Dev Mode. Emulators used.

Seattle Public Schools Special Board Meeting - Nov 9, 2026

Publish Date: 11/10/2026
Description:

Seattle Public Schools

SPEAKER_04

[30s]

Good evening.

This is President Topp.

I am now calling the board's special meeting to order at 6.31 PM.

Please note that this meeting is being recorded.

We would like to acknowledge that we are on ancestral lands under the traditional territories of the Puget Sound Coast Salish people.

For the record, I will call the roll.

Vice President Briggs.

Director Lavallee.

Here.

Director Mizorahi?

SPEAKER_00

[0s]

Here.

SPEAKER_04

[38m10s]

Director Rankin?

Here.

Director Smith?

Here.

Director Song.

Here.

And this is President Topp.

So there are two items on our agenda this evening.

We have an executive section and one action item, approval of resolution number 2026-2711, authorizing legal action regarding initiative measure number Aisle 26-638.

We're going to start with the executive session.

So we will recess into executive session and then come back and address our one action item.

So with that being said, the board is now immediately recessing the special meeting into executive session to discuss with legal counsel representing the agency in litigation or potential litigation per RCW 4230-110-1I.

The session is scheduled for 30 minutes with an anticipated end time of 7 PM.

So we will be back at 7 PM or with an updated time at that time.

Thank you.

Good evening, folks.

The executive session is running past the scheduled end time.

So I'm going to make an extension.

The executive session on litigation per RCW 42301101G was originally scheduled for approximately 30 minutes.

We are running long.

The session is now expected to go an additional 10 minutes with an anticipated end time of 7.10.

Yeah.

and the special meeting of the board is now reconvened at, looking at the time here, 7.09 p.m.

I'm gonna thank you, everyone, for holding, being patient with us with the extension of time.

We will now move on to the second item on the agenda, the action item approving resolution 2026-2711 authorizing the superintendent to take legal action regarding IL-26-638.

Can I have a motion for this item?

SPEAKER_01

[10s]

Yes, you can as soon as I can find it.

Oh, shoot.

It's on my other computer.

Does somebody else have it there?

Can somebody else read it?

SPEAKER_02

[10s]

Yes.

Where's the?

I move the board approve resolution number 2026-27-11, authorizing legal action regarding initiative measure number IL-26-638.

Do I have a second?

Second.

SPEAKER_04

[6s]

Great.

Thank you.

Motion and second.

I'm going to pass this over to Director Mizrahi to introduce this item.

SPEAKER_00

[2m39s]

Thank you, President Taup.

So before I talk about the language behind the resolution, I want to state clearly that as a board director, I was opposed to initiative 638. As a father of three daughters who play sports, I was opposed to 638. But actually, I'm not saying that for that reason.

I'm saying this to say that actually the vote we're taking right now doesn't have anything to do with how I voted on 638 or how any other board director voted on 638. This is actually about our responsibilities as school board directors.

When we take our oath of office, we swear an oath that says that we will support the Constitution of the United States, the Constitution, and the laws of Washington State.

Was an actual quote from the oath we take.

The actual resolution, this resolution, is attempting to sort that out and how we reconcile that oath with the language of Initiative 638. Washington already has important laws on the books, laws that protect student privacy, laws that guarantee equal protection and access to educational opportunities, laws that protect students from discrimination.

And Initiative 638 did not repeal any of those laws.

So all those laws still exist.

And right now, I don't see how we can implement the requirements of Initiative 638 without violating those other laws and constitutional protections.

It raises serious questions about equal protection, student privacy, and whether we're creating additional barriers for female student athletes to participate in school athletics.

We can't pick one new law to follow and disregard other laws.

That's not what our oath tells us to do.

And when those laws potentially conflict, we actually have a system for resolving those conflicts, and that's called the courts.

Our responsibility is to ask the courts to help us understand how to meet all of our legal obligations, especially when the rights of privacy, dignity, and students are at stake.

We've received a lot of messages about tonight's resolutions.

Many people are urging us to act to protect students.

Others are asking us to support Initiative 638 and respect the will of the voters.

I want to address that directly.

I believe that what we're doing tonight is actually both protecting students and respecting the will of voters because, yes, voters supported the Initiative 638, and we do take that seriously, but our democracy also produced all those other laws.

Those laws didn't come out of nowhere.

They came from the democratic process, from representatives, from votes, and from our constitutional principles.

So those protections also reflect the will of the people.

We can't say we're respecting democracy if we treat the most recent vote as a reason to ignore all the other laws that are on the books.

And that's really what this resolution's about.

We're not asking the superintendent to pick and choose which laws to follow.

We're authorizing the superintendent working with our legal counsel to ask the courts to help resolve these serious legal questions.

because we have an obligation to uphold all of the laws and we have an obligation to protect students who are counting on us.

So that's why I'm supporting the resolution tonight.

SPEAKER_04

[7s]

Thank you, Director Mizrahi.

Do other board directors have comments they'd like to make?

Director Rankin.

SPEAKER_02

[2m52s]

Yeah, similar to Director Mizrahi, we as the whole board has taken a position on this initiative before people had the opportunity to vote on it, stating our values.

So I'm not going to repeat all of that.

But the part that makes this important for us to look to legal counsel and to direct our superintendent to authorize the use of those resources is because part of the initiative says that policies, procedures, rules, and other requirements adopted in accordance with RCW 28A 600-200 by a school board of directors must implement the initiative.

And we have 30 days.

in addition to the conflicts in law that Director Mizrahi brought up.

Typically, a board adopts two kinds of policies, their own governing policies or bylaws, and then the policies that provide direction to implement state law.

And those are the policies that the superintendent is charged with following.

The process usually involves other entities like OSPI, like WASDA, who do legal review, do rulemaking, write the model policy to instruct districts how to best comply with the law.

In this case, this initiative is asking 295 districts to do that all individually to figure out how to comply with something that is legally very complicated and does conflict.

and that typically takes months, not 30 days, to go from legislation, rulemaking, model policy, a board adoption of the policy.

And so I wanted to make that really clear that the direction from the board to the superintendent is not overturn the will of the voters.

It's not, let's pretend this never happened.

We do not, among the seven of us and among the groups of five on 294 other school districts in the state, and I've been getting messages and calls from fellow directors all over the state that are saying, how are we supposed to do this?

What is the policy?

How are you able to do this?

Or how are we addressing this?

Because it is actually very much not straightforward.

and so in addition to other positions and what Director Mizrahi has said, we need the advice and support of legal counsel and someone to weigh in on what this law is actually saying.

And yeah, that's it.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Other directors?

SPEAKER_04

[8s]

All right, I will look then to our student representative advisory vote.

I think we had some student representatives join.

Yes.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Student representative Fonts.

SPEAKER_03

[1s]

Hi, can you hear me?

SPEAKER_04

[1s]

Yes, we can hear you.

SPEAKER_03

[17s]

Okay.

I believe Frana is also here.

We're taking, we're doing separate advisory votes, just to make that clear.

So we'll be doing two.

I believe that is all the student reps we have with us this evening.

SPEAKER_04

[7s]

Thank you.

All right, and seeing no other board directors who'd like to speak, I will ask staff to please call the vote.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

Vice President Briggs?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Aye.

SPEAKER_06

[5s]

Director Lavallee?

Aye.

Director Mizrahi?

SPEAKER_00

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_06

[9s]

Director Rankin?

Yes.

Director Smith?

Director Song?

SPEAKER_03

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_06

[1s]

President Topp?

SPEAKER_04

[0s]

Yes.

SPEAKER_06

[2s]

This motion is passed unanimously.

SPEAKER_04

[26s]

Thank you, board directors.

I know that a special meeting at the last minute is not an easy thing to put on your calendar, but I think Director Mizrahi summarized it well.

I think getting some clarity when there is some confusion will be helpful as we move forward.

That is the only item on our agenda this evening.

So as there's no further business on the agenda, the meeting stands adjourned at 7.19 p.m.

Have a good evening, everyone.