning, lack of district-wide cell phone policy, and now when I say that, people are going, oh, we already have one, don't we?
Yes, we didn't at the time that we were doing these surveys and meeting and engaging with public.
That's one of the reasons why we did what we did, was being responsive to what we were hearing from our educators and the public, specifically around cell phones.
and then also our overpurchasing or the perception of overpurchasing of digital programs and being so many things going on in Seattle Public Schools around digital software, what are we doing specifically?
public didn't know.
So one of the things that we have been doing the last few years, and this is information for everyone to know, is that we just didn't start responding to technology, software, AI, media literacy in the last year or two.
We've been doing this for a number of years.
And so one of the things that we have been focusing on is through this slide here, is the Safe and Purposeful Pledge as our North Star when we're thinking about technology.
And for our public, it's the ISTE, ITSE is how we describe it.
It's the International Society for Technology and Education.
and also ASCD, which is the Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.
Nonprofits who are very much aligned about if technology is going to be used, just because it's available doesn't mean you should be using it.
But if you are going to interact with technology, this is what they are saying that school districts and systems should be doing.
One is you need to have clear policy.
and clear expectation of technology use.
Two, there needs to be professional learning and support for the educators who are the ones who are interacting with that technology to help students interact with technology.
Three is that if you're using and supporting your educators in such a way that they also need to have quality tools and that the district needs to define what quality tools are within their system.
And then also for the students, there needs to be some digital citizenship.
Students need to learn safe, ethical uses and practices of technology.
and the last one there is family engagement.
You have to engage families in transparent communication and engagement on the issues of technology use.
So some of our policies and protocols.
This is some of the many literacies that we're talking in Seattle Public Schools and I'll just take a minute to say that Traditionally, when we talk about literacy, we are talking about the ability to read, write, understand, do math.
We conflate literacy on all number of issues.
But if we take literacy and add it to what the topic of tonight is, educational technology, we have digital literacy, which is the ability to use digital tools effectively.
We have digital citizenship, which is the ability to use technology safely, thoughtfully, responsibly and ethically.
We have media literacy, the ability to assess, critically evaluate and create information and be able to discern and judge media.
and then also we have now this new one that is all the rage for some folks is AI literacy, the ability to understand and critically evaluate and responsibly use AI.
And one of the things I think you will see and hear from us all night is the intentionality, the purposeful, the ethical use.
That has to be taught to students.
And when we're looking at what we're doing in Seattle Public Schools, Some of the things that guide us in what it is that we're doing is past practice and past priorities based in school board policy.
So our school board policy 2022, superintendent procedures 2022 as well.
We have digital citizenship and media literacy in 2023. And these aren't years, these are the actual school board policies.
And then student internet access, 3540, and data privacy, I should say.
and so one of the things that we want folks to know is that Seattle Public Schools isn't just making this up, we are being guided and this has happened over a number of years and it's also being informed by national policy and it's also being informed by state policy as well.
I just want to highlight again, maybe 2023, right?
I think the idea, of course, is that art students need to know how to use technology, which means we have to teach that.
And the board, way before I got here, recognized that.
And the idea of establishing digital citizenship and media literacy as part of preparing students to participate safely, critically, and responsibility in a digital society.
We cannot certainly pretend like we're not in a digital society.
And I think it would be a mistake for us to not address that fact, not to make a different kind of political point.
Abstinence only does not work.
And we want to make sure that we also think critically about what our children are exposed to throughout their lives and making sure, age-appropriate, we can do that.
And I want to thank Mike for once again highlighting that there was a huge equity issue around access to technology, access to the internet, access to things that can help children.
And we want to make sure that now that we've gotten kind of past that, that now we sort of were the dog that caught the car, and now it's like, what do we do?
And I think we have to be very critical as to what we allow on our computers, what we don't allow on our computers, but to not say we shouldn't teach about these things because that actually would set up our children to be in a position where they can't to address these things critically.
And when they're surrounded by it, they won't have the skills or the tools to really understand in any sort of deep way what the technology is that they're seeing.
So I think guided by policy 2023, that's where a lot of this, I think, work that Mike and the team are doing.
I will be the first one to admit that when I got here, what I saw was definitely a district that just kind of was overwhelmed by technology and just kind of said, go to it, right?
And now that we're saying, look, we need to be thoughtful, critical, we go back to our board policies and we say, what does it mean to be a citizen of this idea of being a critical and responsible digital society?
So thank you, Mike.
And, you know, to be clear, our goal isn't for students just to be excellent at technology.
Our goal is for our students to do all the things that we very much care about, to be critical consumers, to be critical thinkers, to be creative, to be collaborative.
Those are the skills that we want to be building into.
It's not to be focusing on technology as a means to an end.
One of the things that I'd like to bring Deb's voice into is just when it comes to our board policy, some things that we'd like you to as board members to consider checking out and why we would like you to check this out.
So the board policies that are specifically called out here, apologies, are 3540 and 2022 have some significant overlap.
3540 is an older one and it's specifically related to student internet use.
I think it's 2011 the last time it was put in.
It also doesn't have a connection with the state model policies.
2022 does.
That is a more recent policy that we've kept up with.
So I think that's something Mike and I have talked about and needs to be looked at.
2023 is really closely connected to state law.
That is the digital citizenship and media literacy component.
that has not been updated since 2018, so we're really looking to update that.
We've got a model policy that we think would be good.
It's got some implementation components to it, so I look forward to leadership, kind of focus on how we're going to implement the digital citizenship media literacy, and then it also includes AI literacy in that model policy.
So one of the things that is important for us is that whatever we're doing is that we're basing it in research, informed practice.
And one of the things I just want to assure folks is that We're not developing our guidance based on vendor marketing, our technology company recommendations, as Ben spoke about earlier.
We're drawing on what we believe is research best practices for child development, research, educational research, state standards, public policy and guidance, as well as the guidance from our school board.
And one of the things that is important when we're talking about educational technology is our definition, it's just the purposeful use of digital tools grounded in how people learn to support teaching and help students meet clear learning goals.
So if it is going to be used, if technology is going to be used, our expectation with our educators is that it's connected to a goal, it's connected to learning, it's helping students some way be able to reach their learning goals.
And then it has benefits, but it's not just using technology for the sake of using technology.
So, one of the things that, as we're saying, you know, so what are you relying on or who are you relying on?
Here's just some of the folks that we're relying on in our guidance, in our research.
Child Development and Learning Science, National Academy, of Mathematical and Sciences, American Academy of Pediatrics.
We have our own public education standards in Seattle Public Schools, as I've mentioned, OSPI, WASDA.
We have the ITSE and ASCD, which I mentioned earlier.
We have some great documents that are being provided to us from some of our partners in the public and community, specifically around common sense media, has been very helpful for some of the things that we're doing in crafting some of our behaviors.
So what does the research suggest or say?
Well, it's a little bit of everything.
It depends on what you want it to say.
And when we're saying specifically about technology, some of the evidence is, the first one, is that quality matters more than quantity.
It's not how much technology you're using.
It's the intentionality behind the technology that you're using.
Number two, that educational technology is particularly impactful to underserved students.
And that, I think, is something I just want to hang on a little bit here because of our previous presentation.
So if it's particularly impactful for underserved students, it can expand access to educational resources.
provide individualized academic support for students.
It can assist students with disabilities, support our multilingual learners, and create opportunities for advanced learning that might otherwise not be available to students.
And so we're not putting the cognitive load on the student to figure out all this by themselves.
as a district, as a system, we are wanting to support our students in being able to utilize these in intentional ways.
And so what we should be especially thoughtful is ensuring that the students who have the fewest resources outside of school are not disadvantaged when they come into school in Seattle Public Schools.
So equity is still at the center of what we're trying to do with technology.
It's just shifted from just a device to not only just access, but how to use it also matters.
And that's where our behaviors are changing and shifting.
and the three and four is consumer technology and ed tech are not the same thing.
Getting on your favorite website to shop is consumer technology.
What we're talking about is specifically using educational technology for learning and teaching.
And then also implementation significantly affects the effectiveness and that's where the professional learning comes in.
So how much technology?
Great question.
And what you see these fine signs that are around the room is we're changing and adjusting.
We're changing and adjusting our guidance on how much technology.
But what's getting us to these time limits or these maxes or just specific guidance is the following questions.
we must be mindful about both the amount of technology our students are interacting with as well as the quality and the intentional use.
And so what we want our educators asking is, does this support learning?
And students, you should be asking that same question too.
How does this support my learning or not support my learning?
Does it improve access?
Does it improve access to some of the groups of students who are just a few of the groups of students that exist within our system, but does it improve access?
And are students creating, communicating, and thinking?
That is a big concern for everyone involved, for both students, for families, for community.
is that if by interacting with technology that it might be taking off the cognitive load for students is a concern.
And so again, are students creating, communicating, and thinking?
And then the last one, is the use developmentally appropriate?
What's developmentally appropriate for a second grader is not the same thing for one of our 11th graders or a senior.
So as a student goes through Seattle Public Schools, what we think you'll see and recognize tonight is that it changes as a student ages through our system.
And as you see around the room, some of the things that we just want to make sure that we're always concerned about is that learning comes first.
that it's intentional and purposeful.
I think you can feel the repetitiveness of what I'm stressing tonight because of what we believe is really important for our students and our educators.
So some of the things that we're talking about right now, and I'll just not go through all of these, I'll just pick out one example, is what we want to be mindful of as if I were a teacher, what I would be thinking about.
and one, the first thing I would want to know is what's the learning goal for my student or my students or my class and I'd want to know is there a technology that I'm wanting to use or wanting my students to interact with and then what tools are available to me in Seattle Public Schools and one of the things that I heard from our earlier presentation about Emerge was just talking about, it was alluding to fluency.
And so here's this, a small miniature micro example of how technology could be being used in a classroom on the intentional use of technology from a teacher to her students.
And so with Emerge, we have a platform where a student can record their reading fluency.
and what a student can do that, they can do that independently on a device, record it, upload it, send it to the teacher and when the teacher's available and can look at that, can listen to that, give the student feedback written and send it back to the student in real time.
And why that's important is because for our students, think about, well, maybe not some of our high school students, but maybe this is, I'm dating myself.
When we were thinking about fluency, what would happen a long time ago is that we would get a textbook and you just read a paragraph and each of us would read it out loud and you just go around the room and what all of us would be doing, all of us veterans, would be counting the paragraphs, counting the people and knowing which one am I going to be reading and I got to read this and I'm going to be practicing and I'm not listening to anything you're saying or what's going to come after me.
I'm just listening and trying to figure out what I'm going to say so I don't mess up in front of the class.
that's not fluency but that was taught as fluency and so for us the ability to use these small things intentionally well for educators is we want to give them the access and the tools but also we want our students to be able to know how they should be using them and then also how they shouldn't be using them
Yeah, I mean, Mike and I could probably spend 100 hours showing really examples, one after another after another, about how technology, when used thoughtfully, is incredibly powerful.
So I see one of these things are about science, understanding complex ideas.
is running predictive models, running explore predictive models.
One of the things that you can do is you can put inputs, let's say, about snow levels or rain levels and how that works or wind.
That's not something you can do without technology.
And then you say, OK, if the wind is at this miles per hour, what happens to a building?
What happens to a tree?
Then you up it.
Then you see.
And you can start to adjust.
There are things that technology can do that's light years away from when I was in high school.
And I wouldn't want to keep that away from children.
But I think, again, where we've been before is just throw all technology at children and not be thoughtful about what we're using.
and this is where we lean on our teachers and our educators and of course Mike and the team and Deb and everybody here saying, are we using technology in a thoughtful, controlled way that actually is leading towards those learning goals?
Is it understanding complex ideas?
Is it strengthening essential skills?
And again, I think that we as a district and really as a community of educators around the country haven't been thoughtful enough about being clear about how to use it again for good or just letting people use it and then not basically getting good outcomes for our children.
So one of the things that is I think just a great demonstration of our responsiveness to community, to our educators, and to our students is that we're changing and adjusting our prior guidance about technology usage.
And so earlier in the fall, we announced our K-2 guidance from kindergarten through second grade that we were no longer going to be a one-to-one district and that we were going to limit the maximum amount of time on technology to 30 minutes per day.
Tonight we're announcing that in grades three through five that we will no longer be a one-to-one district, that students can still have access to computers, but they will not be issued a computer.
So we will no longer be a one-to-one district, K-5.
And then for our older students in grades three through five, they will have a maximum amount of screen time or interaction with technology of 60 minutes per day.
and how we came up with that number is we listened to our educators, we listened to our principals who spoke with their teachers and it was kind of a Goldilocks effect, how much is too much, what feels right, 90 dozen is too much and so we're going with 60 minutes, we're gonna be responsive and listen to our educators.
If it needs to go down, we'll go down.
If we need to maintain, we'll maintain.
If we need to change or adjust, we will do that based on what our educators are saying.
we would expect that to go into effect in January of 2027. Give our educators a little bit more time.
Less time than the K2 staff had, but I think they've been adjusting very well, very quickly.
And then also, what you'll see there is YouTube is now blocked.
Thank you.
will be blocked on Monday, so get your last searches in while you can, kids, is that YouTube is blocked beginning Monday on all student devices K-5.
and then in addition to that Minecraft which was we heard from community was a very big concern that students were engaging and had access to that is also blocked K-12.
So one of the things that we want to make sure that we're being responsive to is that no device should be used as incentives for free time or rewards.
There's got to be other creative great things that kids can buy into and teachers can support that do not include the use of technology for those purposes.
Yeah, I can't stress this one enough.
You know, I've spent a lot of time in our schools, visiting all the schools, thousands of classrooms.
And where I saw technology being, let's call it abused, was when it was used as a reward or an incentive.
And what it really was was, hey, here's your laptop.
Go have fun.
Children will have fun and they will go to places that they're probably not supposed to.
And so if we're, again, being thoughtful and intentional about how to use technology, great.
But if we're using it as free time or reward or incentive, then that's not actually using technology for a good.
And so that piece, I was so thrilled when I saw Mike put this up because this, more than probably anything else, was how I was seeing technology be abused within our schools.
And I also want to highlight this about YouTube and Minecraft.
The reason why it took us a little bit of time here was that we had to talk to our teachers and say, look, if we block YouTube, is that going to impact some of your curriculum?
And we, of course, wanted to get rid of YouTube the moment I got here.
But what we were hearing from some teachers was, well, I actually do use it for things, and I do want the kids to use it for things.
and so that's why we were able to spend some time with our faculty, with our ed directors, and we feel right now at K-5 that we really can do this and not impact too strongly any of the work that our wonderful professional educators do.
Now, Minecraft is a really interesting one, and I think it highlights why this isn't the simplest thing we can do.
We actually have classes that use Minecraft in a very thoughtful way, especially some students with disabilities or special needs.
and they use it as world building, they use it as thoughtful construction and spatial recognition.
So we don't want us to be just like, hey, Minecraft is all blocked.
What we're saying is it's blocked for our children K-12 except in the class where the teacher is using it in a very specific way.
But again, if we're taking away the time for incentive and free time and rewards, then that's where this kind of really comes from.
So this is not as easy as it might seem because we do know that there are instructional uses of some of these things.
Getting rid of YouTube K5, I'm thrilled with, and certainly no Minecraft K12 unless it's actually part of a classroom with a teacher, then we feel really comfortable with this.
Just Minecraft, not other video games.
Driven by data, like you're looking at data, what is most egregious use?
Yeah.
I mean, we are happy if any community member wants to give us lists of things they would like us to block, we are certainly happy to do that.
But again, When you're taking away the usage during free time and rewards and incentives, we really do hope that that is it.
And I'll defer to Carlos.
Throughout this time, we are trying to block as many things as we can once we know about them.
Minecraft was the one that we had overwhelming families say, hey, could you guys do this?
And we said, let us look into it.
to be honest, we did it, then we heard from a teacher, hey, wait a second, you just erased all of my children's work.
And we go, aha, I get it.
And so we went back, we were able to retrieve that work, but we were still then able to not allow it for everybody else.
We do filters for games besides the ones in YouTube.
But what we heard the most from the community is that kids were getting to YouTube and downloading and opening windows with games, the interactive games.
So this will be a good block.
Yeah, YouTube was a gateway to things.
And so by shutting off YouTube, it was shutting off some of the gateways.
Kids are very smart.
Kids really very, very smart.
I had a sixth grader during COVID, and all he did was watch YouTube and try to hack the district's firewalls.
And then my third grader was on a trampoline.
It was good times.
We have come across some of those students, and I want to hire him.
OK.
So let's see.
Can we go to the next slide, please?
One more.
We want to go to the next section.
There we go.
So in the sake of time, I'd like to be able to hand it over to Carlos, who's going to be specifically speaking about keeping students and data safe and the number of things that we do in Seattle Public Schools to make that happen from him and he and his team.
saying that Mike and Deborah did touch about some of the policies that we have for the district, but we operate under the bigger umbrella because we have state requirements that we have and we have federal requirements that we have to follow.
So it is a combination of how do we secure the network and how we balance all these regulations and laws.
So let me see how to move on to this.
So what DOTS supports the academic side is we're providing all those tools that he's talking and we vet the tools as we go and protection of the data as well.
We provide all this instructional technology when there's a requirement for a piece of software or a platform, we facilitate that.
We facilitate the software governance, which I'm going to be speaking here a little bit.
And then infrastructure devices, you know, computers, the network, we oversee over 100,000 endpoints in the network.
So there's a lot of architecture that we have to cover.
Data governance and privacy, this is how we protect the data, whether there is whether there is data agreements that we have to do with the vendors or any other requirements that are given by the state or the federal laws.
Also, the cybersecurity, we have a pretty robust three-people cybersecurity team.
They're great.
They manage all the risk, monitor the network, and they're on top of any malicious activity that happens in our network.
And then we have audits and compliance of all those controls that we put in place that translate to those laws and regulations.
We actually, the last audit that we have on the cybersecurity side, we did fairly well.
The auditor was very happy about us.
So what kind of mechanisms we use to protect the data and the network?
I always say that cybersecurity is the job of everybody, from the top to every student out there.
So we do a lot of training of our people, recognizing how to handle information, how to handle data.
Part of one of our requirements is for the SIPA, where we have to teach kids how to operate safely online.
Then we have processes.
We have one new process for the software reviews.
We have processes for data classification, vendor management.
We looked at when the academic side looks at some of the tools, we also went in on the AI risk that it might bring to the network.
We have a lot of dependencies on the network.
We've got to make sure that we test a platform through before it touches our premises.
Making sure that it adheres to ADA compliance, cybersecurity, and so on.
And then the technology, this is all our guys in the background, you know, making sure the identity and the access controls are working appropriately, that we have encryption and approved storage for the data.
Also managing the devices and the well filtering I mentioned earlier, over 100 endpoint devices.
That's vectors that we have to take care of.
And then monitoring in the detection and backup recovery.
I know that a focus of this conversation really is EdTech, but I want to give Carlos and the team a lot of credit Education facilities are one of the most hacked organizations in America.
Knock on fake wood, because of the work that Carlos and the team have done, we have not been taken over like many, many school districts and universities have.
And so when we talk about the hundreds of thousands of endpoints and devices and just technology backbone that we have because of the way that we do work, I've been very, very impressed.
And I think Carlos and the team need some real kudos for that because it has been brutal as just an educator in America to see my friends lose weeks of school.
I mean, Lansing Community College, when I was superintendent in Lansing, had to shut down for days because they were unable to actually function because somebody had hacked them and taken away their ability to run.
So I do want to highlight that as a part of this piece.
So thank you, Carlos.
And as we bring new systems on board, we do actually do some continuous improvement, you know, to make sure that we're always on top of the new technology.
Mike mentioned earlier, you know, every day there's a new piece of technology out there that we need to worry about and put the controls, you know, that are available to make sure that it doesn't affect us.
Let me get here.
Okay.
Thank you, about the team.
I actually have, I gotta think first, we have our Chief Information Security Officer present, Robbie.
and his team.
They've been doing a lot of work on this Google.
I'm going to start with the filter because I'm excited about telling about this.
Google search Gemini.
A while back ago, the SVET brought some concerns and we heard a lot of concerns.
We thought we blocked all energetic AI on the network.
you name it, Cloud, Grog, all of those.
And we keep monitoring for any other tools that come out of there that are similar to energetic AI.
That has been blocked.
We had a problem with the Google search where the kids can go do a search and they come back with a recommendation, an AI recommendation, You click on it, and it takes you to a chat.
So that's how the kids were getting around it.
So what we're doing is we're going to block it by getting in touch with our vendors securely, and they came out with a package to do an upgrade to our software that will block completely that loophole.
Now, when we tested it, we found out that it also works in other searches, like Bing and Edge.
So I think it's a great win for the district.
And again, this is to highlight the open dialogue we have with our families, especially SFIT.
But we knew this was an issue.
It was brought to us.
It was told repeatedly, this is something you need to deal with.
And we were.
Now, I appreciate sometimes this is a big ship.
We don't act as quickly as maybe we could.
But the fact that within about a month or two, the ability to get this done is a big deal.
Now, I do appreciate that there's been some news about Google and some of their conversation about the use of Gemini.
But we are not really a big Google district.
We are much more on the Microsoft.
I mean, surprise, surprise, we are Seattle.
And so because of that, there's some of the things that you might be reading about in the news.
We don't think it's really impactful for us, but we are certainly looking into it.
This is very, very new information, like the last two days.
But the good news is, Carlos and the team, to block Gemini also meant blocking a lot of the other things as well.
So we do believe that this is there.
There was a loophole.
We also know our students are brilliant.
And if they find another loophole, we will try to address that as well.
So let us know if they do.
Absolutely.
But I think this is a really big win because this was this backdoor into generative AI and Gemini and some of the other issues that we were dealing with.
Let me add to that.
How I mentioned earlier, when we bring a new system on board, we bring software, we do a lot of testing to make sure the dependencies, whether it's for software architecture or network architecture.
So we did a pilot before we decided, yes, we're ready to do this.
We did a pilot with eight schools, a mixture of high schools, middle schools, and KAs in high schools.
The kids did the test and they all come up positive that we could block it efficiently.
So that's good news.
It looks like one of our student board directors has a question.
Is this a clarifying question?
Okay.
I think we're gonna hold, like, unless it's a clarifying question, we'll hold all of our questions to the end.
Does that work?
Okay, great.
Carlos, can you, for the listening public, let people know when this is taking effect again?
Yes, that was gonna be my next comment.
Both, I'm sorry, all of them, Minecraft block, the Gemini AI block loophole, and the YouTube, those are actions that are gonna be performed this weekend.
and they're going to be in effect starting on Monday.
Now, let me change a little bit of direction here.
As part of our software, it's been an issue for quite a bit of years.
As a matter of fact, when I got here, I started trying to reduce some of the software, and it's just been built up over the years.
Who knows how many years before me?
But what we found out about two years ago, there was about a thousand pieces of software in the network, and that causes a lot of concerns, because some of them we didn't know they even existed.
and that could be channel IT where data, you know, someone at a school can grab a piece of information that's protected, put it in the network and we don't know.
So we started digging into that.
Also, the schools were able to purchase their own software, so we didn't have an inventory of what that looked like.
So as far as the cost, we couldn't actually see if it was duplicates on the network or not of that same software.
So we're spending probably two, three times the amount of money that if we were to get an enterprise license.
So that was one of the major issues.
So the goal is to holistically handle this at an enterprise level and make clear distinctions of, is this software meeting the needs of the academics?
and operational needs.
Also, there's going to have more visibility at the leadership level for accountable decisions, both in budget and value, academic value to the district.
And obviously, the TALFO stewardship of funds in the data.
We find out that some of the schools were using general fund money.
So we're flipping that over to the tech to save those dollars on that side.
I think the entire community of Seattle knows I've been talking about how we have no money and that one of the things that we were trying to do is cut down bloat.
This is a perfect example.
we had over 2,000 different softwares.
No school district needs 2,000 different softwares.
In addition, what we were finding were individual schools were purchasing the same software repeatedly.
so you can imagine how much money one could save is if instead of doing that you could either have a district purchase or you actually don't need some of this software in addition as Carlos was saying we have this amazing wonderful capital levy thank you voters of Seattle and what that levy allows us to do is to use some of that money for technology as well as capital.
But we were using operational money for this.
So now because of the work that Carlos has done and the team is we're bringing these things to the central office and bringing it to cabinet where we're able to shift the dollars from operational to levy and that is a dollar save every time you do that.
I think in the last two months we've saved something like $200,000 just by sitting and going, wait a second, does this need to be in operations or could it be in levy?
And then, do we even need this?
And so sometimes we say no, we don't need it.
Off it goes.
And sometimes we say we actually do need it, but we can move it towards levy, which is again a pure dollar-for-dollar savings.
To the workflow process that Ben just mentioned, we're looking, we created this portal where users can input the request, ensuring that they, you know, tell me what's the purpose, what's the use, the cost, funding, what is it coming?
And then there's a cross-functional review, both academic and the technology.
Mainly in the academic, the value of the ADA compliant.
There's a cyber security check.
There's many checks that we do cross-functional to make sure that that that piece of software will deliver what the requirement is.
From there, once it's reviewed, that piece of software goes out to leadership, like you mentioned, and that's where we make the decisions, and that's where we've been catching a lot of the duplicates coming in, and we are moving forward, you know, appropriately taking this into consideration.
And then once it's decided if it is approved by Cabinet or not, it goes into a catalog that we have implemented on Atlas, our warehouse, that tells users, yes, this software is allowed for you to buy or this is not allowed for you to buy.
So that is an editing process that we started working this year.
And we're fixing it as we go, but it seems to be working fairly well so far.
So just to add to this, this is what we review on that cross-functional, the data privacy issues, you know, data collection, use sharing, you know, all the compliance with the federal and state guidance, our cybersecurity, you know, encryption vulnerabilities that piece of software might have, or any risk that they might bring to the, you know, and then the ADA accessibility, it makes sure they have, by law, we're supposed to have something called VPAC that is deterring that software is applicable for students with disabilities.
and then the technical, obviously the technical value, can we support it?
Can we pay for it?
Does it even make sense?
Does it break something if we install this?
And then lastly, the curriculum, which is the most important part of this, what is the instructional value audience and the existing tools that we might have that duplicated that we can shrink to just one enterprise license?
So basically, you know, be intentional about how do we support software, you know, and meet our needs, supportable, and then align to the academic goals of the district.
You want to talk to this one?
No, I'm talking to this one.
So let me talk a little bit about Community Engagement, I'm not sure a lot of people know, but we have a committee, the Information Technology Advisory Committee.
It was instituted back in 2018 with the purpose of planning, advising, and representing the community.
It is composed of three students, A staff and we have a mix of teachers, union members, central staff, you name it.
There's a big mix on that one.
And then if we get eight parents or community partners, could be experts in technology, they might want to be part of the committee.
That's where we get these eight.
It basically just, they help us with a lot of feedback and thinking and brainstorming about long range planning.
analyzing the tools, they will always bring briefings to ITAC before we even execute anything to ensure that we haven't missed something.
Could be, I don't know, 88 something or conflict with something in the community, you name it.
We also bring the budget, the technology budget, monthly for them to review it and ask questions on where the money's being spent and such.
They meet every month on the third Monday of every month.
We post the agenda the week before and it has a link for anyone to want to come to join us and listen.
We do meet, we're going to start meeting here on Central, and that information is going to be online.
We're going to be here in Central, but at the same time we're going to have a hybrid meeting because there's people that might want to take it from home.
So they voted last month to have it, you know, hybrid.
Pause for a quick second.
Director Lavalle has a clarifying question.
Yeah, I just wanted to check, is this for kind of that planning of the actual technology that we're purchasing, or is this planning on how it is being applied in the classrooms within this committee?
I would say both.
And it's been a, let me get to the next slide.
If this works.
Can you go to the next slide, please?
Can you move the slide, please?
So this is all the areas and priorities that we look into.
And one of them that's been increasing, and we have our first meeting last October 26th.
There was a lot of interest and establishing a subcommittee so we can address a lot of the AI and the EdTech.
We have done that in the past, but I think we're going to be more intentionally hitting that very hard this year.
So we do both.
to bring the best side of technology to meet the goals of the district and things that we need for, I don't know, networks, technology, frameworks and stuff.
Carlos, can I jump in here real quick?
Sure.
One of the things that's going to be evolving with ITAC specifically is that there will be some subcommittees that will be coming as a result of that, which hasn't been the traditional work, because what we're trying to reimagine, repurpose for them, not with their overall goal and purpose as directed through school board policy, but to be a representative group being able to meet with community, be able to hear from community, not just through staff, but through the representatives, and so that they're truly a representative group.
So we look forward to changing and evolving and being responsive to schools and also community about how ITAC traditionally has worked with a smaller group to be more of a representative group that's being responsive and bringing the issues and ideas from people who are outside of iTech to the group as well.
Let me end by saying the 26, 27 membership, great folks.
We have a full house now.
We have 18 members and there are 23 that we selected because four of them are alternates.
Out of this new year, we got about 15 people that are new.
The way it works is every year around summer, we put an application online and we We make sure that we do the communications out to the community and the folks in the district to apply for it.
I mean, anyone at home that want to apply for this, please.
We have the application going on summer.
They served for one year with the ability to volunteer for another year, and that's it.
But, you know, how I said, we got great folks on board.
We just did the onboarding last month, and they went to work.
I mean, we briefed the communications project, which is looking into reducing the amount of communications tools in the district.
websites, you know, letters and all that.
And they gave us a pretty good feedback, you know, for being so new, they did great.
So I'm expecting that this is going to be a great year with ITAC and, you know, trying to make all these decisions that we have done, you know, a little bit better.
So with that, I think, yeah.
Okay, Director Briggs, here we go.
We're gonna accelerate a little bit here.
So one of the things that we wanted to make sure that we were intentional about was that we were speaking about the entirety of educational technology and that we saved talking about AI for the end very intentionally because it's just a small part but a very big part that everyone has an opinion about, about AI.
And so one of the things I think is just really important as we move along through this is that when we're talking about AI specifically, that people have feelings, their values, their attitudes, their beliefs, their opinions that are all across a continuum.
And they change, some stay the same.
And so we're not advocating as a school system for one extreme or the other.
What we're advocating when we're talking about specifically AI literacy is the knowledge that it exists for our students.
That we have a duty as an educational system to educate our students on this, not necessarily for them to interact with it, but if they are going to interact with it, that they do so knowledgeably, with some skill, as best as we know it, because none of us in this room have certainty about where we think it is going to go.
We have some ideas, but it's always changing as Ben just spoke about a few minutes ago about what Google's announcing.
That just happened two days ago and we're just now talking about this.
Technology is always changing and very adaptable.
One of the things that we know about AI specifically is that for school districts, school districts are basically doing this on their own.
they're doing it individually.
They're figuring it out on their own, and that's why it's so important for Seattle Public Schools to be reaching out to other districts within the state, across the country, to learn what they're doing, what we're doing.
We have some things and resources that districts are just clamoring for, specifically around our digital literacy, our AI guidance, our AI handbook.
and some of the tools that we've been doing and sharing.
And so one of the things that I'd like to make sure is an emphasis is that, again, if students do choose to interact with AI, that they do so safely, ethically, and responsibly.
And here's one of the things that I know for our students, with 100% certainty, I don't say 100% too often, but this is as close as I can get to it.
I know what our students are concerned about.
If you talk with our students, students are concerned about the cognitive decline, their own cognitive decline.
Are they learning or not?
and for a student to say that, that's a vulnerable place to be, to actually admit that.
In some of the small groups that Deb has conducted with some of our focus groups, students have discussed a number of issues, but this is one that consistently comes up.
So if students are concerned about their cognitive decline, Students are also concerned about job security and their job aspirations because what they used to think about was a possibility or reality may be changing, it may not be there, and that causes them some discomfort and uncertainty and anxiety.
And another thing that I know our students are very much concerned about is academic integrity for themselves, for their peers, for their educators, for their teachers.
And so if our students are concerned about their cognitive, potential cognitive decline, their job security and job aspirations and academic integrity.
I'd say parents and community have that same concern.
Parents and community are also concerned about issues of academic integrity.
They're also concerned about their own job security and aspirations and how AI is impacting them on the daily, not only personally but also professionally.
But when it comes to their students, to their kids, they're also concerned about their potential cognitive decline.
Are they learning?
and so when we're talking about AI, AI is a tool.
It's a thing that could be the wrong tool, the wrong thing and it could be potentially the right tool and the right thing if it's used intentionally.
What we're trying to be clear about, it's not a binary choice.
It's not either you are or you're not.
when we think about AI, we are all interacting with it either intentionally or passively every single day if you're using any type of technology.
And some of the data that we're gonna share with you reinforces that.
So the role of education in our community is how we're informing our approach and how our approach is changing.
And so one of the things I think is important is for some level setting, Let me move this one more.
Come on.
Is when we're talking specifically about AI, some just general terms for the public is that when we're talking about AI is technology that enables computers, machines to simulate human learning, comprehension, problem solving, decision making, creativity and autonomy.
It's data mining.
Generative AI, which we've heard a lot about.
Sometimes people can inflate generative AI and AI in general, but when we're talking about generative AI, it's deep learning models that can create complex original content.
Some would say it's original, some would argue it's not original content.
And some of the things that it can be high quality, it's long form text, It creates images, realistic video, audio, and that leads to this third one is about like deep fakes, agents, bots.
There's a number of issues around AI which our students and our adults and our teachers also need to be equally aware of and literate in.
Next slide please.
Thank you.
I'm gonna let Deb talk about this next slide specifically.
I think that's very important for what AI looks like in Seattle Public Schools classrooms.
So we've been working on the reality of AI for a few years now, the digital learning team, knowing that our educators were going to be using AI, knowing our students were going to be using AI, like what we talked about before, we do feel very strongly that our educators need to be prepared for the technology that they experience, as do our students.
So one of the first things we did was get some approved tools out there.
It's much easier to say only use certain things if you've actually approved tools.
So that was where Magic School and Copilot that use started.
We also felt very strongly that we wanted to protect data privacy.
That's why we approved those tools.
Those are specifically tools that we have purchased.
They are tools where we exist in our own tenant.
We have done a lot of work with educators and with work you'll hear later where AI literacy is really important.
And so while we're protecting data privacy in the tools, it's important that the user also protects data privacy with what they put in the tools.
Everything should be verified and any use of AI, it is back to any use of technology.
The goal is student learning and student thinking.
If you are using AI, it should be in conjunction with that goal.
We also, in talking to students, there was a lot of concern about transparency around AI use.
They knew educators were using AI and yet there wasn't a lot of discussion in classrooms.
And we felt like that was something that was important, that there needed to be a conversation.
We couldn't talk openly about AI literacy and what AI looked like for them.
if we didn't feel comfortable speaking about it in classrooms.
And a lot of students, in fact a previous board member, was saying that they did not feel comfortable talking about it at school because they were worried about being thought of as that they were cheating.
And then we wanted to make sure we were applying an equity and inclusion lens.
We know these tools are available to our students, especially students that have the access that a private machine would give them.
So we wanted to make sure that we were giving all of our students access to the learning about this technology that they were going to experience.
Oops.
So again, what we're always trying to strike is a balanced approach in how we're approaching issues around educational technology.
So specifically around AI is we want to make sure that first and foremost our students have AI literacy.
K-12 that they're at least at the younger ages that they're at least aware of it, what it is.
We're not expecting them or wanting them to interact with AI, but we want them to be able to be knowledgeable that it exists and what it is.
And then also we want to be able to provide guidance to our educators and we want to provide them safe tools.
so it should always be human-centered.
If you visit our website, you'll see all of our AI handbook and we stress this very strongly that it should always be human-centered and learning-centered is why you would interact with AI if you're going to intentionally.
Some of the Data that we're seeing I think is really interesting and I think this will resonate with many in the room is that students are using AI intentionally and unintentionally.
So 86% of youths 9 through 17 have used or interacted with AI.
75% have interacted with AI generated summaries and search results.
78% of youth have used AI access on a personal device.
Now, we're talking about one-to-one devices in Seattle Public Schools.
We're talking about all the technology in Seattle Public Schools.
The likelihood of a student interacting with AI is more likely on a family-issued device than it is a Seattle Public Schools device.
But it doesn't matter how they're interacting with it.
What our job as educators is to educate our students to be thoughtful, to be knowledgeable.
Consumers, if they are going to consume or interact with AI, we want them to be aware of the risks, the limitations, the bias.
There's all types of things that it has potential, but when you look at this data here, 49% of our teens have not discussed what AI is and how it works with a teacher.
So what that tells us, and you'll see some of the actions that we've taken as a school district about why we're trying to address that gap right there.
44% of teens say a parent or guardian has not talked to them about using AI safely.
Adults, many of us, if we were talking about our own AI literacy, have a lot of growth and understanding, let alone for ourselves, let alone how we would talk with our own kids about it.
There's a lot out there that we don't know.
And here's the thing that I think is important.
If you wanted to ban AI, if you wanted to ban access during the school day for our students, 44% of teens who use AI for schoolwork, had an AI tool blocked or banned on a school network or school-issued device.
Great.
But 59% of those students got on a personal device to access it after it was blocked.
So they're still interacting with it.
and for us as educators and as a community is we need to solve this one together and it's not just Seattle Public Schools and so that's why we are being responsive to community about how it is that we're responding.
And so one of our problems of practice is last year we came to this group here and we were talking about our AI policy, our AI handbook and what we understood was that we needed to be clear with our parents and our community and our educators and our students about what our expectations for AI use was and what it's not.
And so we did this, a lot of thinking, a lot of planning to come up with a way that we could publicize, get the word out there about what it is that we're doing around AI for our communities and our parents.
and so what we want our students to know is that if they are going to work with AI that it's literacy, their AI literacy.
Again, I want to get back.
Oops.
Project SAIL is Seattle AI literacy.
And Project SAIL is focused on that problem of practice, is that we needed to better communicate with our communities.
our teachers and our students about what our AI policies are.
And so one of the areas of focus is communicating our clear AI literacy to groups.
That's one of the reasons why we're here tonight.
Preparing our school leaders and our teacher leaders for training and support, which we did this summer at our school leader engagement session.
We had over 500 educators where we went over our project sale PowerPoint and presentation and gave guidance for what we would be expecting every single school to be working with their school communities to say what their AI guidance is as a school or as a classroom.
and then also delivering K-12 instruction for our educators.
So these icons, and for people who didn't attend this training but somehow the people were liking the presentation that I shared at SLI and they were sending me these questions about about Project SAIL, and this is SAIL Public Schools' AI Literacy.
And it's just based on a stop signal or a light signal, you know, red, yellow, green.
We all understand what red means.
It means to stop, yellow, proceed with caution, and green, go for it.
And what the default, default, position in classrooms for educators is it should always be red.
It should always be red unless the teacher decides and agrees with our students about why it might be yellow and why it might be green.
and why we did that was it's easily understood.
It means something.
People might not agree with it, but at least you know it.
And a year ago, we couldn't have said with certainty that people were even aware of this.
So part of this campaign was to raise awareness.
One of the things that we've done is focused on professional learning for our educators, our teachers, and we've done that and turned that around in a very short amount of time.
And one of the feedback that we got last year was, so how do you know that teachers are actually aware of this?
and so we created a mandatory course.
And one of the things that you can see here is this is from Common Sense Media and why I'm showing this slide is to show how we're aligned and how we're evolving and being responsive as a school system.
So common sense media with some people in the community have brought this forward to us and what you see in K2, it's just for our students is that they don't expect them and want them interacting with AI.
It's just awareness.
As they get older, they have some interaction with it.
They just know how it works in the grades three through five.
Six through eight, they have some guided practice with an adult who's monitoring, teaching them how to use it, what are the limitations, and for our high school students, it's not just opening up the flood gates, it's giving them guided practice as well so that they can be informed consumers.
So when you see this, which some of the folks have mentioned about, you see this poster in schools, Well, I'm glad you're seeing the poster in schools, but what you might not know is that our default is that AI guidance should always be read.
It should be read unless the teacher says something different.
But for our K2 students, you'll see it says in the middle, and I know it's hard to see here, but maybe it's easier online, it says AI Literacy Awareness K2, and then literacy and engagement 3.5.
And one of the things that we're beginning to recognize is we might need to adjust that guidance based on what we're going to be hearing from ITAC and community and our educators.
But what we always want to be responsive to anything, and specifically around AI, is that it changes so much, and it changes so fast, we're trying to have a conservative, pragmatic, realistic approach for our students, first and foremost, and their safety, but also for our educators and their ability to be able to use it effectively.
Here's our resources.
Folks, please visit our website and check out our resources.
We have a plethora of resources that many districts are asking us for.
It details our project plan.
But I'll just end on this last note here.
In three months' time, so this summer, what we in the digital learning team helped create was a digital learning professional development that was required for all educators around AI and our guidance.
Seven weeks into school, We've had nearly 3,000 educators take and pass that course.
We've had 240 educators trained during our tri-day.
We've had 104 schools impacted by that training.
And what you'll notice here, which is the consistency of the guidance of AI specifically, is that the younger students, developmentally appropriate, is you'll see our elementary educators and K-8 educators, 55% of them so far have taken the course and passed it, 60% of all middle school educators, and nearly 70% of high school educators have taken and passed that course.
So a year ago, we didn't have that.
Three months ago, we didn't have that.
But now we do, and we're being responsive and try and not only raise awareness for everyone, but making sure that if they are going to interact with it, that it's a tool and that ideally we want our students to ask and be able to answer this most essential question.
What is the AI guidance on this?
So students here, I hope you can ask that question of your teachers.
And teachers, I hope you can give that answer to your students.
Because what that indicates is that an educator has been proactive in their their teaching with their students about AI.
What that indicates is students have the trust that they can ask that question and that they can get an answer that they should be able to demystify and not shame our students if they are going to use AI.
It's probably default should be read.
And if a student asks what is the AI guidance on this, our educators should be able to answer that.
Alright, so that was a lot.
Any more, Dr. Starosky?
Great.
So just in summation, we've had a long conversation about the technology that we do use, we don't use.
Today we're announcing the banning of Gemini AI, Minecraft, and YouTube starting on Monday.
We're going, as we promised, we started with K2, where we did zero to 30 minutes.
Now we're at 3.5 to zero to 60 minutes.
We explained a lot about how we do software, or how poorly we do software, and how we're changing that, thanks to the tech team.
And Mike just went over some of the AI stuff.
I know this is something that people care a lot about.
I will defer to answer as many questions as we can, but please know that this is not the last time we should have this conversation because this is, as you know, incredibly iterative.
So with that, I turn it over to Vice President Briggs and take it away.
Thank you.
I'm gonna open it up to questions from everybody else, but I first have a clarifying question, both for myself and for a number of parents who have actually come up to me this evening and asked about the one-to-one.
What do we mean when we say that at K2?
Because I think what people are confused about is that, does that just mean we're not sending kids home with devices?
Because it sounds like they're still able to use a device on a one-to-one basis at school.
I will defer to Mike.
But what we have heard over and over again is the computers on wheels, having the computers in a kind of a closet, allowing kids to still have access, but access to it when it's needed or when we're using it.
The previous iteration was every kid was assigned a laptop or an iPad, was handed it to them.
It was theirs.
The move, and again, it's taking some time because of the way that we do examination.
is that we're saying there should be a computer that a kid has access to, but that it could be in a computer lab or in a computer on wheels or some sort of closet.
But Mike, you know better than I do.
No, I'd say that's very accurate.
And so what we know with our technology is that students still have to have access to some technology throughout the day because a lot of our curriculum is digital curriculum that students need access to.
Okay, how about if we go around the U this way this time?
That's helpful because I actually have to leave to pick up a child, so thank you.
Somewhere in this presentation it talks about that there was a lot of feedback from elementary school parents.
I actually met with a group of middle school students and they had a lot of feedback.
And I feel like at least the two middle schools in my director district have asked for laptop cards.
Do we have any ability to just, we need to have district standards, but if we have school principals, students that are asking for something, do we have the ability to move a little bit more quickly?
Sure.
urge the principals to reach out to their executive director.
I love that you're speaking to students, and I love that you're speaking to the schools, but certainly if a school would like something like that, they should ask their executive director, and the executive director can get to the tech department immediately.
Yeah, that's great.
I will advise them that.
This presentation is really helpful.
I'm personally very excited to hear about this slide where we're talking about how technology does it enhance learning.
I think we really need to just nail down what is the problem we're trying to solve?
And in each of these examples, is the technology doing something that?
That's right.
that we wouldn't be able to do otherwise.
I am, again, going back to the middle school and I'm just primed to think about that because I talk to the students.
I would love for us to have a deeper conversation about technology.
I think we've made a lot of progress on the elementary and as a parent of both high school, middle, and elementary.
That feels obvious to me.
But the middle school, that's when the kind of brain development, the social skills, it's a very intense time.
And I would love for us to have a little bit of focus on middle school.
Yeah, I really appreciate you saying that, Director Song.
One of the reasons why we started with K-2 and then went to 3-5 is K-2 really, they don't have a lot of tech, and they probably shouldn't have a lot of tech.
So when we said to the teachers, do you mind if we get rid of all of this, they go, sure.
With starting in middle schools, K-6, 7, 8, Some of them have actually computer classes.
They have coding classes.
They have CTE classes.
They have a lot of use of technology.
What we didn't want to do was just ban stuff.
So that's why we are very much talking to those schools.
But I think you're right that starting with the middle schools, that's where the real conversation about the usage of it in a very deep and meaningful way, but just for anybody listening at home or in the audience, the reason why we're not doing a lot of this stuff with middle school immediately is the moment we started to ask middle school teachers, they're like, well, our CTE program and our computer science program and things like that.
So that's why we haven't gone here, but we're absolutely looking at it.
In the data that we received back from our principals, just on a very simple survey, was very consistent elementary K-8.
And then when you got to middle school and high school, it just went all over the place.
And so that just indicates for us that we need to have further discussions.
All right.
Can I go, Evan?
Are we going this way?
All right.
Thank you.
I have a number of notes here that I took.
I appreciate the existing policy foundation page, not surprisingly.
That's one I was excited about.
And also, not surprisingly, already in my spreadsheet of policy, I've noted the last time those were updated and that it's a problem that they were updated quite some time ago.
So, and then as you noted, Deborah, some of the policies, as in other places, are kind of one-offs that maybe were relevant at the time they were adopted, but are probably not relevant anymore.
And so Joe and I were sort of, you know, a side conversation that we, speaking on behalf of the policy committee, we would be excited to see some proposals or work on those in the near future to get those updated.
Yeah, that's the first thing.
So something about the digital curriculum I'm a little bit, okay, so my understanding when we have gone through the last couple curriculum adoptions was that, I mean, curriculum providers are very much more and more what you get is something that's digital, but of course we have workbooks and the kind of consumables also.
But my sort of understanding is that the kind of the curriculum access more for the instructor was digital, but the students weren't necessarily accessing it digitally.
and then you said something about curriculum access for students just a minute ago.
So I wanted to clarify if that's actually an issue or not because I know like Emerge, it's all tangible.
So what...
Yeah, that's a great distinction is that the majority of the student interface is hard materials the digital component is on the teacher side of things for the most part.
And so that's a great distinction and something that we're seeing definitely play itself out with Emerge, just about the vast amounts of hard materials that we shared last month or two weeks ago with you.
Okay, great.
I just, I wanted to Be very clear about that, because the way that you just set it towards the end sounded a little bit conflicting.
I mean, there is some, certainly, digital stuff for our children.
But as you know, and you've seen it, the overwhelming amount is hands-on, digital, tangible stuff.
So yeah.
I'm so excited that you're blocking YouTube.
I have been asking for YouTube to be blocked since COVID.
I would also say, why not middle school and high school?
Because...
Yeah.
I mean, and I know you said it as a kind of a throw-off, but it's a really good point.
You're saying, hey, look, if we think YouTube is problematic, why wouldn't we ban it 6, 12?
And the reason, again, is working with our staff, working with our principals, there are some pedagogues that are saying, look, I use it for X, Y, and Z.
So again, we're working with them.
Yeah.
This is where we're trying to go as quickly as possible.
I mean, I'm ecstatic.
I mean, literally, YouTube is just like a window into wasting time and brain cells and all kinds of things.
For kids, especially, who don't have the best impulse control and time management anyway, it's Along those lines, I wanted to clarify.
So again, during COVID, I'm the only one on the board that was here during COVID.
Yes, the adoption of technology at the time is something that's sort of lingering, but I have to say that we have some kind of mindset things that we have to get around generally, that I was one of the leading authors on a resolution to pilot outdoor learning during COVID.
And when we first brought it up, people said, but where will they plug in their laptops?
And I was like, no, they'll be outside.
They'll be outside to play and be together and run around.
They're not going to take their online curriculum and sit outside with it.
And that was not, we had no excuse of, well, we're all just so used to one-to-one devices.
We weren't used to them.
They were new.
And so I just kind of want to point that out, that we do have a tendency, and maybe it's just a human tendency, but it feels more acute in our system for whatever reason that like kind of the same thing with why did we do two grade levels ahead for highly capable?
Well, that's the way that we've always done it.
That's the worst reason to do anything.
And so I just kind of wanted to like, yes, we should have had a lot of opportunities to rethink this since COVID, but also even during COVID, People very quickly were like, no, this is all that we can do.
So it's been a long time coming, but I'm glad we're having this conversation.
I would like to see some iterative, I guess, clarity around YouTube.
Because that was another thing, is teachers said, but I use YouTube for this, and how am I going to teach if I can't use, you know, I have lessons on here that I use every year or whatever.
but teachers can still use them and display them in the classroom, right?
So every student doesn't have to have it on their laptop.
It is also my understanding, and I believe I asked about this during COVID because this was very frustrating, that an adult could download a video from YouTube and share it through the Microsoft, I can't remember what it's called, but there's a way to do that.
And yes, it takes a little bit more planning and foresight, they could still use that same video without opening up the Pandora's box of YouTube.
Absolutely.
And that's where a lot of the professional development comes in as well, to support teachers to use things that they think is really helpful, but also limit access.
But again, this is why you have standardized curriculum, so that you can actually not have those kinds of concerns.
And then also in terms of some of our tendency to be rigid is we need to be really clear about our instruction and support and limitations for our students versus for our educators.
Because I guarantee you there will be someone who said, well, we're not allowed to use it anymore in K-5.
and we'll have to say, no, no, no, the kids aren't allowed to use it.
You're a grown up.
You can still use it, but not for a word, et cetera, et cetera.
So I just, we should just, because things are now thankfully moving a little more quickly, we do need to really be careful that we're clear about that.
Oh, this is kind of a technical question.
Carlos, the workflow for software, so great.
Also seems very basic, but also apparently something that wasn't happening.
With the kind of central oversight to avoid duplication and allow central purchasing and stuff, does that mean that central office is also taking some of that kind of administrative labor from our buildings to do like software updates and repurchases and things?
Or is that something that the principals have to manage kind of continually?
Well, every year there's a request to renew the software.
So it is still going to go through a software committee to see if that piece of software is even needed anymore or not.
So it's built in within the process.
OK.
Great.
ITAC.
Just very quickly, I think this is a really good time to maybe refresh that charter.
Just putting that out there, that things have changed.
Originally, it was a board-created committee to advise the board on technology purchases specifically for the levy.
And I just don't think that's the...
adjusting the purpose makes a lot of sense.
And I think this is my last thing, yes.
So the, I really like that you provided the AI guidance stage, but did you notice that it says no student AI use at this age for K2, which I think is 100% appropriate.
I really don't think I mean, kids learn stuff really quickly.
We don't have to tell them that AI exists.
They'll get it when they're 9 or 10 or whatever.
But to help them understand the media literacy skills and just kind of online stuff in general.
And then it says here that, you know, grades three through five, kids at this age teach how AI works without using it.
Kids at this age are still building the reading, writing, and reasoning skills AI can do for them.
AI literacy is essential and doesn't require devices or AI.
But then our guidance has that K2 AI literacy is awareness of what AI is and ways they interact with it.
And then the 3.5 says that students build literacy and capacity through exposure to and experience using AI in an educational setting.
And it seems like we, like, Yes.
Just bump that.
Yeah.
And so for those in the room, that was intentionally done so to illustrate how we're changing and evolving because we created that first, our version of that.
Then we saw the media matters second.
and so as we're seeing that we're reconsidering say well maybe we should readjust this to make that aligned to that.
That's why I included that as an example.
How we're going to change and evolve.
So we think we're going to move more towards that.
Yes.
That is fantastic.
The one final thing that I'll say is that something that's really interesting about this as compared to maybe some other technologies or things that have come along or I guess it would have happened when we were kids with the internet.
but that the technology and the tool and the thing is new for the adults and the kids at the same time.
And so I'm glad that there's the professional development about educating at age-appropriate levels, but I'm...
I also know a lot of adults are not super comfortable with technology themselves.
So are we also kind of teaching them as adults?
Like, this is what it does and doesn't do.
I'd say Deb and her team, we have a digital learning team that has five people.
Their express mission is to work with our educators to help them get comfortable with the technology because if they're going to be using it, they need to have some level of competency and comfort with it.
And so to be able to do that in a safe space where they're learning together is something that the digital learning team provides.
And I will say, too, that from the presentation a year ago to now, I sort of am hearing that difference.
A year ago, it was very, like, Wait, we're talking about teaching the kids to use it, but the adults don't know how to use it.
And so it seems like things are moving better.
And then really the final, final thing I will say is that as a former post-secondary arts educator, I have always told my students that everybody can learn different tools, but the thing that makes you you and you, well, it was for theater design, so your design is your own perspective that cannot be replaced by any kind of tool.
And I also would like to see a little bit of intellectual property and copyright understanding somehow in here.
I don't know where that comes from, but the understanding of what's referential creation versus an original work versus a copy is something that applies to a lot more things just about intellectual property and thought and creativity.
But thank you.
OK, so first of all, I just want to say I 100% agree with AI literacy.
I think it is extremely important.
I think AI is here.
It's kind of like Pandora's box.
It's not going to go away.
Even if we ban it in school, students are going to find a way to use it.
So I think it's really important that students understand to not go to AI for certain things, like for mental health, to do their assignments.
don't replace AI for source evaluation, so I really like the Gemini thing, because when you look up something on Google and it gives you the Gemini overview, you're not actually seeing if these sources are reliable or not, it's kind of just giving you, I don't know, random fact points.
I do have a question, though, specifically with Magic School.
I'm just wondering, a lot of the wording in this packet is talking about focusing human learning, not replacing AI for doing the work for you, and that AI is supposed to be used as a tool.
So I'm just wondering, could you give me a specific example of how it would be used as a tool specifically for students?
Yeah, so Magic School, you clearly haven't used it yet.
I actually have.
I used it once this whole school year.
I've used it once.
Our teacher had us cross-check it with a rubric, except she didn't know how to use it, so it didn't work, which is another issue.
So you got to experience an AI literacy lesson.
Yep.
So, yes, so I will say there are multiple uses.
We've had teachers set up magic school tools to allow students to, for example, study for a test.
A teacher only has so much time, so many resources to prep, you know, sample tests and sample test banks.
but an AI will continue to ask questions.
And so we've seen things like that.
We've seen doing lessons during class where students have had an opportunity.
One really interesting lesson that happened recently was they had learned about a particular character.
They had read this novel, looked and learned about this character.
and then they interacted with this AI tool that was based in that character, that's what it was supposed to be, and then their job was to evaluate whether they believed this is how the character would react or not.
So the goal was to not only lean into what they understood about that character in that novel, but also how the AI was portraying what the AI understood about that character.
So those are some examples of what we've seen in a high school.
Okay.
I think that's it for now.
I might come back with more questions.
Okay.
All right.
With the 60-minute limit for the upper elementary grades here, I want to know a little bit more about how that was decided.
You had said that there's some flexibility in that.
And as you go forward, you could change that and vary that up.
So why was 60 minutes decided not a 30-minute timeline?
to mirror the lower grades as well, and then be like, hey, is this working?
Are there a lot of people being like, hey, we need to use it for longer?
And go up if you're building in that flexibility with it.
So one of the things that we heard from principals clearly was that they wanted to be a little bit more conservative on the timing.
For them, when students get devices or access to devices, they're using touch typing as a skill.
That's not gonna take 60 minutes of their day.
But what we wanted to make sure was that with the breadth of subject matters that students are going a little bit deeper, spending a little bit more time in math and ELA is the reason why we wanted to go with the 60 minutes.
We're flexible to be able to go down, but we wanted to make sure that it was just not open-ended, and so we're closing it down, and we'll see how it goes from there, but it's more of a trial run in the moment.
Yeah.
I mean, the conversations we had with principals, or at least I had with principals, was they started to do their math in their head and talking to their teachers and saying, OK, well, in fifth grade, if they do, let's say, 15 minutes of math on a computer doing some sort of, like, test prep or getting questions that were getting harder, whatever it was.
Then they were running one Amplify science program in about 15 minutes where they were doing it to do modeling.
Then they were doing a merge for the 20 minutes.
They were already up to about 45. And then if the social studies teacher wanted to use for 10 minutes, or the social studies time used for 10 minutes, they were already getting to like 60. Now, that was the absolute limit.
But what we don't want to do is say, well, the limit's 30, and then everybody goes, oh my god, we can't do it.
It was a feedback from the principals.
To Mike's point, we're happy to go down, but since this is the first foray into this, we didn't want the principals and the staff to immediately freak out.
we thought that an hour was at least the outer limits, and I have no problem.
We did talk about 45 minutes, and then when principals went through a kid's day at an upper L, they said, wait a second, we're really, really nervous.
We might not hit that 30 minutes, or 45 even.
The next question that I have is, you were talking about that You were talking about kind of comparing to what's going on nationally, that everyone's grappling with this issue on an international level at this point in time.
Many districts have severely limited or restricted AI usage.
What conversations have you reached out and had with those people?
What are you following on what they're tracking on and how they're knowing what works and what doesn't?
As you said you were comparing, I'm kind of like, well, what are we looking at in comparing this to?
Yeah, so one of the things that Deb and I interacted with last week was we had a convening with some school districts around the state sharing what it is that we're doing from policy to actual guidance to people who are creating bots within their system using it within central office to write IEPs.
I mean, there's all types of things that people are doing.
We're not there.
I mean, some of the things that you're hearing go, that's not us.
But also what we're hearing is that from other districts is that it is a very isolated endeavor because, say, Puyallup School District went from one swing of the pendulum to the other where they had everything was available to students and then they closed it off in July, July 1, debt and what they're seeing is that that was too much of a swing for the educators because educators were interacting with it in a very specific way and they didn't know how they could or should be using it.
Are they breaking rules now?
Students who had access to a number of things, it just becomes a big management issue for some districts.
But what we see time and time again is that You have to include the school board.
You have to include community.
And what we're seeing is it varies community to community, school board to school board about what people are valuing in the moment.
So I don't see any true consistency except for the need for policy at the state level.
I think in guidance would be helpful and be supportive.
We met with some people from the state.
and they asked us what we would need.
And I think the people who are on the call are very clear that we would like some more clear guidance at the district level around the state.
What I can tell you, certainly my wonderful friends in New York City who made a ban on AI, they've already had to walk it back.
and I appreciate and love that they kind of took that big swing, but we're doing the opposite because of my experience, which is they said we're gonna ban AI and they put all these things on a list and now what's happening is they're walking it back.
software after software after software is being added, being added, and the problem is they're now having to do these one-on-one conversations about what is it, what isn't, and it's caused a lot, a lot of confusions.
I don't want to do that to Seattle.
What I want to be able to do is the opposite, which is let's go step by step.
K2, we feel really comfortable here.
K35, okay, YouTube, Gemini, Minecraft.
I mean, what was happening in New York now is they're saying, wait, this language software for kids needing translations was now being banned, and now a bunch of kids couldn't even get the translations they needed.
So I think we just have to be really thoughtful about what is the end result.
The end game is we want our children to learn it the best possible way, and we know that there are possible uses of technology and there's also a lot of abuses of technology.
But my fear is you ban everything and then you find all these issues and actually end up hurting kids.
And maybe it's a little bit slower and maybe it's a little bit more, I guess, is process-oriented, but hey, it is Seattle, is that I actually think in this case it's a good thing because what you're seeing in New York, there's a great Chalkbeat article about this about a month ago that talked about what happens when you ban everything and then you have to walk everything back.
My last comment was the same kind of as Director Rankins, that this slide that has the red, yellow, green here is different from the previous advice two slides before.
And so I know I heard your answer that you had updated something.
This slide deck wasn't uploaded to the board until this morning, last night.
So there was time to update it.
We're not updating that slide until we've had input from other folks.
So that's to come, but that's accurate as of right now.
Which one is accurate?
He was saying they were going to they're looking at updating the practice to align to the...
That's not our slide.
That's from...
Common Sense Media.
Okay, and so you're looking at updating this one to align with Common Sense Media?
Yes.
Okay, is there any reason why it wasn't updated by the time for this presentation?
Are you bringing it to the committee for update first?
So we're going to bring it to ITAC.
We have our processes internally that we need to follow so that we can make a change like that that withstands a form like this.
The slide is accurate.
The slide represents current practice.
The common sense media, if I'm understanding right, is the recommendation that they're going to move towards, and then they would update the slide.
I mean, I'm happy to make a decision.
But I would like ITAC to at least have a vote on it.
But I think, again, the reason why Mike is putting the common sense one is this is where we would like to go.
I think there's a lot of people who've done a lot of research.
I think the work that was done initially was at least that first foray into trying to do something.
Now, with a lot of the work, a lot of the iteration, we're starting to move.
And that's what you're seeing here is slow change or relatively quick change for Seattle, but getting there.
But thank you for highlighting that.
Do you have any questions?
Katie.
OK.
So my first question was also that same two slides.
And I'm glad we have that clarity on where we are, where we're going.
I do have a question.
There was a slide that had Canva listed as a tool.
And I know that there have been reports of students using generative AI within Canva.
And then there's also the slide that shows Magic School being the approved AI.
So could you clarify just like Do we block generative AI in Canva or is that possible?
So we can block generative AI in Canva.
Canva is a tool that is currently being used by our CTE programs.
There are some schools that are actually utilizing it to teach some AI literacy.
Luckily because of some changes we made last year, blocking it is a possibility at the school level.
and that's one of the things we're gonna talk about with ITAC.
Thank you.
I also, on the 30 minute screen time limit for K2, it's early, but I'm wondering if we could get reports on how well that's being adhered to, if that will be possible, and you might not have the data right now, but when we can, I would love to get updates on how that's going.
I mean my suggestion for my boss is to ask me to do more work is I think that it would be great if after winter break we came back with a kind of early lessons learned so that we can share what we're seeing in the classrooms.
OK.
Look at my notes and decide.
Oh, I did have a question.
I think, Deborah, you had mentioned that there's a model policy to add on to the digital citizenship and media literacy to cover AI.
And I was just wondering what the source of that is.
Is it a WASDA model policy?
Yeah, it is, it's a loss to policy.
Okay, so that will be good to see.
With Director Rankin, I'm looking forward to covering the policy updates.
Oh, and there's also, there was, I think this fall, there was a National AI Student Senate that came up with a national student AI policy recommendation.
Is that something you all are tracking?
OK, I'm seeing nods, so that's good.
Yeah, I mean, the crazy thing about AI, of course, is everybody's talking about it in every facet.
I mean, every superintendent conference I go to, there are sessions about it.
I mean, so there's some really good student work.
There's some student superintendent work.
But I want to be the first one, and not that I would ever say anything about the people at this table.
I will say for myself, We can always learn.
And to you, to the folks in the audience, the people listening at home, if there is information you want to share with us, please do so.
Everything is changing every day.
Google makes the announcement two days ago, and now everybody is spinning.
So we know that we have to learn very, very quickly, and we rely on the community as well as our own expertise in all this.
So thank you.
Okay, and then just the last topic I wanted to touch on is the idea of teaching AI literacy separately from media literacy.
I would actually in some ways push back on that because I think that Dr. Starowski, when he saved the AI piece for last, because AI is actually a very small component of tech, and I would say that even in our focus on AI literacy, that the majority of what we want to teach in AI literacy is really just media literacy.
But you're looking at media that could be coming from different sources.
not to go too far into being like we need to teach all this stuff about AI when really what we're teaching about is just critical thinking and evaluating media.
You look like you might want to respond.
No, I agree.
Thank you.
Okay.
And then my last, last comment on your abstinence only comment, Ben, that no, you don't want to teach abstinence only, but even in sex ed, you teach kids about how to understand and critically evaluate and responsibly navigate situations, but you don't want those situations happening in your school, in your classrooms, necessarily.
Yes, that's right.
That's also, you can learn about AI, and that is separate than just using it.
That's right.
I just, you know, again, we cannot pretend like this doesn't exist, right?
And so this idea of, you know, not to talk about AI is a disservice to everybody.
Now, how we talk about AI, that's what matters, right?
And I think that what we know about pretending like things don't work is that that actually means that people are just using it without us helping them understand how to use it.
And I'm sure, Director Briggs, you have plenty of comments.
And we are coming up on the end of time.
But I do just want to say that my job is using AI every day to create more AI tools.
And that having a culture where there are accepted uses of AI and knowing what it's good at and what it's not good at and what really needs human input is important.
All right, I have a lot of things to say.
I'm gonna try to whittle it down.
Just, I mean, I guess to start, I have not heard anyone say, nor is it my position that anybody should be pretending that AI doesn't exist.
I don't think anybody is advocating for that.
We all know it exists, and we all know it needs to be acknowledged, but as Director Smith pointed out, that doesn't mean that we have to incorporate it into education.
we do need to make sure that the thing that I think is absolutely so essential is that our students are critical thinkers so that they can understand intellectual property and copyright infringement and how many companies are suing AI companies for copyright infringement.
And these are the things that our students need to know about, AI.
This is very complex, and they need to be taught about it.
But what is perplexing to me is how much of the talk around what EdTech is doing for us just feels very based on vibes.
I have seen no data to suggest that there is, in fact, supporting enhanced learning for students.
Nowhere in this presentation was there any data that said, well, ever since we've incorporated Magic School, reading scores have gone up this percent.
We don't have that data.
It doesn't exist.
so we don't know if this is actually enhancing learning but we're making a lot of assertions that we think it does when what we do know is that paper and pencil and critical thinking is actually really good for kids' brains.
So I'm still struggling with why we have bought into this when it's unproven, untested and we do know what does work.
So the other thing that is troubling to me is in a lot of different places I'm seeing, like here on this green, and I know this is gonna be updated, but you can, green AI allowed, you can use AI to help you learn or do this task.
How are kids supposed to know if AI is helping them learn?
I literally do not understand how we are expecting that of children.
To say, oh, I can tell this is helping me learn.
They don't know.
They don't know if it's helping them learn.
They really don't.
I don't know if it's helping me.
I don't know who does know if it's helping them learn.
AI literacy, ability to understand, critically evaluate, and responsibly use AI.
Who knows how to responsibly use AI?
I don't know that we're there yet.
I literally just read over the weekend a horrible, tragic story of a young woman who was living in Seattle, turned to ChatGPT to help her figure out how to taper off her meds, and she ended up dead.
And then ChatGPT's response was, oh, well, this is a very heartbreaking story, but we've come out with a new model since then, so that shouldn't be...
I'm sorry, they're just unleashing this technology that is having these grave consequences and then being like, whoops, well, we've updated it.
That shouldn't happen again.
And so my point is really just I think, speaking of other things I read this weekend, the preponderance of Silicon Valley tech executives who send their children to San Francisco Waldorf School because I think they understand that the kids don't actually need to have this technology in their classroom that is most likely not the best way for them to learn.
I mean, as we have all acknowledged, the kids are smart.
They already know this technology.
They know how to get around it.
They know how to use it.
They're using it all the time.
I don't think that we need to be afraid that we are not exposing the kids to this.
Like, they are exposed.
They are exposed to screens all the time.
Like, their entire lives are screens.
And so I think what a lot of families would love to see is that when they are in school, they are protected from that life.
I appreciate what you're saying, Director Briggs, but I have a real hard time equating that with the story of the person that used ChatGPT to basically get misdiagnosed and do bad things.
I think the entire point of what we're trying to say is we need to talk to children about how not to do that or how to use that because you're right they are using it and I think they're using it in a problematic way and if we don't actually have the conversations about that because you're saying what we don't know what to say or how to do or what to work with we as the educators need to say to students look don't use AI for this My worry is if we don't have those conversations, they think that AI is somehow going to diagnose them and tell them how to taper off their meds, right?
I'm 100% in agreement with you.
This is what I'm saying.
This is the conversation we should be having with them.
What I'm also saying is that that conversation can happen independent of ed tech existing in the classroom.
So for example, book creator, that is also something that uses generative AI.
And there was an incident of a student typing in Egyptian Queen, and it generated a pornographic image.
So I'm making a larger point about, I mean, that actually happened, I can send you the link.
And that kind of thing, because this technology is new and unregulated, these kinds of things, even when they're embedded in educational tools, the kids are still being exposed to crazy stuff.
So my point is we should absolutely talk to them about the scariness of relying on how absolutely you should not be going to chat GPT for mental health.
we can have that conversation and also we don't need these tools in the classroom in order to have that conversation.
So I think that's the distinction.
Yeah, I mean, I hear that, but I mean, I guess which tools are we talking about?
I mean, when we say we don't want ed tech, that's a lot different than saying we don't want generative AI, right?
And I just want to be careful because I serve at the pleasure of the board.
I want to understand what the board's asking of me.
But when you say there's no research, so we know that the eMERGE curriculum is really good.
We know it is top of the line.
And it uses EdTech.
I don't want to say we're not going to use it because there's EdTech in it.
And so I want to understand where the board is in terms of the direction for us in terms of saying, well, we don't have the research.
We don't know the things.
Well, what we do know is that The eMERGE curriculum, which was adopted by the board, which went through rigorous evaluation, includes technology.
So I need to understand where you would like me to go, because I hear you.
I don't want there to be a use of technology that is not good for kids.
But when you say there's no research about technology being used for children, I just need to understand what you mean by that.
Well, I mean AI, but also all of these platforms, like Magic School, is it actually helping kids learn?
Are these assertions that we're making?
And Joe has a question, which I accidentally skipped over.
So Joe, I see you.
You will be called upon shortly.
is that where is the, where is, yeah, I think we just wanna see like where is the data that's saying like these, when kids are on a screen, when kids are learning something on a screen, it's helping them.
That's really the question that we would like to see answered concretely with data, and I haven't seen that.
I haven't seen how increased time, and I can also appreciate how there are, in unique situations where there are accessibility issues and language interpretation, I can totally appreciate how that is useful, but for the average default to be like, oh, this is definitely better because this technology exists, I haven't seen any evidence of that, and that's what I'm concerned about.
And I hear that and I think what I'm trying to level set with the conversation is the reason why we have an expectation of what a day is supposed to look like is that we have math curriculum, we have English curriculum, we have science curriculum, social studies curriculum, we have recess, we have PE, we have all these things.
the way that they're going to be exposed to screen time should only be through the approved curriculum.
So I hear you.
I really do.
But if we're saying screen time, that screen time is tied to the approved curriculum that we have.
if a child is using something to put something else in to get a picture of something that they're not supposed to, that should not be part of any of our curriculum.
So I think what I'm really taking away from it isn't there isn't research about the use of the curriculum that we use that happens to have screen time.
What you're, I think, really talking about is what that slide, whenever it was, was don't use it for free time.
Don't use it for rewards.
Don't use it for this or that.
But I just want to make sure that we're not throwing the baby out with the bathwater saying there's no research around screen time.
What there's the research about or what the approval process is is we have curriculum that we're following that happens to include some screen time.
What I would love to see is, again, it's not used for rewards, it's not used for free time, it's not used for any of that.
So now, if magic school's an issue, that's a different story, right?
Because that's not, you know, the Emerge K-5, that's not envisioned.
That I think we should have a conversation about, you know.
Yeah, and I kind of want to carve to carve curriculum as a separate topic, because I think there is a conversation we had about how much we are excited about curriculum that's digital.
But curriculum is kind of its own thing.
And that's that conversation, and I'm not referring to that in this moment.
though I think we should talk about how much people think digital curriculum is a good idea or not, as opposed to physical textbooks.
But again, separate conversation from other platforms that we're using that are what would be called EdTech, just to make that distinction.
And that makes a lot of sense.
And I think that where I would want the board's help with is Other than the approved technologies or approved curriculum that includes tech, what are the ones that would be concerning?
Because that's why we're trying to block Minecraft and YouTube and Gemini.
If there's other issues that you would want us to block, I think we're all for that, right?
Yeah.
Okay, great.
And I think the community has a lot to say about this, too.
And I know you've been listening to them, and I think we just, yeah, we need to keep the conversation going.
Let me turn to Joe, because he's been waiting patiently, and I jumped him in line.
Joe.
I appreciate the conversation around access because I do think that is an important factor that gets overlooked in some of the rightful concerns we have about technology.
In my day job, I work with a lot of very, very low-wage workers in Seattle, and the digital divide is real.
large portion of those workers do not have computers at home, do not have iPads at home.
Their sole computer is the parent's smartphone.
So I actually don't think we can take for granted that kids are getting access to technology literacy outside of school.
And I do think that there is a role that we play, that the school system plays in leveling that playing field to some degree.
And in one of the slides, that was talking about access and now I'm remote so I don't have slides in front of me.
We talked about no longer having the one device but we're going to find other avenues for access and I would love to hear you expand on what that looks like because that is a concern of mine that we're swinging the pendulum too far the other way and it is going to harm lower income students that don't have access outside of school to the same technology that, you know, if my kids have less technology in school they're going to be able to still gain a lot of computer literacy at home.
So I want to understand how we're going to be doing that.
Well, I think first and foremost is, you know, Director Mizrahi, I appreciate you reemphasizing the students who we're specifically talking about, who are underserved students, who traditionally, you know, pre-pandemic, we were trying to solve for something, and now post-pandemic, and now that students have the devices, What we're prepared to do is, again, double down on the literacy.
The skills that if they're not being taught at home or they don't have access to it at home, we can't assume that all students have the same amount of access and the skills that you're describing.
And so school does play a role in that and school systems do play an important role in that and we are going to continue to double down on our literacy and our awareness for our students.
Can I ask a quick question that I meant to ask before that's clarifying about the three to five, one to one?
Will three to five kids take, so they will not be taking computers home?
No, they won't be issued computers to take home.
However, students do have the opportunity to be able to check out technology, depending on what the students need.
But it's not a blanket.
Everyone takes one.
But kids who don't otherwise have access to a computer can always take one from school.
Is that right?
Yes.
Oh, yes, please.
I wanted to add on to Director Smith you can also use AI to generate or rephrase highlighted text in Word documents and since that's such a widely used software especially like my school and many other schools I just was wondering if that was something you guys were also planning on working on
Are we talking about like in Word?
Is that what you're talking about?
Yeah.
So that kind of AI, that's a little bit what we've been working on and talking about for the last few years.
AI is not really new.
It's been around for quite some time.
And so with that, those kind of functionality, that is something that we are aware of, and it's actually not even something we could turn off in those kind of tools.
President Topp, do you have anything to add?
Hi, Director Briggs.
No, I'm just listening.
Thank you.
You're welcome.
Does anybody else have any final thoughts before we wrap this up?
Okay, well thank you very much for the presentation.
Okay, there being no further business, this meeting is adjourned at 8.53.
Thank you.